Aufsichtspflichtverletzung – eine heikle Angelegenheit
Transcription
Aufsichtspflichtverletzung – eine heikle Angelegenheit
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`92+<*2+93'%!O1$'&!$%!&'(!.'33'!6/9,'+'%a[! ! >>>5!R$+&'()F!-&0/#1.-&$-0?! ! "!T'%%!&$'!A%<'$9/%,'%!K$9962+3'3!<'(&'%;!K/99!&'(!A/B9$2+39BD+('%&'!'$%,('$B'%!/%&!6%,'&(:+3'! .:%9'_/'%E'%!&/(2+BD+('%F! ! ! U5!V-+-19)&B0!;-.!"#$%&'()%*$+&'()?! ! bK!G'('$2+!&'(!H$%E'1DC'(3(6,/%,!$93!&$'!I'1',63$:%!&'(!A/B9$2+39?B1$2+3!,(/%&9*3E1$2+!/%E/1*99$,F! I'%%!$%!&$'9'%!X*11'%!$93!$KK'(!&6J:%!6/9E/,'+'%;!&699!&$'!A/B9$2+3?B1$2+3!%/(!6%!&$'9'!C'93$KK3'! 8'(9:%!DC'(3(6,'%!<:(&'%!$93F!H$%'!I'1',63$:%9K>,1$2+='$3!KD993'!J'('$%C6(3!9'$%F! ! G'$9?$'1M!H$%!.$%&!'(+*13!H$%E'1/%3'(($2+3!C'$!'$%'K!Z'%%$91'+('(F!H9!</(&'!6/992+1$'c1$2+!K$3!$+K!'$%! Q'(3(6,!,'92+1:99'%F! ! A%&'(9!$93!'9!C'$!Q'('$%'%!:&'(!6%&'('%!b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`DC'(<62+'%a;!C$9!K6%!9$2+'(!$93;!&699!9$'!$+('(!A/B,6C'!,'<62+9'%!9$%&F! ! I$'!I'1',63$:%!C'B('$3!%$2+3!J>11$,F!I'(!Q'('$%!K/99!/%3'(!6%&'('K!611'!b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`.B)/!C-.+-)/#01!;-.!"#$%&'()*$+&'()!3-&0-!a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bNa-+$-.!&$'!A/B<'%&/%,'%!BD(!&$'!L2+6&'%9(',/1$'(/%,!9++-&0-!3(6,'%;! ! !" C'$!1.B8-.!H9(.+E%%&13-&)!,$13!'C'%B6119!,(&9F!&$'!/%C'92+(*%=3'!V6B3/%,!&'9!WbNa-+$-.%;!'9!9'$! &'%%;!&699!9'$%!Q'(&$'%93!$%!&'/31$2+'K!#$99J'(+*13%$9!E/K!L2+6&'%!93'+3!-&$'9!<$(&!C'$! '+('%6K31$2+!Z*3$,'%!+*/B$,!&'(!X611!9'$%7F! ! !" C'$!7&))+-.-.!S0B.79+-.T!H9(.+E%%&13-&)!+6B3'%!&'(!Q'('$%!/%&!&'(!RNYV'1B'(!90)-&+&1! -L2+6&'%3'$1/%,7;! ! !" C'$!+-&'()-%)-.!H9(.+E%%&13-&)!S1-.&01-!['(#+;T!+6B3'3!&'(!C-.-&0!9++-&0F! ! ! ! Z$??M! !" XD(!#$3,1$'&9J'('$%'!&'9!GNLQ!/%&!&$'!J:%!$+%'%!C'6/B3(6,3'%!8'(9:%'%!C'93'+3! V6B3?B1$2+3J'(9$2+'(/%,992+/3E!DC'(!&$'!L?:(3J'(9$2+'(/%,F!bK!L2+6&'%9B611!9:113'!/K,'+'%&'! #'1&/%,!'(B:1,'%!6%!&69!Q'(9$2+'(/%,9CD(:!$K!V6/9!&'9!L?:(39!$%!#D%2+'%F! 4 ! ! #$3J'(92+/1&'%!/%&!V6B3/%,96/992+1/99! ! !" X6119!&'(!O'92+*&$,3'!9'1C93!B6+(1*99$,!,'+6%&'13!+63;!=6%%!9'$%!A%9?(/2+!<','%!#$3J'(92+/1&'%! ('&/E$'(3!:&'(!9:,6(!6/9,'92+1:99'%!9'$%F!I$'9!,$13!%$2+3!C'$!.$%&'(%!J:%!4!d!e!06+('%F!AC! Q:11'%&/%,!&'9!fF!N'C'%9)6+('9!C$9!E/(!Q:11)*+($,='$3!,$13!&$'9!%/(;!<'%%!'(!DC'(!&$'!'(B:(&'(1$2+'! H$%9$2+3!-,'$93$,'!H%3<$2=1/%,7!J'(BD,3;!/K!9'$%'!Q'(6%3<:(31$2+='$3!E/!'(='%%'%F! ! !" U62+!&'K!L2+6&'%9B611!=6%%!&$'!V6B3/%,!&/(2+!Q'(3(6,!E<$92+'%!L2+*&$,'(!/%&!O'92+*&$,3'K! ,6%E!6/9,'92+1:99'%!<'(&'%F! ! !" I$'9'!Q'('$%C6(/%,!=6%%!6/2+!J:(!&'K!L2+6&'%9B611;!&6%%!)'&:2+!%$2+3!BD(!Q:(963E!&'9!L2+*&$,'(9! ,'3(:BB'%!<'(&'%F! ! !" ]-#M!L'$3!g4Fg4Fhggh!-['(#+;.-'()%.-$B.7S7!=6%%!$%!"++1-7-&0-0!A-%'(E$)%8-;&01#01-0!d! AOGi9!d!-EFGF!H$%3($339=6(3'%!/F6F!J:(B:(K/1$'(3'!Q'(3(6,9C'&$%,/%,'%7!&$'!V6B3/%,!BD(! 8'(9:%'%92+*&'%!%$2+3!K'+(!'$%,'92+(*%=3!<'(&'%F!H$%!V6B3/%,96/992+1/99!$93!%/(!%:2+!BD(!K$3! '$%B62+'(!X6+(1*99$,='$3!J'(/(962+3'!L62+92+*&'%!K>,1$2+F! ! ! Z$??M! !" a9$)#01%9#%%'(+#%%!;#.'(!&0;&,&;#-++-0!C-.).91!-$K!H$%E'1%'%!E<$92+'%!&'%!Q'(3(6,9?6(3%'(%! 6/9,'+6%&'137M!`XD(!8'(9:%'%"!/%&!L62+92+*&'%!<$(&!='$%'!V6B3/%,!DC'(%:KK'%F!I$'9'(! V6B3/%,96/992+1/99!,$13!%$2+3!C'$!Q:(963E!&'9!Q'('$%9!9:<$'!9'$%'(!,'9'3E1$2+'%!Q'(3('3'(Fa! ! !" a9$)#01%9#%%'(+#%%!;#.'(!"AJ?!`H$%'!V6B3/%,!BD(!L62+92+*&'%!$93!6/9,'92+1:99'%F!V$'(J:%! 6/9,'%:KK'%!9$%&!X*11'!,(:C'(!X6+(1*99$,='$3!:&'(!Q:(963E'9Fa! ! ! >>5![).9$.-'()+&'(-!HB+1-0?! ! T$(&!'$%!A/B9$2+3C'&D(B3$,'(!$%B:1,'!'$%'(!A/B9$2+39?B1$2+3J'(1'3E/%,!J'(1'3E3!:&'(!,'3>3'3;!9$%&! 93(6B('2+31$2+'!X:1,'%!&'%=C6(F! ! H9!=*K'!'$%'!G'93(6B/%,!<','%!B6+(1*99$,'(!.>(?'(J'(1'3E/%,!-,(/%&9*3E1$2+!L3(6B6%3(6,!&'9!Q'(1'3E3'%! '(B:(&'(1$2+S7!:&'(!B6+(1*99$,'(!Z>3/%,!$%!G'3(62+3F! ! I'(!L3663-96%<6137!K/99!6C'(!&$'!Q'(1'3E/%,!&'(!A/B9$2+39?B1$2+3!%62+<'$9'%S! ! >>>5!".8-&)%c!#0;!;&-0%).-'()+&'(-!HB+1-0?! ! I$'!Q'(1'3E/%,!&'(!A/B9$2+39?B1$2+3!$93!E/,1'$2+!'$%'!Q'(1'3E/%,!&'(!I$'%93?B1$2+3F! ! #>,1$2+'!X:1,'%M! "!@/(D2=93'11/%,!J:%!'$%'(!G'B>(&'(/%,! "!H%3E$'+'%!'$%'(!N'$3/%,9B/%=3$:%;! "!ACK6+%/%,;!.D%&$,/%,! ! Q'(B699'(!/%&!W(+'C'(('2+3M! ]'2+396%<613!I(F!A1B:%9!V>1E1;!./K?BKD+1'(!L3(F!jg;!kjgl4!]','%9C/(,;!! Z'1F!gk!m4Ykm!hf!kf"g;!X6n!gk!m4Ykm!hf!kf"4j;!H"K6$1M!6F+:'1E1o=6%E1'$"+:'1E1F&'!! Stand 01 / 2002 5