Tèlècharger PDF

Transcription

Tèlècharger PDF
:?IJ?BB7J?ED
6gi^XaZYZA^dcZa9jXdb
9^hi^aaVi^dc/
YZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^h
SFNQMBDFOUMFHB[
?ZVc"Adje Zi 6aWVc BZgX^Zg hdci YZjm Wdj^aaZjgh YZ Xgj! ^chiVaa‚h | 7g‚k^aaZ! fj^ dci [V^i egZjkZ YZ hZch YZ aV egdheZXi^kZ YVch
a¼^beaVciVi^dcYZaZjgcdjkZaaZY^hi^aaZg^Z#AVeZgheZXi^kZYZg‚Va^hZgjc^ckZhi^hhZbZci^bedgiVcifj^hd^iVYVei‚VjmhigjXijgZhYZ
aVegdeg^‚i‚YVchaZh'%|(%Vcc‚Zh|kZc^gaZhV^cX^i‚h|VWdgYZgaVg‚ÄZm^dciZX]cdad\^fjZegZcVciZcXdbeiZaVegdWa‚bVi^fjZ
YjXd’iYZa¼‚cZg\^Z#>ahhZhdciYZbVcY‚hh^a¼‚cZg\^Z®gZ^cZ¯fj¼ZhiaZ\VoVj_djgY¼]j^aZhZgV^iZcXdgZYVch&%!&*dj'%Vch#AZjg
g‚ÄZm^dcVY‚WdjX]‚hjgjcegd_ZiYZY^hi^aaZg^ZfjZa¼dceZjifjVa^ÃZg|aV[d^hY¼VbW^i^ZjmZig‚Va^hiZ#
BWbWcX_YWkn]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_iZWdibWfWhj_[Y[djhWb[Z[bWZ_ij_bb[h_[$
AV Y^hi^aaZg^Z YZ XZiiZ egdeg^‚i‚ VkV^i ‚i‚
^chiVaa‚Z! YVch aZ XdjgVci YZh Vcc‚Zh hd^"
mVciZ"Y^m!|egdm^b^i‚YZa¼VcX^ZcX]V^YZk^"
c^ÃXVi^dcZiZaaZYdccV^ieaZ^cZhVi^h[VXi^dc
Zc iZgbZh YZ fjVa^i‚ YZh ZVjm"YZ"k^Z Zi
YZ [dcXi^dccZbZci ‚Xdcdb^fjZ# A¼VaVbW^X
YZ '%]a YZ X]Vg\Z eZgbZiiV^i YZ Y^hi^aaZg
aV egdYjXi^dc YZ aV igZciV^cZ Y¼]ZXiVgZh
YVchYZWdccZhXdcY^i^dch!b„bZh^a¼dji^a
c¼‚iV^i eajh idiVaZbZci Zc e]VhZ VkZX aZh
ViiZciZh Zck^gdccZbZciVaZh VXijZaaZh# AZh
YZjm k^i^XjaiZjgh ‚iV^Zci XdchX^Zcih fjZ
a¼jc^i‚YZY^hi^aaVi^dcVaaV^ic‚XZhh^iZg!YVch
jc VkZc^g egdX]Z! YZh g‚Vb‚cV\ZbZcih#
AV XdchigjXi^dc Y¼jc ViZa^Zg YZ Y^hi^aaVi^dc
cZj[ cZ edjkV^i eVh „igZ Zck^hV\‚Z XVg!
‚Xdcdb^fjZbZci! XZaV c¼‚iV^i eVh _jhi^"
Â#AV[dgiZVj\bZciVi^dcYj\VoYZej^h*
|+Vch‚iV^iW^Zch’gYZkZcjZjchj_ZiYZ
eg‚dXXjeVi^dc bV^h! [VjiZ YZ edjkd^g Y^h"
edhZg Y¼VjigZh hdjgXZh Y¼‚cZg\^Z bd^ch
dc‚gZjhZh! ^a [VaaV^i W^Zc ®[V^gZ VkZX¯# 6#
Zi?#"A#BZgX^ZgedhhƒYZcijcZhV\ZhhZcV"
ijgZaaZ fj^ aZh ^cX^iZ | W^Zc ®b’g^g¯ aZjg
egd_Zi VkVci YZ h¼Zc\V\Zg YVch idjiZh Y‚"
bVgX]Zh# A¼‚a‚bZci Y‚XaZcX]Zjg Yj egd"
_ZiYZcdjkZaaZY^hi^aaZg^ZV‚i‚a¼Vgg^k‚ZZc
egdYjXi^dc! Zc'%&) Zi'%&*! YZ &,]V YZ
k^\cZh hjeea‚bZciV^gZh# 6kZX '%%%]a YZ
k^ch YZ eajh | Y^hi^aaZg! a¼VaVbW^X YZ '%]a
VaaV^i„igZigde_jhiZZia¼V\ZcXZbZciYZaV
Y^hi^aaZg^Z cZ eZgbZiiV^i eVh a¼^beaVciVi^dc
Y¼jcZ YZjm^ƒbZ X]VjY^ƒgZ# AZ hdj]V^i YZh
YZjmWdj^aaZjghYZXgj‚iVciYZY‚kZadeeZg
aZjgVXi^k^i‚YZY^hi^aaVi^dc|aVegdeg^‚i‚!aZ
egd_ZiYZcdjkZaaZY^hi^aaZg^ZV‚i‚b^h®hjg
aZhgV^ah¯Vjeg^ciZbeh'%&'#
k^h^W^a^i‚ Vj c^kZVj YZ cdh Y‚WdjX]‚h eZg"
bZi Y¼Vkd^g jcZ VeegdX]Z eajh gVi^dccZaaZ
Yj Y‚kZadeeZbZci YZh higjXijgZh YZ egd"
YjXi^dc YZ aV egdeg^‚i‚# Jc iZa XdciZmiZ V
W^Zch’g[VX^a^i‚aZegd_ZiY¼^beaVciVi^dcYZ
aV cdjkZaaZ Y^hi^aaZg^Z# Ed i½[ij Z[cWdZƒ
i_ b[ ]Wp i[hW_j jek`ekhi kd[ ƒd[h]_[
Z½Wl[d_h ZWdi '& ek (& Wdi fekh Z_ij_bb[h$
J[Y^d_gk[c[dj" Y½[ij b[ YecXkij_Xb[ he_
fekh cW‰jh_i[h Wl[Y iekfb[ii[ [j hƒWYj_#
l_jƒb[iYekbW][i$Iedkj_b_iWj_edWf[hc_i
Z½WXehZ[h b[ f_bejW][ Z[i Y^Wk\\[i Wl[Y
X[WkYekf fbki Z[ j[Y^d_Y_jƒ$ FWh Yedjh["
b½Wk]c[djWj_edZ[iedfh_nZ[fk_iZ_nWdi
[ijZ[l[dk[fhƒeYYkfWdj[$B[Ye“jZk]Wp
fekh Z_ij_bb[h kd ^[Yjeb_jh[ Z½WbYeeb fkh W
ZekXbƒ[dgk[bgk[iWddƒ[i$7Yjk[bb[c[dj"
b[i\hW_iZ[YecXkij_Xb[i[i_jk[dj[djh[*&
[j*+ç>J%Z½7F[jbWhWhƒ\WYj_edZ[iƒd[h#
]_[i\eii_b[iZWdib[iZƒY[dd_[i}l[d_hd[
lWfWi_dl[hi[hY[jj[j[dZWdY[$;VXZ | XZ
B[]Wpd[i[hW#j#_bfWi
ZcXdgZa¼‚cZg\^Zji^a^h‚Z
edjgY^hi^aaZgYVch'%Vch4
?#"A#BZgX^ZgVXdch^Y‚g‚fjZa¼dWa^\Vi^dcYZ
Xg‚ZgjcZhigjXijgZYZY^hi^aaVi^dccZjkZZc
YZ]dgh YZh W}i^bZcih Y¼Zmead^iVi^dc Zm^h"
iVcih ‚iV^i jcZ deedgijc^i‚ jc^fjZ edjg
eZchZgjcdji^aY^[[‚gZci/®AVWdccZhVci‚
VXijZaaZ YZ a¼‚Xdcdb^Z Yj Xd\cVX Zhi jcZ
deedgijc^i‚ fj^ cdjh V eZgb^h YZ i^hhZg
YZh Zc\V\ZbZcih Y¼VX]Vih YVch aV Yjg‚Z
VkZX jcZ \gVcYZ BV^hdc# 8ZiiZ bZ^aaZjgZ
@[Wd#BekfC[hY_[h$
XdchiVi!^acdjhVhZbWa‚fjZcdjh!k^i^Xjai"
Zjgh!cdjhY^hedh^dchY¼jcZW^dbVhhZk‚\‚"
iVaZcVijgZaaZ^bedgiVciZZi^cZmead^i‚ZVkZX
bZchjZac•&&).DEL;C8H;(&')B[FWoiWdK><C:GDC>&*
:?IJ?BB7J?ED
aZhhVgbZcihYZk^\cZ#AZ[V^iYZaV^hhZgVj
c^kZVj Yj hda YZh WgdnVih YZ hVgbZcih cZ
cdjheVgVˆieVh„igZjcZWdccZX]dhZk^h"
|"k^h YZh bVaVY^Zh Yj Wd^h# AZh g‚Xje‚gZg
Zi aZh ji^a^hZg hdjh aV X]VjY^ƒgZ ‚iV^Zci
jcZ ^Y‚Z fj^ bZ eVgV^hhV^i h‚Yj^hVciZ
YVch aV bZhjgZ! W^Zc h’g! d‘ jc egdX‚Y‚
iZX]cdad\^fjZ VhhjgZgV^i a¼Va^bZciVi^dc Zc
Xdci^cj Yj [Zj# 8djgVci '%&%! cdjh Vk^dch
Y‚_|eg^hYZhXdciVXihVkZXaZhhZgk^XZhYZ
a¼6YZbZEd^idj"8]VgZciZhedjgZhhVnZgYZ
igdjkZg YZ a¼^c[dgbVi^dc hjg XZ hj_Zi# AZh
‚X]Vc\ZhVkZXaZhZmeZgihWd^hYZa¼6YZbZ
dcicdjgg^cdigZg‚ÄZm^dcZiaZegd_Zih¼Zhi
egd\gZhh^kZbZci [dgbVa^h‚ Zc eg^k^a‚\^Vci
eajh^Zjgh cdjkZaaZh e^hiZh YZ XdbWjhi^WaZ
|WVhZYZWd^h!YZheaVfjZiiZhZiYZh\gV"
cja‚h#¯
B[YecXkij_Xb[]hWdkbƒ
YZWd^hh¼Zhi^bedh‚XdbbZ
jcZVaiZgcVi^kZg‚Va^hiZ
Egd\gZhh^kZbZci!a¼^beaVciVi^dcY¼jcVaVb"
W^X c¼ji^a^hVci eajh XdbbZ ‚cZg\^Z aZ \Vo
V\Zgb‚YVcha¼Zheg^iYZ?#"A#BZgX^Zg#AZh
XdbWjhi^WaZh|WVhZYZWd^hhdciYZeajhZc
eajh[g‚fjZbbZciji^a^h‚hedjg[V^gZ[dcX"
i^dccZgYZhX]VjY^ƒgZhYZhi^c‚Zh|X]Vj[[Zg
YZhbV^hdch!YZhadXVjmXdaaZXi^[hZi^cYjh"
ig^Zah# A¼VjidbVi^hVi^dc YZ a¼Va^bZciVi^dc
YZh [dnZgh V eZgb^h YZ gZcYgZ Xdbe‚i^"
i^kZ XZ ineZ Y¼^chiVaaVi^dc Zi aV YZbVcYZ
YZ \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h Zi YZ eaVfjZiiZh Zhi
Zc XdchiVciZ Vj\bZciVi^dc# 9Z cdjkZVjm
‚X]Vc\Zh XdjgVci '%&& VkZX I]VZg 6ahV"
[Vg!YZa¼6YZbZ!dciXdckV^cXjaZhYZjmk^"
i^XjaiZjghYZa¼^ci‚g„iYZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^h
edjg e^adiZg YZh VaajgZh YZ XdbWjhi^dch
bd^h eajh ii Zc >hƒgZ YZjm VaVbW^Xh Va^"
bZci‚hVjm\gVcja‚hYZWd^hedjgY^hi^aaZg
YZhVaXddahYZ\gV^ch#B[ZƒfbWY[c[djZ[i
Z[kn l_j_Ykbj[khi Y^[p Y[ Z_ij_bbWj[kh Z[
b½?i„h[ W Äd_ Z[ b[i YedlW_dYh[$ 8_[d gk[
bW YedZk_j[ Z[i Y^Wk\\[i ƒjW_j jh„i Z_\\ƒh#
[dj["b[iY^WkZ_„h[iƒjW_[djƒgk_fƒ[iZ½kd
Xh“b[khWkn]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_iZedjbWfk_i#
iWdY[ Z[ \[k feklW_j …jh[ ceZkbƒ[ ZWdi
kd[ fhefehj_ed Z[ ' } '&$ B½Wb_c[djWj_ed
WkjecWj_gk[ Zk Xh“b[kh [d ]hWdkbƒi
f[hc[jjW_j Z½_dj[hl[d_h Z_h[Yj[c[dj ikh
b½_dj[di_jƒZk\[k$8_[dgk[bWYedZk_j[Z[i
YoYb[i Z[ Z_ij_bbWj_ed ie_j jh„i Z_\\ƒh[dj["
b[ Z_ij_bbWj[kh _iƒhe_i WlW_j YWbƒ Z[i Zk#
hƒ[ifhƒY_i[iZ[YekbW][[jZ[i[n_][dY[i
Z[ ZƒX_j } h[if[Yj[h$ 7k lk Z[ Y[i hƒikb#
jWji" @$#B$ C[hY_[h i½[ij Z_j gk[ b[ fhe`[j
Z½kj_b_i[h Z[i ]hWdkbƒi Z[ Xe_i ieki kd
WbWcX_YY^Wh[djW_iƒjW_j[dl_iW][WXb[$B[
iekj_[dZ[b½7Z[c[fekh_cfbWdj[hkdfh[#
c_[hWbWcX_YY^Wk\\ƒWkn]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_i
ZWdibWhƒ]_edZ[9e]dWYWÄd_Z[b[Yed#
lW_dYh[$B[Zeii_[hZ½W_Z[Z[ÄdWdY[c[dji
W ƒjƒ WYY[fjƒ fWh b½7Z[c[ [j bW hƒ]_ed
Fe_jek#9^Wh[dj[i$
Kd[Z_ij_bb[h_[YedY_b_Wdj
aZhVheZXihg‚\aZbZciV^gZh!
aV[dcXi^dccVa^i‚Zi
a¼VgX]^iZXijgZadXVaZ
8djgVci '%&'! a^beaVciVi^dc YjcZ Y^hi^a"
aZg^ZV‚i‚aVcX‚ZZch¼ZcidjgVciYZhXdb"
e‚iZcXZh Y¼jc XVW^cZi YVgX]^iZXiZ! aV hd"
X^‚i‚ 6g`dhZ | 7dgYZVjm &# AZ X]d^m YZ
h¼VeejnZghjgaZhXdbe‚iZcXZhY¼jcVgX]^"
iZXiZXdggZhedcYV^i|jcZZm^\ZcXZYZXg‚Zg
BWYedY[fj_edZkX~j_c[djZ[bWZ_ij_bb[h_[Wl[Yjhe_iƒbƒc[djifh_dY_fWkn$
Y¼^ciZch^i‚h kVg^VWaZh# ?#"A# BZgX^Zg V eg^h
XdciVXi VkZX aZh XdchigjXiZjgh g‚\^dcVjm
Y¼VaVbW^Xh edjg hVkd^g h¼^ah VkV^Zci Y‚_|
g‚Va^h‚dj‚ijY^‚YZhegd_ZihYZXZaajaZhYZ
XdbWjhi^dc [dcXi^dccVci Vjm \gVcja‚h YZ
Wd^h#AVhZjaZg‚edchZZhikZcjZYZaVhd"
X^‚i‚8]Vak^\cVX!fj^VkV^i^chiVaa‚fjZafjZ
jcdji^afj^XdcX^a^ZaZhVheZXihg‚\aZbZc"
iV^gZh! aV [dcXi^dccVa^i‚ Zi a¼VgX]^iZXijgZ
Yj W}i^bZci# 8ZiiZ YZgc^ƒgZ cdi^dc Zhi
^bedgiVciZ XVg kd[ Z_ij_bb[h_[ d½[ij fWi
kd X~j_c[dj W]h_Yeb[ Yecc[ b[i Wkjh[i$
9½[ij kd ƒgk_f[c[dj Z[ lWbeh_iWj_ed Zk
fWjh_ce_d[ l_j_Yeb[ Zedj b½W][dY[c[dj [j
&+>B[FWoiWdK><C:GDCDEL;C8H;(&')bZchjZac•&&).
b½Wif[Yj Ze_l[dj h[if[Yj[h [j i½_djƒ]h[h
ZWdibWjof_Y_jƒZ[iX~j_c[djihkhWkn[n_i#
jWdji$ B½_cfbWdjWj_ed Z[ bW Z_ij_bb[h_[ d[
Z[lW_j fWi ZƒdWjkh[h b½[dl_hedd[c[dj
Z[ fhen_c_jƒ Yedij_jkƒ Z½kd [di[cXb[ Z[
cW_iedi Y^Wh[djW_i[i jhWZ_j_edd[bb[i [d
f_[hh[i$B½_dl[ij_ii[c[djZWdikd[fh[ijW#
j_edZ½WhY^_j[Yj[f[kjfWhW‰jh[}fh[c_„h[
lk[ ikf[hÅk cW_i" Wk ÄdWb" b[ jhWlW_b Z[
:ec_d_gk[B[iYWdd[WWffehjƒkdh[]WhZ
d[k\ [j ZƒXekY^ƒ ikh kd W][dY[c[dj
WijkY_[kn gk_ W ]ƒdƒhƒ Z[i ƒYedec_[i
ikXijWdj_[bb[i Wk d_l[Wk Z[ bW YedijhkY#
j_ed$ A¼Zme‚g^ZcXZ Vci‚g^ZjgZ YZ XZ bVˆigZ
Y¼¶jkgZYVchaZhXdchigjXi^dchY¼jc^i‚hYZ
hidX`V\ZZiYZeg‚eVgVi^dcYZ8d\cVXh¼Zhi
Vk‚g‚Z _jY^X^ZjhZ edjg aV Xg‚Vi^dc Y¼jcZ
higjXijgZ YZ W}i^bZcih gZheZXiVci aZh
cdgbZhYZh‚Xjg^i‚ZiZck^gdccZbZciVaZh#
AVY^hi^aaZg^ZV‚i‚higjXijg‚ZVjidjgYZigd^h
‚a‚bZcih/jcbdYjaZXZcigVaedjga¼VaVbW^X
Zcidjg‚ YZ YZjm VccZmZh ]‚WZg\ZVci Y¼jc
Xi‚ aZ edda YZ e^adiV\Z Zi aV g‚hZgkZ YZ
XdbWjhi^WaZ! Zi YZ a¼VjigZ aZ hidX`V\Z YZh
ZVjm"YZ"k^Z# 8]VfjZ higjXijgZ V ‚i‚ Xdc"
higj^iZZcgZheZXiVciaVg‚\aZbZciVi^dcYZ
h‚Xjg^i‚ egdegZ Vjm Y^hi^aaZg^Zh! VkZX YZh
bjgh eVgZ"[Zj! YZh WVXh YZ g‚iZci^dc! aV
g‚hZgkZ^cXZcY^ZZiaZhidX"`V\ZYZhZ[Äj"
Zcih#A¼VheZXiZmi‚g^ZjgYjW}i^bZciVYZjm
c^kZVjm VkZX jcZ XdjkZgijgZ igVY^i^dccZaaZ
Zc ij^aZ! Zi jcZ \gVcYZ edgiZ Zc [dgbZ YZ
edgX]Z h¼^ciƒ\gZ YVch a¼]VW^iVi Yj ]VbZVj
YZhE^Zgg^ƒgZh#
Kdi_beZ[ijeYaW][
Zc‚a‚kVi^dc^ci‚\g‚YVch
jcZV^aZYjW}i^bZci
AVhigjXijgZYjW}i^bZciZiidjiZhaZhVc"
cZmZh! aZ WVhh^c Y¼Z[ÄjZcih Zi YZ g‚hZgkZ
^cXZcY^Z dci ‚i‚ Xdcjh edjg VXXjZ^aa^g Vj
bd^ch YZjm dj igd^h VaVbW^Xh! b„bZ h^
XZiiZVcc‚ZjcZhZjaZX]VjY^ƒgZV‚i‚^ch"
iVaa‚Z# A¼jcZ YZh he‚X^ÃX^i‚h Yj W}i^bZci
‚iV^i fj¼^a YZkV^i ^ci‚\gZg jc bdYjaZ YZ
hidX`V\ZZiY¼Va^bZciVi^dcYZh\gVcja‚hYZ
Wd^hedjgfjZaVY^hi^aaZg^ZV^ijcZVjidcd"
b^Z YZ [dcXi^dccZbZci YZ igd^h dj fjVigZ
hZbV^cZh#>a[VaaV^i^beaVciZgjch^adYZhidX"
`V\ZYZXVeVX^i‚hj[ÃhVciZYdciaVh^ijVi^dc
YZkV^i[VX^a^iZga¼VXXƒhedjgaZha^kgV^hdchZi
aV b^hZ Zc ¶jkgZ Yj XdbWjhi^WaZ# 7fh„i
c“h[ hƒÅ[n_ed" Z[kn jhƒc_[i Z[ ijeYa#
W][Z[i]hWdkbƒiZ[jof[i_bei}YƒhƒWb[i
edj ƒjƒ _cfbWdjƒ[i [d ƒbƒlWj_ed Wk#Z[i#
ikib[Yekbe_hj[Y^d_gk[e’i[jhekl[djb[
\eo[h_dl[hiƒZ[b½WbWcX_Y$Kd[ekl[hjkh[
Wk d_l[Wk Zk je_j f[hc[j } kd YWc_ed Z[
h[cfb_h b[i hƒi[hl[i fWh#Z[iiki [d kj_b#
_iWdjkdXhWiZ[h[cfb_iiW][ceX_b[Yec#
fWhWXb[ } Y[bk_ Z[i ce_iiedd[ki[i#XWj#
j[ki[i$BWhƒi[hl[Yed\„h[}bWZ_ij_bb[h_[
kd[Wkjedec_[Z[fbkiZ[jhe_ii[cW_d[i[j
b[ZƒY^Wh][c[dji½[\\[Yjk[jh„i\WY_b[c[dj
[jhWf_Z[c[dj)&c_dkj[i$AZhXdcY^i^dch
YZ hidX`V\Z YZh \gVcja‚h hdci egde^XZh |
B[iYWhWYjƒh_ij_gk[i]ƒdƒhWb[i
Z[i]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_i
™AZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^hhdci[VWg^fj‚h
| eVgi^g YZ hX^jgZ Zi YZ XdeZVjm YZ
Wd^h egdkZcVci Y¼VgWgZh [Zj^aajh
eg^cX^eVaZbZci Yj X]„cZ! YZ g‚h^"
cZjmZiYZhVgbZcihYZk^\cZ#
™JcZgZhhdjgXZYZegdm^b^i‚X]ZoaZh
^cYjhig^Zah Yj Wd^h Zi YVch aZh idc"
cZaaZg^Zh#
™Jc egdXZhh YZ [VWg^XVi^dc Zc igd^h
e]VhZh/h‚X]V\ZYZhbVi^ƒgZhegZ"
b^ƒgZh!WgdnV\ZZi[Vg^cV\ZZiXdb"
eVXiV\Z#
™AZh
\gVcja‚h hZ XdchZgkZci W^Zc
adghfjZaZjgiVjmY¼]jb^Y^i‚hZh^ijZ
ZcigZ-Zi&D#
B_djƒh_[khZki_beZ[ijeYaW][Wl[Yb[iekl[hjkh[iikfƒh_[kh[if[hc[jjWdjb[h[cfb_iiW][$
jcZXdchZgkVi^dc|jciVjmY¼]jb^Y^i‚YZ-
Zi &%! XZ fj^ gZeg‚hZciZ jc \V\Z YZ g‚"
\jaVg^i‚edjgaVbVˆig^hZYZaVXdbWjhi^dc#
AZigVch[ZgieVg\gVk^i‚YZhig‚b^ZhkZghaZ
Wg’aZjg gZheZXiZ a¼^ci‚\g^i‚ YZh \gVcja‚h
Zi a^b^iZ aZ Y‚\V\ZbZci YZ edjhh^ƒgZh fj^
hdciidj_djghegdWa‚bVi^fjZh#
Kd[kd_jƒf_bej[\edYj_edd[
[d?i„h[Z[fk_i(&'&
A¼}bZ YZ XZiiZ cdjkZaaZ Y^hi^aaZg^Z hZ h^ijZ
Vj c^kZVj YZ aV XZaajaZ YZ XdbWjhi^dc YZ
aV X]VjY^ƒgZ# 6j Y‚eVgi! aZh ‚X]Vc\Zh Zc"
igZ ?#"A# BZgX^Zg Zi I]^Zggn GZbWa^Zg! aZ
gZhedchVWaZ egdYjXi^dc Yj Y‚eVgiZbZci
Y^hi^aaVi^dc YZ aV hdX^‚i‚ 8]Vak^\cVX '!
dci edgi‚ hjg aZh edhh^W^a^i‚h Y¼VYVeiVi^dc
Y¼jc hnhiƒbZ YZ X]Vj[[V\Z Vjm \gVcja‚h
YZ Wd^h Vjm Zm^\ZcXZh fjVa^iVi^kZh YZ aV
Y^hi^aaVi^dc X]VgZciV^hZ# AV g‚Va^hVi^dc Zc
'%&% Zc >hƒgZ Y¼jcZ Y^hi^aaZg^Z VkZX igd^h
VaVbW^Xh X]Vj[[‚h Vjm \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h V
‚i‚ edjg aZ XdchigjXiZjg jc WVcX Y¼ZhhV^h
g^X]Z Y¼ZchZ^\cZbZcih Zc bVi^ƒgZ YZ XV"
eVX^i‚h iZX]cdad\^fjZh Zi YZ bVˆig^hZ YZ
™AZ edjkd^g XVadg^ÃfjZ YZh \gVcja‚h
a¼ji^a^hVi^dc# I]# GZbWa^Zg Xdch^YƒgZ fjZ
a¼ji^a^hVi^dc Y¼jc XdbWjhi^WaZ XdbbZ aZh
\gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h c‚XZhh^iZ aZ Y‚kZadeeZ"
bZci Y¼jc egdXZhh iZX]cdad\^fjZ ‚kdaj‚
fj^ZhiZck^hV\ZVWaZ\g}XZ|a¼ji^a^hVi^dcYZ
igVch[Zgih YZ iZX]cdad\^Z/ ®FjVcY cdigZ
egZb^ZgXa^ZciYVcha¼>hƒgZcdjhVhdaa^X^i‚h
Zc'%&%edjgbdciZgYZhVaVbW^XhX]Vj[[‚h
Vjm\gVcja‚hYZWd^h!dekiWledihƒfedZk
}iWZ[cWdZ[[ddekWdjZ[iYedjWYjiWl[Y
kd fWhj[dW_h[ gk_ cW‰jh_iW_j b½kj_b_iWj_ed
Z[i ]hWdkbƒi Z[ Xe_i ZWdi Z½Wkjh[i Ze#
cW_d[i$ Deki Wledi _djƒ]hƒ kd Xh“b[kh }
W_h iek\Ń ZWdi kd \eo[h Z½WbWcX_Y gk_ W
ƒjƒ jejWb[c[dj h[f[diƒ fekh kj_b_i[h Y[
dekl[Wk YecXkij_Xb[$ B[i fh[c_„h[i i[#
cW_d[iZ½kj_b_iWj_ededjYedÄhcƒb½_djƒh…j
Z[ Y[jj[ ZƒcWhY^[ [j [dik_j[ bW hƒWb_iW#
j_edZ[gk[bgk[iWcƒdW][c[djiWf[hc_i
Z[ ÄWX_b_i[h b[ fheYƒZƒ$ AV YZbVcYZ YZ
B#BZgX^Zg‚iV^ieajhXdbeaZmZXVgaZhZm^"
\ZcXZhfjVa^iVi^kZhYZaVY^hi^aaVi^dcX]VgZc"
iV^hZ hdci eg‚X^hZh# Dc hdj]V^iV^i Vkd^g jc
XdbWjhi^WaZYdciaZedjkd^gXVadg^ÃfjZhd^i
XdccjZihiVWaZYVchaZiZbeh#BWdej_edZ[
gkWb_jƒ Z[i ]hWdkbƒi Z[ Xe_i c_i [d ·k#
lh[ deki fWhW‰j _cfehjWdj[$ BW fh_dY_fWb[
Zhi a^‚ | aV cVijgZ YZh ZhhZcXZh YZ
Wd^hfj^aZhXdbedhZci#
™9Zh \gVcja‚h | WVhZ YZ Y‚X]Zih YZ
X]„cZ Zi YZ g‚h^cZjm dci jc E8> YZ
*@XVa$`\#
™9Zh\gVcja‚h|WVhZYZhVgbZcihYZ
Wd^hdcijcE8>YZ)!*`XVa$`\#
™AZ igVchedgi YZh \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h
ZckgVXh¼Z[[ZXijZ[VX^aZbZcieVgYZh
XVb^dch‚fj^e‚hYZWgVhbdW^aZhYZ
Y‚X]Vg\ZbZci#
™AZ eg^m ^cY^XVi^[ YZh \gVcja‚h YZ
Wd^ha^kg‚hkVg^ZZciZ&-%Zi'*%æ$i
hZadc aZjg Xdbedh^i^dc Zi aZh kdaj"
bZhVX]Zi‚h#
bZchjZac•&&).DEL;C8H;(&')B[FWoiWdK><C:GDC>&,
:?IJ?BB7J?ED
Z_\ÄYkbjƒWƒjƒZ[jhekl[hkdXh“b[khgk_W_j
kd[ƒj[dZk[Z[fbW][iZ[\edYj_edd[c[dj
[jZ[ifeii_X_b_jƒiZ[ceZkbWj_edZ½Wbbkh[
Zk\[kfhƒY_i[i[j[\ÄYWY[i$BWZ_ij_bbWj_ed
Z[i[Wkn#Z[#l_[Z[9e]dWYdƒY[ii_j[Z[bW
hƒWYj_l_jƒ fekh fekii[h [j hWb[dj_h b[i Wb#
bkh[i Zk \[k Wk cec[dj effehjkd$ 7fh„i
Z_l[hi[i _dl[ij_]Wj_edi" deki deki iec#
c[i hWffheY^ƒi Zk YedijhkYj[kh _jWb_[d
J^[hceYWX_"gk_WZƒl[beffƒZ[iXh“b[khi
}Wbbkh[ilWh_WXb[i$8¼ZhijcYZXZh‚fj^eZ"
bZcihfj^V‚i‚bdci‚YVchaVY^hi^aaZg^ZYZ
B#BZgX^Zg#¯
Kd\eo[hifƒY_Ägk[[j
kdXh“b[kh}W_hiek\Ń
AV hdX^‚i‚ 8]Vak^\cVX V Xdchigj^i jc [dnZg
YZ XdbWjhi^dc eg‚[VWg^fj‚ Zci^ƒgZbZci
cdjkZVj! VkZX YZh bVi‚g^Vjm g‚[gVXiV^gZh
Y^[[‚gZcih Vj hZ^c YjfjZa V ‚i‚ bdci‚ jc
Wg’aZjg|V^ghdj[ĂVa^bZci‚VjidbVi^fjZ"
bZci Zc \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h# 9½[ij kd \eo[h
ƒjWdY^["Yed‚kfekhhƒi_ij[h}Z[id_l[Wkn
Z[ j[cfƒhWjkh[i ƒb[lƒi" gk_ Z_ifei[ Z½kd
lebkc[ X[WkYekf fbki _cfehjWdj ieki b[
\edZ Z[ bW Y^WkZ_„h[$ B[i jekhi } \[k [d
YZ XdbWjhi^dc eZgbZiiZci Y¼dei^b^hZg aZ
g‚\aV\ZYjgZ\^higZZiW^Zch’gY¼Vb‚a^dgZg
aZgZcYZbZciYZXdbWjhi^dc#
'&fWb_[hiZ[YecXkij_ed
edjge^adiZgidjiZh
aZhe]VhZhYZhXdjaV\Zh
Jc VjidbVi^hbZ ^ci‚\g‚ Vj Wg’aZjg \ƒgZ
YZ [Vdc h^bjaiVc‚Z a¼Va^bZciVi^dc Zc
\gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h Zi a¼VYb^hh^dc Y¼V^g YVch
aZ [dnZg! XZ fj^ eZgbZi YZ e^adiZg VkZX Z["
ÃXVX^i‚ aZ Y‚gdjaZbZci YZ aV XdbWjhi^dc#
B½ƒgk_f[c[djZ_ifei[Z['&fWb_[hiZ[hƒ#
]bW][iZ[b½_dj[di_jƒZ[bWYecXkij_edgk_
f[hc[jj[dj Z½_dj[hl[d_h [j Z[ fhe]hWc#
c[h bW fk_iiWdY[ Zk \[k$ ?b [ij feii_Xb[
Z[ fWhWcƒjh[h b[i fWb_[hi [d _dj[hl[dWdj
Z_h[Yj[c[dj ikh bW l_j[ii[ Z½Wb_c[djWj_ed
Z[i]hWdkbƒil_j[ii[Z[hejWj_edZ[bWl_i
fekh WZWfj[h b[ Y^e_n Z[i Wbbkh[i Z[ \[k
Wkn Z[cWdZ[i ƒd[h]ƒj_gk[i Z_\\ƒh[dj[i
Z[iZ_l[hi[iiƒgk[dY[iZ[iYekbW][i$B[i
hƒ]bW][i Z[i fWb_[hi Z[ YecXkij_ed iedj
efj_c_iƒiWl[Ykd[kj_b_iWj_edZ[]hWdkbƒi
WoWdjkdfekle_hZ[YecXkij_ed^ece]„d[
[jijWXb[$I]#GZbWa^ZgVYZbVcY‚|aVhd"
X^‚i‚I]ZgbdXVW^YZY‚kZadeeZgjcVjidbV"
i^hbZYZe^adiV\ZYjWg’aZjg^ci‚\gVcieajh
YZeVa^ZghYZg‚\aV\Zhedjgg‚edcYgZ|YZh
ViiZciZh YZ XdjgWZh YZ XdjaV\Z eajh Xdb"
eaZmZh# AZh \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h YZhXZcYZci
eVg \gVk^i‚ YZh ig‚b^Zh YZ hidX`V\Z YVch
jcXV^hhdcYZhidX`V\Z^ciZgb‚Y^V^gZd‘^ah
hdci gZeg^h eVg jcZ eZi^iZ k^h Y¼6gX]^bƒYZ
Va^bZciVci Y^gZXiZbZci aZ Wg’aZjg# 6kVci
X]VfjZVaajbV\ZYjWg’aZjg!jcZeZi^iZ^c"
_ZXi^dcY¼V^gcZiid^ZaVi„iZYZXdbWjhi^dc#
AZh XZcYgZh idbWZci eVg \gVk^i‚ YVch aZ
[dcYYj[dnZgZihdci‚a^b^c‚ZheVga¼Vgg^ƒgZ
Yj[dnZg^ckZgh‚#
:[iYekbW][icW‰jh_iƒi
ZiYZhgZidjghYZY‚\jhiVi^dc
ZVjm"YZ"k^ZZcXdjgV\ZVcih
J^_[hhoH[cXb_[h[jF^_b_ff[J_ped"Z[bWieY_ƒjƒ
9^Wbl_]dWY$
_den" gk_ edj kd[ YedÄ]khWj_ed YbWii_gk["
iedj _iebƒi Wl[Y Z[i cWjƒh_Wkn Z[ dek#
l[bb[ ]ƒdƒhWj_ed$ B[ Xh“b[kh ƒc[j kd[
ÅWcc[^eh_pedjWb[fWhWbb„b[Wk\edZZ[bW
Y^WkZ_„h[gk_[ijbƒ]„h[c[dj_dYb_dƒ[l[hi
b[XWi$9[jj[fei_j_ed[ij_cfehjWdj[fekh
ƒl_j[hgk½_bd[i[fheZk_i[fWiZ[fe_djiZ[
Y^Wk\\[Wkd_l[WkZk\edZZ[iY^WkZ_„h[i$
JcZ kZci^aVi^dc ^chj[ÄZ YZ a¼V^g YVch aV
X]VbWgZ YZ XdbWjhi^dc edjg VhhjgZg aZ
Y‚gdjaZbZci Yj [Zj hZadc jcZ ^ciZch^i‚
bdYjaVWaZ#AZh[jb‚ZhhdciZmigV^iZhYVch
jcZ X]Zb^c‚Z XaVhh^fjZ VkZX jc gZ\^higZ
fj^gZhiZZceZgbVcZcXZYVchjcZedh^i^dc
ÃmZYjgVciaZhX]Vj[[Zh#A¼^chiVaaVi^dcY¼jc
Y‚eg^bdbƒigZ Zi aV g‚Va^hVi^dc Y¼VcVanhZh
?#"A# BZgX^Zg ‚iV^i eaZ^cZbZci XdchX^Zci
fjZ aZh egZb^ƒgZh _djgc‚Zh YZ Y^hi^aaVi^dc
VkZXaZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^hc¼VaaV^ZcieVh„igZ
h^beaZhZiXZaVV‚i‚aZXVh#A¼jcZYZheg^c"
X^eVaZhY^[ÃXjai‚hV‚i‚VjY‚eVgiY¼^ci‚\gZg
aZh he‚X^ÃX^i‚h Yj Y‚gdjaZbZci YZh Xdb"
Wjhi^dch Vjm \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h/ ®?¼VkV^h
eaZ^cZbZci XdchX^ZcXZ fjZ a¼ji^a^hVi^dc
Y¼jc cdjkZVj XdbWjhi^WaZ XdbbZ aZh
\gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h VaaV^i b¼dWa^\Zg | gZXVaZg
idjiaZY‚gdjaZbZciYZhXnXaZhYZXdjaV\Zh#
CWfh_dY_fWb[_dgk_ƒjkZ[ƒjW_jX_[di“hbW
gkWb_jƒ Z[i [Wkn#Z[#l_[$ 7l[Y b[ ]Wp" b[i
f^Wi[i Z[ YekbW][ } XWii[i fh[ii_edi Wk
d_l[Wk Z[i c_i[i Wk YekhWdj" Zk YekbW][
Zk Y·kh [j Z[ bW Yekf[" d[ f[kl[dj …jh[
X_[d cW‰jh_iƒ[i gk[ ]h~Y[ } kd[ fWh\W_j[
ceZkbWj_ed Zk \[k$ AZ Wg’aZjg | \gVcja‚h
YZ Wd^h YZkV^i Vkd^g aV b„bZ g‚VXi^k^i‚
Y¼ji^a^hVi^dc edjg gVaZci^g dj VXX‚a‚gZg aZ
&->B[FWoiWdK><C:GDCDEL;C8H;(&')bZchjZac•&&).
B[Xh“b[kh_dl[hiƒWl[YiedWb_c[djWj_ed
WkjecWj_iƒ[[jbWkjecWj[Z[f_bejW][Zk\[k$
[Zj# 8¼‚iV^i a¼‚a‚bZci fj^ b¼^cfj^‚iV^i aZ
eajh# ?Z cZ hdj]V^iV^h eVh fjZ a¼VaVbW^X
hd^i‚fj^e‚YZhnhiƒbZVjidbVi^h‚YZXdc"
Yj^iZYZhXdjaV\Zhedjg_jhiZbZciVeegZc"
YgZ | \‚gZg aZ [Zj ^hhj YZ aV XdbWjhi^dc
YZh \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h# ³ cW ]hWdZ[ ikh#
fh_i["b[Xh“b[kh[ijjh„ihƒWYj_\[jiekfb[
Z½kj_b_iWj_edbehiZ[ic_i[iWkYekhWdjek
Wkcec[djZ[bWYekf[$EdjgXdcYj^gZaZh
XnXaZhYZXdjaV\Z!_Zgƒ\aZaVej^hhVcXZYj
[Zj\g}XZ|YZjmediZci^dbƒigZh!a¼jcYZh"
i^c‚ Vjm c^kZVjm YZ XdbWjhi^dch ‚aZk‚h Zi
a¼VjigZ Vjm c^kZVjm eajh WVh# ?¼ji^a^hZ YZh
\gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h Ydci aZ [djgc^hhZjg! aV
hdX^‚i‚ 9jgZeV^gZ | KZgY^aaZ! VhhjgZ fjZ
aZ edjkd^g XVadg^ÃfjZ Zhi XdchiVci# 7fh„i
gk[bgk[i`ekhiZ[j~jedd[c[dj"`[ik_iWh#
h_lƒ } YWb[h b[i YoYb[i Z[ YekbW][ Z[ l_di
[jb[iXedd[iY^Wk\\[icƒj^eZ[Z[Z_ij_b#
bWj_ed>[dd[iio"cW_ib[lƒh_jWXb[l[hZ_Yj
WƒjƒbWZƒ]kijWj_edZ[iƒY^Wdj_bbedi$B[i
h[jekhiZ[iYecc[djW_h[iZ[Zƒ]kijWj_ed
i½Wl„h[dj[dYekhW][Wdji"Y[gk_fekhce_
[ij [ii[dj_[b$ 9Zej^h bV^ciZcVci fjVigZ
hZbV^cZh! aZh XdjaV\Zh hZ Y‚gdjaZci cdg"
bVaZbZciZiaZheVgVbƒigZhYZg‚\aV\ZYj
Wg’aZjg YZk^ZccZci YZ eajh Zc eajh [VX^aZh
|\‚gZg#¯
B½_dÅk[dY[[ii[dY[Z[Xe_i
hjgaZedjkd^gXVadg^ÃfjZ
YZh\gVcja‚h
AZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^hhdci[VWg^fj‚h|eVgi^g
YZ hX^jgZ Zi YZ XdeZVjm fj^ hdci XdaaZXi‚h
Vjegƒh Y¼^cYjhig^Zah Yj Wd^h fj^ ‚kdajZci
YVch YZh hZXiZjgh Y¼VXi^k^i‚h Y^[[‚gZcih#
AdXVaZbZci!aVhdX^‚i‚9jgZeV^gZ(!^chiVa"
a‚Z|KZgY^aaZ!egdYj^iYZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^h
YZej^h egZhfjZ Y^m Vch Zi aV egd\gZhh^dc
YZhkZciZhZhiVhhZoheZXiVXjaV^gZ#AV[VWg^"
XVi^dc YZh \gVcja‚h c‚XZhh^iZ YZh bdnZch
iZX]cdad\^fjZh ^bedgiVcih edjg VhhjgZg
Y^[[‚gZciZh de‚gVi^dch / aZ h‚X]V\Z YZh
bVi^ƒgZh egZb^ƒgZh hX^jgZ Zi XdeZVjm! aZ
[Vg^cV\ZYZhY‚X]ZihZiZchj^iZaV[VWg^XV"
i^dcegdegZbZciY^iZYZh\gVcja‚h#EVig^X`
B‚cVgY!aZgZhedchVWaZYZaVhdX^‚i‚9jgZ"
eV^gZ!Xdch^YƒgZfjZ!g‚\^dcVaZbZci!aVgZh"
hdjgXZ Zc Y‚X]Zih YZ Wd^h Zhi ^bedgiVciZ
edjg‚aVWdgZgaZh\gVcja‚h/®AVeg‚hZcXZ
YZ cdbWgZjhZh idccZaaZg^Zh Zi YZ hX^Zg^Zh
YVchaVg‚\^dccdjheZgbZiYZcdjhVeegd"
k^h^dccZg [VX^aZbZci Zc XdeZVjm YZ X]„cZ
Zi YZ g‚h^cZjm# AZ b‚aVc\Z YZ XZh YZjm
ZhhZcXZh YZ Wd^h eZgbZi Y¼‚aVWdgZg YZh
\gVcja‚hVnVcijcedjkd^gXVadg^ÃfjZ‚aZk‚#
Cdjh Vkdch Vjhh^ b^h Zc eaVXZ jcZ Ãa^ƒgZ
YZegdYjXi^dc|eVgi^gYZhVgbZciYZk^\cZ
fjZ cdjh XdaaZXidch Zi igV^idch | a¼jh^cZ#
B½ƒbWXehWj_edZ[i]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_idƒY[i#
i_j[ kd fheY[ii j[Y^debe]_gk[ fWhj_Ykb_[h
gk[ deki cW‰jh_iedi jejWb[c[dj ikh b[
i_j[Z[L[hZ_bb[$Kd]hWdkbƒ[ijkdfheZk_j
ijWXb[ gk_ i[ Yedi[hl[ X_[d i_ ied jWkn
Z½^kc_Z_jƒi[i_jk[[djh[.[j'&cWn_#
ckc$B[fekle_hYWbeh_Ägk[Z[i]hWdkbƒi
[ij Z_h[Yj[c[dj Zƒf[dZWdj Z[i [ii[dY[i
Z[ Xe_i gk_ b[i Yecfei[dj$ Deki Yec#
c[hY_Wb_iedi Z[kn jof[i Z[ fheZk_ji 0 Zk
F_YjeXe_i}XWi[Z[\[k_bbki[jZ[hƒi_d[kn
WoWdjkdF9?Z[+aYWb%a]"[jZ[i]hWdkbƒi
Z[iWhc[djiZ[l_]d[WoWdjkdF9?ce_d#
Zh[Z[*"+aYWb%a]$AZhidX`V\ZY¼jcZidccZ
YZ\gVcja‚hc‚XZhh^iZjckdajbZY¼Zck^gdc
&!*b(# B#BZgX^Zg ji^a^hZ Yj E^XidWd^h fjZ
cdjh a^kgdch VkZX jc XVb^dc ‚fj^e‚ Y¼jc
WgVhYZY‚X]Vg\ZbZcibdW^aZ#¯
KdYe“jZ[(+ç>J
YZ\gVcja‚hYZWd^h
edjgY^hi^aaZg&]aY¼6E
AV Y^hi^aaZg^Z Vjm \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h YdccZ
hVi^h[VXi^dc|6#Zi?#"A#BZgX^ZghjgaZeaVc
iZX]c^fjZ! bV^h a¼^ckZhi^hhZbZci YVch aV
XZaajaZ YZ XdbWjhi^dc cdjkZaaZ Zhi W^Zc
B[ife_djiYbƒiZ[bWZ_ij_bb[h_[
Z7$[j@$#B$C[hY_[h
™JcZ Y^hi^aaZg^Z cZjkZ eZch‚Z edjg
[dcXi^dccZgVjm\gVcja‚hYZWd^h^c"
i‚\g‚Z YVch jc W}i^bZci XdcX^a^Vci
[dcXi^dccVa^i‚! b^hZ Vjm cdgbZh Zi
VgX]^iZXijgZ#
™Jc VaVbW^X YZ '* ]a ‚fj^e‚ Y¼jc
Wg’aZjg | V^g hdj[Ă Va^bZci‚ Zc
Xdci^cjeVgYZh\gVcja‚hYZWd^h#
™Jc [dnZg ‚iVcX]Z Y¼jcZ XdcXZei^dc
he‚X^ÃfjZ edjg hjeedgiZg YZh
c^kZVjm YZ iZbe‚gVijgZh ‚aZk‚h Zi
^ci‚\g‚jcWg’aZjg^ccdkVci#
™Jc
VjidbVi^hbZ YZ e^adiV\Z YZ
aV XdbWjhi^dc bdYjaVWaZ VkZX &%
eVa^ZghYZg‚\aV\ZhYZa¼^ciZch^i‚Yj
[Zj#
™AZhdj]V^iYZ?#"A#BZgX^ZgYZcZeVh
ji^a^hZgedjga¼^chiVciY¼VjidbVi^hbZ
YZ \Zhi^dc YZh XdjaV\Zh edjg
VeegZcYgZ|bVˆig^hZgaVXdbWjhi^dc
YZh\gVcja‚h#
™JcZXZaajaZYZXdbWjhi^dchdjeaZ|
XdcYj^gZYj[V^iYZaVWdccZg‚VXi^k^"
i‚Vjc^kZVjYZaVXdcYj^iZYj[Zj#
™9ZhXnXaZhYZXdjaV\ZhYZk^chZiYZ
WdccZh X]Vj[[Zh ^YZci^fjZh | XZjm
Y¼jcVaVbW^XVj\Vo#
™Jc Xd’i YZh \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h YZ
'* æ =I edjg Y^hi^aaZg jc ]ZXida^igZ
Y¼VaXddaejg#
h’geajh‚aZk‚fjZXZaj^Y¼jcZX]VjY^ƒgZVj
\Vo#AZh‚Xdcdb^ZhYZXd’iYZXdbWjhi^WaZ
eZgbZiiZci"ZaaZhY¼Zck^hV\ZgjcgZidjghjg
^ckZhi^hhZbZci YVch YZh Y‚aV^h gV^hdc"
cVWaZh#6egƒhjcbd^hYZY^hi^aaVi^dc!?#"A#
BZgX^ZgVjcZ^Y‚ZVhhZoeg‚X^hZYZhXdc"
hdbbVi^dchYZ\gVcja‚hYZWd^h/®9Zej^h
igd^h hZbV^cZh! a¼VaVbW^X [dcXi^dccZ YZ
bVc^ƒgZ cdgbVaZ Zc iZgbZh YZ Yjg‚Z YZ
XdjaV\Z Zi cdjh Vkdch jcZ ^Y‚Z eajh _jhiZ
YZh XdchdbbVi^dch YZ \gVcja‚h YZ Wd^h#
;d ceo[dd[" _b \Wkj ''& } '(&a] Z[ ]hW#
dkbƒifekhZ_ij_bb[hkd^bZ½WbYeebfkh$7l[Y
kdfh_nZ½WY^WjZ[iF_YjeXe_iZ[((+ç>J%
j" b[ fh_n Z[ h[l_[dj Zk YecXkij_Xb[ fekh
Z_ij_bb[h '^b Z½WbYeeb fkh i[ i_jk[ Wkjekh
Z[(+ç>J$B½ƒYedec_[Z[Ye“jfWhhWffehj
Wk ]Wp [ij Z½[dl_hed '+ç >J%^b Z½WbYeeb
fkh$B½_dl[ij_ii[c[djZWdib[Xh“b[kh[jb[
\eo[hWkn]hWdkbƒiZ[Xe_i[ijd[jj[c[dj
fbkiƒb[lƒ1)&}*&Z[fbkifWhhWffehj
} kd \eo[h ]Wp Z[ Z[hd_„h[i ]ƒdƒhWj_edi$
9[jj[Wddƒ["bWZ_ij_bbWj_edZ½[dl_hed)-&^b
Z½WbYeeb fkh lW ]ƒdƒh[h kd[ ƒYedec_[ Z[
YecXkij_Xb[Z[fbkiZ[+&&&ç>J"Y[gk_
d½[ijfWidƒ]b_][WXb[$6jkjYZXZX]^[[gZ!
aZhjgXd’iY¼^ckZhi^hhZbZciYVchaVXZaajaZ
YZ XdbWjhi^dc kV „igZ gVe^YZbZci Vbdg"
i^# 6j"YZa| a¼^ci‚g„i ‚Xdcdb^fjZ! aZ [dcX"
i^dccZbZciYZhXZaajaZhYZXdbWjhi^dcVjm
\gVcja‚hYZWd^hY‚\V\Z)|*[d^hbd^chYZ
\Vo|Z[[ZiYZhZggZYVcha¼Vibdhe]ƒgZfjZ
YZhXZaajaZh[dcXi^dccVciVjm‚cZg\^Zh[dh"
h^aZh#8Zi‚a‚bZciZhiVjhh^^bedgiVciedjg
cdjh fj^ hdbbZh YZh V\g^XjaiZjgh hdj"
X^ZjmYZeg‚hZgkZga¼Zck^gdccZbZci#¯
B_ed[b:kYec
&HdX^‚i‚6g`dhZ!gjZYZhIZggZh"CZjkZh!((&(%
7ƒ\aZh# " GjZ YZ HZ\dcoVX! &+&%% 8d\cVX# I‚a#
%**+..)))%0%*)*-')&'-#
'HdX^‚i‚8]Vak^\cVXEgja]d9^hi^aaVi^dc!O68Yj
bVhYZaV8djg!gjZ;gVcd^h"B^iiZggVcY!&+&%%
8]}iZVjWZgcVgY#I‚a#%*)*(**(#
( HdX^‚i‚ 9jgZeV^gZ! ^beVhhZ Yj Ad\^h! &+&)%
KZgY^aaZ#I‚a#%*)*'&%%-&#
4 1 a n s d ’ e x p é r i e n c e 1 9 7 2 -­ 2 0 1 3
MARTIN
Dominique
Réfection de cuverie béton
et métallique
Décapage à l’eau
Ultra haute pression (U.H.P.)
Revêtements alimentaires
Bassin de collecte
Conception et installation
sur mesure
Revêtements de sol
Vinasse de distillation
et tous effluents
CUVERIE
EFFLUENTS
22, bd Oscar Planat -­ BP 159 -­ 1605 COGNAC Cedex -­ Tél : 05 45 35 04 74 -­ Fax : 05 45 35 38 17
S i t e : w w w . m a r t i n -­ d o m i n i q u e . f r -­ E -­ m a i l : e r i c . m a r t i n @ m a r t i n -­ d o m i n i q u e . f r
bZchjZac•&&).DEL;C8H;(&')B[FWoiWdK><C:GDC>&.

Documents pareils