BORDEAUX REDS – FRANCE

Transcription

BORDEAUX REDS – FRANCE
Best Buys are bolded below and summarized in a separate section
WINERY*
WINE / APPELATION & YEAR
A Nos Amours
Bordeaux 09/10
Dom de l’A
Cotes de Castillon 05-10
AWARDS & RECOGNITION
10 70%Merlot-25%CF-5%CS
07 65%M-30%CS-CF
Ch L’Abbeye
Blaye Cote de Bordeaux 08
08 Very Successful Hachette 11
Haut-Medoc 09
09 Comm’d Decanter; IWC 12
Ch de L’Abbaye St-Ferme
Bordeaux Sup Les Vignes du Soir 02/03
Ch Abelyce
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06
RATINGS
PRICE
10 RP=88
09 RP=86-88
10 $23 RP
10 TWCI=91-93
10/09 ST=89
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=88
08 JJB=90-92
08 RP=89-91
07 WS=87
07 ST=89
07 RP=88
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=92-94
05 ST=91
04 ST=89
04 WS=80-84
08 Hachette=1 star
09 $30-38 RP
08 $26 WS
08 $27 JJB
07 $28 Zachys
07 $25 RP
05 $43 Zachys
L’Absolut de Ch Quinault
06
03 WR=88
02 WR=85
06 WS=86
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=84
04 Hach=1star
06 RP=91
Acappella
Montagne St Emilion 07
07 RP=86-87
Ad Francois
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=88
Adaugusta
St-Emilion 09/10
10 ST=86
09 75%M-CF
09 WBlB=90
09 $25-49 WBlB
09 ST=87
10 RP=87
10 $20-25 RP
10 JR=14.5 (82)
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=86-88
10 RP=88
10 $15-20 RP
10 ST=86
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5/20
08 WS=86
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=79-82
06 WS=85
06 $30 WS
05 SS=16.5/20
05 $27 WS
05 WS=90
05 $20 Zachys
05 ST=85-87
04 WE=91
04 WS=87
04 Gold Challenge 07
09 Great Value at $25 WBlB
Ad Vitam
Bordeaux 08/09/10
Ch D’Agassac
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-10
09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter
05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09
05 “Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09
05 Silver Paris 07
04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08
03/02 $10 WR
06 $55 RP
10 $20 RP
1
Ch D’Aiguilhe
03 Hachette=1star
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
10 RP=91
10 ST=89
10 TWCI=90-92
09 ST=89
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=90-92
08 WS=88
08 JJB=88-91
07 WS=90
07 ST=88
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 02-11
05 No, thank you WD 4/06
04=80%CS-29%CF
03 Smart Buy WS 06
Seigneurs d’Aiguilde 04-08 (Merlot)
06 WS=90
06 RP=88
06 ST=87-89
05 WS=92
05 RP=92
05 NM=93 & 92
05 ST=91
05 WD=12.5-13.5
04 ST=87-88
04 WS=88
04 RP=89
03 WS=91
03 RP=90
03 ST=89
02 RP=87
02 ST=88
02 WS=89
08 WS=87
06 RP=90
05 Bronze IWC 07
04 Silver Decanter 06
Ch D’Aiguilhe Querre
09 Outperformed Price JJB
06 Decent style WD
05 Cited Wine Hachette 09
03 Vin Remauquable Hachette 07
Alexandre Sirech
Bordeaux Le Bordeaux 10
Ch Alfa la Bernarde
Prem Cotes de blaye 03/04/05/08
D’Alienor
Bordeaux Sup 08
08 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Sup Sel Maracan 08
08 Silver LA 10
Ch Allegret
Bordeaux 09/10/11
11/10 Silver LA 12/11
09 Gold LA 10
Alter Ego de Ch Palmer
Margaux 04-10 (Ch Palmer’s second wine)
10/09 51%Merlot- 49%CS
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
09 JJB=91-93
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=86-88
07 RP=88
07 RC=88
07 CellarT=90 (5)
06 WD=14-15/20
06 ST=86-89
05 ST=88-90
05 RP=92
05 WS=92
04 ST=88
04 RP=87
03 Hach=2star
03 WS=75-79
02 ST=87
10 WS=86
11 $22JJB Fut
10 $22-42 RP
09 $14 JJB
08 $20 K&L
08 $22 WS
08 $25 WClub
07 $25 K&L
07 $22 WS
07 $20 JJB
06 $25 K&L
06 $19-30 RP
06 $25 Zachys
05 $36 K&L
05 $40 WClub
05 C$55 NM
03 $30 K&L
02 $20 WS
08 $18 WS
06 C$20 LCBO
06 $15 K&L
05 £4 IWC
10 $14 WS
10 $16-32 RP
09 $14 JJB
08 $15 JJB
07 $17-28 RP
07 $22 Zachys
07 $19 K&L
07 $9 JJB
05 $36 K&L
05 $16-19 RP
04 $10-17 RP
03 $30 K&L
`0 $16 WS
08 WS=85
05 WS=80-84
04 WS=79
03 WS=78
08 $13 WS
10/09 ST=88
09 RP=89-92
09 $55+ ST
09 $48-66 RP
2
09 WBlB=90
08 RP=89-90
05 Big, juicy, velvety, long WW 06
05 One of Top 8 “Seconds” QWR
Les Amants de mont-Perat
Bordeaux 05/06/07
07 Gold Bordeaux 09
Amauton
Fronsac 09
09 Outdtanding Value WBlB
L’Amboisie du Ch la Croix Lalande-de-Pomerol 03/05/06/07
des Moines
07 Silver Brussels 10
06 Grand Gold Brussels 09
08 WE=88-90
08 WS=87-90
08 JJB=87-89
07 ST=87
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=86-89
07 RP=87-89
06 WE=89
06 RP=87
06 AG=89
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=89-91
05 WS=82
05 ST=87-90
05 WE=91/89
05 RP=90-92
04 ST=87-90
04 WS=88
04 WS=88-90
03 WS=88
03 RP=87
02 WS=89
02 RP=89
05 WE=88
09 WBlB=90
09 RP=90-92
09 WS=88-91
Lalande-de-Pomerol 05/08 (M-CF-CS)
Amiral de Beychevelle
St-Julien 05
05 WS=83
Ch Amelisse
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=88
Ch Ampelia
Cotes de Castillon 06/07/08/09/10
Ch l’Ancien
Lalande-de-Pomerol 06-10
10 RP=89
09 WBlB=87
09 RP=87-89
08 WS=87
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=87-88
06 RP=87
04 IWE=87
05 NM=88
Cotes de Castillon Cuvee Carolle 05
07 C$60 BCLS
07 $37-48 RP
07 $44 Zachys
07 $43-70 RP
06 $32-62 RP
06 C$80 AG
05 $51 WS
05 $47 Zachys
05 $28-56 RP
09 $12 WBlB
09 $15 K&L
06 WS=88
05 WS=86
04 WS=84
03 WS=90
01 WS=87
08 ST=88
05 WE=90
Ch Ame de Musset
09 Great Value a4 $21 WBlB
09 $51 WBlB
08 $40-56 RP
08 $40 K&L
08 $60 Zachys
10 $10-18 RP
09 $21-41 WBlB
08 $20 WS
08 $10-20 RP
07 $10-12 RP
06 $13 RP
05 C$25 NM
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 Merlot
06 WS=90
05 WS=88
05 RP=84-86
03 WS=85-88
Ch les Ancres
Bordeaux 09/10
Andre Lurton
Bordeaux Merlot-Cab Sauv 08
Andrea Franchetti
Cuvee Numero 3 Winemaker’s Selection 07
10 Bronze Decanter 12
09 Silver LA 11
08 Silver LA 12
07 RP=87-90
07 $25 RP
3
Ch Andron Blanquet
St-Estephe 03/04/05/08/09/10
10 RP=85
10 $25 RP
09 WE=90
u08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
Ch Aney
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 05/09
05 IWR=87
04 WE=86
03 WS=87
09 Futures offered by Kermit Lynch
05 Gold Brussels 09
05 Good SFCh 3/28/08
03 $15 WS
09 $258/12
09 $22 WClub
09 $28 Astor
05 SFCh=2star
05 WE=83
05 $24 SFCh
Ch Angelique Monbousquet St-Emilion 05
05 WS=81
05 $30 WS
Les Angelots de Gracia
08 RP=91-93
07 RP=80
07 ST=88
06 RP=89
06 ST=88-90
05 RP=91-93
Ch Aney d’Amaussan
Ch l’Angelus
Haut-Medoc 05
St-Emilion 03-09 (Gloria’s second wine)
St-Emilion PGC 99-10
07 $85-110 RP
06 $52 RP
05 $60 RP
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07
10 55%Merlot-45%CF
10 ST=91
10 $350+ ST
10 TWCI=96-98
09 60%M-CF
09 WE=95
09 ST=92
09 WBlB=96
09 RP=96-100
09 $297-394 RP
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5/20
08 WE=94
08 RP=92-94
08 $100-208RP
08 ST=90
08 $225 Zachys
08 WS=89-92
08 $170 K&L
08 JJB=90-92/89-91
07 RP=92
07 $159-198 RP
07 WE=92
07 WS=88-91
07 $170 K&L
07 ST=91
07 $180 Zachys
06 RP=95
06 $147-463 RP
06 Coup de Coeurs Hachette 06
06 WE=92/96/97 06 C$299 BCLS
06 WE=94/95
06 Decent WD
06 WD=15-16/20
06 RP=92-95
06 $189-288 RP
06 ST=92-93
06 WS=93
06 $215 WS
05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96
05 $400 W&S
05 Magnificently concentrated WW 06 05 WS=96
05 $295 WS
05 Magnificent SS in Decanter 06
05 RP=96-99
05 $234-385 RP
05 SS=19/20
05 C$475 BCLS
05 ST=96
05 WW=96-98
05 WE=94
04 RP=92-94
04 WS=91
04 ST=91
03 WS=94
03 RP=92-94
03 ST=92
02 WS=91
02 RP=91
02 ST=90
01 WS=92
01 RP=93
01 ST=91
4
00 WS=97
00 ST=93
00 RP=93-96
99 RP=88
99 WS=89
99 RP=88
99 ST=88
See also their second label Carillon d’Angelus
Ch d’Angludet
Margaux Cru Bourgeois Sup 02-10
10 50%CS-38%Merlot-12%PV
10 ST=88
09 ST=88
09 RP=88-91
08 WE=90-92
08 Decanter=4star
08 SS=16.5/20
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=87
07 WS=87
06 Top Pick K&L
Ch Anthonic
Antoine Moueix
Ch L’Apolline
Ch Tour de Copet St-Emilion GC 08
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
06 AG=88
06 WE=89
05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1-1½star
05 WS=90
05 ST=87-90
05 WE=88/88
05 RP=90-92
05 SS=17/20
04 ST=86-88
04 WS=89
04 WE=88
04 RP=89
03 A success WD 10/05
03 WS=89
03 very Successful Hachette 07
03 Hach=1star
03 ST=87
03 RP=89
02 WS=88
02 RP=89
01 WS=89
10 RP=86
09 Gold Paris 11
09 WE=89
07 WE=90
06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 05 IWR=91
08 Gold Brussels 10
St-Emilion GC 08
08 Silver Brussels, Challenge 10
Bordeaux 08
08 Bronze Challenge 10
Bordeaux la Grande Chapelle 08
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06
Moulis-en-Medoc 06/07/09/10
06 WS=84
05 WS=83
04 RP=88
04 WS=85
09 $33+ ST
09 $31-39 RP
08 $24 K&L
07 $28-37 RP
07 $28 WS
07 $28 K&L
07 C$45 BCLS
06 $18-24 RP
06 $29 WS
06 C$39 BCLS
05 $50 K&L
05 $53 WS
04 $24 WS
10 $20 RP
07 $30 WE
04 $28 RP
04/03 Cited Wine Hachette 08/07
Ch Archambeau
Graves 05
Ch L’Archange
St-Emilion 03/04/05/06/07/08
03 RP=86-88
05 WS=84
08 WS=87
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=89
05 WS=91
05 NM=92
05 $42 Zachys
04 WS=91
06 $37 WS
05 $41WS
05 C$62 NM
5
Ch d’Arche
Haut-Medoc Cru Medoc Sup 03/05/06 (CS)
06 Bronze IWC 09
06 Comm’d Decanter 09
Ch d’Arcins (Castel)
Haut-Medoc 02-10
10 Silver Decanter; Bronze IWC 12
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CS-Merlot
03 WS=85-88
06 WS=82
05 WS=89
03 RP=90-93
03 WS=85
10 RP=88
10 WS=87
05 $30 Zachys
10 $22 RP
10 $25 WS
09 $19 Astor
07 Gold Paris 09
07 Silver IWSC 09
05 Silver Decanter, IWC 07
05 Bronze Bordeaux 07
04 Gold Brussels 06
04=Merlot
Ch d’Argadens (Sichel)
Grand Vin de Bordeaux 08/09
09/08 Comm’d IWC 12
08 CF-CS-Merlot
06 Silver LA 10
Ch L’Argenteyre
Medoc 10
10 Rec’d Decanter
10 Silver Paris 12
Ch l’Argilus de Roi
St-Estephe 04/05/08
Aria du Ch de la Riviere
Ch d’Armailhac
Fronsac 03/04/05
Paulliac 5th Cru Classe 03-10
06 WS=85
05 WE=87
05 WS=88
05 IWR=88
04 WE=87
04 WR=87
03 WS=84
02 WR=88
05 Outstanding for price QWR
05 Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 Impressively endowed WW 06
05 Comm’d IWC 07
05 $22 WS
04 $20 WR
10 WS=90
10 $19 WS
10 WE=87
10 $17 K&L
10 Decanter=15 (84)
10 JR=16.5 (90)
08 Gold Paris 11
05/04 Very Successful Hachette 09/08 05 WS=88
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=81
03 RP=90-92
03 WS=88
10 60%CS-23%Merlot-15%CF-2%PV 10 ST=86
10 JJB=91
09 ST=90
09 60%CS-24%M-14%CF-PV
09 RP=90-93
08 WS=89
08 RP=88-90
08 WS=89
08 JJB=86-88
08 JJB=85-87
07 RP=87
07 ST=90
07 WS=86-89
06 Very successful Hachette 10
06 $32 WS
06 RP=91
06 WE=88
06 ST=88-89
06 WS=89
06 AG=90
05 WS=90
05 WE=92/90
05 W&S=1star
05 RP=90-93
05 WS=89-91
05 ST=89+?
04 ST=88
04 WS=90
04 RP=89
04 WE=87
03 $30-35 RP
09 $39-62 RP
08 $32-67 RP
08 $38 Zachys
08 $35 K&L
08 $35 JJB
07 $28-37 RP
07 $36 Zachys
07 $48 B&M
07 C$59 BCLS
06 $28-95 RP
06 $60 B&M
06 $30 K&L
06 C$65 AG
05 $46 WS
05 $60 B&M
04 $34 B&M
04 $27-50 RP
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07
Ch Armens
St-Emilion GC 03-10`
10 55%CF-45%Merlot
03 ST=89
03 RP=90
10 ST=95
10 $1700+ ST
6
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
05Cited Wine Hachette 09
08 WS=89
Ch l’Armont
St-Emilion 08
06 WS=86
05 WBlB=87
05 WS=88
04 WS=89-91
03 WS=88
08 WS=87
Ch Arnauld
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=86
10 $20 RP
Ch Arnauton
Fronsac Grand Sol 07/08/09/10
10 WS=90
10 RP=87
09 JJB=91-93
09 RP=90-92
10 $14 WS
10 $14-23 RP
09 $14 JJB
09 $17-22 RP
09 $15 K&L
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
Ch Arnaud de Jacquemeau
St-Emilion GC 04/05
Aromes de Pavie St Emilion 06
Arrogant frog
Lily Pad Red Pays d’Oc 10
Ch les Arromans
Ch l’Arrosee
05 $20 WS
08 RP=90-92
08 RP=87-88
07 Gold Brussels 10
07 Silver Bordeaux 10
05 WS=83
06 RP=86
10 Cab Sauv-Merlot
10 Best Buy WE
06 $45 RP
10 WE=85
10 $10 WE
Bordeaux 10
10 WS=87
10 WE=88
Cuvee Prestige 10
10 WE=89
10 $12 WS
10 $15 WE
10 $10 WClub
10 $15 WE
St-Emilion GC 03-10
10 ST=88
10 $45 ST
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17/20
09 ST=88
09 RP=92-94
09 $40-58 RP
08 WS=91
08 RP=90-93
08 $40-43 RP
08 WE=89-91
08 $45 K&L
07 ST=86-88
07 $50 K&L
07 RP=89-91
07 $35-44 RP
06 WS=89
06/05 RP=92-94 06 $50 RP
06 ST=87-90
05 ST=90
04 RP=90
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07
Ch l’Arrosee
Ch d’Arsac
Haut-Medoc Le Monteil d’Arsac 10
Margaux 05/06/08/09/10
98 WW=88
98 $48 B&M
08 RP=90-93
08 WE=89-91
08 WS=88-91
07 RP=89-91
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=89
06 RP=89
08 $40 K&L
05 WS=91
10 WS=88
10 WS=90
10 RP=88
09 RP=87-89
07 $44 Zachys
07 C$69 BCLS
06 $45-50 RP
06 C$75 BCLS
05 $61 WS
10 $13 WS
10 $22 WS
10 $17-28 RP
7
Arte
Bordeaux 05/06
Les Asteries
St-Emilion GC 04-10
10 83%Merlot-17%CF
09 80%M-20%CF
07=85%Merlot-15%CF
06 Cellar Selection WE
04 Editor’s Choice WE
Augey (Cave de Rauzan)
Bordeaux 09
09 Gold LA 10
Ch Auguste (Vig Mejier) Bordeaux 10
10 Gold LA 12
08 RP=88-89
06 RP=89
05 WS=86
06 WS=80
05 WS=80-84
10 ST=92
09 ST=90
09 WE=93
09 RP=95-97
08 ST=90
08 RP=94-96
07 RP=90
07 ST=88
06 WE=92
06 RP=93+
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=90
05 WE=94
05 RP=92-94
05 ST=92
05 WS=90
04 WE=91
04 WS=88
06 $28 RP
05 $31 WS
09 $97+ ST
09 $80-93 RP
08 $90 RP
07 $70-100 RP
06 $135 WE
06 $138 RP
06 $150 WS
05 $189 WE
05 $190 WS
04 $188 WS
Ch Au Grand
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 LA=91
10 WE=88
10 WS=78
Ch Au Grand Paris
Bordeaux 05
05 IWR=86
05 $11 IWR
Ch l’Aura de Cambon
Margaux 05/06/07
07 Audience Fav Vine Talk TV
06 WS=88
05 ST=87-90
06 $40 WS
Ch L’Aurage
10
10 85%Merlot-15%CF
10 TWCI=88-90
Ch d’Aurilhac
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeoise 03-10
09 Silver Paris 11
Ch Aurelius
Ch Ausone
Haut-Medoc Sectionl la Fagotte 07
07/06 Gold Bordeaux 10
St-Emilion 05/08
08 Gold Paris 11
St-Emilion PGC 99-09 (0% M-10%CF)
10 $15 WE
10 $9 WS
10 RP=89
10 $13-17 RP
09 RP=87-89
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=87-89
06 RP=87
06 $25 RP
05 WS=88
09 One of Top 15 Decanter
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19.5/20
09 WBlB=97
09 WE=98
09 ST=94
09 RP=95-97+
09 $1550+
09 One of Top 32 JJB
09 JJB=98-100
08 ST=92
08 $1400 ST
08 RP=96-100
08 RP=1196+
08 WS=93-96
08 $999 Zachys
08 WBlB=96
08 $1,060 B&M
07 WE=95
07 $850 WE
07 RP=94
07 $589+ RP
07 WS=90-93
07 $600 K&L
07 ST=92
07 $950 Zachys
07 WBlB=93
07 C$1299 BCLS
06 WE=96/97
8
05 Great Wine W&S 4/06
05 Velvety, long, seductive WW 06
05 Outstanding SS in Decanter 06
04=52% CF, 48%M
04 Collectible WS 3/31/07
04 Top 10 WW 06
06 RP=98
06 $816+ RP
06 ST=92-95
06 C$1699 BCLS
06 WS=93
06 $1400 WS
05 W&S=3-3½stars
05 WS=100
05 $2000 WS
05 RP=98-100
05 $1700+ RP
05 SS=20/20
05 ST=98+
05 WW=95-98
05 WE=98
04 RP=95-97
04 WS=95
04 ST=93+
04 WW=95-96
03 WS=96
03 ST=95+
02 RP=95
02 WS=92
02 ST=93+
01 RP=98
01 WS=95
00 RP=100
00 WS=97
00 ST=97+
99 RP=95
99 ST=92
See also their second wine: La Chapelle d’Ausone
Ch l’Avocat
Graves Rouge 05
Bad Boy
See: Ch Thunevin
Ch Clos Badon
St-Emilion 04-10
05 $18 K&L
Clos Badon-Thunevin
St-Emilion GC 06/07
Clos des Baies
St-Emilion 08/09/10
Clos Bandon
St-Emilion 05
Ch Bahans-Haut-Brion
Pessac-Leognan 01-06 (Ch Haut-Brion)
04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08
10 70%Merlot=30%CF
08 100%Merlot
10 ST=86
09 WE=91
09 ST=89
09 RP=87-90
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=87-90
07 ST=87
06 RP=90
06 ST=87-89
06/05 WS=89-91
05 RP=88-90
05 ST=90
05 WS=90
05 RP=89-91
04 WE=90
04 WS=80-84
04 WS=87
04 RP=86
04 RP=86
04/03 WS=88
03 WS=88
03 RP=86-88
02 WS=87
07 ST=87
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=90
06 $50 RP
05 $33-45 RP
04 $45-55 RP
04 $35 RP
10 ST=87
09 WE=88
08 ST=89
05 WE=90
06 RP=88
06 $36-84 RP
9
05 Silky, long, flavorful WW 06
Graves 03/04/05
Ch Ballan
Bordeaux 06/07/08
Ch Ballan-Larguette
Bordeaux 07/08/09/10
Ch Balestard la Tonnelle
St-Emilion GC 03-10
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=92
06 WBlB=88
05 WE=92
05 WS=91
05 ST=88-91
05 WW=92-94
04 WS=87
04 ST=88
03 WS=90
03 ST=90
02 WS=88
01 WS=87
05 ST=89-92
05 WW=92-94
05 RP=89-91
04 RP=87-88
04 ST=88-90
03 RP=89
03 ST=90
02 RP=87
02 ST=88
01 RP=88
01 ST=89
00 ST=90
00 RP=90
99 ST=88
Clos Bandon
St-Emilion GC 05
08 Very Successfuo Hachette 11
10 Gold Paris, LA; Bronze Macon 11 10 LA=92
10 55%CS-28%Merlot-17%CF
10 WE=88
10 WW=88
10 RC=87
09 Silver LA 10
09 WW=89
08 Silver LA 10
07 Gold LA 09
07 RC=87
06 WW=88
06 RC=87
05 Gold France-Macon 07
05 WW=90
05 RC=87
03 WW=89
10 ST=88
09 WBlB=90
09 ST=87
09 RP=89-92
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=87
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=85
06 WS=88
05 WE=88/88
05 WS=87
04 WS=88
03 WS=86
01 RP=86-88
09 RP=88-90+
09 Great Value WBlB
09 WBlB=87
08 RP=90-93
07 ST=88
07 RP=88-91+
06 RP=90+
WE=90
Ch de Barbe Blanche
Lussac-St-Emilion Res 03/04/05/06/07/09
09 Gold Paris 11
Balthus
Bordeaux Sup 06/07/08/09
06 $100 B&M
05 $69 WS
05 $75 WE
04 $50 WS
03 $49 B&M
05 $56-70 RP
04 $36-62 RP
03 $38-66 RP
02 $27-60 RP
10 $10 B&M 5¢
10 $15 WE
09 $29-57 WBlB
08 $30 RP
07 $25 RP
06 $28 RP
09 $21-41 WBlB
06 $55 RP
10
Ch Barbetron
St-Emilion 05
Ch Barde-Haut
St-Emilion GC 03-11
10 90%Merlot-10%CF
09 65%CS-35%Merlot
08 Great Value WBlB
05 Amazing, very elegant, long WW
St-Emilion le Vallon de Barde-Haut 08
Ch Baret
Pessac-Leognan 04/05/06/07/08
07 Com’d Decanter 10
Le Baron de Brane
Margaux 08/09
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=85
05 WS=89-91
05 $25 TW&M
04 WS=86
03 WS=87
03 Hachette=1star
05 WS=84
WS 90-93
RP 90-92
NM 90-92
10 ST=87
10 TWCI=91-93
09 RP=93-95
09 ST=90
09 WBlB=92
09 WS=89-92
08 WBlB=91
08 RP=91-93
08 WS=90-93
08 ST=88
07 RP=90-92
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=89
06 RP=89
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=87
05 WW=92-95
05 NM=90
05 ST=93
05 RP=91-93
05 WS=90
04 WS=91
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
08 WS=89
08 WS=89
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=88
05 WS=89
04 WS=88
09 RP=87-88
09 WBlB=87
05 WS=83
Baron Herzog Ch Delagrave Kosher 10
Ch Barrabaque
Cuvee Hugo Canon-Fronsac 04/05/06
07 $35 Dec
06 RC=87
05 WS=84
05 ST=86
05 RP=87-89
05 RC=87
05 WW=92
04 WS=85
10 $35 Costco
09 $32-49 RP
09 $35 K&L
08 $30 WBlB
08 $26-40 RP
08 $28 K&L
08 $33 JJB
07 $24-40 RP
07 $32 Zachys
07 C$49 BCLS
06 $29-36 RP
05 $33
05 C$69 NM
05 $33-52 RP
05 $36 WS
05 $40 B&M
04 $35 WS
04 $34 ST
04 $14-49 RP
09 $21-41 WBlB
08 $25 Sh-L
05 $34 WS
10 $14 Sh-L
06 $13 B&M 5¢
05 $22 WS
05 $19 Zachys
05 $19 RP
05 $13 B&M 5¢
Cuvee Prestige Canon Fromsac 06/09/10
Canon Fronsac 04-10
03 RP=87-89
03 WS=87
10 RP=87
09 RP=87-89
06 RP=90
10 $16-21 RP
06 $12-18 RP
10 ST=86
11
Ch Barrail Lassac
Ch Barreyre
Ch Barreyres
Bordeaux 03/04
Bordeaux Sup 03/05/06/07/08/09
Haut Medoc 06/07/08/09/10
04 Hach=1star
04 WS=80
03 WW=88
03 WS=83
10 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 12
08 Cab Sauv; Bronze Challemge 10
07 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 09
03 $10
06 WBlB=87
05 €8-11 Hach
10 WS=88
10 $25 WS
06 WS=87
05 WS=82
05 WE=89
05 IWR=90
05 $14 WS
05 $17 WE
05 $20 IWR
04 WS=87
03 WS=78
03 WD=16/20
Prem-Cotes-deBordeaux Cuvee Tradition 05
Ch Barrie
Cotes de Bourg 05/09
Barton & Guestier
The Pairing Coll Chops & Burgers 10
09 Gold Bordeaux 10
05 Great appeal WR
10 Best Buy WE
WR=88
10 WE=86
$12 WR
10 $10 WE
Bordeaux 10
10 Best buy WE
10 WE=85
10 $10 WE
10 WE=87
07 WE=84
10 $18 WE
06 WE=85
06 $10 WE
07 $17 B&M
Bordeaux 07/10
Bordeaux Passeport 10
10 Bronze IWSC; Comm’d IWC 12
Bordeaux Gold Label 04/05/06/07/08
06 Best Buy WE
Bordeaux la Grande Cuvee 10
04 Vin tres reussi Hachette 07
10 Bronze IWSC 12
Bordeaux Thomas Barton Res 06/10
Medoc Res Privee 08
05 Gold Brussels 2007
05 Silver IWC 07
Margaux Gold Label 05/06/07/08/09/10
Margaux Thomas Barton Res 04/05/06
05 Bronze IWSC 07
Medoc 06/07/10
Cab Sauv-Merlot
04 WS=79
10 WE=85
06 WE=86
04 WE=83
04 WS=82
10 $12 WE
06 $13 W
10 WE=87
07 WE=84
06 WE=85
05 WS=86
04 WS=85
03 WS=84
06 WE=84
05 WS=87
04 WE=85
04 WS=83
10 WE=86
07 WE=85
06 WE=86
05 W&S=84
05 WS=86
03 WS=86
10 $30 WE
06 $25 WE
06 $25 WE
10 $15 WE
06 $19 WE
12
Medoc Thomas Barton Res 06/07/08/09/10 (CS) 10 Bronze IWC 12
08 Silver IWSC 12
05 Comm’d IWC 07
Medoc Thomas Barton Res Privee 04/05
04 Silver IWSC 07
St-Emilion 04/05/10
St-Emilion Gold Label 04
06 WE=85
05 WS=86
04 WE=85
04 WS=84
05 WS=88
05 WE=88
04 WE=87
04 WS=85
10 WE=87
05 WW=87
04 WS=86
Ch la Bassonnerie
Pomerol 07
10 WE=88
06 WE=87
05 WS=84
04 WE=85
04 WS=86
07 WE=88
Ch la Bastienne
Montagne-Saint-Emilion 10
10 WE=90
Ch Batailly
10 78%CS-19%Merlot-2%PV-CF
07 Value QRW Autumn 08
06 Vert Successful Hachette 10
05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 Vin Remarquable Hachette
03 Merely quite good WD 10/05
Bordeaux 06
Ch Beard la Chapelle
05 $50 WE
10 $18 WE
04 WS=83
St-Emilion Thomas Barton Res 04-10
Ch Bateau (Beychevelle)
06 $20 WE
10 $20 WE
06 $24 WE
10 $27 WE
07 $46 WE
10 ST=90
09 WE=94
09 ST=89
09 WBlB=92
09 RP=90-92
09 $39-49 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5/20
08 WS=90
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=88+
07 $46 RP
07 WE=90
07 $35 WE
07 WS=83
06 RP=91
06 $35-53 RP
06 WE=90
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=87
05 W&S=2stars
05 WS=90
05 ST=87-89
05 WE=89/89
04 WS=89
04 ST=86-88
03 WS=90
03 WD=14.5/20
06 RC=86
06 $10 K&L
09 WE=85
09 $25 WE
Ch Beaulieu
Comtes de Tastes Bordeaux Sup 05-12
10 One of world’s best values RP
Cotes de Bourg 10
12 RP=79-81
11 RP=84-86
11 $10 RP
10 RP=84-86
09 WS=88-91
09 $12 JJB
08 RP=86
08 $14 JJB
08 CellarT=87 (13) 08 $16 Zachys
07 ST=88
07 RP=89-91
07 $22 RP
06 RP=88
06 $20 RP
05 IWR=90
05 $15 IWR
05 RP=89
05 $18 JJB
04 RP=86
03 RP=89
13
Ch Beaumont
Haut-Medoc Sup 03-10
09 Merlot-CS-CF
09 Great Value WBlB
08 Great Value WBlB
06Very Successful Hachette 10
05 12 Outstanding Values QRW 06
Ch de Beaumont
Prem Cotes de Blaye Rouge 05/06/07
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 05/08/09
04 Sehr Gut (Bronze) MVini 06
03 Gold Brussels 06
03 Silver Challenge 06
07 Silver Brussels, Paris 09
06/05 Silver Brussels 07
09 53%CS-46%Merlot-PV
09 Silver Bodeaux 11
09 Comm’d Decanter
05 Excellent SFCh 3/28/08
Le Clos du Beau-Pere
Pomerol 06/07/08/09
Ch Beauregard
Pomerol 04-10
10 75%Merlot-25%CF
06 Very Successful Hachette
10 WS=88
10 RP=87
09 ST=87
09 WBlB=88
10 $22 WS
10 $12-19 RP
08 WBlB=85
08 WS=86
08 ST=86
08 RP=83-84
07 WS=86
06 WS=85
06 NM=88
05 RC=88
05 WS=88
05 WE=88
05 RP=87-88
05 W&S=90
05 NM=90 & 89
05 IWR=93
04 WS=85
04 RP=86
08 $13 K&L
08/07/06 $13 WS
09 $16 WBlB
08 $13 RP
06 C$21 NM
05 $17 WS
05 $25 B&M
05 $14-16 RP
05 $23 K&L
05 C$25 NM
03 RP=85
09 WE=89
09 WS=87-90
09 ST=87-89
08 SS=14.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
05 SFCh=3star/4
05 WW=87-89
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=88
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=88
10 ST=86
09 ST=87
09 WBlB=89
09 RP=88-90
08 WS=91
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=84-86
07 WS=86
06 RP=86
06 WS=87
06 WE=84
05 WS=92
05 RP=89-91
05 NM=91
05 WE=86
04 WS=89
04 RP=88
04/03 WE=85
04 $17 Dec
09 $18 K&L
09 $25-49 WBlB
09 $40-49 RP
08 $19 WS
08 $35 K&L
08 $26-40 RP
07 $26-32 RP
07 $22 WS
06 $34-40 RP
06 $33 WS
05 $40 WS
05 $38-47 RP
05 C$65 NM
04 $38 WS
04 $45 RP
03 RP=86
Ch Beauregard Ducasse
Grave Rouge 01
Grave Cuvee Albert Duran 09
Ch Beauregard-Ducourt
01 $13 K&L
10 Merlot
10 WE=84
10 $13 WE
14
Ch Beau-Sejour Becot
St-Emilion 04109
09 Bronze Paris 11
08 Best Buy WE
08 Com’d Decanter, IWC 10
10 70%Merlot-25%CF-2,5%CS/CF
Ch Beausejour
Montagne-St-Emilion Clos L’Eglise 02/03/05
Montagne St-Emilion “1901” 05-10
06 50%CF-50%Merlot
Montagne St-Emilion 06-10
Ch Beausejour-DuffauLagarrosse
St-Emilion GC 06
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 04
08 WE=88
08 $13 WE
10 ST=89
10 $80+ ST
09 ST=88
09 WBlB=93
09 RP=93-95
09 $63-87 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 WE=93-95
08 $47 K&L
08 RP=91-93+
08 RP=42-61 RP
08 WS=88-91
08 $47 Zachys
07 RP=86-88
07 $36-55 RP
07 ST=87
07 $60 Zachys
06 RP=91
06 $37-83
06 WS=90
06 $62 WS
06 WE=94
06 ST=89-91
05 WS=92
05 $85 WS
05 RP=90-92
06 $51-73 RP
05 ST=92
04 ST=87-90
03 WW=90
04 $60 B&M
03 ST=89-91
02 ST=87+
05 ST-88-90
02/01 WS=84
02 $25 WS
10 ST=88
10 TWCI=89-91
07 WS=89
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=85-88
05 ST=88
05 RP=87-89
05 $20 RP
05 W&S=1½-2stars
10 ST=87
07 WS=88
07 $28 WS
06 WS=80-84
10 ST=90
09 WE=93
09 ST=87
09 WBlB=93
09 RP=96-98+
09 JJB=97-99
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 RP=87-89
07 WE=91
07 RP=85-87?
07 ST=86
06 RP=89
06 WE=90
06 WS=89-91
06 ST=88-90
05 ST=91+
05 W&S=2stars
05 WS=92-94
05 WE=89
05 RP=92-94
04 WS=91
04 ST=88
10 $250+ ST
09 $110-168 RP
07 $45 WE
07 $38-47 RP
06 $50-51 RP
05 $49-131 RP
04 $40 WS
15
Ch Beau-Sejour Becot
Ch Beau-Site
Graves 04/05
04 RP=90
03 ST=89
03 WS=92
03 RP=89
02 ST=87
02 WS=91
02 RP=88
09 WE=95
08 JJB=90-92
08 JJB=88-90
08 WE=93-95
08 RP=91-93
08 WS=88-91
07 WE=93
06 WE=94
06 RP=90-92
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=85-88
05 Great balance, superb finish WW 06 05 WS=92-94
05 Very elegant SS in Decanter 06
05 SS=18.5/20
05 ST=91-93
05 WW=93-95
05 WE=93
04 WW=92-94
04 WS=92
03 Very Good WD 10/05
04 ST=89
09 WE=91
08 Silver Paris 11
08 Decanter=3star
08 SS=15.5/20
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=85-87
05 WS=90
05 Gold Paris 07
05 SS=16/20
05 IWR=91
04/03 WS=88
04=Cab Sauv
03 WD=16+/20
03 RP=87-88
08 Silver Bordeaux, Brussels 10
07 Silver Paris 09
10 RP=86
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=86
Pomerol 03-09 (07=100%Merlot)
St-Emilion PGC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-09
Cotes-de-Bourg 07/08
Ch de Beau-Site
Ch Beau-Soleil
St-Esteph 06/07/10
09 WE=88
09 WBlB=88
09 RP=86-88
08 RP=88-90
07 ST=87
06 WS=90
06 ST=85-88
05 WS=92
05 WE=88
04 WS=90
04 $37-44 RP
08 $47 K&L
08 $52.50 Zachys
07 $55 WE
06 $51-73 RP
05 $80 Zachys
04 $50
04 $45 WS
05 $21 RP
05 $35 WS
10 $18-24 RP
06 $25 WS
05 €15-23 Hach
09 $23-38 RP
08 $21 RP
06 $25 WS
05 $30 WS
03 Vin Tres Reussi Hachette 07
03 WS=88
Ch Begot
Ch de Bel
Bordeaux Superieur 08/09/10
10 Silver LA 12
10 90%Merlot-10%CabFranc
09 Silver LA 11
08 Silver Paris 11
05 Hach=1star
05 €5-8 Hach
10 WS=89
10 RP=89
10 WE=83
10 $24 WS
10 $21 RP
10 $15 WE
10 $15 Sh-L
09 $20 W&S
09 W&S=83
16
Bordeaux Sup Le Capitane 09/10
10 Bronze LA 12
09 Gold BofClass LA 11
09 LA=94
06/05 WBlB=88
Ch Bel Air
Laland- de-Pomerol 05/06
Ch Bel-Air
Lussac-Se-Emilion 06
Ch Bel-Air
St-Estephe 10
Ch Bel Air
Fronsac 05
10 WS=87
05/04 Very Successful Hachette 09/08 05 IWR=85
Ch Bel Air
Bordeaux Cotes de Bourg 08/10
08 Bronze Challenge (FR) 09
Ch Bel-Air
Haut Medoc 06/07/08/09/10
06 $20 WBlB
10 $25 WS
05 €15-23 Hach
10 RP=87
08 RP=85-87
10 $10-10 RP
08 $9-10 RP
10 WS=91
10 $23 WS
08 Silver Paris 11
07 Silver Paris 09
Blaye la Royere 06/09
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 04/05/06
06 RP=87
09 Gteat Value at $21 WBlB
09 WBlB=87
06 RP=87
05/04 Very Successful Hachette 09
03 WBlB=87
06 WS=85-88
Fleur du Ch Bel Air 06
05 RP=87-88
05 RP=90
05 $14 RP
03 $27 RP
Lalande-de-Pomerol 05
05 WE=89
05 $40 WE
Puisseguin-St-Emilion 10
10 WS=86
10 WE=90
10 $25 WS
Puisseguin-St-Emilion Bacchus 05
Ch de Bel Air
Lalande-de-Pomerol 05/06/07/08
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
05 Gold Brussels 07
Ch Belair
09 $21-41 WBlB
06 $18 RP
06 RP=87
Bordeaux Sup 04/05
Ch Bel-Air
06 $16 RP
St-Emilion PGC 01/04/05/06/07
03 Good Style WD 10/05
Ch Belair-Monange (Moeiux)St-Emilion PGC 08/09/10
06 WE=89
06 $30 WE
05 WS=87
05 $30 WS
02 WS=80-84
07 RP=82-84
07 $51-66 RP
07 WS=86-89
07 C$69 BCLS
07 ST=86-89
06 RP=87
06 $64 RP
06 WE=91
06 C$75 BCLS
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=88
05 SS=18.5/20
05 $50 K&L
05 ST=90
05 WS=90
05 $85 WS
05 WE=95/95
05 RP=88-90
05 $32-65 RP
04 WE=92
04 ST=86-89
04 WS=90
04 RP=78
04 $19-38 RP
03 WD=16/20
03 RP=86
10 ST=91
10 $300+ ST
09 WE=95
09 ST=90
09 WBlB=93
09 RP=94-96+
09 $125-228 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 JJB=88-90
08 $200 JJB
17
08 RP=93-95+
08 JJB=86-87
08 $121-150 RP
07 $30 K&Lyu
Ch Bel-Air Montagne
Montagne-St-Emilion 08/09
09 Silver Paris 11
Ch Bel-Air-Ouy
St-Emilion 08/09/10
Ch Bel Air Perponcher
Bordeaux 09
Bordeaux Reserve 07/08/09/10
08 WS=87
08 Coeur Selection Hachette 11
07 Gold Bordeaux Bordeaux 09
06 WS=87
05 WE=88
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=88
Ch Bel-Air la Royere
Blate 08/09
Ch Bel Enclos
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Evidence 10
Ch Bel-Orme Tronquoy de
Lalande
Ch de Belcier
Haut Medoc 10
Ch Belgrave
10 WS=85
10 WE=87
10 WS=89
Cotes de Bordeaux 09
Cotes de Castillon 05/06
Cotes de Castillon le Pin de Belcier 09
08 ST=89
10 ST=87
09 WE=90
09 ST=87
08 WS=87
Haut-Medoc 03-10
Ch Belgrave du Poujeau
Haut Medoc 05
Ch Belingard
Bergerac 10
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
10 Best Buy WE
Bergerac Cuvee Alliance 10
Ch Bellefont-Belcier
St-Emilion GC 04-10
10 70 Merlot-20%CF-10%CS
05 $17 WE
10 $20 WS
10 $25 WE
10 $18 WS
06 WS=84
10 ST=88
10 JJB=90
09 WBlB=90
09 WE=89
09 ST=88
09 WS=92-95
09 RP=88-90+
08 ST=86
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=82-85
07 RP=83-85
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
09 $29-41 WBlB
09 $23 JJB
09 $31-47 RP
05 WE=89
05 RP=87-89
05 WS=91
04 RP=88
04 WS=87
07 $22-27 RP
06 $36 RP
06 $38 WS
06 C$39 BCLS
05 $27 Zachys
05 $22-33 RP
05 $28 WS
04 $25 RP
04 $32 WS
04 WS=89
09 $23 JJB
04 $38 WS
05 W&S=81
05 $19 W&S
10 WE=88
10 $13 WE
10 WE=86
10 $15 WE
10 ST=89
08 WS=87-90
07 RP=86-88
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=86
08 $33 Zachys
07 $24-35 RP
07 $35 Zachys
Pomerol 04/09
Haut Medoc Diane de Belgrave 05
08 $200 ST
18
Ch Belle-Garde
Bordeaux 07/08
Ch Bellegarde l’Excellence
Bordeaux Sup 05/07
Ch Bellegrave
Haut Medoc 10
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/08/09/10
10 52%Merlot-41%CS-4%PV-3%CF 10 TWCI=89-91
10 WS=88
09 WBlB=87
Pauillac Cru Bourgeois 04/05/06/09
Lalande-de-Pomerol 07/08/09
Ch les Belles Murailles
Bordeaux 10 (org grapes)
Ch Belle-Vue
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03-11
06 $27-38 RP
06 $33 WS
05 $41 Zachys
05 $45 WS
05 $50 K&L
05 $33-44 RP
08 $15 WS
Ch Belles-Graves
06 RP=89-91
06 WS=86
06 ST=86-88
05 WS=93
05 ST=90
05 RP=92-94
04 WS=90
04 RP=88
08 WS=86
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
10 Gold LA 12
08 WS=86
06 WS=86
05 WS=87
04 WS=89
09 WE=92
06 WS=88
04 Bronze IWC 10
04/03 Cited Wine Hachette 07
02 Gold Bordeaux 05
Bordeaux Rouge 10
06 $36 WS
05 $35 WS
04 $38 WS
05 WS=88
06 $19 WS
06 $25 K&L
05 $40 K&L
07 WS=84
07 $30 WS
10 LA=91
10 50%Merlot-30%Malbec-20%PV 10 WS=91
10 RP=89
10 IWCI=88-90
09 Cab Sauv
09 RP=90-92
09 WS=89-91
09 JJB=91-93
09 WBlB=90
08 WE=90
08 SS=16+/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=88-90
07 Selected by Vine Talk TV
07 WS=83
07 RP=88
07 ST=87
08 €5-8 hach
10 $20 WS
09 $21-41 WBlB
09 $23 JJB
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=85-88
05 ST=88
05 WS=86
05 SS=16.5/20
11 $18 JJB
11 $20 wine.com
10 $25 WS
10 $15-25 RP
09 $16-35 RP
09 $25 K&L
09 $17 JJB
08 $13-16 RP
07 $14 WS
07 $12-19 RP
07 $19 K&L
07 C$35 BCLS
06 $13-26 RP
05 $16 WS
04 WS=88
10 WS=84
10 $11 WS
06 ST=85-88
05 ST=89-91
10 WE=89
10 $25 WE
06 Gold Bordeaux 07
Bordeaux Superiere 04/05/06
Haut-Medoc 10
19
Cotes-de-Castillon Cuvee VV 06
Ch Bellevue
Blaye 10
08 Gold Paris 09
Bordeaux Sup 10
Cotes de Castillon Cuvee VV 05
05 Very Good SFCh 3/28/08
St-Emilion GC 05-09 (98%M-2%CF)
Fronsac 04
Medoc Eleve en fut de chene 04/05
Ch de Bellevue
Lussac-St-Emilion 04/05/ 07/08/09
06 RP=92-94
05 W&S=2stars
05 WS=89-91
05 RP=94-96
05 SS=15/20
04 WS=88
04 ST=86-89
04 RP=88
03 RP=93
02 ST=88
02 RP=97
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=91-93+
07 RP=88
07 WS=87-90
05 IWR=85
10 WS=86
10 WE=81trt
05 SFCh=2½star
09 WBlB=90
08 ST=88
08 RP=91-93+
08 JJB=90-92
08 WBlB=91
07 RP=91-93
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=89-91
06 RP=86
05 ST=91+
09 Futures offered by Kermit Lynch
04 $42-55 RP
05 $38-=100 RP
04 $40 WS
04 $13-42 RP
09 $24-81 RP
08 $39-43 RP
08 $45 Zachys
07 $40-67 RP
07 $65 Zachys
05 $10 IWR
10 $15 WS
05 $23 SFCh
09 $37 WBlB
08 $42 Zachys
07 $39-60 RP
07 $60 Zackys
07 C$99 BCLS
06 $30-93 RP
06 $80 B&M
05 $84 WS
07 WS=87
09 $282/12
07 $24 WS
10 $20 WS
Ch Bellevue Claribes
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 WS=82
Ch Bellevue-Figeac
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=84
Ch Bellevue-Mondotte
St-Emilion 02-09 (90%M-5%CF-5%CS)
09 ST=88
09 RP=95-100
09 JJB=95-97
08 RP=96-98
08 ST=90
08 JJB=93-95
07 RP=94
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=93
06 RP=95+
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=92-94
05 ST=94
05 WS=97
06 Vin Temarquable Hachette 10
05 RP=96-100
04 WS=92-94?
04 ST=89
04 RP=95
03 ST=90+
09 $300-416 RP
08 $200-268 RP
08 $275 Zachys
08 $220 K&L
07 $183-300 RP
07 $275 Zachys
07 C$399 BCLS
06 $224-395 RP
06 C$429 BCLS
05 C$439 BCLS
05 $345 WS
05 $280 K&L
05 $153-614 RP
04 $81-210 RP
20
Ch Bellevue Peycharneau
03 WS=92
03 RP=93
02 ST=91
10 WS=89
09 Silver LA 12
08 Gold LA 11
07 Silver LA 10
Ch Bellevue de Tayac
Margaux 05/06/07/08/09/10
06 Cited Wibe Hachette 10
Ch Bellisle Mondotte
St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 90%Merlot-5%CS-5%CF
10 $18 WS
09 LA=93
10 RP=87
10 ST=87
09 WBlB=89
08 RP=81-83
07 WS=81-84
06 ST=87-88
06 WS=87
06 RP=88-90
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=78
10 ST=90
09 WS=91-94
10 $22 RP
09 $25-49 WBlB
09 $25 K&L
09 $22 JJB
08 WS=88
07 WS=85-88
Benitey
St-Emilion 08
Benjamin de Vieux
Ch Gaubert Graves Rouge 03
Ch Bergat
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08
Ch le Bergey
Bordeaux 10
Ch Berliquet
St-Emilion GC 04-10
Ch Bernadotte
10 51.5%CS-Merlot
09 56%CS-Merlot
05 WS=91
05 $30 WS
08 RP=
$25 Sh-L
03 SFCh=2star
03 $26 SFCh
08 WS=87
08 RP=85-87
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
04 WS=88
10 WE=83
10 ST=90
09 JJB=93-95
09 ST=87
09 RP=87-89
09 WS=93-96
09 WBlB=90
08 WS=88
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=85-88
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=87
06 RP=86
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
05 RP=88-91
05 WE=91
05 ST=89-91
04 WS=85
04 RP=84-86
03 RP=88
12/11 WS=85-88
11 RP=87-89
10 RP=89
10 WS=89-92
10 TWCI=88-90
09 ST=88
09 RP=89
09 WS=87
09 WBlB=89
08 ST=86
10 $10 WE
06 C$22 BCLS
10 $40+ ST
09 $30-41 RP
09 $30 JJB
08 $25-34 RP
07 $26-32 RP
06 $35 RP
05 $33 RP
04 $37 WS
04 $43-47 RP
03 $15-34 RP
11 $15-21 RP
10 $17-35 RP
09 $30 WClub
09 $11-32 RP
21
Pauillac 03/04/05
St-Emilion GC 05
Bernard Magrez
08 WS=87
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=87-88
08 $13-20 RP
07 Bronze Decanter, IWC 11
07 WS=83
07 $18 Sh-L
07 JMQ=87
07 Decanter 16 (88)
07 JR=16 (88)
06 RP=87
06 $18-20 RP
06 WE=88
06 $20.37 B&M
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=87
05 12 Outstanding Values QRW 06 05 RP=85-87
05 Fine tannins, well done WW 06
05 WS=87
05 WW=91
04 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 10 04 WS=87
04 RP=86-88
04 $20 Sh-L
03 WS=90
03 RP=90
03 WW=90
05 ST=86-88
04 ST=85-87
Bordeaux Maison Magrez 10
10 WE=84
10 $10 WE
Confiance Gerard Depardieu Cotes de Blaye 04 04 Gold BinClass IWSC 07
La Croix du Prieure Prem Cotes de Blaye 03/04 04 Silver IWSC 07
Ma Verite Haut Medoc 04/06
04 Silver IWSC 07
04 RP=87-90
03 RP=90
06 ST=87-90
Ch les Grands Chenes Medoc 10
10 WE=90
10 $22 WE
10 WE=86
10 $13 WE
Le Bordeaux de Bernard Magrez 10
See also: La Serenite Bernard Magrez
See also: Ch Guerry
See also: Ch la Tour Carnet
Ch Bernat
Puesseguin-St-Emilion le Roy Soleil 06
Ch Bernateau
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/08/09/10
Berriere Freres
Jacques Sans Souci 06
06 WS=86
10 Comm’d IWC 12
08 WS=89
06 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 10 06 RP=86
06 WS=86
05 WS=90
05 Silver IWC 07
04 WS=86
04 Hach=1star
04 Comm’d IWC 10
03 Hach=2star
03 Silver IWC 07
03 WS=90
06 Best Buy WE
06 WE=88
Grand Bateau 06
Ch Bertineau St-Vincent
Lalande de Pomerol 04-10
10 85%Merlot-15%CF
09 75%Merlot-25%CF
06 $25 RP
06 $9 WE
06 WE=85
06 $10 WE
10 RP=86
10 ST=87
09 ST=87
09 RP=87-89
09 WBlB=89
08 WS=85
08 RP=85-87
05 WS=85
10 $25 RP
08 $30 WS
05 $46 WS
22
05 RP=87-89
04 WE=88
04 RP=87
04 RP=87
Ch Bertinerie
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 10
10 Merlot-CS
10 WE=89
03 $24 RP
10 $19 WE
06 WE=90
06 $28 WE
Cru Res Cotes de Bordeaux 06
Ch Bessan Segur
Medoc 10
Ch la Bessane
Margaux 05/06/07/08
Ch Beychevelle
St Julien 4th Cru Classe 03-10
The Society’s Exhibition 06
04 $22 RP
10 WS=86
10 WE=88
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 WS=87
08 WE=91
07 WE=85
06 WE=88
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
10 54%CS-38%Merlot-5%CF-3%PV 10 ST=88
10 JJB=93
09 ST=89
09 RP=92-94+
09 WBlB=92
08 ST=88
08 RP=88-90
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WE=88
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=89
06 NM=90 & 87
06 Comm’d IWC 12
06 WE=90
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-89
06 WS=88
05 ST=90
05 Highly Rec’d to great W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2-3stars
05 Fine tannins, medium finish WW 06 05 WS=89
05 WE=95/93
05 RP=90-93
04 WS=91
04 WE=90
04 ST=88
04 RP=89
03 ST=89
02 Excell F&W 06
03 WS=89
03 RP=90
03 WD=15.5+/20
10 $25 WS
10 $22 WE
08 $30 WS
08 $38 WE
07 $32 WE
06 $32 WE
05 $35 WS
09 $65-112 RP
08 $99-129 RP
08 $39 Zachys
07 $49-120 RP
07 $60 B&M
07 $49 Zachys
06 C$65 NM
06 $43-99 RP
06 $70 B&M
06 $46 WS
05 $80 B&M
05 $60 WS
05 $46-135 RP
04 $36 WS
04 $43 B&M
04 $40 ST
04 $25-53 RP
See also: Ch les Bruliers de Beychevelle
See also: Ch Bateau
Ch Bibian
Ch la Bienfaisance
Listrac –Medoc 10
St-Emilion 03-10
09 65%M-35% CF)
10 WS=87
10 RP=86
06 RP=86
10 $23 WS
09 ST=87
09 RP=87-88
09 WS=88-91
08 RP=90-92
06 RP=85
06 ST=86-88
05 WS=84
05 ST=88-91
05 RP=92
04 ST=89
09 $19 JJB
09 $19-20 RP
06 $25 WS
08 $33 RP
06 $45 RP
05 $35 WS
05 $30 K&L
05 $29-39 RP
23
Bila Haut (M. Chapoutier)
Cotes du Rossillon Villages 10
Ch Bire
Boredeax Sup 08
Ch de Birot
Cotes de Castillon 08
Ch Biston-Brillette
Moulis 05/06/08/10
Ch Blaignan
Medoc 09/10
Blasson d’Issan
Margaux 05/06
Blason de L’Evangile
Pomerol 04-09 (Merlot) (Ch L’Evangile)
04 RP=89
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 WS=89-91
03 RP=90
10 #38 Top 100 of 2012 WS
10 WS=90
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 RP=90
10 RC=88
08 WS=83
04 $50 RP
10 $11 JJB
10 $12 K&L
10 $11 TW&M
08 $13
08 WS=85
08 JJB=84-86
10 RP=90
06 WS=88
10 WE=92
10 WS=85
09 Silver Bruxelles, France Macon 12 09 WS=87
09 JR=15.5 (86)
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=87
05 Excellent SFCh 3/28/08
05 SFCh=3star
03 WS=85
09 nGreat Value at $38 WBlB
09 WBlB=91
08 WS=90
09 RP=90-92
07 RP=80-83
06 RP=87
06 WBlB=89
06 ST=90-92
05 WS=86
05 RP=87-89
04 ST=91
04 RP=88
08 WS=85
06 WS=81
05 $14 JJB
10 $25 RP
10 $16 WE
10 $22 WS
09 $17 WClub
05 WS=27 WS
05 $40 B&M
05 $40 SFCh
04 $50 RP
09 $38-75 WBlB
07 $50 RP
06 $45 RP
06 $25-49 WBlB
05 $48 WS
05 $17-33 RP
04 $29 RP
08 $17 WS
Ch Blavia
Premieres Cotes de Blaye 05/06/08
Clos la Boheme
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=99
10 $18 RP
Ch du Bois Chantant
Bordeaux 05
05 WE=85
05 $12 WE
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Laurence H 10
10 WS=86
10 $14 WS
Bernard Magrez Grands Vignobles 05
05 IWR=87
05 $17 IWR
05 IWR=88
05 $9 IWR
10 WE=85
05 IWR=88
10 RP=88
10 RWCI=86-89
09 WBlB=90
09 RP=88-90+
09 WS=90-93
08 RP=87-88
07 WBlB=90
07 RP=89-92
10 $10 WE
05 $9 IWR
10 $10-16 RP
Bordeaux Sup 10
Ch du Bois Favereau
Ch Bois-Malot
Bordeaux 05/06/07
07 Gold Bordeaux 09
Bordeaux Eleve en Fut de Chene 07
07 Gold Bordeaux 09
Bordeaux Sup 06/07/08 (unoaked)
08 Silver LA 11
06 Silver LA 10
09 Silver LA 12
08 Bronze LA 11
06 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Sup Tradition 08/09
Ch Bois Redon
Bordeaux Superieur 10
Ch Bolaire
Bordeaux Sup 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 40%PV-35%Merlot-25%CS
09 Outstanding Value WBlB
07 Great Value WBlB
09 $14+ WBlB
09 $13-14 RP
09 $13 JJB
07 $19 RP
24
Ch Bonalgue
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
07 ST=89
07 RC=87+
06 RP=88
06 ST=87-89
05 IWR=85
05 RP=88-90
05/04 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 04 RP=88
07 $10-21 JJB
09 $25-49 WBlB
Ch Bonfort
Montagne-St-Emilion 10
Ch Le Bonnat
Graves 04/05/06/08/09
Ch la Bonnelle
St-Emilion GC 05/06
Bonnes Rives
Lalande-de-Pomerol 05/09
Ch Bonnet
Bordeaux 06/07/08/0910
Bordeaux Reserve 04-09 (Cab Sauv-Merlot)
10 Merlot-CS
09 WBlB=89
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WS=82-85
06 RP=87
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=89
05 WS=91
05 WE=89
05 RP=88-89
04 WE=88
04 WS=80-84
04 RP=87
03 WS=90
10 WS=87
09 GDP=3.5 stars
09 WS=86
08 WS=85
06 $20 RP
05 $20 IWR
04 $23 RP
08 $26-33 RP
07 $55-65 RP
06 $28 RP
06 $59 WS
05 $25 RP
04 $38 RP
10 $20 WS
09 $15 Sh-L
09/08 $20 WS
05 WE=88
04 W&S=84
05 $20 WE
04 $16 W&S
05 WS=87
08 RP=87-89
05 $25 WS
10 WS=88
09 LA=93
10 $15 WS
09 $10 Sh-L
09 $16 wine.com
07 WS=87
06 NM=87
07 $15 WS
06 C$15 NM
06 $18 wine.com
09 Bronze Paris 11
06 Comm’d IWC 10
05 Comm’d Decanter 06, IWC 07
07 WS=84
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=85-88
05 W&S=85
04 WW=85
03 WS=86
05 $11 W&S
04 WS=85
See also: Divinius de Ch Bonnet
Ch le Bon Pasteur
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
10 ST=89
10 TWCI=91-93
09 Outpreformed Price JJB
09 JJB=94-96
09 WE=93
09 ST=90
09 RP=92-94
08 WS=87
08 RP=93-96
08 WE=91-93
07 RP=89
07 ST=90
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=90
05 Full-bodied, ripe fruit, long WW 06 05 WS=92
05 ST=91+?
05 WE=91
09 $65+ ST
09 $65-92 RP
08 $65-70 RP
08 $70 K&L
07 $55-65 RP
06 $60 RP
06 C$89 BCLS
25
05 RP=93-95
04 WE=91
04 ST=89
04 RP=90
04/03 WS=90
03 RP=89
04/03 Very Successfull Hachette 08/07 04/03 Hach=1star
10 RP=85/87
10 $10 RP
09 RP=87-88
09 $7 K&L
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=86-88
06 RP=87
Bord’Eaux
Bordeaux 06/07/08/09/10
Bordeaux Single Vd
See: Ginestet
Ch Bordes-Quancard
Bordeaux 10
10 Best Buy WE
10 WE=88
10 $10 WE
Chai de Bordes (Cheval Q)
Bordeaux Rouge 09
09 WW=89
09 LA=92
09 $18 B&M
Ch Borie de Noaillan
Bordeaux 09
09 Gold LA 11
09 Bronze Bordeaux, Decanter 12
09 Bronze France-Macon 11
09 Silver LA 12/11
Ch le Boscq
04/03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07
Medoc Ch Patache d’Aux 08
03 WS=88
03 RP=87
08 RP=87-89+
Medoc 09
09 70%CabSauv-30%Merlot
09 $14 Sh-L
05 WS=84
05 IWR=88
05 $15 IWR
10 $20 WE
Ch de Bouchet
Bordeaux 09
Ch le Bourdieu
Medoc 10
10 WE=84
Ch Bourgneuf
Pomerol 06/07/08/09/10
10 ST=89
08 WS=89
08 JJB=85-87
07 WS=86-90
07 ST=84
06 RP=89
06 AG=89
09 ST=89
09 WBlB=89
09 RP=86-88
08 ST=88
08 RP=86-88
07 RP=80-84
07 WS=88-89
06 RP=84
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=80
05 W&S=1½stars
05 WS=91
05 ST=86-89
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=91
Ch Bourgneuf-Vayron
03 $36 WS
03 $32 RP
Boston
Ch Bourbon la Chapelle
09 WE=91
09 RP=87-88
09 $21 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16+
07 C$39 BCLS
07 C$33 LCBO
06 WS=87
06 $44 WS
05 RP=88-90
05 $22-24 RP
05 WS=89
04 WS=85
04 $30 WS
04 RP=84-86
04 $22 RP
09 Bronze LA 11
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09
05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06
07 $33 Zachys
07 C$49 BCLS
06 $39 RP
06 C$49 AG
09 $40-49 RP
07 $33-43 RP
06 $35-46 RP
06 $37 WS
05 $42 WS
26
03 Vin Tres reussi Hachette 07
Ch Bouscaut
Classique 09
Pessac-Leognan 03-10
10 55%Merlot-40%CS-5%Malbec
04 Very Successful Hachette 08/07
Graves Rouge 03/05
Les Portes de l’Am 03/05/06/07/08/09
07=50%Merlot-25%Malbec-25%CS
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee la Gargone 07 (07=60%Merlot)
Dom du Bouscat
Bordeaux Sup 09
Borfeaux Sup Cadice 10
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee la Gargone 05-10
Bordeaux Suo la Porte de l’Am 07
04 RP=87
09 RP=88-90
10 ST=88
09 WBlB=89
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=87-88
07 WS=88-89
07 ST=84
06 RP=86
06 WE=88
06 ST=85-88
06 WS=90
05 WS=92
05 WE=86
05 ST=86-88
04 Hachette=1star
04 WS=89
04 WW=87-88
04 WE=88
04 ST=86-88
04 RP=86
03 WS=89
03 RP=85-87
05 ST=87-89
03 ST=86
09 RP=90-93
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=91-93
07 ST=87-89
06 RP=91
06 ST=87-90
05 ST=90
03 ST=89
07 ST=88
09$9-10 RP
07 $30+ ST
06 $18 RP
06 $30 WE
06 $22 WS
05 $30 WS
05 $40 B&M
04 $25 B&M
04 $31-36 RP
09 $34-36 RP
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=88-91
10 WS=88
09 $9 JJB
10 WS=89
09 RP=90-92
09 WS=90-93
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=89-91
10 $20 WS
09 $17 RP
09 $17 JJB
06 RP=89
06 ST=87-89
05 Cited Wine Hachette 0805 ST=87-90
07 ST=87
10 $14 WS
07 $15 RP
07 $15 K&L
06 $25 RP
Le Boscq
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=90
10 $23-30 RP
Ch Boumac
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=86
10 $16 RP
Ch Bouscat
Cuvee Gargon 10
10 RP=91
10 $17-23 RP
Ch Bouscat Cadus
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=88
10 $22 RP
Ch du Bousquet (Castel)
Cotes de Bourg 06/07/08/09/10
09 Gold Paris 11
08 Silver Brussels; Bronze Decanter 10
07 Silver Paris 09
07 Bronze IWSC 09
05 WE=82
05 $13 WE
27
Ch Boutisse
St-Emilion GC 04/0506/07/08/09
Ch La Bouyere
Bordeaux 10
Ch Boyd-Cantenac
Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 01-10
10 Best Buy WE
09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90+
08 WS=91
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=88
06 WS=84
05 WS=86
04 RP=85
03 RP=87-89
10 WE=87
Ch Brague
06 WS=84
10 Hachette=4 star
10 ST=87
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=86-88
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=88
06 WE=87
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=92
05 RP=91-93
04 WS=87
04 RP=91
03 RP=89
02 WS=85
02 RP=90
01 WS=90
01 RP=90
01 TA=4stars
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee du Plantier de la Reine 07 07 Silver LA 10
Ch de Brague
Bordeaux Sup 07/08/09
Ch Branaire-Ducru
10 Vin Exceptionelle Hachette 13
Bordeaux Sup Plantier de la Raine 08
09 Bronze LA 11
07 Bronze LA 10
08 Silver LA 11
St-Julien 4th Cru 02-10
10 70%CS-23.5%Merlot-4.5%CF
08 Great Value WBlB
07 63%CS-M-PV-CF
06 Top Pick K&L
05 #59 Top 100 Wines WE
05 Unusual character, top effort WD
10 ST=90
10 JJB=94
09 ST=92
09 RP=92-95
08 WBlB=92
08 RP=91
08 ST=91-93
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=90
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=90
06 WD=15.5-16.5
06 RP=90+
06 WE=92
06 NM=91
06 AG=92
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=90
06 WS=89-91
05 RP=94-96
05 WE=95
05 W&S=2stars
05 WS=92
05 ST=94
05 WW=91-93
06 $38 RP
05 $40 WS
04 $28 RP
10 $10 WE
10 $10 Sh-L
09 $46-60 RP
08 $31-38 RP
07 $26-41 RP
06 $25-42 RP
05 $70 B&M
09 $65 ST
09 $60-85 RP
08 $39 WBlB
08 $40-58 RP
08 $43 Zachys
08 $40 K&L
07 $35-60 RP
07 $50 K&L
07 $48 Zachys
07 $60 B&M
07 $45 Sh-L
07 C$75 BCLS
06 $35-82 RP
06 $65 B&M
06 C$79 NM
06 C$89 BCLS
06 $53 WS
05 $140 B&M
28
05 RW=17-18/20
05 WE=94/95
04 WS=88
04 WE=91
04 ST=90
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 03 ST=92
03 Not very expressive WD 10/05
03 WS=93
03 WD=15.5/20
02 ST=90+
02 RP=90-92
02 WS=88
02 ST=88-92
02 WW=91
10/09 ST=87
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16+
08 WS=87
06 WS=86
06 $35 WS
06 WE=90
05 WS=90
05 $35 WS
04 Gold Best Reg Red < £10 Dec 07 04 WS=89-91+
04 $23 Dec
03 WS=87
08 ST=86
05 #59 Top 100 wones WE
Ch Branas Grand Poujeaux Moulis-en-Medoc 03-10
Branda
Lussac St-Emilion 08
Puisseguin St Emilion 10
10 ST=86
Ch Brande-Bergere
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee O’Byrne 08/09
Ch de Brandey
Bordeaux Rouge 08/09/10/11
Bordeaux Cuvee Passion 08
11 Gold bruxelles 12
11 $10 B&M 5¢
11 Bronze Bordeaux, Challenge Intl 12
09 Silver LA 10
09 WW=92
09 100% Merlot
09 JR=15 (84)
08 Gold Paris 09
08 RC=87
08 Silver Challenge (FR) 09
08 WN=92
07 WW=92
07 RC=87
06 RC=86
06 WW=90
06 Corkd.com=88
06 Winelog.net=3.5
05 WW=90
Bordeaux Vignobles Chevillard 09 (unoaked)
09 Silver LA 10
Ch Brane-Cantenac
Margaux 2nd Cru 01-10
09 WS=87
08 WS=84
11 WW=90
10 ST=92
10 JJB=94
09 53%CS-40%M-CF
09 ST=89
09 RP=93-95
08 RP=90-93
08 JJB=88-90
08 CG=90
07 RP=88
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=88
06 RP=92
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=90
05 Bal’d, fine tannins, med finish WW 05 WS=92
05 ST=91+
05 WE=94
05 RP=93-95
04 WS=87
04 WE=92
04 ST=89
09/08 $30 WS
09 $63-88 RP
08 $37-68 RP
08 $43 Zachys
07 $34-49 RP
07 $40 Zachys
07 $56 B&M
06 $35-57 RP
06 $88 B&M
06 $51 WS
05 $63 WS
05 $30-74 RP
29
Ch la Branne (Ginestet)
Margaux Baron de Brane 08
04 RP=90
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 04/03 Hach=1star
03 WS=90
03 ST=90
03 RP=91
02 WS=90
02 RP=89
01 WS=91
01 RP=89
00 WS=91
08 WS=86
08 $25 WS
Medoc Cuvee Fernand Ginestet 04/05/06/07
07 Comm’d Decanter 09/10
Medoc 05/07/08/07/08/09
Ch Branon
Ch de Brandy
Bordeaux 09
Ch Brassac (Dourthe)
Bordeaux Sup 10 (org grapes)
Ch de Braude (Montgravey) Haut-Medoc 06/07/09/10 (CS)
05 WS=86
04 Silver Decanter, Paris 06
04 WS=81
03 WS=79
03 Bronze Blaye & Bourg 05
10 ST=88
09 50%CS-CF-CS
09 ST=91
09 RP=96-98+
08 RP=94-97
08 ST=89
08 WS=89
07 RP=92-94
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=90
06 Very Good K&L
06 RP=93
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=90
05 WS=91
05 ST=92+?
05 RP=94-96
04 WS=88
04 RP=91
09 Bronze Bordeaux, Challenge 10 09 WW=92
10 Silver LA; Comm’d IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
09 Gold IWC 12
07 Cab Sauv; Bronze IWC 10
10 WE=91
10 WS=89
03 $14 WS
05 €8-11 Hach
09 $95-138 RP
08 $65-90 RP
08 $64 Zachys
08 $65 K&L
07 $55-69 RP
06 $59-78 RP
06 $67 WS
05 $86 WS
05 $95 Zachys
05 $73-114 RP
04 $30-60 RP
09 $10 B&M 5¢
10 $17 WE
10 $22 WS
06 WS=82
05 WS=87
Ch la Bretonniere
Prem Cotes de Blaye Eleve en Futs de Chene 05
05 WE=88
05 $28 WE
Ch du Breuil
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=85
10 $25 RP
Ch Brillette
Moulis-en-Medoc 03/04/05/06/08/09
Brio de Cantenac Brown
Bordeaux 08
08 WS=85
06 WS=85-88
06/05 VerySuccessfulHachette10/09 05 WS=90
05 WE=92
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=87
04 WE=90
03 WS=90
09 CellarT=87 (2)
Ch Briot
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=86
05 $30 WS
05 $23-24 RP
04 $37 WS
03 $35 WS
08 $23 Costco
10 $13 WE
30
Brisson
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 09/10
Dom de Brondeau Lalande
Bordeaux Sup 06/09
Ch Brown (Yvon Mau)
Pessac-Leognan 04/05/06/07/08/09
10 RP=86
09 RP=87-89
09 Bronze LA 12
06 Bronze LA 10
09 Bronze Decanter, IWB 12
09 CS-Merlot-PV
06 Gold Paris 09
06 vin Remarquable Hachette 10
05 Silver Decanter 07; IWC 09
04 Silver Brussels, VinaliesInt’l 06
Ch Brulieres de Beychevelle Haut Medoc 04/05/06
06 Vin Reamarquable Hachette 10
Ch Brun-Despagne
Bordeaux Sup 10
Ch Buisson-Redon
Bordeaux 08
08 Silver LA 10
Ch les Cabannes
10 $9-12 RP
09 $15 RP
09 RP=88-89
08 WS=91
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=88
06 WE=89
05 ST=88
05 WE=91
05 WS=90
04 WS=85
04 WE=88
06 $37 WS
06 $65 WE
05 $26 Zachys
05 $26 WS
05 €11-15 Hach
10 WS=86
10 $15 WS
05 NM=89
04 WC=4stars
05 C$24 NM
04 C$24 WC
02 WC=4½stars
02 TA=4stars
St-Emilion 05
Ch la Cabanne
Pomerol 04/05/06/08/09/10
04 Vin Cite Hachette 07
Ch Cabredon
Bordeaux 08/09
CABS
See: Meuliere CABS
Ch La Caderie
Bordeaux 10
Ch Cadet-Bon
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/08/09 (Merlot-CF)
Ch Cadet-Piola
10 ST=88
10 JJB=92
08 RP=86-88
06 WE=88
06 RP=88
06 WS=87
05 WS=91
05 WE=88
04 WS=90
10 $50+ ST
06 $20 RP
06 $39 WS
05 $49 WS
04 $45 WS
09 Bronze LA 10
08 Silver LA 10
10 WS=87
10 $13 WS
08 WS=85
08 RP=84-86
07 RP=85-87
07 ST=87
06 RP=86
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=81
05 ST=90
05 WS=90
05 RP=89=91
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 04/03 WS=88
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=89
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=86
04 RP=82
03 WS=87
03 RP=88
07 $25 RP
06 $28-36 RP
04 $32 RP
04 $32 RP
03 $26 WS
03 $35 RP
31
Ch Cadillac
Bordeauz Sup Cuvee JJ Lesgourgues 06
06 WE=89
06 $16 WE
Ch de Callac
Graves Cuvee Prestige 04/05
05 W&S=85
05 $16 W&S
05 C$22 LCBO
Ch Calon
Bordeaux 05/06
06/05 WS=89-91
04 WS=90
03 WS=91
05 WE=88
Montagbe-St-Emilion 05
Ch Calon Segur
St-Geitges-St-Emilion 06
06 Cited WineHachette 08
St-Esthephe 3rd Cru 03-10
10 86%CS-7%M-2%PV
08 Great Value WBlB
10 ST=94
09 ST=93
09 RP=92-94+
09 ST=93-96
09 WS=93-96
09 JJB=95-97
08 WBlB=92
08 RP=90-93
08 ST=90
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=87
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=87
07 AG=88
Capbean Gasquelton 06/08/10
Calvet
Bordeaux Res 08/09/10/11 (Merlot-CS)
Prestige de Calvet 09 (CS-Merlot)
06 ST=89-92
06 RP=91
06 NM=93
06 WS=92
05 Super tannins, long WW 06
05 WS=93
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 ST=92+?
05 W&S=3stars
05 RP=94-96
05 WW=93-94
04 WS=90
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
03 WE=94
03 WS=95
03 ST=92-94
03 RP=94
02 RP=89
01 WS=90
10 ST=87-90
08 RP=85-87
06 RP=85
09 Bronze IWSC 12
08 Bronze IWC 10
06 Comm’d IWC 09/10
05 Comm’d IWC 07
03 Silver BinClass IWSC 07
11 Comm’d IWC 12
09 Bronze IWC 10
06 NM=87/86
06 AG=85
02 WE=84
Medoc
04 $65 WS
05 $20 WE
10 $125+ ST
09 $75-148 RP
09 $110 K&L
08 $45 WBlB
08 $46-73 RP
08 $60 K&L
08 $95
07 $46-64 RP
07$60 K&L
07 $53 Zachys
07 C$89 BCLS
07 $66 B&M
06 $103 B&M
06 $47-130 RP
06 C$85 NM
06 C$99 BCLS
05 $130 B&M
05 $80-129 RP
`
10 $29 Zachys
06 $26 RP
06 C$14 LCBO
06 C$14 AG
C$14 LCBO
Medoc Res de L’Estey 05/06
06 RC=86
05 WE=84
03 RC=87
06 $8 TrJoes
05 $12 WE
32
St-Emilion 05
05 Comm’d IWC 07
St-Emilion Res des Remparts 05
Calvet, Benoit & Valerir
Dom Calvet-Thunevin
Oak Aged Claret 05
05 Bronze IWSC 07
Pauillac 03
03 Silver/Bronze Challenge 06
Bordeaux Presidial 04
04 Best Buy WE
Presidial 04
04 Best Buy WE
Cuvee Constance VDP des Cotes Catalanes 04
Ch Cambon la Pelouse
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03-09
09 CS-Merlot-PV
07 Comm’d IWC 10/12
06 Silver IWC 09
Margaux L’Aura 06/07
03 RC=87
05 RC=86
$10 TrJoes
05 WE=87
05 $14 WE
WE=86
01 RP=90
04 WE=86
$12 WE
01 $45-90 RP
04 $12 WE
04 RP=90
04 $12-17 RP
09 WS=89
09 $22 K&L
09 RP=90
09 Cellart=87.5 (35)
09 JR=15.5 (86)
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=16 (88)
07 WS=84
07 $14 WS
07 ST=85
06 RP=87
06 $17-28 RP
06 WE=88
06 $20 WE
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=86
05 ST=88-89
05 WS=85
05 $22 WS
05 RP=88-90
04 $10-30 RP
04 WS=84
04 $20 WS
04 RP=86
04 $9-38 RP
Bordeaux Sup Eleve en Futs de Chene 10
06 WE=90
10 WS=88
07 $35 Dec
06 $40 WE
10 $13 WS
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 10
10 WS=89
10 $20 WS
Ch Cambon la Pelouse
Haut-Medoc 09/10
10 $20 WS
10 $10-35 RP
09 $22 K&L
Ch de Camensac
Haut-Medoc 03-10
10 WS=90
10 RP=88
09 RP=90
09 WS=89
10 RP=87
10 ST=86
10 JJB=89
Ch de Camarsac
08 RP=79-81
05 Good WD 4/06
10 $12-35 RP
09 $23 JJB
08 $17-25 RP
08 $20 Zachys
07 $23 Zachys
06 $25 RP
06 $25 WS
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
06 WE=90
06 WD=13.5-14.5
05 WW=88-91
05 $35 B&M
05 WE=92
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=87-90
05 $11-26 RP
04 RP=87-89
04 $25 RP
03 WS=86
03 RP=89
Campot-Lafond
Ch Canada
Bordeaux 05/07
Bordeaux 05/06
05 WW=85
06 AG=84
05 NM=87
07 $12 Andys
05 $13 B&M
06 C$20 BCLS
05 C$15 NM
33
Ch de Candale
St-Emilion GC 05-09
09 RP=89-91
06 WS=88
06 WE=90
05 SFCh=2star
05 WS=89
05 WE=91
06 $45 WS
06 $47 WE
05 $33 SFCh
05 $35 WS
05 $55 WE
06 WE=86
05 WE=89
06 $35 WE
05 $40 WE
St-Emilion Roc de Candale 05/06
Clos Canon
St-Emilion GC 05/07
Ch Canon
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
05 Good RW 3/06
05 Classic SS in Decanter 06
05 Best value demanded wines QWR
Ch Canon-La Gaffeliere
Canon-Fronsac 04
04/03 Bronze Decanter 07/06
St-Emilion GC 02-10
10 55%M-35%CF-10%CS
05 WS=87
10 ST=89
10 $135= ST
10 JJB=93
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5/20
09 ST=92
09 $158 ST
09 RP=93-95
09 $125-175 RP
08 RP=90-93
08 $59-78 RP
07 RP=90
07 $43-70 RP
07 WS=87-90
07 $70 Zachys
07 ST=87
06 WE=94/93
06 RP=90
06 $63-94 RP
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=90
06 $87 WS
06 RP=89-92
05 WS=94
05 $100 WS
05 ST=90
05 C$249 BCLS
05 SS=18/20
05 WD=15.5-16.5
05 WE=93/93
05 RP=90-93
05 $79-122 RP
04 WS=90
04 $65 WS
04 ST=87
04 RP=88
04 $67-72 RP
03 ST=87
03 RP=89
10 ST=88
10 JJB=95
09 ST=89
09 RP=94-95
08 WE=93-95
08 RP=91-93
08 WS=89-92
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=90
07 AG=88
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=90
06 WD=16-17+/20
06 RP=92
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=93
05 Great aromas, balanced, big WW 06 05 ST=92+?
05 Excellent WD 4/06
05 WS=95
05 One of their greatest Decanter 06 05 WW=92-94
05 RP=92=94
05 SS=18/20
05 WD=17.5-18.5
05 WE=93/94
04 WS=91
04=M55% CF35% CS10%
04 ST=91
04 RP=91
03 WW=93-96
03 RP=87
09 $80-118 RP
08 $55 K&L
08 $47-58 RP
08 $60 Zachys
07 $49-64 RP
07 C$99 AG
07 $60 K&L
07 $60 Zachys
07 C$99 BCLS
06 Very good WD
06 $61-100 RP
06 C$129 BCLS
06 $76 WS
05 $105 B&M
05 $102 WS
05 $100 K&L
05 $43-130 RP
05 C$169 BCLS
34
03 WS=89
03 ST=89-91
03 RP=89
02 ST=91
02 RP=88
Ch Cantelauze
Ch Canteloup
Pomerol 05/06
Haut Medoc 05
Medoc 05
Prem Cotes de Blaye Rouge 05 07
Ch Cantelys
05 Editor’s Selection WE
05 Bronze Bordeaux
05 Vin Remarquable Hachette
Haut-Medoc GC 04-11 (CS-Merlot-CF-PV)
06 Made well for the vintage WD
06 Top Pick K&L
06 Vin Remarqable Hachette 10
05 Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 Acceptable one day WD 4/06
05 Silky, very long WW 06
Ch Cantenac
St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09/10
05 RP=88
05 WS=87
05 $14 WC
05 €5-8 Hach
Ch Cantemerle
05 WE=92
09 WS=90-93/90
09 JS=93
08 WS=86
08 RP=87-88
07 WS=86-89
06 WS=87
09 $25 K&L
09 $29 Zachys
05WS=89
04 WS=86
03 WS=92
11 JS=90
11 $17 JJB Fut
10 JJB=90+
09 RP=92-94
09 $38 K&L
09 WE=90-92
09 $31-48 RP
09 WS=88-91
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17/20
08 WS=87
08 $27 WS
08 RP=89-91
08 $23-44 RP
08 $25 K&L
08 $26 JJB
08 $30 Zachys
07 WS=85
07 $27 K&L
07 ST=88
07 $29 Zachys
07 RP=90
07 $11-34 RP
07 $28 WS
07 $27 JJB
07 $35 B&M
07 $30 Sh-L
07 C$49 BCLS
06 WD=14.5-15.5 06$27 K&L
06 RP=90
06 $21-45 RP
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=88
06 $31 WS
05 W&S=1star
05 $32 Zachys
05 WD=15-16/20
05 WS=90
05 $33 WS
05 ST=88+?
05 RP=89-91
05 $13-48 RP
05 WE=88
04 RP=87
04 ST=86
04 WS=86
03 RP=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=85
05 WS=87
04 WS=87
04 ST=86-89
06 $35 WS
05 $30 WS
04 $33 WS
03 WS=86
02 ST-87
35
St-Emilion Climat 04/05/06/07
St-Emilion Selection Madame 07/08/09/10
Ch Cantenac-Brown
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=88
05 WS=92-94
04 WS=87
10 66%CS-34%Merlot
06 Good effort WD
05 Might be a classic WD 4/06
03 Out of kilter WD 10/05
10 ST=91
10 JJB=93
09 ST=88
09 RP=94-96
09 WS=93-96
09 WE=94
08 ST=89
08 JJB=87-89
08 RP=90-921
07 WS=87
07 RP=86
07 ST=87
06 WD=14-15/20
06 RP=90-92
06 WS=90
06 ST=86-88
05 WS=89-91
05 ST=88+?
05 WS=91
05 WD=16-17/20
05 WE=89/89
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=87
04 WE=89
04 RP=86
04 ST=85-88
03 RP=87
03 ST=87-88
03 WD=14/20
03 WS=89
02 WE=90
02 WS=88
02 ST=86+
02 WS=88
01 WS=90
00 WS=92
06 $49 WS
04 $33 WS
10 $68+ ST
09 $60 ST
09 $51-75 RP
09 $65 K&L
08 $35-46 RP
07 $58-72 RP
06 $72-82 RP
06 $73 WS
05 $40 Zachys
05 $45 WS
05 $20-52 RP
04 $36 WS
04 $22-61 RP
See also second label: Brio de Cantenac Brown
Ch Cap de Faugeres
12 WS=88-91
12 RP=88=90
11 WS=88-91
11 RP=87-89
10 WS=90
10 RP=89
10 ST=87
10 TWCI=89-91
09 RP=91
09 WS=86
08 WS=85
08 RP=90-92
08 JJB=88-90
07 ST=87
07 WS=85
07 RP=89
06 RP=86
06 Wine of the Week Tampa Bay Times 06 ST=86-89
06 WS=88
05 Fine tannins, long WW 06
05 WS=89
05 RP=89
04 WS=87
04 RP=88
12 $12-28 RP
11 $16 wine.com
11 $12-16 RP
10 $23 WS
10 $20-32 RP
10 $26 Zachys
10 $18 JJB Fut
09 $20-32 RP
08 $15 WS
07 $11 WS
06 $20 Sh-L
06 $18 WS
04 $20 WS
36
Mouleyre 10
Ch Cap Leon Veyrin
Listrac-Medoc 10
Ch Cap de Merle
Lussac-St-Emilion 08/09/10
Ch Cap de Mourlin
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
Capbem-Gasqueton
Ch Carbonnieux
St-Estephe 06/09/10
Pessac-Leognan GC 03-10
10 73%CS-27%Merlot
03 Rather good, has potential WD
03 WS=81
03 WS=90
03 RP=90-92
10 RP=92
10 WE=91
06 WS=85
10 WS=86
08 WS=86
09 RP=87-89
08 WS=87
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=87-88
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=85
06 WS=88
05 WE=87
05 WS=90
04 WS=89
03 WS=90
10 WS=89
10 ST=87
09 RP=85-87
10 ST=88
10 JJB=90
09 ST=89
09 RP=89-92
08 WS=88
08 ST=88
08 RP=90-92
08 JJB=82-84
07 RP=89+
07 ST=85
10 $24 RP
10 $30 WE
10 $16 WS
08 $16 WS
09 $31-38 RP
06 $36 RP
05 $29 WS
10 $25 WS
09 $19-35 RP
09 $21 K&L
09 $30-54 RP
08 $39 ST
08 $24-38 RP
08 $40 Zachys
07 $24-50 RP
07 $30 Zachys
07 $30 Sh-L
06 WD=15-16/20 06 $29 K&L
06 RP=89
06 $30-50 RP
06 WE=89
06 $30 TW&M
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=88
06 $32 WS
05 W&S=2stars
05 $40 Zachys
05 WS=88
05 $39 WS
05 WE=93/90
05 ST=88
05 RP=91-93
05 $31-45 RP
04 WS=87
04 $27 WS
04 WE=89
04 RP=90
04 $27-43 RP
03 WD=16+/20
03 RP=89
05 ST=85-88
Graves Rouge 05
Best value generally F&W 06
Ch Carcanieux
Medoc 10
Ch la Cardonne
Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 04-10
07 Merlot
05 Comm’d Decanyter 10
03 Comm’d IWC 10
Ch Cardus de Cardonne
Medoc 05/06/07
10 WE=87
10 $30 WE
10 RP=90
07 WE=89
06 WS=85
05 WS=87
10 $22 RP
07 $22 WE
05 $20 WS
04 WE=88
04 WS=83
07 WE=85
06 WS=85
05 WS=85
97 $17 WE
37
Ch Carignan
08 Silver IWC 12
10 RP=86
09 RP=87-88
05 RP=85-86
10 WS=90
Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 10
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 03/04/05/06/07/08
02/01 Bronze Decanter 06
02 Gold Brussels 06
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux Prima 02-12
Carilion
Bordeaux 10
Le Carillon d’Angelus
St-Emilion GC 05/09
Ch de Caries Haut Caries
06
Ch de Carlmagnus
Fronsac 09/10
Ch de Carles Haut Carles
Fronsac 04/05/06/07/08/09
Ch les Carmes-Haut-Brion
Pessac-Leognan 01-10 (Ch Haut Brion)
10 $20 RP
10 $25 WS
08 WS=86
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=85
05 WS=80-84
05 RP=85-87
04 WS=84
03 WS=86
03 AG=83
02 WS=77
00 WR=88
12 RP=84-86
10 RP=88
09 RP=88
09 WS=89-92
09 JS=93
08 WS=87-90
08 JJB=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 RP=86-88
04 WS=86
03 WS=88
02 WS=84
01 AG=88
01 WS=85-88
10 RP=87
10 $22 RP
09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90
05 WW=91-93
06 RP=91
09 $64-80 RP
05 $96 B&M
06 $36 RP
10 WS=91
10 RP=87
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=89-92
08 RP=89-91
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
09 RP=90-93
08 WS=87
08 RP=90-91+
07 WS=84
06 RP=85
05/04 RP=89-91
04 WS=85
03 WS=85-88
10 ST=88
09 WE=93
09 ST=89
09 RP=90-92
08 ST=88
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=88
06 ST=86-89
06 RP=90
06 WS=90
05 WE=93
06 $25 WS
12 $12-16 RP
10 $12-32 RP
09 $14 JJB
09 $20 Astor
09 $35 TW&M
06 $39 WS
10 $18 WS
10 $13-16 RP
08 $17 JJB
05 $28 WS
08 $25 RP
06 $28 RP
09 $55-75 RP
08 $32-53 RP
07 $38-56 RP
06 $44-88 RP
06 $50 WS
38
Ch de Carolle
Ch Caronne-Ste-Gemme
Graves 05/06/10
05 Best Buy WE
07 Gold Bordeaux, Challenge 10
07 Comm’d IWC 12
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Bronze IWC 10
04 Gold IWC 09
Ch le Carre
Les Carruades de Lafite
St-Emilion 03-10
Pauillac 02-10
03 Very Good F&W 06
10 85%Merlot-15%CF
09 80%Merlot-20%CF
05 WS=90
05 RP=91-94
05 ST=91
04 RP=88-90
04 ST=88
03 RP=89
03 ST=90
02 RP=90
01 WS=87
01 RP=89
05 $65 WS
05 $53-86 RP
04 $32-57 RP
05 WE=87
05 $12 WE
05 WS=87
10 RP=90
10 $12-26 RP
09 Dec=4star
09 Dec=16.5 (90)
09 WS=90
09 $20 K&L
09 RP=86
08 SS=16 (88)
08 Decanter=3star
06 WS=88
06 $16 WS
05 WS=91
05 WE=90
05 RP=88-90
03 WS=84+
10 ST=88
09 ST=91
09 WE=91
09 RP=93-95+
08 RP=93-95
07 RP=90
07 ST=87
06 RP=93
06 WE=92
10 $40+ ST
09 $65+ ST
09 $65-90 RP
08 $69 RP
07 $100-125 RP
06 $101 RP
06 C$109 BCLS
06 WS=90
05 WE=93
05 $138 WE
05 WS=85
05 $120 WS
05 ST=90
05 C$129 BCLS
10 59%CS-42.5%M-5.1%CF-2.4%PV 10 ST=87
09 51%CS-42%Merlot-CF-PV
09 ST=86
09 $295+ ST
09 RP=92-94+
09 $300-606 RP
08 RP=91-93
08 $505-662 RP
08 ST=87
08 $85 Zachys
07 WE=87
07 $200 WE
07 ST=85-88
07 RP=90
07 $502-633 RP
07 WS=86-89
07 $135 Zackys
06 RP=90
06 $100-391 RP
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=89
06 $130 WS
05 $80 Zachys
05 ST=91
05 Highly Rec’d to great W&S 4/06
05 W&S=2½stars/4
05 Gorgeous aromas, fine tannins WW 05 WS=89
05 $103 WS
05 WE=91
05 RP=89-90
05 $60-175 RP
04 ST=88
04 WW=88-91
04 $40
39
Ch Carteau
St-Emilion Cotes Daugay 06/08
Cassagne
Haut-Canon-la-Truffiere 10
Ch du Castillon
Haut-Medoc 08
Castel
Bordeaux Merlot Famille Castel 11
Ch le Castelot
St-Emilion 05
Ch Castera
Medoc 09/10
04 RP=87
04 WS=87
03 RP=93
03 WS=89
02 RP=87
02 WS=87
02 ST=87
02 WW=88-89
05 RP=91-93
08 WS=89
06 ST=86-89
10 RP=87
04 $50 WS
10 $16-21 RP
08 WE=88
11 Bronze IWC 12
11 Merlot
05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=87
10 RP=85
10 WE=85
10 $15-19 RP
10 $24 WE
05 WS=87
Ch du Cauze
St-Emilion 05
Cave Du Marmandais
Ch Campot Lafont Bordeaux 10
10 WS=84
10 $9 WS
Caves Fleury
Bordeaux 05
05 WE=81
05 $10 WE
Bordeaux Leo Vinis 09
09 WE=85
09 $12 WE
La Fleur Bordeaux 05
05 W&S=88
05 $13 W&S
05 W&S=85
05 $17 W&S
Ch Cazenove
Bordeaux Suoerieur 05/06
Ch Certan-Marzelle
Pomerol 04-09 (09=100% Merlot)
08=100% Merlot
05 Oustanding for price QWR
Ch Certan de May
Pomerol 99-10
09 ST=87
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=91-93
08 $77-101 RP
08 ST=89
08 JJB=85-87
08 JJB=84-86
07 RP=87
07 $76-116 RP
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=85
06 RP=89+
06 $45-72 RP
06 WE=89
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=87
06 $42 WS
05 WE=92
05 WS=89
05 RP=93-96
05 $60-160 RP
05 W&S=1½stars
05 ST=88
05 WS=89-91
04 ST=87
04 RP=90
04 $16-58 RP
04/03 WS=90
04 $63 WS
03 RP=89
10 ST=85
09 ST=91
09 RP=93-95
09 $79-129 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
08 JJB=90-92
08 $82 K&L
08 RP=91-93
08 $77-101 RP
08 ST=90
08 $85 Zachys
40
05 Best value QWR
Ch Chadenne
Fronsac La Fleur 05/06/07/09
07 RP=87
07 WS=89-92
07 ST=90
06 NM=89
06 WE=93
06 WS=88
06 RP=92
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=89-91
05 WS=93/94
05 ST=89+?
05 WE=93
05 RP=03-96
04 WS=85-88
04 WE=91
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
03 WS=90
03 RP=88
02 WS=89
02 RP=85
01 RP=87
00 WS=91
00 RP=91
99 WS=89
99 RP=87
99 WW=90
09 ST=88
07 $78-118 RP
07 $90 Zachys
07 C$123 BCLS
06 C$145 NM
06 $110 WS
06 $100-333 RP
05 $135 WS
05 $125 Zachys
05 $60-160 RP
04 $60 ST
04 $29-58 RP
07 Gold Paris 09
05 WS=88
05 WE=85
Chamarre
Reserve Bordeaux Tradition 05
Ch de Chambrun
Chambrun le Bourg
09
Champ de Fleuret
Champ de Gaillard
Bordeaux 10/11
Ch du Champ des Treilles
Ste-Foy-Bordeaux 06
10/09 Silver LA 11/10
11 Gold LA 12
09 Bronze LA 11
06/05/04 Cited Wine Hachette
Champs de la Gallard
Puisseguin-Lussac 09
09 Silver LA 10
Ch la Chandelliere
Medoc 05
Ch de Chantegrive
09 RP=89-92
08 WS=89
08 RP=90-92
09 RP=91-93
05 $12
08 $30 RP
11 LA=93
11 LA=92
06 WS=83
05 NM=90
05 WS=83
Medoc Civee Particuliere 06
Graves 03-12
12 RP=88-90
11 RP=87-89
11 JS=90
11 WS=91 ?
10 WS=90
10 RP=90
10 JJB=89
09 Gold Bruxelles 11
09 RP=90
09 Silver Bprdeaux 11
09 JS=92
09 WE=90
09 SR=87
09 JR=15.5 (86)
09 Decanter=16
08 WS=89
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 RP=84-86
07 Gold Brussels; Silver Bordeaux 10 07 RP=88
06 RP=85
05 WE=87
05 WS=87
05 C$27 NM
12 $12-28 RP
11 $13-28 RP
11 $18 wine.com
10 $25 WS
10 $10-25 RP
10 $25 Zachys
09 $14-25 RP
09 $22 Zachys
09 $22 Sh-L
09 $12/375 K&L
08 $20 WS
08 $12-15 RP
07 $12-15 RP
06 $17 RP
05 $19 WClub
41
04 Gold Brussels 06
Ch Chantelune
Margaux 05/06/07
Ch Chantelys
Medoc 10
Ch Chantemerle
Medoc 03/04/05/08
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
05/04/03 Very Successful Hachette
La Chapelle d’Ausone
Bordeaux Sup 04-09 (05=50%Merlot-CF)
09 Value WBlV
La Chapelle de la MissionHaut-Brion
St-Emilion 99-10
10 47%CS-27%merlot-26%CF
09 46%CS-44%Merlot-CF
07=64%Merlot-30%CS=6%CF
04 RP=83
04 WS=87
03 RP=87-89
03 WS=81
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=90
05 WS=89
10 WE=91
10 RP=86
09 WBlB=95
09 RP=93-95
08 RP=91-93
04 $12-22 RP
04 $22 WS
05 $25 WS
10 $19 WE
10 $20 RP
09 $223-278 RP
08 $140=229 RP
08 $115 Zachys
07 $105-186 RP
07 $140 WE
07 RP=89
07 WE=90
07 ST=87
06 WBlB=91
06 WS=80-84
05 WBlB=94
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=85
10 ST=88
09 ST=89
08 ST=89
07 RP=91-93
07 $99-206 RP
07 WS=85-88
07 $140 Zachys
07 ST=91-93
07 $206 B&M
06 RP=91
06 $121-211 RP
06 WE=92
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=89
06 $125 WS
05 RP=92-94
05 $101-202 RP
05 ST=92
05 WS=94
05 $160 WS
04 WS=87
04 $58 WS
04 RP=90
04 $95 RP
04 ST=88-91
03 RP=93
03 WD=16.5/20
03 WS=89
03 ST=89-92
02/01/00/99 RP=90
10 ST=88
10 $185+ ST
09 RP=91-94
09 $85-115 RP
09 ST=87
08 WE=91-93
08 RP=87-88+
08 WS=89
07 ST=87
07 RP=88
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=88
06 ST=88-90
05 WE=90
05 WS=89
05 RP=89
05 ST=89+?
04 WS=87
04 RP=89
04 ST=87-90
03 WE=89
03 WS=89
03 RP=89
08 $38 K&L
08 $37-56 RP
08 $55 Zachys
07 $55 Sh-L
07 $48-73 RP
07 $50 Zachys
06 $48 WS
06 $38-50 RP
05 $52 WS
05 $35-55 RP
04 $31 WS
04 $35-38 RP
42
La Chapelle de Potensac
Medoc 03/04/05/06/08/09/10
Chapoutier, M
See: Bila Haut
Charles de Sarpe
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
02 RP=86
02 WS=79
10 RP=85
10 $12-27 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 decanter=15.5
08 RP=82-84
06 WS=83
05 WS=81
04 WS=82
03 WS=85
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=93-96+
07 RP=92+
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=88
Ch Charmail
06 RP=94+
06 ST=89-92
06/05 WS=85-88
05 RP=94-96
05 NM=97
04 RP=90
00 RP=87
11 JS=90
10 RP=90
09 RP=90
09 WS=89
09 JS=92
09 ST=90
08 WS=88
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=89-91
06 WS=84
09 $110-183 RP
08 $69-102 RP
07 $40 RP
07 $95 Zachys
07 $40 K&L
07 C$119 BCLS
06 $86-140 RP
05 $80-130 RP
05 C$155 NM
11 $18 wine.com
10 $16-26 RP
09 $19-24 RP
09 $25 K&L
09 $28 Astor
08 $14-22 RP
07 $14-22 RP
06 $25 Zachys
06 ST=85-87
05 ST=88-90
05 WS=85
05 RP=90
04 WS=86
04 RP=89
02 RC/CC=88/89
02 RP=88
02 ST=87
Ch Charron
Prem Cotes de Blaye les Gruppes VV 06/07
Ch Chasse-Spleen
Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 04-10
06 WS=86
10 RP=90
10 $12-50 RP
10 ST=86
10 JJB=91
09 ST=87
09 RP=90-92
09 $16-53 RP
09 WE=91
09 $30 K&L
09 ST=87-90
08 ST=87
08 Decanter=4star
08 SS=16.5/20
08 RP=85-87
08 $12-30 RP
07 WS=88
07 $24 WS
06 WD=13-14/20
06 ST=84-87
06 $27 B&M
06 WS=89
06 $29 WS
06 CellarT 89.2 (21)
06 JR=14 (80)
06 G&M 17 (92)
43
05 One of 15 Best Buys QWR
05 Balanced, very fine flavors WW 06
05 Good potential WD 4/06
Ch Chauvet
05 WW=91-92
05 WE=92
05 W&S=1½stars
05 ST=85-88
05 WS=90
05 WD=16-17/20
05 RP=88-90
05 SS=17/20
04 WS=87
04 ST=86-88
04 WW=92-93
04 RP=88
03 WS=89
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07 03 RP=86
Haut-Medoc L’Heritage de Chasse Spleen 04/05 05 Bronze Paris 07
04 Cited Wine Haritage 08
10 RP=85
08 RP=87-88
06 Gold Brussels 09
06 RP=88
05 IWR=88
Bordeaux 09
Ch Chauvin
St-Emilion GC 03-09
Ch Clos Chaumont
La Chenade
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
09 Merlot-CF
Ch le Chene
Hau- Medoc 10
Ch Cheval Blanc
10 56%CF-44%Merlot
09 60%M-40%CF
05 Best of Vintage W&S 4/06
05 Complex, very long WW
04 Top 10 WW 06
09 RP=90-93
08 WS=88
08 RP=90-92
07 WS=87
07 RP=87-88
07 ST=85
06 WS=90
05 RP=90-92
04 RP=89
03 WS=85-88+
03 RP=89
10 ST=87
10 WS=90
09 ST=87
08 WS=86
07 WW=87-89
06 WW=88
05 WS=86
10 WE=90
10 ST=95
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 ST=96
09 RP=98-100
08 ST=91
08 RP=95-97
08 WE=95-97
08 WS=92-95
07 RP=91
07 WS=89-92
07 ST=92
06 WE=97
06 RP=95
06 WE=97
06 ST=92-94
06 WS=95
05 RP=96-100
05 W&S=96
05 ST=96+?
05 WS=97
05 WE=96/97
05 WW=97-99
05 SS=19/20
05 $30 B&M
05 $35 WS
05 $31-33 RP
04 $27 WS
04 $30 B&M
04 $11-41 RP
04 €8-11 Hach
10 $20 RP
06 $20 RP
05 $26 IWR
09 $10 Sh-L
09 $33-44 RP
08 $22-27 RP
07 $25 WS
05 $19-44 RP
05 $35 K&L
04 $26 RP
10 $18+ ST
10 $21 WS
07 $19 B&M
06 $30 B&M
05 $17 WS
10 $18 WE
10 $900+ ST
09 $995+ RP
08 $470-689 RP
08 $470 K&L
07 $399+ RP
07 $400 K&L
07 $700 Zachys
07 C$999 BCLS
06 $800 B&M
06 $440-938 RP
06 C$999 BCLS
06 $810 WS
05 $725+ RP
05 $1200 W&S
05 C$1299 BCLS
05 $945 WS
44
04 RP=90-92
04 ST=90+
04 WW=97-100
04 WS=94
03 WS=96
03 RP=89
03 ST=91
03 WW=89-92
02 RP=90
02 ST=91+
02 WS=92
01 RP=93
01 WS=92
01 ST=92+
00 RP=100
00 WS=93
00 ST=90+
99 RP=93
99 WW=93-95
99 WS=89
99 ST=91
04 $200-374 RP
03 $340 B&M
See also their second wine: Le Petit Cheval
Dom de Cheval Blanc
Bordeaux Presdial 04/05
05 Gold Paris 07
04 Brest Buy WE
05 WS=85-88
04 WE=86
Bordeaux 05-11
04 $12 WE
11 $13 WClub
08 Gold Paris 09
05 WS=85-88
Prem-Cotes-de-Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 04-07 07 Silver Bordeaux 10
Pessac-Leognan 07
Cheval Noir
St-Emilion le Fer 05/06/08/09/10
05 €5-8 Hach
07 RP=90-92
07 WS=88-91
10 RP=84
08 WS=87
Cheval Quancard
Bordeaux 06/07/08 (Ch Terrefort Quancard)
06 Comm’d IWC 09
06=Merlot
07 Silver Paris 09
05 Bronze IWC 06
Bordeaux Res 08/09/10
Dom de Chevalier
10 63%CS-30%M-5%CF-2%PV
09 CS-M-CH-PV
08 Great Value WBlB
07 Value < $500 QRW 08
07 $42 K&L
10 $20 RP
09 $18 Sh-L
08 $17 WS
08 $18 Sh-L
06 WS=85
05 WS=86
08 WW=88
10 WE=87
10 WW=91
10 $15 WE
10 $10 B&M 5¢
10 ST=92
10 JJB=94
09 WE=94
09 ST=91
09 RP=94-96
08 WBlB=92
08 RP=92-94
08 WS=90-93
08 ST=90
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=91
07 WE=91
07 ST=91
09 $68-108 RP
08 $39 WBlB
08 $44-90 RP
08 $60 Zachys
08 $43 K&L
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=93-96
06 RP=92
06 WS=91
06 NM=92
06 ST=89-90
07 $34-49 RP
07 $45 WE
07 $40 Zachys
06 $46 WS
45
05 Highly Rec’d to Great W&S 4/06
03 Silver IWC 07
03 Lots of potential WD 10/05
Christian Moueix
Bordeauz Superieur 05
05 Best Buy WE
Bordeaux Merlot 09
Medoc 05
Pomerol 05/06/07
St-Emilion 05/06/07
St-Estephe 06
Ch Cissac
Haut Medoc 09/10
06 WD=15-16/20
05 W&S=2-3stars
05 WE=91/91
05 WS=93
05 RP=90-92
05 ST=92
04 ST=90
04 WE=93
04/03 WS=90
03 ST=90
03 WD=17+/20
02 ST=88
02 WS=88
05 WE=86
05 WS=85
05 WW=86
09 JR=16.5 (90)
05 WE=84
05 WS=85
05 WS=85
05 WE=88
07 NM=90
06 WS=88
05 WE=88
05 WS=87
07 NM=89
06 WS=87
06 WC=3½ stars
06 NM=88 & 88
05 WE=88
05 WS=85
06 WS=88
10 RP=87
06 $44 K&L
05 $52 K&L
05 $11-13 B&M
05 $11 WE
05 $18 WS
05 $23
07 $25 LCBO
06 $25 WS
05 $23 WE
05 $22 WS
07 C$23 LCBO
06 $25 WS
06 C$20 LCBO
05 $24 WE
05 $20 WS
06 $27 WS
10 $24 RP
Ch Citran
09 CS
03 Bronze Decanter 07/06
Dom du Claouset
Bordeaux Sup Res 08/09
Ch la Clare
Medoc 08/09/10
06 WS=85
05 WS=87
10 WS=90
10 RP=88
10 WE=94
10 ST=86
10 JS=90-91
09 ST=87
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=83-85
07 WS=82
06 RP=75
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
05 WE=93
05 SS=16/20
04 ST=85-87
04 WE=90
04 WS=84
05 $17 WS
10 $26 Zachys
10 $20 JJB
10 $20 K&L
08 $39 Zachys
08 $14-17 RP
06 $17-36 RP
06 $17 WS
05 $21 WS
03 WS=86
02 WE=87
02 WS=84
0/089 Silver LA 12/11
09 70%CabSauv-30%Merlot
10 WS=84
10 WE=90
10 RP=88
09 WS=90
08 WS=88
10 $25 WS
10 $16 RP
09 $22 Zachys
08 $25 WS
46
Clarendelle
La Clarence du Haut-Brion
Ch Clarke (Rothschild)
Bordeaux Rouge 10
10 RP=90
06 WS=86
05 WE=85
10 52%Merlot-36%CS-19%CF-2%PV 10 ST=87
09 ST=90
09 46%Merlot-39%CS-CF
09 RP=90-93
08 RP=89-91
Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-10
09 One 0f 10 Best Values Decanter
06 Fine Value CG
06 Vin Remarquable 10
04=Merlot
Ch Clauzet
08 Bronze Paris 11
Ch la Clemence
Ch Clement-Pichon
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-10
07/06 Comm’d IWC 10
05 “Discoveries of the Vintage” QRW
04 Silver IWC 07/09; Brussels 09
03 Gold Brussels 06
10 $25-35 RP
07 $20 Sh-L
10 $100+ ST
09 $125-205 RP
08 $95-226 RP
08 $57 K&L
08 $65 Zachys
07 $75 Zachys
07 $122-210 RP
07 $85 B&M
08 WS=88
07 ST=86
07 RP=87
07 WS=85-88
06 ST=88-89
10 RP=87
10 $25-26 RP
10 JJB=89
09 ST=87
09 Decanter=3star 09 $24 K&L
09 Decanter=16/2009 $24 SH-L
09 WS 90-93
08 SS=16+/20
08 $30 Sh-L
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=84-86
06 WS=89
06 $22 WS
06 $20 K&L
05 WS=89-91
05 RP=90-92
05 SS=16.5/20
05 WE=90
04 WE=90
04 WS=86
04 RP=87
03 WS=88
02 WS=86
02 RP=89
10 WS=89
05 $22-24 RP
05 $22 K&L
04/02 $30 Dec
04 $30 RP
10 $25 WS
08 Decanter=3star
08 SS=15.5/20
06 WS=84
05 WS=89
05 RP=81-83
04 WS=84
03 WS=85
05 $19 WS
05 $11-22 RP
03 RP=87-88
03 $25-30 RP
09 WE=84
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=87-89+
07 ST=90
07 RP=88-90
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=88+
05 WS=91
10 WS=90
10 RP=89
10 ST=86
10 WE=90-92
10 JR=16 (88)
09 RP=89-90
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=86
03 $20 WS
09 $54-68 RP
08 $44-54 RP
07 $40-50 RP
06 $84-88 RP
05 $86 WS
10 $20 WS
10 $20-23 RP
10 $20 K&L
47
Ch Clement Saint-Jean
Medoc Cru Bourfeois 10
10 Gold Bordeaux 12.
Clementin de Pape-Clement Pessac-Leognan 08/09
Ch Clerc Milon
Paulliac PC 03-10
05 SS=15.5/20
05 RP=85-86
04 WS=82
03 WS=86
10 WS=85
10 WE=89
10 RP=90
10 JR=14.5 (84)
09 RP=87-90
08 RP=88-89
09 $30-49 RP
08 $23-36 RP
05 WW=89-91
05 $60 B&M
10 50%CS-36%Merlot-11%CF-2%PV 10 ST=90
10 JJB=90
09 42%CS-40%M-CF-PV
09 ST=90
09 RP=90-92+
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 WE=93
08 ST=89
08 RP=89-91
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=88-90
07 Value < $500 QRW Autumn 08
07 RP=88-90
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=89
Clevens
Ch Clinet
Bordeaux l’Independence Red 09
06 RP=91+
06 WE=90
06 Top Pics K&L
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=91
05highly Rec’d WS
05 WS=95
05 WW=89-91
05 ST=92
05 WE=91/91
04 WS=90
04 WE=90
04 RP=87-88
04 ST=89
03 WE=89
03 WS=93
03 Good WD 10/05
03 WD=15/20
02 ST=89
02 WS=89
09 WS=87
05 $8-18 RP
10 $15 WS
10 $14 Zachys
09 $50-86 RP
08 $38 K&L
08 $37-80 RP
08 $45 Zachys
08 $41 JJB
07 $32-62 RP
07 $45 K&L
07 $42 Zachys
07 $57 B&M
07 C$69 BCLS
06 $32-74 RP
06 $70 B&M
05 $60 B&M
03 $47 B&M
09 $17 WS
Bordeaux Sup Fossile 09
09 WS=86
09 $20 WS
Les Triologies Ltd Res 09
09 WS=87
09 $20 WS
St-Emilion la Procession 09
09 WS=88
09 $24 WS
10 ST=88
10 TWCI=95-96
10 JJB=95
09 ST=89
09 RP=97-100
08 RP=94-97
08 ST=88
08 WE=92-94
07 RP=91
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=90
06 RP=90+
06 WS=90
10 $128+ ST
Pomerol 02-10
09 $180 ST
09 $162-275 RP
08 $90-126 RP
08 $65 K&L
08 $125 Zachys
07 $48-73 RP
07 $65 K&L
07 $63 Zachys
06 $47-79 RP
06 $73 WS
48
06 WE=91
06 ST=88-91
05 Hughly Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 WS=93
05 Fine Tannins, delicious finish WW 05 ST=89-92
03 Wine of quality. A success WD
Clos
See: main/family name
Clos du Clocher
Pomerol 04/06/07/08/09
Ch Olivier
Pessac-Leognan 08
La Closerie de Fourtet
St-Emilion 11
05 W&S=2stars
05 WE=92/90
05 RP=93-95
04 WS=88
04 ST=89
04 RP=90
03 ST=87
03 WS=91
03 WD=17+/20
03 RP=86
02 ST=88
02 WS=88
02 RP=88
09 WE=91
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=83-85
07 ST=85
06 WS=89
06 RP=89
05 WS=91
05 WE=92
02 RP=87-88
08 WS=88
05 $140 WS
05 C$179 BCLS
05 $49-184 RP
02 441-92 RP
08 $45-54 RP
07 $31-41 RP
06 $35 WS
05 $34 WS
08 $25 WS
11 $25 JJB Fut
05 WS=88
Ch la Clotte
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
05 Very Sussessful Hachette 09
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=91-93
07 RP=89
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=85
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=89
05 ST=90
05 WS=92
05 RP=91-94
04 WS=89
04 RP=90
03 WS=88
03 RP=90
09 $40-56 RP
08 $30-39 RP
07 $38-50 RP
10 WS=88
07 WS=87
10 $16 WS
03 RP=85-87
03 $20 RP
06 $35 RP
05 $40 WS
05 $37-40 RP
04 $26 WS
04 $29-30 RP
Ch de Clotte
Ch la Clotte de Jouanin
Bordeaux 09
Ch du Cluzeau
Listrac-Medoc 05
La Coin
Bordeaux 10/11
09 Silver LA 11
05 WE=86
11/10 Silver LA 12
49
Dom des Collines
Dom des Combes
Bordeaux 08//09/10/11
09 CF-CS-Merlot
07 Bronze LA 11
11 JR=16 (88)
10 WE=83
10 TWCI=85-88
10 $13 WE
09 Silver LA 12; Bronze Paris 11
Bordeaux Sup 08
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
Ch les Combes
09 Gold Paris 11
Ch de Come
St-Estephe 05/07/08/09/10
08 WS=85
05 WE=85
08 $11 WS
10 RP=87
10 $23 RP
07 Cab Sauv; Comm’d IWC 10
Ch la Commanderie
St-Emilion 05/08
St-Esthephe Cru Bourgeois 03-10
09 Silver Bordeaux 10; Decanter 12
05 Well made SS in Decanter 06
05 WS=83
08 WS=88
05 WS=89
10 RP=86
09 RP=87-89
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=86
05 SS=15/20
05 WS=84
04 WS=88
04 RP=88
03 Gold Brussels 06
03 WS=90
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 03 RP=88-90
03 Silver Aquitaine 05
02 WS=88
02 RP=86-88
Ch Commanderie Mazeyres Pomerol 04/05/06/07
07 WS=83-86
07 RP=85-87
06 Bronze Paris 09
06 WS=90
05 WS=89
05 ST=87-90
04 WS=87
03 WS=88
Ch Commanderie Queyret Medoc 06/07
06 WW=86
07 Cited wine Hachette 10
Ch Compassant (Thunevin) Bordeaux Bad Boy 04/06
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=80-84
05 Sleeper of the vintsge RP
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=87
Ch la Confession
St-Emilion 03-09 (CF-Merlot-CS)
09 JJB=93-95
09 RP=90-93
08 RP=92-94
07 RP=87
07 WS=87-90
06 NM=91
06 RP=91
05 WS=89
05 RP=94-96
04 RP=91
03 WS=85-88
03 RP=90
02 WS=88
Confiance Gerard Depardieu Cuvee d’Exception Prem Cotes de Blaye 06-09
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=89
06 RP=89-90
06 RP=88
Connetable de Talbot
St-Julien 05
05 WS=88
05 $30 wine.com
10 $17-23 RP
09 $19-24 RP
04 $15-17 RP
06 $15 B&M
09 $33-43 RP
08 $28-41 RP
07 $27-55 RP
07 $42 Zachys
06 $62 NM
06 $31-57 RP
05 $86 WS
05 $70-80 RP
04 $22-35 RP
07 $35-42 RP
06 $35 RP
05 $30 WS
50
Ch la Connivence
Pomerol 08
Ch la Conseillante
Pomerol 03-10
08 WS=88
10 ST=90
10 JJB=97
09 81%Merlot-CF
09 ST=92
09 RP=95-98
08 RP=92-94+
08 WS=90-93
08 ST=90
07 ST=88
07 RP=89
07 WS=88-91
06 WE=91
06 Very good, excellent potential WD 06 WD=17.5-18.5
06 RP=93
06 ST=91-92
06 WS=94
05 WS=97
05 W&S=2stars
05 Best in a long time WW 06
05 ST=93
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WE=87/90
05Coup de Coeur Hachette 09
05 RP=93-95
05 W&S=96
04 WS=92
04 ST=88
04 RP=89
03 Real success WD 10/05
03 ST=87
03 WS=90
03 WD=17.5/20
03 RP=89
02 ST=88
02 WS=90
02 RP=82
10 $220+ ST
09 $215+ ST
09 $195-299 RP
08 $73-120 RP
08 $75 Zachys
08 $75 K&L
07 $70 K&L
07 $70-108 RP
07 $105 Zachys
06 $150 WE
06 $99-140 RP
06 $137 WS
05 $189 WS
05 $78-209 RP
05 $350 W&S
04 $63-112 RP
See also: Duo Conseillante
Ch Le Conseiller
Bordeaux Superieur 07/08/09/10
Ch Coquillas
Pessac-Leognan 06
Ch Corbin
St-Emilion GC 03/05/06/07/08/09
10 100% Merlot
07 RP=88
07 WS=86-89
06 WS=87
05 NM=91 & 90
05 WS=88
04 IWR=91
06 WE=88
Montagne St-Emilion 10
Ch Corbin-Michotte
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=86-88
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=87
05 Great finesse, med fruit/finish WW 05 WS=92
05 No elegance SS in Decanter 06
05 SS=14/20
05 WW=90-92
05 RP=88-90
04/03 WS=87
03 WE=87
02 WS=88
06/05/04 Cited Wine Hachette 10/09
St-Emilion les Abeilles 06/07
10 RP=91
10 TWCI=88-89
09 RP=88-90
09 RP=90-91
09 RP=87-89
08 WS=85
07 RP=81-83
05 WE=91
07 RP=81-83
10 $20-22 RP
09 $13-16 RP
08 $20-22 RP
08 $18 WClub
07 $24 RP
06 $21 WS
05 C$26 NM
05 $25 WS
09 $30 RP
08 $19-26 RP
06 $26 WS
06 $28 K&L
05 $43 WS
05 $27-35 RP
04 $24 WS
05 $40 WE
51
Ch Corconnac
Haut-Medoc 10
Ch Cordeillan-Bages
Pauillac 04/05/06/07/08
10 60%CS-40%Merlot
Ch Cormeil Figeac
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Cornelie
Haut Medoc 05/06
Ch Cornemps
Ch Cos d’Estournel
St-Estephe GC 01-10
06 WE=86
10 ST=86
08 WS=89
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=87
03 WS=86
03 RP=88-90
02 RP=87
06 WS=89
06 WE=94
05 WS=89
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=87
05 ST=87-89
00 WR=89
10 WE=88
10 78%CS-19%Merlot-2%CF-1%PV 10 ST=93
09 65%CS-33%M-CF
09 ST=88
09 RP=98-100
09 WS=97-100
09 WE=94-96
09 One of 32 Top JJB
09 JJB=97-99
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08 WE=95
08 RP=94-96+
08 WS=91-94
08 ST=91
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=90
07 WS=90
07 ST=91
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Very racy WW 06
06 WE=94/95
06 RP=94
06 ST=93
06 WS=93
05 W&S=95
05 ST=96
05 WS=98
05 WW=96-98
05 WE=96/97
05 ST=94-96
05 RP=94-96
04 WS=94
04 ST=91
04 RP=92
03 WE=95
03 ST=94
03 WS=97
03 RP=98
02 ST=93
02 WS=93
02 RP=93
01 WS=94
01 RP=93
06 $23 WE
05 $70 WS ?
05 $27-35 RP
04 $55 WS
06 $35 WS
10 $14 WE
09 $298-433 RP
09 $330 K&L
08 $130 K&L
08 $109-184 RP
08 $135 Zachys
07 $100-163 RP
07 $110 K&L
07 $110 Zachys
07 $130 B&M
07 C$376 BCLS
06 $150 B&M
06 $91-205 RP
06 $100 K&L
06 $138 WS
06 C$219 BCLS
05 $300 W&S
05 $232 B&M
05 C$349 BCLS
04 $120 K&L
01 $130 K&L
See also their second wine: Les Pagodes
52
Ch de Costis
Ch Cote de Baleau
Bordeaux 09
09 Silver LA 11
Bordeaux Cuvee Speciale 08/10
10 Bronze LA 12
08 Silver LA 10
St-Emilion 04-10
10 WS=84
10 $12 WS
10 WS=89
10 RP=91
09 RP=88-91+
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=88
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=83
06 WS=90
10 $23 WS
10 $18-28 RP
09 $20 RP
08 $14-19 RP
07 $14-17 RP
05 RP=87-89
05 WS=89
Ch Cote Montpezat
04 WS=84
04 RP=87
03 WS=88
03 RP=87-90
12 WS=87-90
11 WS=86-89
08 WS=78
12 RP=84-86
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 08-12
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux Compostelle
11 WS=86-89
10 ST=87
10 WS=90
09 RP=87
09 WS=89
Ch Cotes de Roi
St-Emilion 05/06 (05= Merlot)
Ch la Coudraie
Bordeaux 09/10
Ch Coufran
05 Comm’d IWC 09
06 $20-30 RP
06 $26 WS
06 C$28 LCBO
05 $10-30 RP
05 $25 WS
05 $24 Zachys
14 $11-15 RP
10 $16+ ST
10 $17 WS
10 $17 K&L
09 $14-25 RP
09 $19 WS
09 $18 WClub
09 $16 K&L
09 $16 JJB
09 $19 wine.com
08 WS=88
06 WS=87
06 $12 WS
05 RP=85-86
05 WS=84
05 $17 Sh-L
05 JMQ=85
05 Decanter=14.5
04 WS=83
03 WS=87
06 WS=82
05 WS=87
10 WS=87
10 $10 WS
09 $17 Zachys
10 WS=88
10 $21 WS
10 RP=86
10 $15-21 RP
10 ST=87
10 JJB=89-90
09 RP=87-88
09 $18-26 RP
09 WE=91
09 $25 K&L
09 WS=88
09 JS=92
JR=16.5 (90)
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=85-87
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=84
06 $28 RP
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
05 $28 WS
05 WE=92
05 RP=88-90
05 $18 RP
05 SS=15.5/20
04 WE=89
04 $13 K&L
04 WS=87
53
04/03 Silver Brussels 07/06
Ch Couhins
04 RC=88
04 RP=87-89
03 WS=88
03 RP=89
10 ST=86
06 Silver Paris 09
Ch Couhins-Lurton
Pessac-Leognan 04/05/06/07 (Merlot-CS)
04 $20 RP
03 $20 K&L
05 €23-30 Hach
07 WS=86
07 ST=85
06 WE=90
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=85
05 ST=88
05 WS=91
04 WE=90
04 WS=86
06 $47 WE
06 $35 WS
05 $38 WS
Ch de la Cour d’Argent
Bordeaux 08/09/10/11/12
10 Bronze LA 12
09 Silver LA 11
08 Gold LA 10
Ch du Courlat
03 WS=88
10 RP=90
09 RP=86-87
06 WS=83
Lussac-St-Emilion Cuvee Jean-Baptiste 06-10
Lussac-St-Emilion 03/04/05/06
Ch la Couronne
Ch Couronneau
06 $28 WS
05 WS=80-84
05 RP=80-84
03 WS=85
03 RP=85
08 WS=88
03 $20 WS
03 $20 RP
08 $25 WS
06 WS=85
05 WS=90
05 $25 WS
Bordeaux Superiere Pierre de Cartier 01-06
05 Silver Paris 07
Dom de Courteillac Bordeaux Sup Merlot-Cabernet 05-10
08 Bronze LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Merlot-Cab 08
10 $25 RP
04 WE=89
04 WS=83
03 WS=90
02 WR=93
12 RP=86-88
11 RP=84-86
10 RP=86
10 $8-18 RP
10 CellarT 87.6 (9) 10 $18 Zachys
09 RP=86-87
09 $11 RP
09 $11 JJB
08 RP=87
06 RP=86
06/05 WS=85-88
05 RP=87-89
06 WS=90
05/03 WS= 85-88
03 RP=87-88
02 WS=79
01 WE=84
01 WS=81
10 WS=87
10 ST=86
09 WS=87
09 RP=88-89
08 RP=87-89
08 NM=86
07 RP=89-91
06 WS=86
05 WS=90
05 RP=87
08 WS=86
06 $23 WS
03 $18 RP
10 $14 WS
09 $18 WS
09 $16 RP
08 $16 RP
07 $13-16 RP
08 $16 WS
54
Ch Courtin
Paulliac 05
05 WS=84
Ch la Couspaude
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
10 JJB=94
09 WE=91
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=90
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=86
06 RP=90
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=88
05 RP=90-92
05 WS=92
04 WS=88
04 RP=89
03 WS=91
03 RP=85-87
05 WE=89
Ch Coustolle
Canon-Fronsac la Horse 05
Ch Coutet
St-Emilion 02/03/04/05/06/08
08 Bronze IWC 12
08 WS=88
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
Coutelin
Merville 10
Couvent des Jacobins
St-Emilion 05/06/07
Ch le Crock
04 WS=85
03 RP=93-96
03 WS=95
02 RP=89
02 WS=87
10 RP=86+
09 $54-67 RP
08 $35-43 RP
06 $38-40 RP
06 $75 WS
05 $31-70 RP
05 $67 WS
04 $43 WS
04 $35-42 RP
05 $35 WE
08 $30 WS
05 $34 WS
05 $55 Zachys
04 $40 WS
10 $20 RP
07 RP=86-88
07 ST=85
10 WS=90
09 WE=93
09 RP=90-92
09 WS=91-94
08 WS=89
08 RP=82-84+
07 RP=85-87
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=89
05 RP=87-89
05 SS=15.5/20
04 WS=88
03 RP=87-89
05 IWR=87
Ch la Crois de Roche
Ch la Croix
Fronsac 04/05/06
06/05/04 Very Successful Hachette 10/09/08
Ch de la Croix
Medo 05/06
06/05 Cited Wine 10/09
La Croix de Beaucaillou
St-Julien 04-10 (Ch Ducru-Beaucaillou)
10 85%CS-15%Merlot
09 75%CS-25%Merloy
10 ST=87
09ST=87
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=89-91
07 WE=90
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
10 $25 WS
09 $25 K&L
09 $22-28 RP
09 $23 JJB
05 $20 WS
05 $18-96 RP
05 $13 IWR
09 $39-56 RP
08 $26-42 RP
08 $32 Zachys
07 $35 Zachys
07 $37 K&L
06 $37-44 RP
06 $36 WS
55
05 One of top 8 “Seconds” QWR
05 WS=91
05 NM=93
04 WS=88
06 Gold Brussels 09
06 WS=85
04 WE=86
04 WS=81
03 WS=85-88
09 Very great value K&L
05 $33 WS
05 C$58 NM
05 $29-38 RP
Ch la Croix Bellevue
Lalande de Pomerol 04/05/06
Ch La Croix Blanche
La Croix Bonis
St-Estephe 06
06 WS=86
Croix Cardinale
Bordeaux 11
$13/375 JJB
La Croix du Casse
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
11 JS=90
11 RP=90-92
09 RP=88-90
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=86
06 WS=86
05 WS=92
Ch Croix de l’Esperance
08 RP=89-91
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
08 $14-26 RP
06 $30 RP
10 RP=89
09 WS=92-95
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=85
10 $16-21 RP
09 $19 JJB
09 ST=88
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=89-91
07 WS=86
07 RP=85-87
09 $30+ ST
09 $30-40 RP
08 $24-30 RP
07 $30 WS
07 $22-27 RP
07 C$34 LCBO
06 $29-40 RP
06 $32 WS
05 $35 K&L
05 $36 WS
05 $19-38 RP
$14 K&L
09 $28-40 RP
07 $22-29 RP
07 $29 WS
06 $37 WS
05 $32 WS
Ch Croix-Figeac
St-Emilion 06/07/09/10
See former name Ch Rocher Bellevue Figeac
Ch la Croix de Gay
Pomerol 05/07/08/09
Ch Croix de Labrie
St-Emilion 02-09
06 RP=88
06 WS=90
05 WE=89/89
05 WS=87
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=86
04 RP=87
03 WS=90
03 RP=85
02 WS=88
02 RP=86-87
09 RP=92-95
08 RP=93-95
07 RP=93
07 ST=89
06 RP=94
06 WS=85-88
06 ST=88-91
05 RP=94-96
05 WS=89-91
05 ST=90-92
04 RP=89
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 WS=87
03 RP=93
Ch la Croix Lartigue
Cotes de Castillon 04/06/08/09
09 WS=92-95
08 RP=84-86
09 $56-80 RP
08 $60 Zachys
07 $42-59 RP
07 $57 K&L
07 $60 Zachys
06 $50-80 RP
05 $78-97 RP
09 $22 JJB
56
Ch la Croix Melin
St-Emilion 08
Ch Croix de Mission
Ch la Croix des Moines
Lalande de Pomerol 04/05/06/07
08 WE=88
08 $22 WE
10 WS=88
10 WE=89
09 WW=90
10 $17 WS
09 $25 B&M
07 Gold Brussels 10
06 Gold Brussels 09
05 WS=82
04 WE=88
Lalande de Pomerol L’Ambroisie 03/05/06/09
09 ST=87
06/05 WS=85-88
03 WS=90
Haut Medoc Bordeaux Sup 04-12( Ch Mouton)
12/11 RP=87-89
11 WS=90?
10 87%Merlot-12%CF-1%PV
10 RP=90
10 IWCI=87-88
10 NM=90-91
10 JS=89-90
10 JR=15.5 (86)
10 CellarT=86 (7)
09 86%Merlot-CF-others
09 RP=90
09 Cellart=86 (26)
09 TWCI 87/85
08 RP=87
08 JJB=86-88
08 WS=85-88
07 RP=88-90
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=89
05 RP=89
05 65%Merlot-35%CS-CR-PV-Malbec 05 IWR=85
05 WE=92
04 WW=88
Bordeaux 07
07 JR=16 (88)
09 $19 Sh-L
Bordeaux Sup Res 09
09 $18 WS
Ch Croix Mouton
Bordeaux Sup 20 Mille 07/10
09 WS=88
10 100% Merlot
11 $12 JJB Fut
11 $14 wine.com
10 $13-23 RP
10 $18 Sh-L
10 $19 Zachys
10 TWCI=89-91
07 WS=88-91
La Croix de Perenne
Cuvee d’Exception Prem Cote de Blaye 06-09
07=100% Merlot
06 Gold Brussels 10
06/05/04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10
06/04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10
La Croix de Peyrolie
Cuvee d’Exception (Gerard Depardieu) LussacSt-Emilion 06/07/08/09/10
Lussac-St-Emilion 05
La Croix du Prieure
See: Bernard Magrez
Ch Croix de Rambeau
Lussac St-Emilion 03/04/06
Ch la Croix de Roche
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=90-93
07 ST=87
06 RP=89
10 RP=92
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=87-89
06 RP=87
05 “Coup de Coeur” Gachette 09
Bordeaux Sup 07/09
Fronsac Collection Privee 06
Ch La CroixSaint Benoit
Bordeaux Sup La Virvee 09
09 Silver LA 12
La Croix St-Georges
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
04 WE=89
04 WS=84
09 RP=87-88
09 RP=90-92+
08 RP=93-95
06 $25 RP
10 $25 RP
06 $25 RP
05 €46-60 Hach
04 $22 WS
09 $45-50 RP
08 $46-80 RP
08 $65 Zachys
57
07 RP=88
07 WS=89-92
06 RP=91
05 WS=92
05 RP=92-95
04 RP=88
03 RP=89
03 WS=89
St-Georges-St-Emilion 04/05
Ch la Croix Taillefer
Pomerol 05/09
Ch Croizet-Bages
Paulliac GC 03-10
St-Emilion 07
Ch Cru Cantemerle
Bordeaux Sup Grand Res 09/10
Cru Monplaisir
Bordeaux 10
Ch Cruzeau
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch de Cruzeau
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05/06/07 (Cab Sauv)
10 WE=85
Lalande-de-Pomerol la Croix des Landes 05
St-Emilion 04/05/06
Ch Dame Jane
10 $24 WE
06 WS=83
Lalande-de-Pomerol 04-11 (90%Merlot-CF)
Clos de la Cure
10 ST=88
09 RP=87=89
09 $27-33 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
08 WBlB=87
08 $15-30 WBlB
08 ST=87
07 RP=75-77
07 $29-38 RP
06 RP=77
06 $29-40 RP
06 WS=84
05 WS=80-84
05 WE=89
05 RP=86-88
05 $27 RP
04 WS=84
04 RP=86
04 $26 RP
07 WS=88
07 $29 WS
03 WS=83
03 RP=85
09 Silver LA 10; Decanter 12
06 Comm’d IWC 10
Ch les Cruzelles
04 €8-11 Hach
09 RP=86-88
Ch le Cros
08 $60 K&L
07 $42-53 RP
07 $58 Zachys
07 C$75 BCLS
06 $60-95 RP
05 $93 WS
05 $46-76 RP
04 $38 RP
03 $30-60 RP
03 $19 WS
06 Very Successful Havhette 10
07 WS=83
07 NM=88
06 WS=82
05 WS=90
04 WS=86
03 WS=87
01 RP=85-87
11 NM=90-92
09 RP=90-93
09 ST=88
08 WS=85
08 RP=90-92
06 RP=88
06 ST=85-88
06 WS=87
06 WBlB=86
05 WS=87
05 ST=88-90
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=86
04 RP=85
05 WS=85
07 $25 Dec
07 C$25 NM
06 $35 WS
05 $29 WS
04 $23
$22 JJB Fut
09 $26-30 RP
08 $28 WS
08 $18-32 RP
06 $10-25 RP
06 $23 WS
05 $24 WS
05 $24 RP
04 $10-19 RP
06 WS=88
06 $23 WS
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=84
10 $14 WE
Le D de Dassault
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=87
Ch Dalem
Fronsac 06/07/08/09/10
10 WS=91
10 $23 WS
58
Dallau
09
Ch Damase
06 Bronze LA 10
Carmenere Superieur 06
La Dame de Montrose
St-Estephe 03-09 (Ch Montrose second wine)
08=56 %M-44%CS
10 RP=89
09 RP=89-91
09 WS=90-93
08 WS=90
08 RP=86-88
07 WS=88
07 RP=87-88
06 RP=89
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
10 $18-24 RP
09 $16-24 RP
09 $20 JJB
08/07 $25 WS
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=86-88
09 $16-24 RP
06 WS=83
06 $14 WS
06 WS=82
06 $16 WS
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=89-90
08 WE=91
09 $40-64 RP
08 $25-37 RP
08 $25 K&L
08 $29 Zachys
07 $21-36 RP
07 $25 Zachy
07 $35 B&M
07 RP=88
Ch Darzac
Ch Dassault
Bordeaux Sup Reserve 06/10
10 Best Buy WE
Bordeaux Sup Heritage 10
St.-Emilion GC 03-10 (Merlot)
05 Magnificent, long, zesty WW
05 Most complete ever Decanter 06
Daugay
09
Ch de la Dauphine
Fronsac 04-10
07 WW=87-88
06 WE=90
06 RP=90
06 WS=80-84
06 ST=87-90
05 WS=89
05 RP=89-91
04 RP=86-88
04 $32
03 WS=90
10 WE=87
06 WE=83
10 WE=90
10 ST=87
10 JJB=91
09 RP=86-88
08 WS=90
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=85
06 RP=89
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=86
05 WS=92
05 SS=17/20
05 WW=92-95
05 WE=87
05 ST=89
05 RP=92
04 WS=88
04 RP=89
04 WW=92-94
07 $14-16 RP
06 $25 RP
06 $24-52 RP
06 $45 B&M
05 $35 WS
05 $36 Zachys
05 $30-36 RP
04 $25-29 RP
10 $12 WE
06 $15 WE
10 $20 WE
09 $40 RP
08 $25-34 RP
07 $25-32 RP
07 $40 B&M
06 $29-30 RP
06 $45 B&M
06 $35 WS
05 $40 WS
05 $35 B&M
05 $40 K&L
05 $34-35 RP
04 $34-40 RP
04 $38 B&M
03 WS=90
03 RP=88
03 WW=92
09 RP=88-90
06 RP=89
09 $25-28 RP
06 $35 RP
10 90%Merlot-10%CF
10 $16-24 RP
10 RP=87
59
09 Silver Paris 11
04 Very Sucessful Hachette 08
Fronsac Delphis du Ch de la Dauphine 07
Ch Dauzac
Le Clos Daviaud
Montagne-St-Emilion 06/08 (60%M-21%CF-CS)
La Defi de Fontenil
Fronsac 04/05/09 (Ch Fontenil’s second wine)
(09=100%Merlot)
10 $24 K&L
10 $21 JJB
09 $21+ ST
09 $20 RP
09 $21 K&L
08/07 $24 WS
06 $15-24 RP
06 $17 WS
05 $27 K&L
05 $17 RP
04 $15-22 RP
Margaux 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
Bordeaux Res 05
10 ST=86
10 WS=90-93
10 TWCI=89-90
09 ST=88
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=90-93
08 WS=89
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=88
06 RP=89
06 WS=86
05 WS=87
05 NM=91
05 RP=90
04 WE=89
04 WS=84
04 RP=87
03 WS=85
03 RP=88
02 WS=86
02 RP=81
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=88-91
07 RP=84-87?
07 WS=86-89
06 RP=87
06 WE=91
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=88
05 WE=92/93
05 ST=86-88
05 WS=92
05 RP=89-90
04 WS=87
04 WE=91
04 RP=87
03 WS=87
02 WS=84
02 RP=87
01 WS=91
09 $35-51 RP
07 $23-58 RP
06 $39-54 RP
05 $41 Zachys
05 $45 WS
05 $37-42 RP
05 Bronze IWC 07
04 Merlot
Ch Delord
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 05
Ch des Demoiselles
Clos des Demoiselles
Listrac-Medoc 06/07/08/09
09 Bronze IWC 12
08 ST=85
06 WS=85
09 ST=88
05 WS=92-94
04 ST=89
nv RP=91-93
nv RP=91-92
05 IWR=87
10 WE=86
06 $30 WS
nv $40 RP
10 $17 WE
06 WS=87
Denis Dubourdieu
Cuvee Numero 2 Winemaker’s Sel 06
06 RP=91
06 $35-40 RP
D’Escurac
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=89
10 $12-17 RP
Ch Desmirail
Margaux 05/06/07/08/09 (Ch Brane-Cantenac)
09 ST=88
09 RP=85-87
08 WS=87
08 ST=86
08 JJB=87-89
09 $28-35 RP
60
Ch Destieux
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
03 Vin Rematquable Hachette 07
Ch Deyrem-Valentin
Margaux 05/06/07/10
Diane de Belgrave
Haut-Medoc 05/07
Ch Dillon
Bordeaux Clarendale Red 10
Divinus de Ch Bonnet
Bordeaux 04/05/06
07 Cab Sauv; Silver Brussels 09
07 Bronze IWC 10
05 Very Siccessful Hachette 09
07 RP=78-81
06 RP=76
06 WE=87
05 WE=89
01 WE=89
09 RP=91-94
08 WS=88
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=88-90
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=90
05 WS=92
05 ST=87-89
05 RP=92-94
04 RP=89
03 WS=80-84
03 RP=92
10 RP=89
05 WS=83
10 WS=88
10 RP=87
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=89-91
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/09
Le Dome
St-Emilion GC 04-10
09 80%CF-20%Merlot
Ch Domenye
St-Estephe 05/06/08/09/10
05 $28 K&L
05 $24-28 RP
04 $21 RP
09 $38-53 RP
07 $25-37 RP
06 $27-38 RP
05 $45 WS
05 $46 Zachys
05 $36-50 RP
10 $18-28 RP
06 WE=88
05 WS=85
04/03 Vin Remarqable Hachette 08/07 04/03 WS=87
Ch du Dom de l’Eglise
07 $43-56 RP
06 $35 RP
09 WE=90
07 WS=86-89
06 WS=85-88
06 ST=87-90
06 RP=88-91
05 WS=89-91
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=88
04 RP=89
03 WS=90
03 RP=87-89
10 ST=90
09 ST=93
09 WE=95
09 RP=95-97
08 ST=89
08 RP=95-97
07 RP=92-94
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=89
06 RP=94
06 WE=93
06 ST=92
06 WS=90
05 WE=93/95
05 WS=93
05 ST=90-92
04 WS=89
04 ST=90
03 WS=87
04 WE=93
10 ST=86
10 $25 WS
10 $20 RP
04 $35 WS
06 $33-34 RP
05 $41 RP
04 $56-65 RP
09 $135-150 RP
08 $143-144 RP
07 $165-205 RP
06 $200-211 RP
06 $260 WE
06 C$199 BCLS
05 $263 WS
61
Ch la Dominique
St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09/10
06 Silver Paris 09
05 Caressing WW 06
05 Rich, elegant, great future Dec 06
09 WS=91-94
08 ST=86
06 WS=90
09 $22 JJB
10 ST=88
10 JJB=92
09 WE=92
09 ST=89
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=90
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=85
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=85
05 WS=89
05 SS=17/20
05 WE=90
05 ST=88
05 RP=90-92
04 RP=76-78
10 $45+ ST
09 $42-59 RP
08 $28-34 RP
07 $29-35 RP
06 $54 RP
05 $50 WS
05 $42-46 RP
Dourthe
Fronsac 09
09 ST=88
09 $21+ ST
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=86
10 $13 WE
06 AG=87
06 C$25.49 AG
05 €5-8 Hach
04 WS=84
04 $13 WS
08 NM=87
08 C$16 NM
Bordeaux Numero 1 - 05/06/07 (Merlot-CS)
Bordeaux Grands Terroirs 11
Bordeaux Res 09
Bordeauc Grand Res 09
Bordeaux La Grande Cuvee 10 (Merlot)
07 Bronze IWC 09
05 Comm’d IWC 07
05 Bronze IWSC 07
11 Comm’d IWC 12
11 CF-CS-Merlot
09 Silver IWSC 12
07 Bronze IWSC 10
06 BronzeChallenge, Decanter 10
St-Emilion la Grand Cuvee 05/06/07/08 (CS+)
St-Emilion Terroirs d’Exception Croix Menuts
Medoc Res 09
07 Gold Bordeaux 09
06 Bronze IWSC; Decanter 10
06 Comm’d IWC 10
09 Bronzr Decanter 12
Medoc Terroiirs d’Exception Terrasse Jalle 09
09 CS-Merlot
10 Bronze Decanter, IWSCyyh 12
06/05/04 Very Successful Hachette 09
Grave la Grande Cuvee 04
Montagne St-Emilion la Grande Cuvee 10
10 CS-Merlot
Medoc Grand Terroirs 10/11
Medoc la Grande Cuvee 10
Montagne St-Emilion Res 10
62
10 CS-Merlot
See also: Ch Pey la Tour
03 RP=82
03 $33-44 RP
Le Douves de la Tour Camer Bordeaux 10
10 RP=87
10 $25 RP
Ch Doyac
10 WS=88
08 WW=88
08 CellarT 86 (5)
10 $25 WS
08 $24 B&M
Haut-Medoc 07/08/09/10
07 Bronze Paris 09
Ch le Doyenne
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 04/05/06/08/09/10
08 RP=88-90
08 WS=88
07 RP=90
06 RP=87
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=80-84
05 ST=89-91
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=82
06 RP=87
Dubois Grimon
06
Duo Conseillante
Pomerol 08
Ch Doyac
Bordeaux 06/08
Ch le Doyenne
Ch Dubourg
St-Emilion 07/08/09
09 Gold Paris 11
St-Emilion GC 04-10
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
10 90%Merlot-10%CF
Clos Dubreuil
Ch Ducla (Yvon Mau)
05 Bronze IWC 07
Ch Ducluzeau
Listrac Cru Bourfeosi 04/05/08
07 $29-35 RP
06 $20 RP
06 $25 RP
08 WW=88
06 WW=89
09 RP=88-89
05 IWR=87
09 $11 JJB
05 $20 IWR
08 WS=74
08 $20 WS
10 ST=90
10 TWCI=91-92
09 RP=93-95
08 RP=92-94
07 RP=89
07 WS=83-85
06 RP=91
06 WS=90
05 RP=88-91
05 WS=90
05 WE=88
04 WE=86
04 WS=90
04 RP=91
08 $24 B&M
09 $69 RP
07 $65-75 RP
06 $66-88 RP
05 $150 WE
Bordeaux Sup Permanence 04/05/06/08/09
Bordeaux Sup Experience 10
10 $11-14 RP
09 $11-12 RP
09 $11 JJB
08 $34 Zachys
St-Emilion Anna 04
05 WS=84
10 RP=86
09 RP=88-89
04 Vin remarquable Hachette 07
04 Silver IWC, VinalesInt’l 06
04=50%Merlot 25%CS 25%CF
10 Merlot-CS
09 Gold Paris 11
09 WE=86
08 NM=89 & 87
06 NM=87
08 C$15 LCBO
06 C$15 NM
05 WE=86
05 WS=82
04 WS=81
06 WE=87
06 $13 WE
05 WE=86
05 $15 WE
08 Decanter=3star
63
Dubois Grimon
09
Ch Ducru-Beaucaillou
St-Julien 01-10
08 SS=16.0/20
05 WS=85-88
05/04 RP=84-86
04 WS=86
03 WS=84
09 RP=86-88
10 90%CS-10%Merlot
09 85% Cab Sauv-15%Merlot
07=90%CS-10%Merlot
05 Intense, big, silky WW 06
10 ST=93
09 WE=96
09 ST=93
09 RP=96-98+
09 WS=96-99
09 JJB=95-97
08 RP=96-98
08 WE=93-95
08 ST=90
07 RP=90
07 WE=93
07 WS=90
07 ST=91
06 RP=94
06 WE=94
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=95
05 ST=94
05 WS=95
05 WE=95
05 RP=96
05 W&S=94
04 WS=92
04 ST=90+
04 RP=93
03 WE=91
03 ST=92
03 WS=97
03 RP=96
02 RP=89
02 WS=89-91
02 ST=90-92
02 RP=89
01 WS=92
01 RP=89
04 $25 RP
10 $220+ ST
09 $260 K&L
09 $225-332 RP
08 $102-175 RP
08 $100 K&L
08 $250 Zachys
07 $71-132 RP
07 $95 WE
07 $90 K&L
07 $95 Zachys
07 C$149 BCLS
06 $95-394 RP
06 C$229 BCLS
06 $145 WS
05 C$319 BCLS
05 $221 WS
05 $209 B&M
05 $99-275 RP
05 $270 W&S
See also their second wine: La Croix de Beaucaillon
Ch Dudon Jean-Baptiste
Cotes de Bordeaus
10 70%CabSauv-15%CabFeanc
10 ST=86
Ch Duhart-Milon
Paulliac 4th Cru 03-10
10 73%CS-27%Merlot
09 63%CS-37%Merlot
10 ST=86
09 WE=93
09 ST=89
09 RP=94-96
08 WBlB=92
08 RP=93-95
08 WE=91-93
08 ST=88
07 RP=90
07 WE=89
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=87
06 RP=92
06 WE=93
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=89
05 RP=90-92
05 ST=91+?
05 WS=93
05 WE=89/90
04 ST=89
08 Great Value WBlB
07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08
05 Chewy, rich, powerful WW 06
10 $120+ ST
09 $59-192
08 $43 WBlB
08 $100-300 RP
08 $49 Zachys
08 $50 K&L
07 $147-184tt RP
07 C$79 BCLS
07 $45 K&L
07 $42 Zachys
06 $38-71 RP
06 $81 B&M
05 $80 B&M
04 $40 B&M
64
Paulliac Moulin de Duhart 08
Ch Duluc de Branaire Ducru St-Julien 05
Ch Duplessis
Moulis 10
Ch Duplessy
Ch Durfort-Vivens
Margaux Cru 01-10
Ch Dutruch Grand Poujeaux Moulis-en-Medoc 05/06/07/08/09
04 WS=87
04 WE=91
04 RP=91
03 WE=89
03 $35 WE
03 RP=92
03 RC=92
03 Cellart=92 (155)
08 WS=88
05 WS=88
05 WW=92
10 WS=88
05 Zachys #1 selling Bordeaux
05 CellarT=90 (7)
05=25%CS-45%M-20%CF-10%Malbec
10 ST=89
10 JJB=91
09 WE=91
09 ST=88
09 RP=87-89+
08 ST=88
08 JJB=82-84
07 RP=88
07 WE=87
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=86
06 Unusual style WD
06 WS=88
06 WE=90/93
06 WD=14.5-15.5
06 ST=86-88
05 WS=85-88
06 WE=93
05 WS=92
05 WW=90-92
05 Nice aroma, fine fruit, zippy WW 05 WE=90/89
04 Bronze IWC 07
05 ST=88+?
03 Lacking WD 10/05
05 WW=90-92
04 WS=87
04 WE=92
04 ST=89
03 WS=89
03 WW=88-91
03 WD=15/20
02 WS=87
02 WW=88-90
01 WE=90
01 WS=90
09 WE=90
09 WS=89
09 JR=15 (84)
09 Cellart 87 (7)
08 WE=89
07 WS=89
07 WE=88
05 WE=90
06 WS=90
Ch L’Ecuyer
Pomerol 05/06
Ch Edmus
St-Emilion 08
08 WS=86
Ch du Dom de L’Eglise
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90+
08 WS=90
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=89-92
05 $42 B&M
10 $20 WS
05 $21 Zachys
10 $54+ ST
07 $26-33 RP
05 $39 WS
05 $25 XZachys
04 $30 WS
09 $28 WClub
08 $35 WE
07 $30 WS
06 $55 WS
09 $38-57 RP
07 $33-44 RP
65
06 RP=88
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
Echo de Lynch Bages
08
L’Eceche
09
09 RP=87-89+
Dom de l’Eglise
Pomerol 07
07 ST=87
Ch Clos l’Eglise
10 ST=86
10 TWCI=93-95
08 $30 Zachys
09 70%M-15%CF-CS
05 Juicy, velvety, long WW 06
Pomerol 02-09 (09=90%M-10%CF)
06 coup de Coeur Hachette 10
Ch l’Eglise Clinet
Pomerol 02-10
06 $39-55 RP
06 $72 WS
09 JJB=95-97
08 ST=85
08 RP=87-89
08 JJB=90-92
08 WBlB=87
07 ST=86
06 RP=85
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=85-88
05 ST=89
05 RP=89-90
03 $25 WS
03 ST=89
09 ST=90
09 RP=96-100
08 ST=90
08 RP=92-94+
07 RP=90-93
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=91
06 RP=9
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=91
05 ST=95
05 WS=94
05 RP=96
04 WE=89
04 WS=91
04 ST=91
04 RP=91
03 ST=88
03 WS=93
03 RP=89
02 ST=90
02 WS=91
02 RP=92
08 $17-21 RP
08 $15-30 WBlB
06 $21-30 RP
06 $26 JJB
05 $26-30 RP
09 $195-266 RP
08 $70-89 RP
07 $89-111 RP
07 $99 Zachys
07 C$189 BCLS
06 $104 WS
05 $150 Zachys
05 $158 WS
05 $160 K&L
05 $110-170 RP
05 C$225 BCLS
04 $100 WS
04 $75-80 RP
03 $95-125 RP
99 C$45 BCLS
10 90%Merlot-10%CF
07=85%Merlot-15%CF
10 ST=95
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 ST=95
09 $40+ ST
09 RP=98-100
09 $362-598 RP
08 RP=94-96+
08 $185-241 RP
08 ST-90
08 $135 K&L
07 ST=92
07 RP=94
06 RP=96
06 ST=93-94
07 $130 K&L
07 $96-156 RP
07 $170 B&M
07 C$229 BCLS
06 $191-603 RP
06 $329 BCLS
66
05 Class, complex WW 06
La Petite Eglise Pomerol 10
Ch Egregore
10 100%Merlot
06 WS=93
06 $420 WS
05 W&S=2½stars
05 WS=98
05 $382 WS
05 ST=95+?
05 RP=96-100
05 $163-982 RP
05 WW=95-98
04 WS=92
04 ST=91
04 RP=93
04 WW=93-96
03 RP=88
03 WS=93
03 WW=91-93
03 ST=90
02 ST=90
02 RP=86
02 WS=90
10 SR=86
Bordeaux 06
06 ST=86-89
Bordeaux Cuvee Exception 04/05/06/08
08 RP=90-92
06 RP=89
05 RP=87-90
04 RP=90
Emilius de Ch Trimoulet
St-Emilion 06/07
Ch l’Enclos
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
Ste Foy Res de la Marquise 03/05
Ste Foy Cuvee Triple A 08
06 $20 RP
06 Comm’d Decantetr 09
03 WS=82
10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12
10 CF-Malbec-Merlot
08 RP=87-89
07 WE=90
07 RP=80-84
06 WE=89
06 WS=88
06 RP=88
05 WE=91
05 Silky, med finish, friendly WW 06 05 WS=85-88
05 RP=88-89
04 WS=87
05 Bronze Bordeaux 07; Decanter 09
06 ST=87-90
02 $25 WS
07 $60 WE
06 $59 WE
06 $30 RP
05 $60 WE
05 $40 K&L
05 $35 RP
04 $30 WS
03 €11 Hach
09 €11-15 Hach
Ch L’Enclos du Beau-Pere
Pomerol 06
Epicurea de Ch Martinat
09 RP=89-91
Listrac-Medoc 09/10
08 RP=88-90
05 RP=90
10 WS=88
09 $18 RP
09 $18 JJB
09 $18.50 Sh-L
08 $17 RP
05 $30 WClub
10 $25 WS
10 WE=85
10 $19 WE
10 WS=88
10 WE=84
09 RP=87-88
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=star
10 $24 WS
Ch L’Ermitage
Ch L’Escart
Ch D’Escurac
Bordeaux Sup 09/10
Bordeaux Sup Agape 09
Bordeais Sup Cuvee Eden 09
09 bronze Decanter 12
Bordeaux Sup Omar Khayam 09
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 05/06 /08/09/10
09 $15 RP
67
02 Comm’d IWC 10
L’Esprit de Chevalier
Pessac-Leognan 04/05
Esprit de l’Eglise
Pomerol 08
Ch de l’Estang
Cotes de Castilion 05/06/07/08/09/10
08 RP=88-89
06 RP=87
05 RP=89
05 WS=86
05 WS=87
04 WS=87
02 WS=82
08 WS=90
10 Best Buy WE
10 WE=90
09 CF-CS-Merlot
09 JJB=90-92
09 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 12 09 RP=87-90
06 $20 RP
05 $19 WS
05 $15 K&L
05 $30 WS
10 $15 WE
09 $10 JJB
09 $10 RP
09 $17 Sh-L
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=85-87
06 RP=87
06 $23 RP
Ete de Mondot Rose
St-Emilion nv (Ch Troplong-Mindot)
WW=92
$11
L’Etoile de Bergey
Pessac-Leognan 09
09 WS=91-94
09 $18 K&L
Etoiles de Mondorion
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=87
Dom de L’Etoile
Bordeaux 08/09/10
Ets. Thunevin
Bordeaux Presidial 10
10 WW=91
08 WW=89
10 WS=88
10 $15 WS
Bordeaux Mauvais Garcon 10
10 WS=90
10 $16 WS
Bordeaux Vieux Poirier 10
10 WS=75
10 $16 WS
10 ST=92
09 ST=93
09 RP=96-100
08 RP=93-95
08 WS=90-93
08 ST=89
07 ST=90
07 RP=88
07 WS=88-91
06 WE=92
06 RP=93
06 WS=90
05 W&S=96
05 WS=100
05 WE=93
05 ST=94
05 WW=94-97
05 RP=95
04 WS=91
04 RP=93
04 ST=90-93
03 RP=88
99 WS=90
10 $230+ ST
09 $265+ ST
09 $266-422 RP
08 $110-145 RP
08 $135 Zachys
08 $120 K&L
07 $180 B&M
07 $102-150 RP
07 $150 Zachys
10 WS=85
10 WE=86
10 $13 WS
09 RP=90-92
09 $16-22 RP
09 $17 JJB
Ch L’Evangile
Pomerol 04-10
10 89%Merlot-11%CF
09 95%Merlot-CF
10 $10 B&M 5¢
06 $126-262 RP
06 $220 B&M
05 $330 K&L
See also their second wine: Ch Blasson
EXEM
Bordeaux 10
Ch Faizeau
Montagne-St-Emilion Vieille Vignes 04-10
10 Bronze Decxanter 12
08 RP=88-90
06 ST=87
06 WS=88
06 NM=88
05 ST=88
06 C$25 LCBO
68
Ch Faugeres
St-Emilion 03-10
08 Bronze Paris 09
07=65%CS-25%Merlot-10%CF
Cuvee Speciale 07
Cuvee Speciale Peby 03-09 (09=100%Merlot)
Ch Faurie de Souchard
09 Gold Paris 11
05 NM=91
05 C$30 NM
04 ST=86
04 WS=87
03 ST=88
03 RP=89
03 $18 wine.com
03 WS=88
03 $30 WS
03 ST=88
02 WS=86
02 $20 WS
02 $20
09 WE=93
09 RP=90-93
09 $32-38 RP
08 RP=89-91
08 $24-34 RP
07 RP=90
07 $40-50 RP
07 WS=87-90
07$38 Zachys
07 ST=87
07 $35 Sh-L
06 WE=93
06 RP=89
06 $28-49 RP
06 WS=91
06 $35 WS
06 WE=93
06 ST=87-89
05 ST=90
05 $36 Zachys
05 WS=93
05 $41 WS
05 RP=91-93
05 $16-48 RP
04 ST=86-88
04 WS=90
04 WE=92
04 RP=90
03 Hachette=2stars
03 WS=86
03 RP=89
07 ST=91
09 ST=90
08 WS=89
07 ST=89
06 RP=90-92
06 ST=90-92
05 RP=94-96
05 ST=92
04 RP=92
04 ST=90
03 ST=90
09 RP=87-89
06 $64-80 RP
05 $54-145 RP
04 $29-80 RP
04 $60 ST
08 WS=88
Ch Favorite
Cotes de Bourg 09
09 WSW=87
09 $11 WS
Ch Farat
09
09 RP=90-92
09 $31 RP
Dom Fayat-Thunevin
Lalande de Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08
08 WS=88
07 WS=84-87
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=85-88
04 WS=88
Ch Fayau
Bordeaux Rouge 09
09 Silver LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Tradition 08
08 Bronze LA 11
Ch la Fer
St-Emilion GC 06
06 Gold Brussels 09
Le Fer de Cheval Noir
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Feret-Lambert
Bordeaux Sup 06/07/08/09/10/11/12
$27 K&L
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
12 WS=87-90
11 RP=81-84
69
09 Silver LA 12
Bordeaux Sup Costes du Feret-Lambert 10
Ch Ferran (Ginestet)
09 Bronze LA 11
06 Gold Bordeaux 09
Ch de Ferrand
Ch Ferrand Lartigue
Ch Ferrande (Castel)
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/08
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
Graves Rouge 05/06/07/08/09/10
Pessac-Leognan 09 /10
Ch Ferre
Haut-Medoc 05
Ch Ferriere
10 WS=89
10 RP=86
10 WE=86
09 LA=91
09 RP=87
09 WS=90
08 RP=87-88
08 WS=88
06 RP=87
05 RP=89+
10/09 WS=88
08 WS=87
10 RP=90
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=88-91
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=84-86
06 WS=87
05 WS=84
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=84
08 Gold Paris 11
08 WS=91
06 Gold Paris 09
09 RP=84-86
08 WS=87
08 RP=87-88+
07 RP=85-87
07 ST=87
06 Gold Brussels 09; Challnege 10 06 RP=86
06 ST=86-89
05 WS=88
05 RP=90
05 ST=89
04 RP=86
10 Silver IWC; Bronze Decanter 12
10 CS-Merlot
09 RP=85-87
08 RP=85-88
07 Silver Paris 09
06 RP=84
05 Silver Bordeaux, Challenge, IWC 0705 WE=91
05 WS=86
04 RP=85
03 WS=85
10 ST=86
09 WE=93
05 WS=88
10 ST=88
09 WE=92
09 ST=89
08 WS=89
08 ST=88
10 $19 WS
10 $13-15 RP
10 $15 WE
09 $20 Sh-L
09 $12-14 RP
09 $12 JJB
08 $20 WS
10 $19 WS
10 $14-23 RP
09 $19 Zachys
05 $25 WS
06 $35 Dec
03 C$40 BCLS
06 $20-22 RP
05 $35 WS
05 $22-36 RP
05 $27 K&L
04 $27 RP
06 $28 RP
05 $24 WS
10 $43 Costco
08 $25 WS
08 $25 K&L
70
05 Vintage’s most masterful WW
05 Plenty of potential WD 4/06
08 WE=88-90
07 WE=87
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=84
06 WE=91
06 WD=16-17/20
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=87
05 WS=91
05 ST=87+?
05 WW=91-93
05 WD=16.5-17.5
05 WE=91
04 WS=87
04 WW=91-93
04 WE=87
07 $34 WE
06 $36 WS
05 $38 WS
05 $54 B&M
04 $28 WS
03 Another Success WD 10/05
Ch Feytit-Clinet
Les Fiefs de Lagrange
Ch de Fieuzal
Pomerol 04-09 (M95% CF5%)
St-Julien 04/05/06/07/10
03 WS=89
03 WD=17/20
02 WS=86
01 WS=91
09 outperformed Price JJB
09 JJB=94-96
09 RP=93-95
08 RP=91-93
07 RP=89-91
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=88
06 Very good, some potential WD
06 WD=15-16/20
06 RP=91
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=90
05 Impressive WD 4/06
05 WD=17-18/20
05 WE=90
05 ST=92
05 WS=91
05 RP=91-93
04 WS=87
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
03 RP=87
10 ST=86
07 WW=85-87
06 WW=87-89
05 Very Good SFCh 3/28/08
05 SFCh=2½star
05 WS=87
05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½stars
05 Delicious, a true bargain WW 06
05 WW=87-89
04 WW=87-89
03 WS=88
10 45%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF-5%PV 10 ST=91
10 JJB=93
09 45%CS-Merlot
09 ST=87
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=90
08 ST=88
08 RP=90-93
08 JJB=86-88
07 WS=90
07 RP=87
07 ST=88
06 RP=87
06 WE=87
06 WS=88
06 ST=89
05 WE=92/92
05 ST=88
09 $63-96 RP
08 $35-157 RP
07 $35-53 RP
06 $41-56 RP
06 $46 WS
05 $65 Zachys
05 $65 WS
05 $54-164 RP
04 $55 RP
10 $35+ ST
07 $21 Zachys
07 $28 B&M
06 $35 B&M
05 $38 SFCh
05 $33-40 B&M
05 $28 B&M
09 $36+ ST
09 $34-51 RP
08 $30 WS
08 $23-41 RP
07 $30 WS
07 $21-36 RP
06 $22-33 RP
06 $20 K&L
06 $30 WS
05 $34 Zachys
71
03 Rather incongruous WD 10/05
Pessac-Leognan l’Abeille de Fieuzal 08
Ch Figeac
Ch la Fleur
Montagne-St-Emilion 08/09/10
St-Emilion 03/04/05/06/07
Pomerol 05
05 WS=90
05 RP=89
04 WE=86
04 RP=89
04 WS=88
04 ST=87
03 WD=15.5/20
03 RP=88
08 WS=89
10 35%CF-35%CS-30%Merlot
10 ST=88
10 $235+ nST
10 JJB=96
09 WE=93
09 $250 K&L
09 ST=88
09 WS=97-199
09 ST=90
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08 JJB=84-86
08 $85 Zachys
07 WE=92
07 $90 WE
07 ST=87
07 $90 K&L
07 RP=91-93
07 $90 Zachys
06 WE=93/94
06 RP=90
06 $61-147 RP
06 Really very good WD
06 WD=16.5-17.5
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=91
06 $100 WS
05 W&S=1½-2½star
05 Great Figeac WW 06
05 WS=95
05 $118 WS
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 ST=92
05 SS=17.5/20
05 WE=92/93
05 RP=91-94
05 $54-164 RP
04 ST=88
04 RP=86
03 ST=88
03 WD=14.5/20
03 RP=86
02 ST=88+
02 RP=88
10 WS=85
10 $17 WS
08 WE=84
08 $17 WE
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=88
06 $35 RP
06 WS=86
05 ST=86-89
05 $31 Zachys
05 WS=91
05 $32 WS
05 RP=89-91
05 $33 RP
04 WS=87
04 $30 WS
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07 04 RP=89
04 $27 RP
03 WS=90
03 RP=88
05 W&S=3stars
Ch La Fleur Des Amendiers Puisseguin-St-Emilion 10
10 WS=99
La Fleur d’Arthus
09 WE=87
09 RP=88-90
08 WS=90
07 RP=85
07 ST=85-87
La Fleur de Bouard
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09
Le plus Lalande-de-Pomerol 04-10
05 $35 WS
05 $14-35 RP
10/09 100%Merlot
10 ST=89
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=90
08 RP=90-93
10 $16 WS
09 $30-55 RP
08 $29 WS
08 $22-35 RP
72
07 RP=90-93
07 WS=88
07 ST=88
06 RP=91
06 WS=90
06 AG=91
06 ST=86-88
06 WE=89-91
05 WS=90
05 WE=91
05 RP=89
05 ST=89-90
04 WS=88
08 $26 JJB
08 $31 Zachys
07 $26-33 RP
07 $30 WS
07 $32 K&L
07 $30 Zachys
07 C$45 BCLS
06 $30-36 RP
06 $34 WS
06 C$55 AG
06 $25 K&L
05 $39 WS
05 $25 K&L
Lalande Pomerol le Plus 03-09 (100%Merlot)
Ch La Fleur Caillrau
Fronsac St-Emilion
Ch Fleur Cardinale
St-Emilion GC 03-11
09 ST=89
08 WS=90
08 RP=93-95
07 RP=91
07 ST=87
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=92+
06 WS=85-88
06 ST=88-91
05 ST=91-93
05/04 WS=89-91
04 ST=89+
03 WS=90
09 $120+ ST
07 $100-125 RP
06 $125 RP
Bargain Snooth.com
10/09 70%Merlot-25%CF-5%CS
11 WS 90-93
11 RP=92-94
10 ST=86
10 TWCI=93-95
09 JJB=94-96
09 ST=89
09 RP=90-92
09 WS=92-95
08 RP=91-93
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=91-93
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=90
06 RP=91
06 WS=89
06 ST=89-91
05 ST=92+?
05 WS=93
05 RP=93-95
04 ST=90
04 RP=91
03 WS=86
03 RP=91
11 $19 JJB Fut
09 $18/375 JJB
09 $33-50 RP
08 $28-44 RP
08 $33 K&L
08 $39 Zachys
07 $27-42 RP
07 C$64 BCLS
06 $28-43 RP
06 $40 WS
05 $41 Zachys
05 $53 WS
05 $22-62 RP
See also their second wine: Secret de Cardinale
Ch la Fleur de Gay
Pomerol 03-10
10 ST=87
09 WE=92
09 ST=90
09 RP=93-96
08 RP=93-95+
07 RP=88-90
07 ST=90
06 RP=92
09 $80+ ST
09 $80-117 RP
08 $70 RP
08 $65 K&L
07 $69-88 RP
06 $76-100 RP
73
05 Balanced WW 06
Ch Fleur Haut Gaussens
Bordeauz Sup 06/07/08/09/10
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
05 ST=89+?
05 WE=92
05 RP=94-96
04 WS=89
04 ST=91
04 RP=91
03 ST=87
03 WS=88
03 RP=88
10 WS=88
06 $82 WS
05 $110 WS
05 $98-113 RP
10 $18 WS
08 Vin Renarquable Hachette 11
07 Gold LA 10
06 Bronze LA 10
Ch la Fleur D’Horus
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=81
La Fleur de Jaugue
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 RP=87-89
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=82-84
06 RP=88
Ch la Fleur Morange
St-Emilion GC 04-12
07 70%Merlot-CF
06 Gold Decanter 10
St-Emilion Cuvee Matilde 05-12
05 RP=90
04 RP=89
12 RP=92-94+
11 RP=92-94+
10 RP=94+
09 RP=96+
08 RP=94
07 RP=92
07 ST=90
06 RP=88
06 ST=89-92
05 RP=92-94
05 ST=91-93
04 RP=88
12 RP=87-89
11 RP=90-92
11 JS=88-89
11 CellarT 89 (4)
10 RP=93
09 RP=92
08 RP=92
07 RP=87
07 ST=89
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
Ch la Fleur Morange
St-Emilion Mathilde 10
Fleur des Ormes
Lalande-de-Pomerol Cuvee Prestige 05
10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 10 WS=90
10 CS-Merlot
10 WE=85
10 RP=88
09 Gold Bruxelles, France-Macon 11 09 RP=90
09 Silver Bordeaux 12.
09 JR=16.5 (90)
09 Bronze IWC
10 WS=89
10 RP=93
05 WS=89
Ch la Fleur des Ormes
Pomerol 04
La Fleur Patris
09
09 RP=87-88
Ch la Fleur-Petrus
Pomerol 03-10
10 ST=92
Ch Fleur la Mothe
Medoc 09/10
10 $14-24 RP
09 $19-24 RP
09 $22 Sh-L
06 $16-28 RP
06 C$29 LCBO
12 $46-62 RP
11 $48-63 RP
10 $68-90 RP
09 $90-124 RP
08 $44-58 RP
07 $48-60 RP
07 $70 K&L
06 $100 Dec
11 $21 JJB Fut
11 $24 Zachys
11 $19-24 RP
10 $20
08 $28 RP
10 $20 WS
09 $15 Zachys
10 $20 WS
10 $280+ ST
74
09 WE=94
09 ST=87
09 RP=96-98+
08 ST=89
08 RP=92-94+
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=90
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=87
06 WE=93
06 RP=90+
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=92
05 W&S=96
05 Best value most demanded QWR 05 RP=92-94
05 WS=95
05 ST=92+?
05 WE=93/94
04 WE=93
04 WS=92
04 WS=92
04 ST=87+
03 RP=89
03 WS=92
03 ST=88
02 RP=88
02 WS=91
02 ST=88
01 RP=90
01 WS=92
01 ST=90
00 RP=95
00 WS=92
00 ST=92
99 RP=89
99 WS=88
10 RP=91
09 Dbl Gold IWC; Comm’d Dec 12 09 WE=91
09 CS-Merlot-PV
06 Bronze IWC 09
05 RP=83-85
04 Dbl Gold IWC 07
03 WE=91
02 WE=86
05 WS=85
10 WS=87
Ch la Fleur Peyrabon
Paulliac Cru Bourgeois 02-10
La Fleur de Plince
Pomerol 04/05
Ch la Fleur Poitou
Ch Fleur de Rigaud
Bordeaux Superieur Cuvee Prestige 05
05 IWR=88
Ch la Fleur des Rouzes
Pomeril 05
05 WS=91
Ch Fleur-St-Antoine
Bordeaux Superieur 07/10
Ch la Fleur-St-Georges
Lalande-de-Pomerol 05/06/07
Le Plus de la Fleur 05/06/07 (100% Merlot)
10 WS=87
07=90% Merlot
09 $250+ ST
09 $136-315 RP
08 $72-208 RP
08 $70 Zachys
07 $141-195 RP
07 C$129 BCLS
06 $93-160 RP
06 $175 WS
05 $149 W&S
10 $20-32 RP
10 $20 WS
10 $18 WS
07 ST=85-87
06 ST=87-88
05 WS=85
07 ST=87
75
Clos Floridene
Graves Rouge 07/09/10
10 75%CS-25%Merlot
09 60%CS-Merlot
07 Comm’d IWC 10
Ch Fombrauge (Magrez)
St-Emilion GC 04-10
06 ST=90-92
05 ST=92+?
10 ST=88
09 ST=88
09 RP=88-90
08 ST=88
05 SFCh=2star
10 RP=91
08 WS=88
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=86
07 ST=88
06 Gold Paris 09; Brussels 10
06 RP=88/92
06 Silver IWSC 09
06 WD=16-17+/20
06 ST=91
06 WS=88/90
05 77%M-14% CF-CS
05 ST=90
05 Ample, made with care Decanter 06 05 WS=91
05 ST=88-91
05 WE=89
05 SS=16/20
05 14.5-15.5/20
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=88
04 Gold Bordeaux, Brussels, Paris 07 04 ST=87
04 Gold Brussels 10
04 RP=89
03 WS=90
03 ST=89
03 TA=4½stars
03 RP=89
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 Silver Paris 11
St-Emilion GC Cuvee le Cadran 09
Ch Fonbadet
Paulliac Cru Bourgeois Sup 03/04/05/06/08
03 Cited Wine Hachette 08/07
Ch de Fonbel
08 WE=92
06 WS=89
05 WS=87
05 RP=86-88
04 WE=91
04 WS=89
03 WS=91
St-Emilion 04-11
09 65%M-25%CS-7%PV
10 RP=87
09 ST=87
09 WE=86
09 WS=88-91
08 WS=86
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=85-89
07 ST=86
06 RP=89
06 NM=90
06 WE=88
06 ST=87
06 WS=86
05 ST=87
05 RP=90-92
05 WS=89
04 RP=90
04 WS=88
Ch Fonchereau
Bordeaux Sup 09
09 Bronze Decanter, LA 12
Le Grand 09
09 Comm’d IWC `12
09 $14-22 RP
05 $33 SFCh
10 $23-35 RP
08 $27 WS
08 $26 JJB
07 $24-31 RP
07 $28 WS
07 $18 K&L
06 $25-51 RP
06 $60 K&L
06 $40 WS
05 $37 WS
05 $35 K&L
05 $38 Zachys
05 $30-41 RP
04 $28 WS
08 $50 Zachys
06 $40 WS
05 $30 WS
05 $23 Zachys
05 $23-28 RP
03 $30 WS
11 $20 JJB Fut
10 $19-32 RP
09 $20+ ST
09 $20 K&L
09 $25 Sh-L
08 $22 WS
08 $27 Zachys
07 $22 RP
07 $22 Zachys
07 $24 B&M
07 $23 Sh-L
06 $15-22 RP
06 C$29 LCBO
05 $26 Zachys
06 $20 WS
05 $13-40 RP
05 $30 WS
76
Ch Fongrave
Ch Fonplegade
Bordeaux Eleve en Futs de Chene 05/06/07/08
09 CF-CS-Merlot
St-Emilion GC 04-11
09 Coeur Selectionnel Hachette 13
St-Emilion Fleur de Fonplegade GC 05-09
Bordeaux 09
Ch Fonreaud
05 $22 WE
11 RP=92-94
11 $19 JJB Fut
11 JS=90-91
09 Hachette=3 star
07 WE=91
07 ST=88
07 RP=87-89
06 RP=91
06 WE=91
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=87
05 WE=92
05 WS=91
05 ST=89+?
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=86
04 RP=89
07 $80 WE
07 WE=87
06 WE=87
05 WE=88
07 $45 WE
06 $44 WE
05 $50 WE
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
09 ST=87-89
09 WS=88-91
09/08 WE=88
08 WBlB=86
08 ST=86
08 Decanter=3star
08 SS=15.0/20
07 WE=88
06 WS=84
06 WE=88
05 WE=89/91
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=84-86
05 SS=16/20
04 WS=85
04 RP=84
03 WS=87
08 RP=90-92
10 $25 WS
10 $15-19 RP
09 $15 K&L
06 $50 RP
06 $79 WE ?
06 $54 WS
05 $69 WS
04 $49 WS
04 $45 RP
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 Cab Sauv
07 Comm’d IWC 10
06 Bronze IWC 09
05 Fine tannins, fruity finish WW 06
Ch Fonroque
05 WE=85
St Emilion GC 05/06/07/08
Ch Fontaine de Genin
Bordeaux 05/10 (Merlot-Cab)
10 Gold Paris 11
Ch Fontblanche
Bordeaux 08
08 Silver LA 10
Ch Fontbonne
Bordeaux 08/09
09 Silver LA 12
08 Gold LA
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=82-85
06 WS=86
06 WE=89
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=85-88
05 WE=90
05 WS=90
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=87
03 RP=86-88
05 W&S=83
$14-28 WBlB
05 $13 RP
04 $22 RP
08 $25 K&L
08 $29 Zachys
07 $20-27 RP ?
06 $60 WS ?
05 $70 WS
05 $27 RP ?
05 $11 W&S
08 LA=93
77
Bordeaux Cuvee Marie 08/09
Ch Fontesteau
Haut-Medoc 10
Ch Fontenil
Fronsac 03-10
09/08 Bronze LA 12/11
10 100%Merlot
05 Excellent WW 06
10 WE=90
10 $25 WE
10 RP=91
10 ST=89
09 WE=91
09 WS=91-94
09 WS=90
07 RP=87-89
07 ST=88
07 WS=87
06 RP=88
06 AG=89
06 RP=90-92
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=90
05 ST=89+?
05 RP=90-92
05 WS=91
04 RP=88
04 WS=88
04 WE=90
10 $22-29 RP
09 $25 JJB
09 $33 WS
06 $35 RP
06 C$45 AG
05 C$65 BCLS
05 $72 WS
04 C$45 BCLS
See also their second wine: Le Defi de Fontenil
Ch de Fontenille
Bordeaux 08/09/10
10 WE=85
10 $14 WE
08 C$15 LCBO
10 $25 WS
09 Bronze IWC 12
08 Silver Paris 10
Ch Fontesteau
Haut-Medoc 10
10 WS=86
Ch la Forge
St-Emilion 09
09 WE=89
Ch Fortet
St-Emilion 05
Ch Fontis
Medoc 05/06/07/08
Les Forts de Latour
Pauillac 03-10
05 Rich, full-bodied, velvety, long WW 05 WW=92-94
05 WS=85
08 WE=89
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
07 WE=84
06 WS=82
06 WE=86
10 72.5%CS-25.5%Merlot-2%PV
10 ST=87
10 $250+ ST
09 ST=89
09 $200+ ST
09 RP=93-95
09 $230-399 RP
09 WS=92-95
09 $250 K&L
09 WE=92-94
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 RP=91-93
08 $327-426 RP
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=88-90
08 JJB=87-89
07 WE=92
07 $100 WE
07 WS=87-90
07 $100 K&L
07 ST=90
07 $115 Zachys
07 RP=90-92
07 $81-318 RP
07 AG=89
07 C$159 BCLS
06 WE=91
06 $140 B&M
06 Top Pick K&L
06 RP=92
06 ST=88-91
06 $81-218 RP
06 WS=89
05 W&S=1½-2½star
05 Fine aroma, minerally, long WW 05 RP=92
05 $115-150 RP
05 WE=92/92
05 ST=92
05 WS=94
05 WW=92-94
04 WS=90
04 RP=91-93
04 WE=91
04 ST=91
78
Ch Fougas Maldoror
Cotes de Bourg 03-10
09/08/06 Bargains Snooth.com
07 Bronzr Paris 09
Ch Fourcas-Borie
Ch Fourcas-Dupre
Ch Fourcas-Hosten
10 $14-21 RP
07 WS=87
06 RP=87
06 WS=86
05 WE=86
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=89-91
05 NM=89
04 WS=84
04 RP=87-88
03 WS=85-88
03 RP=88
Listrac 08/09/10
10 TWCI=88-90
08 WS=86
Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-09 (CS) 09 Bronze Decanter 121
09 WE=90
09 JR=16
08 Comm’d Decanter10
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 JR=16 &15.5+
07 JR=15
06 WE=88
06 WS=86
05 Outstanding Values QRW 06
05 RC=88
05 Taken Listrac to new level WW 06 05 WS=85-88
05 WW=88-90
05 WE=89/90
05 RP=85-87
05 JR=15/20
04 Silber MVini 06
05 SS=16/20
04 WS=84
04 WE=89
03 RP=87-88
03 WS=83
03 WW=85-86
Listrac Hattes Terres du Fourcas Dupre 10
10 WS=89
10 $25 WS
10 RP=86
10 ST=86
09 WE=87
10 $13-20 RP
06 WE=87
06 WS=85
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=84-86
05 WE=90/89
05 SS=16/20
04 RP=80
06 $23 Dec
Ch des Fourgeres
03 RP=100
03 ST=91
02 RP=92
02 ST=90+
01 RP=90
99 ST=90
10 RP=88
Graves la Folie de Montesquieu 05/06/07
07 RP=88-90
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-90
05 WS=88
05 $24 Zachys
08 $25 WS
07 $27 Sh-L
05 $14 RP
05 $8-17 RP
04 $20 Dec
04 $19 RP
06 $28 RP
Graves la Raison de Montesquieu 05
05 WS=87
Clos Fourtet
04 WE=88
10 ST=87
79
09 One of top 32 JJB
08 85 %M-10%CS-CF
06 Good, for this vintage WD
05 Best value QWR
10 JJB=95
09 WE=96
09 ST=88
09 RP=95-98
09 JJB=95-97
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 RP=92-94
08 WE=90-92
08 ST=88
08 JJB=91-93
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=91
07 WE=89
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=88
09 $90+ ST
09 $87-133 RP
08 RP=42-59 RP
08 $50 Zachys
08 $45 K&L
07 $39-75
07 $60 WE
07 $50 K&L
07 $60 Zachys
07 C$89 BCLS
06 $55-60 RP
06 C$99 BCLS
06 $56 WS
06 RP=91
06 WE=92
06 WS=88
06 WD=16-17/20
06 ST=88-91
05 WS=95
05 WE=93/94
05 $128 B&M
05 ST=92
05 RP=98
05/04 WE=93
04 WS=90
03 WD=15/20
03 $80 B&M
03 WS=93
See also: Closerie de Fourtet
Ch de France
Ch la France
Pessac-Leognan 0304//05
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Gallus 09
Ch de Francs
03 Bruxelles 06
03 Brussels 06
08 Very Syccessful Hachette 11
03 Bruxelles 06
09 Silver LA 11
05 WS=89-91
05 WE=86
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=88
03 WS=86
05 €5-8 Hach
Bordeaux Cuvee Selection 05
Bordeaux Cotes-de-Francs Ceresiers 05-10
10 WS=90
09 ST=87
08 Gold Bordeaux, Silver Brussels 10 08 WS=87
08 90%Merlot-10%CS
07 Silver Paris 09
WS=85-88
Hach=1star
03 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette
Hach=3star
05 WE=89
Ch Franc-Cardanle
Bordeaux Cotes de Francs 05
Ch Franc Grace Dieu
St-Emilion 09/10
10 WE=90
09 WE=88
Ch Franc-Maillet
Pomerol Cuvee Jean Baptiste 04/05/06/07
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=88-91
10 $14 WS
08 $13 WS
05 $13 WClub
04/03 €8-11
10 $29 WE
80
Pomerol 04/05/06
Ch Franc Mayne
St-Emilion GC 03-10
Ch Franc-Perat
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 03/05
Ch Franc la Rose
Ch la France
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Gallus 10
Ch de France
10 Merlot
10 ST=86
07 WE=88
07 RP=83-86
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=87
06 ST=89
06 WS=88
05 Chewy, long WW 06
05 WS=91
05 RP=88-91
05 Bronze IWC 07
05 WE=91
05 ST=87-89
04 RP=85
04=Merlot
04 WS=89
03 RP=88-90
05 WE=87
05 WS=85-88
05 Bronze IWC 07
03 WS=86
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=88
05 WS=89
04 Gold Brussels 07
04 WS=87
04 WE=86
03 WS=84
10 Silver LA 12
10 Bronze LA 12
08 Silver LA; Bronze Decanter 10
07 Bronze Challemge, Decanter 09
06/07
Ch de Francs
Cote de Francs Les Cerisiers 03/04/05/06
05 Excell F&W 06
06 $35 WS
05 $38 WS
05 $17-40 RP
05 $35 K&L
05 $38 Zachys
04 $25 WS
04 $29 WE
Pessac-Leognan 10
De Frances
06 $35 RP
10 WS=93
10 JJB=90
06 WS=89
05 WS=89
07 RP=85-87
06 RP=83
06 WS=85
05 WS=85-88
03 WS=90
10 $38 Costco
06 $50 WS
06 $26 RP
03 $20 WS
Frank Phelan
St-Estephe 05
05 WS=86
05 $24 WS
French Rabbit
Fam Res VdP d’Oc nv
nv WS=82
nv $14/L WS
Cab Sauv VdP d’Oc 04/05
05 WS=82
05 WE=83
04 WS=85
05 WS=82
05 WE=82
04 WS=83
05 WS=83
05 WE=81
04 WS=84
05/04 $10/L WS
Merlot VdP d’Oc 04/05
Pinot Noir VdP 04/05
05 Bargain SFCh 8/17/07
Ch Freyneau
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee traditionelle 08
08 Silver LA 12
Ch la Freynelle
Bordeaux 08/09/10
10 Gold LA 12
10 LA=92
10 WS=86
05/04 $10/L WS
05/04 $10/L WS
10 $12 WS
09 Silver LA 11
81
08 Bronze LA 10
Fugue de Nenin
Pomerol 04-10 (Ch Nenin second label)
09 81%Merlot-19%CF
G
10
10 56%Merlot-44%CF
Ch du Gaby
Canon-Fronsac 10/11
10 RP=85
09 ST=87
08 WS=87
07 WE=86
06 RP=87
06 WE=87
06 WS=88
05 WS=88
04 WS=85
03 WS=88
10 TWCI=90-91
Galius
St-Emilion 05
11 RP=92 ?
11 WS=91 ?
10 RP=85
06 WS=88
05 WS=89-91
05 RP=85-86
04 WS=89
03 RP=88-91
03 WS=88
02 RP=78
10 ST=87
09 WE=94
09 ST=89
09 RP=94-96
09 WS=92-95
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 WE=91-93
08 RP=93
08 JJB=90-92
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WE=91
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=87
06 WE=93
06 RP=89+
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=85-88
05 Potentially great SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=18/20
05 WS=93
05 ST=91+?
05 WE=91/90
05 RP=92-95
04 WS=91
04 ST=87-88
04 RP=92
03 ST=86
03 WS=92
03 RP=92
05 WS=90
Ch la Ganne
Pomerol 04/05
Ch de la Garde
Ch la Gaffeliere
07 Silver IWC 09
07 Merlot
10 $24-39 RP
08 $28 WS
06 $30 RP
11 $18 wine.com
10 $25-30 RP
05 $25 Zachys
05 $25 RP
09 $70 K&L
09 $85+ ST
09 $78-103 RP
08 $48 K&L
08 $43-57 RP
07 $41-51 RP
07 $50 WE
07 $50 Zachys
06 $50-76 RP
05 $80 Zachys
05 $79 WS
05 $66-164 RP
04 $50 WS
04 $36-55 RP
05 JR=16+/20
05 €15-23 Hach
05 Decanter=3star
04 WS=85
10 RP=88
10 $20-34 RP
10 ST=86
09 WE=93
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=86
05 WS=89
06 $36 WS
05 $41 WS
82
Bordeaux Sup 04/05/06/07/09
09 RP=88-90
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 Bronzr Challenge 10
07 Silver Brussels, Challenge, Paris 09
07 Comm’d IWC 09
07 Merlot
04 Gold Brussels 07
Ch le Gardera
Ch Garraud
Ch Garreau
Bordeaux Sup 10 (org grapes)
Ch la Garricq
Moulis-en-Medoc 04/05/06/08
Ch Gauthier
Medoc 04/05
Ch le Gay
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08/09/10
04 Comm’d IWC 07
10 Gold LA 12
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
10 Gold LA 12
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
06Vin Remarquable Hachette 10
09 $21-37 RP
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=85
03 WS=87
02 WS=89
10 LA=92
08 WS=89
04 $37 WS
08 $15 WS
06 WS=87
05 WS=84
10 LA=92
08 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 W&S=82
10 TWCI=92-94
09 ST=87
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=91
08 RP=95-98
07 RP=91
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=87
06 RP=93
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=90
05 W&S=2stars
05 ST=92
05 WS=93
05 $15 W&S
09 $100+ ST
09 $106-137 RP
08 $93 K&L
08 $122-150 RP
07 $61-107 RP
06 $95-115 RP
06 $95 K&L
06 $110 WS
05 $150 Zachys
05 RP=94-96
Ch du Gazin
Pomerol 04-10
04 WS=88
04 ST=90
04 SR=88-91
04 RP=93
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 ST=88
03 RP=90
10 ST=86
10 CF-Malbec-Merlot
10 JJB=94
09 90%Merlot-10%CS
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
09 ST=88
09 RP=94-96
09 $80 K&L
09 WS=92-95
09 ST=88-91
08 Bronze IWC 10
08 RP=94-96
08 $60 K&L
08 WE=91-93
08 $58 Zachys
08 WS=88-91
07 RP=84-86
07 $43-57 RP
07 WS=88-91
06 WE=90
06 Pretty, not very substantial WD
06 WD=14-15/20
06 RP=92
06 $50-83 RP
06 WS=93
06 $66 WS
05 WS=94
05 $71 WS
83
05 Very good potential WD 4/06
05 Coup de Coeur Hachette -9
Canon Fronsac 09/10
Ch Gazin Rocquencourt
05 ST=89-92
05 WE=89/88
05 RP=90-93
05 WD=17-18/20
04 WS=89
04 RP=90
03 RP=89
05 $70 Zachys
05 $20-70 RP
04 $39 WS
04 $32-48 RP
03 $18-56 RP
10 RP=90
10 $21-32 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
08 WS=87
06 WS=84
05 WS=89
05 $30 WS
05 WE=87
05 RP=87-89
Geirges Vigouroux
Buzet pigmentum Merlot-Malbec 10
10 Best Buy WE
Gerard Depardieu
La Croix de Peyrolle Confiance Cuvee d’Exception
10 WE=87
10 $12 WE
06 RP=89-90
See als: Ma Verite
Ch Gigault
Prem Cotes de Blaye 05/06
05 RP=88-91
La Croix de Peyrolle Cuvee d’Exception 06
Ginestet
06 RP=88-90
05 RP=91-93
Haut Medoc Ma Verite Cuvee d’Exception 05/06
06 RP=90-92
05 RP=91-93
02 WS=85-88
Prem Cote de Blaye CuveeViva 03-10
10 WS=90
10 RP=88
09 99%Merlot-1%CS
09 WS=89
09 JS=92
09 RP=90
09 CellarT 89 (7)
08 WS=86
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=87
05/04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07 05 RP=88-89
03 Smart Buy WS 06
05 ST=87-88
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=89
04 RP=87
03 WS=91
03 RP=90
Bordeaux de Ginestet 07/08/09/10
10 Silver LA; Comm’d Decanter 12
05 Bronze France-Macon 06/07
05 Cited Hachette 08
04 Gold Blaye & Bourg 06
04 WE=88
04 Silver Blaye & Bourg 05
Bordeaux Classique 09/10
10 Bronze IWSC; Comm’d IWC 12
10 CS-Merlot
09 Comm’d IWC 12
Bordeaux Ginestet Prestige 07/08/09
07 Silver Bordeaux, Challenge 10
Bordeaux Ginestet Res 07/08/09
10 $19 WS
09 $20 K&L
06 $22 WS
04 $8 WE
84
Bordeaux Single Vd 06/07
Bordeaux Merlot-Cab 04/05
French Roots Merlot-CS Bordeaux 04/05
French Roots Cab Sauv Vin de Pays d’Oc 05
06 Gold Bordeaux 09
05 France-Macon 07
05 Best Buy WE
05 Selection Mondiale des Vins 06
French Roots Shiraz Vin de Pays d’Oc 05
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 CF-Merlot-SauvBl
Medoc Classique 09
Margaux Classique 05
05 Silver IWC 07
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
07 Bronzr Bordeaux 10
04 One Star Hachette Guide
04 Bronze France-Macon, Japan 06
04 Selection Mondiale des Vins 07
03 Gold Brussels 05
03 Bronze Korea 06
06/05 Comm’d Decanter 07
05/04 Selection Mondiale des Vin 07
10 Silver LA 12
Mascaroni par Ginestet Bordeaux 03-07
Marquis de Chasse Bordeaux Res 04/05/06
Marquis de Chasse Bordeaux 07/08/09/10
04 Merlot-Cab
Ch Girolate
05/04 WE=85
05 $9
04 WS=82
03 WS=78
05 WE=86
03 $8 WS
05 $8 WE
05 WE=84
St-Emilion Classique 10
Medoc Mascaron par Ginestet 10
04 WS=83
04 WE=85
See also: Ch la Branne
Ch Mouchet
Ch Pierre de Montignac
Bordeaux 03-12
09 100%Merlot
06 Very Successful Hachete 10
$12 Dec
$15 Dec
07€5 Challenge
04 WS=81
03 WE=87
03 WS=84
03 $13 WE
04 WE=83
04 $8 Dec
04 WS=82
05 W&S=82
04 WS=84
12 JR=16.5 (90)
11 JR=16 (88)
10 ST=86
10 JR=16.5 (90)
09 WE=92
09 ST=87
09 JR=16 (88)
08 WS=88
08 JR=17 (92)
07 JR=14.5 (82)
06 RP=90
06 WS=86
06 ST=87-89
05 WE=91
05 ST=89
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=91-93
05 $13 W&S
06 $35 RP
06 $99 WS ?
05 $60-64 RP
85
Ch de Gironville
Ch Giscours
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 06/07/08/09/10
03 Comm’d IWC 07
10 50%Merlot-40%CS-10%PV
04 WE=90
03 WS=89
03 RP=91
10 WS=89
10 WE=91
10 RP=88
10 ST=86
10 TWCI=87-90
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=89-91
09 WS=86-89
08 WS=87
08 WE=86
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 RP=87-89
06 RP=87
06 WS=84
10 71%CS-29%Merlot)
10 ST=92
10 JJB=93
09 WE=95
09 ST=90
08 WE=94
08 WS=87-90
08 RP=88-90
08 ST=87
08 JJB=89-91
07 WE=93
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=86
06 #31 Top 100 Cellar Selections WE 06 WE=94
06 Good effort WD
06 WD=16-17/20
06 Top Pick K&L
06 RP=88
06 Gold Decanter 09
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=91
05 Rec’d-Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 W&S=1½stars
05 Very big, long, best ever? WW 06 05 WS=93
05 Excell RD 4/06
05 ST=91
05 RP=91-94
05 WD=17-18/20
05 WE=94/95
05 WW=91-92
04 WS=90
04 Silver Decanter, IWC 07
04 WE=93
04 ST=88
04 RP=91
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 008/7 03 WE=90
03 RP=90
03 WS=91
03 WW=90-91
03 ST=87-90
03 WD=17+/20
02 WS=90
02 RP=90
01 WS=92
01 RP=90
Le Haut-Medoc de Giscours 04/05/08
10 $18 WS
10 $11-15 RP
09 $14 JJB
08 $17 WS
07 C$23 BCLS
06 $25 RP
08 $35 K&L
08 $39 Zachys
07 $50 WE
07 $39-57 RP
07 $50 Zachys
07 $59 B&M
06 $86 B&M
06 C$79 BCLS
06 $34-75 RP
06 $52 WS
05 $80 B&M
05 $65 WS
05 $54-90 RP
05 $75 WE
08 $30 Astor
05 Bronze Paris 07
See also: La Sirene de Giscours
Ch du Glana
St-Julien 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 WS=90
10 WE=91-93
10 JS=90-91
09 WE=94
10 $25 WS
10 $25 K&L
86
Ch Gloria
St-Julien 02-10
05 Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 Velvety, long, rich finish WW 06
Ch Godeau
Ch De Goelane
Bordeaux Sup 10
09 WS=91-94
08 WS=88
08 WE=92
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
10 ST=88
09 ST=87
09 WE=92
08 ST=87
08 RP=90-93
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=87
07 ST=85
06 RP=90
06 ST=87-88
06 WS=90
05 W&S=1star
05 WS=92
05 ST=88+?
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=89
04 WW=90-92
04 RP=89
03 WS=89
03 RP=90
02 WE=88
02 RP=89
08 WS=87
07 ST=87
05 $26 WS
09 $39+ ST
09 $19/375 JJB
08 $29 K&L
08 $33 Zachys
07 $26-36 RP
07 $29 WS
07 $30 Zachys
07 $38 B&M
07 $30 Sh-L
07 $30 JJB
06 $22-45 RP
06 $56 B&M
06 $34 WS
05 $60 B&M
05 $37 WS
05 $16-50 RP
06 Silver Bordeaux, Bruxelles 08
06 Commended Decanter 08
Ch Gombaude-Guillot
Pomerol 03/04/05/06
Ch la Gomerie
St-Emilion GC 04-10
Ch la Gorre
Medoc 10
Ch Goubau
Cotes de Castillon 05/06/07/08/09
Cotes de Castillon la Source 09
10 WS=88
06 W&S=85
06 WE=84
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
04 WS=86
03 WS=88
10 ST=86
09 100%Merlot
09 ST=88
08 RP=93-95
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=90-93
07 ST=90
06 WE=93
06 RP=91
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=92
05 ST=93
05 Gorgeous, almost classic WS
05 WS=95
05 RP=93-96
04 WS=88
04 ST=89
04 RP=91
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07 03 WS=91
03 RP=94
10 WE=84
06 Bronze Paris 09
10 $14 WS
06 $15 WFoods
03 $70 WS
09 $50+ ST
08 $80 Zachys
07 $64 RP
06 $65-112 RP
06 $73 WS
05 $113 WS
05 $99-160 RP
10 $25 WE
06 WS=83
87
Goulee
Medoc 03-10
10 80%CS-20%Merlot
09 80%CS-20%Merlot
Ch Gracia
St-Emilion 03-10
07 60%Merlot-40%CF
10 ST=86
10 RP=90
10 TWCI=90-92
09 WE=91
09 ST=87
09 RP=89-91
09 WS 88-91
07 RP=87-89
07 ST=86
06 RP=87
06 WE=87
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=85
05 WS=86
05 WE=88
05 RP=87-89
04 WS=86
04 RP=87-89
03 WS=79
03 RP=90
04 WS=86
10 ST=91
09 ST=88
08 RP=94-97
07 ST=90
07 RP=92-94
06 RP=93+
06 ST=91-92
05 RP=94-96
05 ST=93+?
04 RP=93
10 $27+ ST
10 $22-35 RP
09 $25 JJB
06 $30 RP
06 $26 K&L
06 $25 JJB
05 $29 WS
05 $26 K&L
05 $24-29 RP
09 $130+ ST
08 $145 Zachys
07 $115 Zachys
07 $99-115 RP
06 $90-170 RP
05 $110-160 RP
05 $150 Zachys
Les Angelots de Gracia 10
Ch Gramond (B Grammond) Haut Medoc 10
10 ST=89
Ch Grand Barrail Lamarzelle St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09
10 Bronze LA 12
10 WE=91
10 WS=88
09 WE=90
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=84-86
07 WS=85-88
07 RP=85-87
06 WS=79
10 $24 WE
06 $40 WS
05 WS=88
Ch Grand Billard
Bordeaux 10
Ch Grand Bireau
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=86
Ch Les Grands Chenes
Medoc 09/10
10 WS=88
10 $22 WS
10 RP=89
10 $15-24 RP
10 JS=89-90
10 $22 K&L
09 RP=90
09 $25 K&L
09 ST=87-90
10 ST=86
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=15/20
09 WE=93
08 WS=89
08 $30 WS
07 WE=86
07 RP=86-88
07 $20-27 RP
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=90
06 WS=86
06 $27 WS
06 AG=88
05 RP=90-92
05 WS=88
05 $35 WS
Ch Grand Corbin-Despayne GC St Emilion 04-10
10 $30 WE
88
Grand Corbin Manuel
Ch Grand Destieu
06 Silver Paris 09
Ch Grand Donnezac
Bordeaux 08
Grand Enclos de Ch Cerons Graves 05/07
Ch Grand Jean
Bordeaux Traditional 10
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Bordeauz Sup Res 09/10
04 WE=92
04 WS=82
04 RP=90
03 WS=90
03 RP=88
10 RP=88
07 RP=82-85
07 RP=88-90
06 RP=91-93
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=88
06 WE=89
05 WE=87/90
05 WS=87
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=87
04 WE=89
10 $24 RP
06 $34 WS
05 $40 WS
04 $50 WS
08 Bronze LA 10
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
10 Bronze LA 12
05 WS=86
04 WS=84
09 Bronze LA 10
10 WE=84
09 WE=82
08 WE=84
10 $14 WE
09/08 $12 WE
09 WE=85
09 $15 WE
10 LA=93
09 WS=86
09 $18 WS
10 Bronze LA 11
09 Silver LA 10
08 Silver LA 10
Dom de Grandmaison
06 WS=83
Ch Grand Maison
Cotes de Bourg Cuvee Speciale 06/07/10
Cotes de Bourg 06/07/10
Cotes de Bourg Valades 10
Ch les Grands Marechaux Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 06/08/09/10/11
Ch Grand-Mayne
St-Emilion GC 03-10
05 Full, round, long WW 06
05 Big round wine SS in Decanter 06
10 WE=89
07 WE=88
06 WE=90
10 WE=87
07 WE=84
10 $20 WE
10 WE=88
10 $15 WE
10 $27 WE
11 RP=86-88
11 WS=86-89
10 RP=88
10 $20 RP
10 ST=86
10 RP=88-90
10 WS=87-90
09 RP=90
09 $11.50 JJB
09 WS 89-92
09 CellarT=89 (15)
09 RC=87/88
08 RP=87
08 $17-20 RP
08 WS=88
06 WS=87
10 ST=86
10 JJB=90
07 WE=90
07 $30 WE
07 RP=82-85
07 $27-36 RP
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=88
06 $45 RP
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 $48 WS
05 WE=93/93
05 $49 Zachys
05 RP=90-92
05 $21-62 RP
89
Ch le Grand Moulin
Prem Cotes de Blaye 08/09/10
Prem Cotes de Blaye Cuvee Collection 06/08
Prem Cotes de Blaye Cuvee Prestige 06
Ch Grand-Moulinet
Ch Grandes Murailles
Dom du Grand Ormeau
Ch Grand Ormeau
03 Very good with potential WD 10/05 03 WD=16.5/20
03 WS=90
03 RP=90
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 NM=88
06 WS=86
05 WS=88
07 WS=85-88
06/05 $28 WS
05 WS=88
05 $40 WS
06/ 05 Cited Wine Hachette 10/09
10/09 Comm’d Decanter 12
Lalande-de-Pomerol Cuvee Madeleine 02-08
08 ST=87
07 RP=87-90
06 WS=86
06 RP=89
05 WS=89
05 RP=88-90
Grand Paris
08 C$16 LCBO
06 WS=87
04 $38 WS
04 $35-39 RP
06/05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09
Pomerol 05/06
05 SS=15/20
04 WS=85
04 RP=89
06 $35 RP
05 $32 WS
05 $36 Zachys
05 $25 RP
03 WS=80-84
03 RP=87
02 WS=85
Bordeaux 07/08
08 $10 K&L
07 RP=85-86
Ch Grand-Pey-Lescours
Ch Grand-Pontet
St-EmilionGC 05/06
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07
05 Full, fruity, potential WW 06
05 Big spicy lacking finesse Decanter
Ch Grand-Puy-Ducasse
05 WS=82
05 $25 WS
07 RP=85-87
07 $26 RP
07 C$39 BCLS
06 $35 WS
05 $41 WS
06 WS=87
05 WS=92
05 SS=15/20
05 RP=91-93
04 WS=87
04 RP=88
10 60%CS-40%Nerlot
10 ST=86
10 JJB=90+
09 WE=90
09 ST=88
08 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5
08 JJB=87-89
07 WE=86
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=90
06 WE=90
06 NM=93
06 ST=84-87
06 WS=88
05 NM=93
05 ST=86-88
05 $18-54 RP
09 $42+ ST
07 $27 WE
07 $24-31 RP
06 $27-32 RP
06 C$85 NM
06 $32 WS
05 C$52 NM
90
Ch Grand-Puy-Lacoste
Paulliac GC Classe 02-10
Ch Grand Rolland
Bordeaux Grande Cuvee 08/09
Ch Grand Tayac
Margaux 05/06/10
05 WS=87
05 $38 WS
05 WE=86
05 RP=87-90
05 $28-38 RP
04 WS=88
04 RP=90
03 WS=89
03 RP=90
10 83%CS-17%Merlot
10 ST=91
10 $80+ ST
10 JJB=94
09 ST=88
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 ST=89
08 RP=89-91+
08 $46 Zachys
08 JJB=88-90
07 Celebrity Fav Vine Talk TV
07 RP=89-91
07 $41-60 RP
07 WS=88-91
07 $55 K&L
07 ST=88
07 $71 B&M
07 $55 Zachys
07 C$89 BCLS
06 RP=92
06 $37-84 RP
06 ST=90-91
06 $98 B&M
06 WS=91
06 C$99 BCLS
05 Fine tannins, chewy, beautiful WW 05 ST=93
05 $139 B&M
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WS=93
05 RP=95
05 $46-141 RP
04 WS=91
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
03 Very Successfuk Hachette 07
03 ST=90
03 WS=92
03 RP=88
02 RP=86
02 WS=85-88
02 ST=88
09 WE=85
08 WE=84
10 RP=87
10 $25 RP
05 WS=85
05 $25 WS
06 Cab Sauv; Bronze IWC 10
Grand Theatre
Ch le Grand Verdus
Ch Grand Village
Botdeaux Sup 08
Bordeaux 08
08 Silver LA 10; France-Macon 09
Bordeaux Sup Grand Res 04/05/06/07
Bordeaux Sup 05
Bordeaux Sup 09-11
11 75%Merlot-25%CF
10 75%Merlot-25%CF
08 $9 Andys
06 WS=80-84
04 WS=85
03 WS=89-91
11 $20 Zachys
10 $25 WS
10 $15-25 RP
10 $22.50 Zachys
Ch Grand Vincent
Premieres Cotes de Blaye 06
10 WS=89
10 RP=89
10 ST=88-91
10 TWCI=89-91
09 ST=87
09 WS=87
10 WS=90-93
09 ST=89
06 WS=85
Ch la Grande Clotte
08 WS=87
08 $18 WS
Ch les Grands Chenes
Medoc 04-09 (58%Merlot-40%CS)
09 ST=87
08 WS=87
07 RP=87-89
07/06 $15-20 RP
Bordeaux Sup G 09/10
91
Ch Les Grands Marechaux Prem Cotes de Blaye 04/05/06/08/09/10
Ch les Grandes Murailles
St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch la Grange de Bessan
Medoc 09/10
Ch la Grange Clinet
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 05/06/07/08/09
Ch la Grange de Grenet
Bordeauz 08/09/10
Ch la Grangere
St-Emilion07/ 08
Ch des Granges d’Or
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 05
Ch La Grave
Medoc 0/07/08/09/10
Pomerol 05
06 RP=87
07 ST=88
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
05 $21 WS
05 RP=90-92
05 $10-23 RP
04 Silver IWSC 07
04 RP=88-90
04 $26 RP
03 WS=89-91
03 RP=88
10 TWCI=87-89
09 RC=87
09 $11.50 JJB
09 RP=90
09 WS=88
09 CellarT-89 (15)
08 WS=87
08 $17 WS
06 WS=87
06 $18 WS
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
05 RP=89
04 $20 RP
05 WS=89-91
04 RP=85
03 WS=89
10 ST=86
08 WS=89
07 RP=88-90
07 $36 RP
06 WS=84
05 WS=91
05 $53 WS
04/03 WS=90
04 $40 WS
10 RP=87
10 $20 RP
10 WE=85
10 $25 WE
09 Zachys 92
09 $20 Zachys
10 CellarT=86 (32)
09 $11 Astor
06 WS=83
06 $14 WS
05 WE=88
05 WS=80-84
04 Gold Paris 07
03 WS=86
03 $12 WS
02 WR=89
10 WS=84
10/09/08 $12 WS
09 WS=85
08 WS=86
08 WS=89
05 WR=90
05 $14 WR
10 Silver Bruxelles, Decanter 12
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
05 Bronze Paris 07
10 $13 wine.com
04/03 €5-8 Hach
05 W&S=1-1½star
05 ST=87-90
03 ST=87
Fronsac 09
Ch la Grave Figeac
St-Emilion 05
Ch la Grave a Pomerol
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
09 $30 Zachys
05 €8-11 Hach
10 SY=87
09 ST=88
08 WS=89
08 RP=88-90
08 JJB=87-89
07 RP=86-87
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=86
07 $35-42 RP
07 $35 Zachys
07 C$45 BCLS
92
06 WE=89
06 RP=80
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=88
05 WE=90
05 WS=94
05 ST=88
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=92
04 WE=87
04 RP=86
04 ST=87-89
05 Hach=2star
06 $30 K&L
06 $28-50 RP
06 $42 WS
05 $52 WS
05 $49 Zachys
05 $35-52 RP
04 $40 WS
04 $12-35 RP
Ch les Graves
Prem Cotes de Blaye 04/05
Ch des Graves
05 W&S=83
05 $18 W&S
La Gravette de Certan
Pomerol 04/05/06
06 $35-47 RP
Ch La Gravette Lacombe
Medoc 10
Ch Graviere
Medoc 05
06 RP=89
06 WS=86
04 WS=87
10 WE=91
10 WS=87
05 WS=85
Ch la Graviere
Lalande-de-Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08
10 Editor’s Chouce WE
Cotes-de-Bourg 07
Ch les Gravieres
05 $48 RP
10 $18 WE
05 $34 WS
07 Silver Paris 09
St-Emilion 05
05 NM=90
St-Emilion GC 01-12
12 RP=87-89
11 RP=84-86
10 RP=89-92
09 RP=93
08 RP=91
10 100% Merlot
07 Silver Bordeaux 10; Paris 09
06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08ii
Ch des Graviers
Margaux 08
Ch des Gravieres
Margaux Cuvee Prestige 06
Ch des Gravieres
Grave 05
Grave Cuvee Prestige 10
Ch Gree-Laroque
08RP=86-88
07 RP=87-88
06 WS=86
05 WS=86
04 WS=87
03 RP=88-90
03 WS=85
02 WS=84
05 €5-8 Hach
07 RP=88-90
06 RP=88
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=89
05 RP=91
04 RP=87-89
03 WS=87
03 RP=91
02 WS=84
01 RP=90
01 WS=86
01 WE=84
08 WS=86
10 RP=89
10 TWCI=88-90
09 JJB=91-93
07 RP=88-90
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
05 C$54 NM
11 $17-18 RP
10 $17-57 RP
09 $23-50 RP
08 $30 RP
08 $20 JJB
05 $32 Zachys
05 $37 WS
08 $21 WS
10 $16-21 RP
06 $20 RP
93
Gressier-Grand-Poujeaux Moulis 10
Ch Greteau
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Ch Greysac
09 Gold LA 11
08 Silver LA 11
09 Merlot
Ch Griviere
Medoc 05/06/07
Ch Gromel Bel Air
Bordeaux Sup 06
Ch Gruaud-Larose
05 IWR=87
03 WS=85-88
01 WS=83
10 WS=88
10 RP=92
05 WS=86
09 LA=91
05 $30 IWR
10 $22 WS
10 $14-18 RP
10 WS=88
10 $22 WS
10 RP=86
10 $14-17 RP
10 WE=89
10 $17 TW&M
09 WE=89
08 WS=88
08 $15 Sh-L
08 WE=87
08 $19 wine.com
08 CellarT=86 (22)
08 SS=15.5 (86) 08 $17 Cost+
08 JR=15.5 (86)
08 G&M=14.5 (82)
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
05 WE=86
05 SS=15.5/20
05 RP=86-88
04 WE=90
04 RP=84-86
03 Silver IWC 07
03 WS=81
03 RP=88
03 WW=84
07 WE=86
07 $26 WE
06 WS=84
04 Very Suuccessful Hachette 08
06 IWR=88+
06 $14 IWR
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Eva 10
10 WS=89
St-Julien 2nd Cru 02-12
12 WS=89-92
11 WS=90-93
10 ST=92
10 JJB=90
09 WE=94
09 ST=92
09 WS=92
08 RP=89-91
08 WS=90
07 WE=91
07 RP=87-90
07 WS=90
07 ST=88
06 WE=91
06 WD=15-16/20
06 RP=84
06 WS=90
06 ST=89-90
05 WE=95/94
05 WS=91
05 ST=90
05 WD=16-17/20
04 WS=89
04 WE=89
09 65%CS-35%Merlot
06 Good WD
05 Good WD 10/05
10 $12 WS
09 $94+ ST
08 $50 K&L
08 $47 Zachys
07 $50 WE
07 $38-73 RP
07 $55 Zachys
07 $66 B&M
06 $90 B&M
06 $30-104 RP
06 $59 WS
05 $130 B&M
04 $42 B&M
94
04 ST=88
04 RP=87
04 Top 10 WW 06
04 WW=92-96
04/03 Hach=2star
03 WE=90
03 $50 K&L
03 ST=89
03 WR=94
03 WS=92
03 RP=88
03 WD=16+/20
03 WW=85-88
02 ST=88
02 RP=88-90
02 WS=89
02 ST=88
See also: Sarget de Gruard-Larose St-Julien
Ch Guadet
Ch Guadet Plaisance
St-Emilion GC 07/08 (Merlot)
Yvon Mau 10
08 WS=88
07 Silver IWC 10
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 CF-Merlot
Ch Guerry (Bernard Magrez) Cotes de Bourg 09/10
10 WS=87
10 RP=85
10 WE=89
04 Bronze IWSC 07
04 Vin Cite Hachatte 07
Ch Guibot
Puisseguin-St-Emilion la Fourvieille 08
Ch Guillon Nardon
Montagne-St-Enilion 08
Ch Guillot
Pomerol 05/06
Ch Guillot-Clauzel
Pomerol 04/05/06
Ch Guitignan
Moulis en Medoc 10
Ch la Gurgue
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch Hauchat
Bordeaux 08
Ch Hanteillan
Ch Hauchat
Ch Haura
Haut-Medoc 04/05/06
Fronsac 05/06/07
Graves 05/06/07/09
05 RP=88-90
04 RP=87
03 WR=90
08 WS=89
08 WS=89
06 NM=88
05/04VertySuccessful Hachette 09/08 05 WS=92
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
04 WS=88
10 WS=89
10 CS-Merlot-PV
10 ST=86
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=83-86
06 AG=87
06 WE=87
06 WS=89
05 WS=90
04 WE=91
04 WS=89
03 WS=87
02 WS=85
08 Gold Paris 09
Fronsac La Rose 10
07 Gold Paris 09
09 60%CS-40%Merlot
09 HOT BUY WBB
10 $10 WS
10 $20 RP
10 $19 WE
08 $14 WS
06 C$19 NM
04 $39 WS
10 $23 WS
06 C$35 AG
06 $37 WS
08 C$15 LCBO
10 WS=86
10 $15 WS
06 WS=82
05 WS=86
05 $25 WS
08 C$15 LCBO
05 WS=84
09 ST=88
JR=16 (88)
09 $14 Costco
95
G&M=16 (88)
JMQ=89
06/05 Cited Wine Hachette 09/08oygh
Ch d’Haurets
Bordeaux 08
Ch Haut-Bages-Averons
Paulliac 04/05/06/07
05 WS=83
08 WS=83
Ch Haut-Bages-Liberal
10 70%CS-23%Merlot
06 WS=84
06 WW=87
05 WS=87
03 WS=89
10 ST=91
10 JJB=92
09 WE=92
09 ST=90
08 WS=89
08 ST=89
08 JJB=83-85
07 RP=83-85
07 WS=87
07 WE=87
06 Good at best WD
06 Top Pick K&L
06 WD=14.5-15.5
06 WS=92
06 RP=89
06 ST=87-89
05 W&S=2stars
05 Breath-taking, almost 95-100 WW 05 ST=89
05 WS=93
05 WE=93
05 RP=88-90
05 Very good value WD 4/06
05 WD=16.5-17.5
04 ST=85-88
04 WW=92-93
04 WS=88
04 WE=90
04 RP=90
04 WD=16.5-17.5
03 RP=87
La Fleur de Haut-Bages-Liberal 02/08
08 $14 WS
07 $27 Zachys
06 $47 B&M
05 $53 B&M
10 $49 Costco
08 $29 WS
08 $27 K&L
07 $23-33 RP
07 $27 WS
07 $33 Zachys
07 $35 Sh-L
06 $50 B&M
06 $27-46 RP
05 $56 B&M
04 $38 B&M
08 $20 Costco
02 Comm’d IWC 07
Ch Haut-Bages-Monpelou PaulliacCru Bourgeois 05/06/08/09/10
Ch Haut-Bailly
10 RP=87
10 $18-24 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=15/20
08 WS=87
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
04 Cited Eine Hachette 08
06 WS=88
06 £14 Dec
05 WS=88
10 ST=88
10 JJB=93
09 ST=92
09 WE=95-98
09 RP=96-98
08 ST=89
08 WE=92-94
08 RP=95-97
07 WE=91
07 ST=89
07 RP=90-92
09 $135+ ST
09 $160 K&L
08 $80 ST
08 $65 K&L
08 $65 Zachys
07 $58 WE
07 $60 K&L
07 $78 B&M
07 $44-82 RP
96
07 $60 Zachys
06 RP=95
06 $57-106 RP
06 WE=92
06 AG=91
06 ST=90+?
06 WS=92
06 WD=14.5-15.5
05 WE=92/94
05 Wonderful TW 3/06
05 ST=92+?
05 W&S=1½-2stars
05 Wonderful WD 4/06
05 WD=18-19/20
05 WS=95
05 RP=93-95
04 WE=93
04 ST=90+
04 WS=91
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 07 04 RP=93
03 ST=90
03 RP=90
02 ST=89+
03 Potential best Pessac-Leognan WD 03 RP=90-92
03 WS=88
03 ST=88-91
03 WW=89-91
03 WD=17+/20
10 ST=88
09 100%Merlot
09 ST=88
08 WS=87
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 WE=87
10 $14 WE
10 CS-Merlot
06/05 Cited Wine Hachette09/08
06 WS=85
06 $26 WS
05 WS=85
03 WS=89
01 WS=84
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 RP=88-90
08 $31 Zachys
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=85-87
07 $28-37 RP
07 ST=85
07 $32 Zachys
07 WS=87-90
07 $45 B&M
06 RP=89
06 $32-40 RP
06 ST=87-89
06 $70 B&M
06 WS=89
06 $35 WS
05 ST=89
05 WS=93
05 RP=90-92
04 ST=85-87
04 WS=88
04 RP=88
03 ST=87-90
03 WS=90
03 RP=87
02 ST=87
02 RP=87
02 WS=83
08 WS=89
08 $28 WS
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=85
06 WE=89
06 RP=85
06 $36 RP
06 WS=82
06 $22 WS
05 WS=86
05 $22 WS
06 Top Pick K&L
Ch Haut Ballet
Canon-Fronsac 06/08/09/10
Ch Haut Barrail
Medoc 04/05/06/10
Ch Haut Batailley
Paulliac GC Classe 03-09 (CS-Merlot)
Ch Haut-Beausejour
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05/06/07/08
97
Ch Haut-Bellevue
Haut-Medoc 10
Ch Haut Bergey
09 60%CS-40%Merlot
Passac-Leognan l’Etoile de Bergey 08
Ch Haut-Bernat
06 RP=91
06 ST=90-91
06 WS=89
05 Rich, powerful, velvety, long WW 05 WS=91
05 WE=89
05 NM=91
05 ST=90+?
05 RP=92-94
04 WS=86
04 ST=88
04 RP=90
03 RP=86
08 WS=86
Ch Haut Bertinerie
05 SS=16/20
05 RP=81-83
05 RC=88
04 WS=88
04 WE=89
03 WS=83
10 WS=87
10 RP=86
12 WS-90-93
12 WE=90-92
12 RP=90-93
11 WS=90-93
10 ST=88
10 JJB=91
09 WE=88
09 ST=90
09 RP=92-94
09 WS=91-94
08 WBlB=92
08 WS=87
08 RP=92-94
08 WE=91-93
08 ST=89
07 RP=90-93
07 WS=86
07 ST=90
10 WS=87
06 WS=82
05 NM=91
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=82
03 WS=83
07 WE=88
10 $22 WS
12 $23 JJBFuture
11 $25 JJBFuture
10 $37+ ST
09 $35 K&L
08 $25 WBlB
08 $28 WS
08 $25 K&L
07 $24-30 RP
07 $30 K&L
07 $27 Zachys
07 $28 WS
07 $26 JJB
07 C$39 BCLS
06 $26-35 RP
06 $25 Zachys
05 C$49 NM
10 $12 WS
07 $24 WE
05 WE=88
Ch Haut Bessac
Bordeaux Sup 08
Ch Haut Beyzac
Haut-Medoc du Haut Beyzac 04/05
Haut Beyzac Grand Vin 06
08 Bronze LA 10/11
Haut-Medoc 04/05
Ch Haut Blagnac
Bordeaux 06/07
Ch Haut-Brion
05 $20 WE
05 WE=89
05 $27 WE
05 WE=89
05 $31 WE
Haut-Medoc I Second 05
Ch Haut-Beychevelle Gloria St-Julien 03/04/05/06
05 WE=86
04 W&S=85
09 46%Merlot-40%CS-CF
07 WW=87
06 WW=89
10 ST=97
05 €11-15 Hach
07 $10 5¢
10 $900+ ST
98
06 Top Pick K&L
04 Collectable WS 3/31/07
04 Vin Exceptionel Hachette 08
Grave 03/04/05
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19.5/20
09 WE=96
09 ST=97
09 $945+ ST
09 JJB=95-97
08 ST=92
08 $325 ST
08 RP=95-97
08 $500 K&L
08 WE=94-96
08 $325 Zachys
08 WS=93-96
07 WE=94
07 $450 WE
07 AG=92
07 C$599 AG
07 RP=91-94
07 $280-527 RP
07 WS=89-92
07 $430 K&L
07 ST=94
07 $500 Zachys
07 $530 B&M
07 C$599 BCLS
06 WE=96
06 RP=96
06 $530 K&L
06 ST=92-94
06 $315-650 RP
06 WS=94
06 $575 WS
05 RP=96-100
05 $590+ RP
05 W&S=98
05 WS=100
05 $930 W&S
05 WE=96/98
05 $1500 WE
05 ST=97
05 WW=95-98
04 WS=95
04 RP=90-92
04 $107-407 RP
04 WE=96
04 ST=91+
03 RP=95
03 WS=96
03 ST=94
03 WW=95-98
02 RP=89
02 WS=93
02 ST=92+
02 WW=92-95
01 WS=95
01 RP=94
01 ST=92+
00 WS=94
00 RP=98
00 ST=96
99 WS=91
99 RP=93
99 ST=92
05 ST=95-98
05 WW=95-98
04 ST=92-94
03 ST=94
02 ST=92+
See also their second wine: Ch Bahans Haut-Brion
See also: Le Clarence de Haut-Brion
Ch Haut Brisson
St-Emilion GC 06/10
St-Emilion La Reserve GC 04/06/07/08
St-Emilion La Grave 04/05/06/07/08/09
10 RP=90
06 90%Merlot-CS-CF
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
04 Silver Paris 07
09 Comm’d IWC 12
07 RP=90-92
06 RP=90
10 $21-27 RP
06 $20 JJB
06 $80 RP
06 $60 Dec
05 $40 JJB
00 RP=88
99
Ch Haut-Canteloup
Haut-Medoc 04/05
Medoc 05/06/08
Prem Cotes-de-Blaye Cuvee Prestige 05-10
Ch Haut-Carles
Fronsac 04/05/06/07/09/10
Ch Haut-Chaigneau
Lalande-de-Pomerol Cuvee Prestige 03-08
Ch Haut Colombier
Prem Cotes de Blaye 06/07/08/09/10
Ch Haut Condissas
Medoc 04-10 (Rollan de By)
Medoc Prestige 04-10
Ch Les Hauts Conseillants
Lalande de Pomerol 09
09 CF-CS-Merlot
06 RP=89
06 $40 RP
05 $24 JJB
05 WS=87
05 $17 WS
04 WE=87
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
10 Hachette=2 stars
10 Gold Paris 11
09 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 Gold Bordeaux, Brussels 10
07 Viun Remarquable Hachette 10
07 Silver Paris 09
06 Gold Bordeaux 07
10 ST=86
09 WE=89
09 ST=88
07 RP=87-89
07 ST=88
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=88
06 WBlB=87
06 $15-30 WBlB
05 RP=88-90
05 $25-30 RP
05 WS=91
05 $34 WS
05 $30 Zachys
04 RP=86-88
04 $24 RP
04 WS=87
03 RP=89
03 WS=88
01 WS=85
08 WS=88
06 WS=86
06 NM=89
06 C$28 NM
05 WS=87
04/03/02 WS=86
10 WS=89
10 $20 WS
09 $17 WClub
08 WS=86
08 $14 WS
05 $20 Zachys
10 TWCI=89-91
09 Decanter=4star
09 Merlot
09 Decanter=17/20
07 RP=88-91
06 RP=91
06 $45-64 RP
05 Silver IWC 09
05 RP=90-92
05 $42-47 RP
04 RP=90
04 $35 RP
10 ST=87
07 ST=87
06 Gold Brussels; Silver Decanter 10 06 RP=90-92
05 ST=89+?
05 WS=88
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=87
03 WS=89
09 Merlot dominant
09 RP=87-89
09 $27 Astor
100
Ch Haut Corbin
St-Emilion GC 04-09 (65%M-20%CS-15%CF)
Ch Haut Faugeres
Ch Haut-Gardere
Ch Haut Gaussens
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Ch Haut-Gravet
St-Emilion 03/04/05/06/07/08
Cuvee la Croix Fourche 08
07 RP=87-89
06 WS=85
05 RP=88-90
05 WS=89
04 WS=86
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 03 RP=88-90 RP
03 WS=82
08 Comm’d IWC 12
08 CF-CS-Merlot
04 WS=88
09 Bronze LA; Comm’d Decanter 12
Prem Cotes de Blaye 08
Ch Haut Guillebot
Bordeaux Sup 09
Ch Haut-Guiraud
Cotes de Bourg Peche du Roy 08/09/10
10 Bromze Decanter 12
08 Regional Trophy > £5 Decanter 10
08 Gold Brussels 10
Les Hauts de Lagarde
Bordeaux 10
10 Bronze LA 12
Ch Haut-Lagrange
Fronsac 04/05/06
Ch Haut-Maillet
Pomerol 04/05/06
Ch Haut-Marbuzet
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Exceptionnel 03-10
05 $54 WS
07 $30 WS
05 $25 WS
09 Silver LA 11
08 Bronze LA 10
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
Ch Haut Grela
Ch Haut-Lariveau
09 ST=87
08 WS=88
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=87
05 WS=91
04/03 WS=87
02 WS=85
01 WW=88
01 WS=87
08 WS=89
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
04 WS=89
07 WS=89
05 WS=84
05 WE=90
10 WE=83
06 $50 WS
05 $34-42 RP
10 $13 WE
08 WS=85
06 WS=84
05 WS=79
03 Hachette=1star 03 €15 Hachette
05 WS=86
06 WS=88
06 $50 WS
05 WS=88
04 WS=87
04 $42 WS
10 ST=91
09 WE=94
07=50%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF)
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=87
07 ST=87
07 RP=83-85
06 RP=87
06 WD=15-16/20
06 WS=88
06 ST=88-89
05 WS=91
05 ST=92
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=89
04 ST=88
04 RP=88
04 $13-25 RP
04/03 Hach=2star
06 Decent WD
07 $35-46 RP
06 $32-50
06 $40 WS
05 $48 WS
05 $50 Zachys
05 $40 K&L
05 $21-60 RP
04 $35 WS
101
Ch Haut-Maurac
Ch Haut Mayne
Ch Haut Mazeris
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 04/06/ 07/08/09
Graves Rouge 08
04 Gold Brussels 06
03 WS=91
03 RP=88
10 ST=87
09 WS=90-93
08 WS=87
03 $40 WS
03 $19-75 RP
09 $20 K&L
07 $23 Dec
08 €5-8 Hach
03 WS=80-84
07 RP=88-90
07 ST=86
Ch Haut-Mazeris
Fronsac 04/05/06
Canon-Fronsac 04/05/06
05 Silver Paris 07, Bordeaux 07
04 Gold Brussels 06
Canon-Fronsac Res Capucine 03/05
Ch Haut Mazerolles
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 10
La Haut-Medo Betchevelle
Haut-Medoc 05
Haut Medoc de Maucaillou
Haut-Medoc 05
Ch Haut Mondain
Bordeaux 10/11
10 WE=90
10 $25 WE
06 $30 RP
03 $23-25 RP
03 $20 WS
05 $23 RP
04 $23-25 RP
05 WS=86
08 WS=86
05 WE=87
06 WS=84
11 Gold LA 12
10 Silver LA 11
Grande Res 10
Ch Haut Nadeau
03 $14-45 RP
05 Gold Brussels 09
Ch Haut-Meneau la Victoire Prem Cotes de Blaye la Victoire 05/08
Ch Haut Meynard
03 RP=91
02 WS=80-84
06 RP=88
06 ST=86-88
05 ST=89-90
04 WS=84
03 RP=87
03 WS=85
02 WS=86
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=89-91
04 RP=87
04/03 WS=86
03 RP=91
02 WS=85
05 WS=85-88
03 WS=89-91
02 WS=89-91
Bordeaux Sup 10
Bordeaux Sup Res du Prop 04/05/08
Ch les Haut de Palette
Ch Haut la Pereyre
Bordeaux Sup 05/06
Prem-Cotes-de-Bordeaux 05/06
08 $22 WS
11 LA=92
10 WE=88
10 $15 WE
05 K&L=91
05 IWR=88
05 RP=87-89
04 WW=89-90
03 RP=85-87
05 WE=88
05 $12 K&L
05 $16 IWR
04 $13-19
05 $18 RP
05 $15 WE
06 Hach=1star
05 Hach=1star
03 WR=87
03 $12 WR
09 WW=89
09 $25 B&M
Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Hachette 11
Ch Haut Peyrillat
Medoc 09
102
Ch Haut-Peyrous
Graves Retour des Palombieres 08
08 WE=89
08 $28 WE
Ch Haut Peyruguet
Bordeaux 10
10 WS=85
10 $10 WS
Ch Haut Phillippon
Bordeaux 10
Ch Haut-Plantey
Haut-Medoc 10
10 WS=88
10 $14 WS
Ch Haut Pommarede
Graves 05/06
10 Bronze LA 11
Graves Cuvee Apoteke 05
Les Hauts de Pontet-Canet
05 WS=85
05 WS=87
Paulliac 05/06/07/08 (Ch Pontet Canet)
Ch Haut Prieur
Premieres Cotes de Blaye 06/08
08Silver Brussels 10
Ch Haut-St-Georges
St-Emilion 05
Ch Haut Sarpe
St-Emilion 08
Ch Haut Selve
Graves 05/06/07/08/09
05 WW=91
08 $25 K&L
07 $23 Zachys
07 $25 Sh-L
07 C$36 LCBO
05 $70 B&M
06 WS=84
05 WE=90
05 $60 WE
05 €15-23 Hach
08 WS=89
05 WS=90
09 CS-Merlot
08 WS=86
07 Silver Paris 09
Graves Reserve 05/06/08
08 Bronze IWC 12
08 CS-Merlot
06 WE=91
05 WE=89
05 WS=889
05 WS=89
Graves Grand Reserve 05
Ch Haut Simard
06 WE=89
05 WE=88
05 WS=84
06 WS=88
St-Emilion 08/09 (70%M-30%CF)
08 $24 WS
07 C$22 LCBO
05 $20 WE
05 $30 WE
09 WE=89
09 ST=87
08 WS=86
05 IWR=91
05 $25 IWR
Ch Beau-Lite Haur Vignoble St-Estephe Cru B
05 IWR=91
05 $25 IWR
Les Hauts de Smith Rouge
06
06 RP=86
06 $35 RP
Haut Sociando
06
06 RP=96
06 $16 RP
Ch Haut-Sorillon
Bordeauz Superieur 06/07/09/10
10 Silver LA 12
Ch Haut-Surget
Lalande-de-Pomerol10
10 Merlot dominant
Ch Haut-Site Haut Vignoble St-Estephe 05
Les Hauts de Ste-Marie
Bordeaux Sup Ch Ste-Marie Vieilles Vignes 10
10 CellarT=87 (3) 10 $8 TrJ
07 RC=85
06 RC=86
10 $22 Astor
10 $25 WFoods
06 WS=88
06 $24 WS
05 WS=88
05 $24 WS
04 W&S=87
04 $20 W&S
10 WS=86
10 $15 WS
Les Hauts de Tousquiron
Medoc Cuvee Lucie 10
10 WE=86
10 $28 WE
Ch Haut-Vigneau
10 WS=89
10 JS=90
10 JR=17 (92)
08 WS=88
10 $23 WS
10 $18 K&L
10 $20 Sh-L
08 $23 WS
10 Bronze Decanter 3 stars 12
08 Comm’d IWC 10
103
Prem-Cotes-de-Blaye 04
06 WS=88
06 NM=88
05 WS=88
03 WS=79
03 WC=4stars
04 Hach=1star
Hautes Terres du FourcasDupre
Les Hauts de Brillette
Listrac 06
06 WS=86
Moulis 05
05 WS=85
Ch les Hauts-Conseillants
Lalande de Pomerol 03/04/05/06
06 WS=87
05 WS=86
05 NM=90
06 $35 WS
05 $38 WS
05 C$69 NM
05 WS=86
05 WW=91
10 WS=85
05 $70 B&M
Les Hauts de Pontet-Canet
Paulliac 05 (second Ch Hauts dePontet- Canet)
Les Hauts de Ste-Marie
Cotes de Bordeaux Ch Ste-Marie le Moulin 10
Les Hauts de Smith
Les Hauts du Tertre
Margaux 05
Henri Luis Faggard
See: Ch Bois Redon
Henri de Villamont
Savigny-les-Beaune le Village 05
L’Heritage de le Boscq
St-Estephe 05
10 $20 WS
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 WS=82
05 Gold Brussels 07
05 WS=80
L’Heritage de Chasse-Spleen Haut-Medoc 04/05
L’Heritier
St-Julien 09/10
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 CS-Merlot
09 Silver IWSC; Bronze IWC 12
Clos L’Hermitage
09
Ch de L’Hermitage
Horeau-Beylot
06 $15 WS
05 WS=87
09 RP=87-88
06 RP=87
06 $40 RP
10 WE=89
10 $17 WE
Bordeaux Sup Ch Lajarre 10
10 WE=88
10 $27 WE
Canon-Fronsac Ch Tour 10
10 WE=87
10 $30 WE
10 WE=87
10 $11 WE
Montagne-St-Emilion Ch la Fleur 10
Ch Bellevue 10
Hortevie
06/07
Ch Hosanna
Pomerol 04-10
10 Best Buy WE
09 Merlot-CF
06 Barrel Selection WE
07 RP=86-87
06 RP=87
10 ST=92
09 ST=92
09 WE=95
08 ST=91
08 RP=96-98
08 JJB=89-91
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=89-91
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=89
06 WE=93/93
06 RP=94
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=90
05 ST=94
05 WE=93/95
05 WS=96
05 RP=94-96
06 $38 RP
10 $206+ ST
09 $280+ ST
08 $250 Zachys
07 $88-118 RP
07 $95 Zachys
06 $150-222 RP
06 $135 WS
05 $155 Zachys
05 $163 WS
05 $145-230 RP
104
Ch de L’Hospital
Graves 05/07
Ch Hostens-Picant
Ste-Foy Bordeaux 04/05/06/08/09/10
Ste-Foy Bordeaux Lucullus 07/10
Ste Foy Bordeaux Cuvee D’Except 04-09
Ch Hourtin-Ducasse
04 WS=91
04 ST=90
04 RP=90
04 WE=93
03 WS=93
03 RP=90
07 Silver Brussels; Bronze Challenge 10
05 WS=84
10 RP=85
09 Silver Paris 11; Comm’d IWC 12
09 CF-Merlot
08 WS=88
06 WS=85
06 ST=87-89
05 WS=80-84
03 RP=88-90
10 RP=89
07 45% CF
07 ST=87
Ste Foy Bordeaux Cuvee des Demoiselles 05
09 Bronze IWC 12
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
04 Gold Brussels 07
04 Silver IWC 09
05 Gold Brussels 07
Graves-de-Vayres 06
Haut-Medoc 09/10
08 WS=89
05 ST=87-89
05 ST=90
05 WS=85-88
10 $16-18 RP
03 $15 RP
10 $16-18 RP
04 $30 Dec
03 WS=82
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
10 $20 WS
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 CF-CS-Merlot
Ch de la Huste
Fronsac 07-10
Ch Hyot
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 08/09/10
Ch l’Isle Fort
Bordeauz Sup 08-10
Ch d’Issan
10 WS=90
09 WS=89-92
07 WS=86
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
10 Smart Buy WS
10 WS=90
10 Gold Bordeaux, France-Macon 11 10 JS=89
08 WS=88
06 WS=84
05 WS=87
10 ST=90
09 Bronzr Decanyer 12
08 WS=86
10 69%CS-31%Merlot
10 ST=91
09=60%Me4rlot-CS
09 RP=93-95
09 ST=89
09 WE=89-91
08 ST=89
08 RP=91-93
08 WS=87-90
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=87-90
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=88
06 ST=88-89
09 NM=95
06 WE=92
06 RP=94
06 WS=89
05 ST=89
05 W&S=2stars
10 $25 WS
09 $14 JJB
07 $20 WS
10 $17 WS
10 $13 K&L
08 $17 WS
09 $60 K&L
09 $65+ ST
08 $45 K&L
08 $45 ST
07 $43 RP
07 $42 Zachys
07 $55 B&M
07 C$59 BCLS
06 $75 B&M
06 C$68 NM
06 $43-50 RP
06 $48 WS
05 $60 B&M
105
05 Stunning concentration WW
Ch des Jacobins
St-Emilion 08
Ch Clos des Jacobins
St-Emilion GC 04-10
05 WS=92
05 RP=92-94
05 WW=92-93
04 WS=87
04 WW=89
03 WS=89
03 WW=88-90
02 WS=85
01 WS=90
00 BTI=91
00 WS=88
08 WS=87
05 $61 WS
04 $30 WS
04 $35 B&M
10 RP=90
10 SR=87
10 TWCI=90-93
09 WE=91
09 ST=87
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=89-91
07 WS=86
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=92
05 SS=17/20
05 WS=94
05 ST=90-93
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=91
04 ST=87
04 RP=89
06 RC=87
05 WS=85
05 WE=84
10 WE=85
10 $30 WE
Santenay 03
03 WS=84
03 $28 WS
Savigny-les-Beaune 03
03 WS=87
03 $20 WS
Ch de Janicon
Graves 10
10 WE=85
10 $30 WE
Le Jardin de Petit-Village
Pomerol 04
04 WS=88
04 $39 WS
Ch de la Jaubertie
Bergerac 10
10 WE=86
10 $12 WE
Clos du Jaugueyron
Margaux 05-10
10 RP=89
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=87-88
07 ST=86
06 RP=89+
06 ST=86-88
05 ST=88-90
10 $14-20 RP
09 $15-19 RP
09 75%M-23%CF-CS
05 Classic, excell future Decanter 06
05 Smart Buy WS
Ch Jacques Blanc
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Jacques Noir
St-Emilion 09/10
10 $24-59 RP
09 $36-63 RP
06 $32-42 RP
06 $35 WS
05 $45 WS
05 $40-47 RP
Jaffelin
09 CS-Merlot
Haut-Medoc 06
Ch Jean-Faure
07 $12-14 RP
06 $17 RP
St-Emilion GC 04-10
10/ 09 54%CF-40%M-Malbec
10 ST=90
09 ST=89
08 WS=87
08 ST=89
07 WE=87
07 ST=87
07 RP=85-87
06 WBlB=86
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=86
05 $40 WS
106
Ch Jean Faux
05 WE=89
05 ST=91
04 ST=87
10 RP=89
09 WS=88-91
09/08 RP=87-89
10 $20-25 RP
09 $13 JJB
09 $13 RP
09 $28 Zachys
08 Silver LA 11
Ch Jean de Gue
Lalande-de-Pomerol 04/05/06/08
06 Vin Remarquabls Hachette 10
05 A sleeper RP
Lalande-de-pomerol Cuvee Prestige 03/05/06
07 WS=88
07 RP=85-87
07 $28 WS
08 WS=88
06 RP=91
05 WS=88
05 RP=88-91
04 WS=88
04 RP=88
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=89-91
08 $25 WS
06 $35 RP
05 $28 WS
05 $25 RP
04 $28 RP
03 WS=85-88
Ch Jean L’Arc
Bordeaux Rouge 09
09 Silver LA 11
Jean-Pierre Mouiex
St-Emilion 05
Ch Jean Voisin
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Jean Voisin Fagouet
St-Emilion 05
St-Emilion Cuvee Amddee 04/06
Ch Joanin Becot
04 Vin Remarquabls Hachette 09
09 75%Merlot-CF
05 WE=87
05 $24 WE
06 WS=88
05 WS=84
05 WS=78
06 $27 WS
10 RP=89
10 ST=86
09 ST=87
09 RP=91-93
09 WS=89-92
10 $19-27 RP
08 RP=90-92
08 WS=87-90
08 JBB=89-91
07 WS=84
07 RP=88-91
07 ST=89
Ch Joinin
Bordeaux 03/04/05/06/07/10
07 Bronze LA 10
Ch Jonqueyres
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Dorothee 07
Ch la Jorine
Lussac-Saint-Emilion 10
Ch des Joualles
Bordeaux Sup 08
06 RP=90
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=88
05 WE=91
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=90
05 ST=90
04 WS=87
04 ST=88
03 WS=89
03 ST=89
10 WS=90
09 $24+ ST
09 $25 K&L
09 $25 WClub
09 $24 JJB
08 $21 K&L
08 $25 Zachys
08 $21 JJB
07 $22 WS
07 $16-26 RP
07 C$39 BCLS
07 $20 Zachys
06 $17-25
06 $22 K&L
06 $22 WS
05 $30 JJB
05 $26-40 RP
05 $40 Zachys
10 $12 WS
06 WS=83
06 $11 WS
04/03 WS=82
07 WS=87
06 WW=87
10 WE=88
07 $18 WS
06 $10 B&M
10 $18 WE
08 Silver LA 11
107
Ch le Joyeux
Bordeaux 10
10 Silver LA 11
Ch du Juge
Bordeaux 11
11 Bronze LA 12
Ch Julien
Haut-Medoc 03/04/05/06/09
09 Bronze Paris 11
Ch Julian
Bordeaux 07/08/09/10/11
06 WS=87
05 WS=87
04 Hach-1star
03 Hach=2star
04/03 €11-15
11 Bronze LA 12
10 WE=85
09 WE=84
Bordeaux Traditional 10
10 LA=93
Bordeaux Sup Traditional 09
09 Gold LA 11
09 LA=92
Bordeaux Sup 09/10
10 Silver LA 12
09 WE=84
10 $14 WE
09 $15 WE
Ch le Jurat
St-Emilion GC 04-09 (87%Merlot-9%CS-CF)
Kirkland Sig (Costco)
Bordeaux Sup 10 (SCEA Gongfrier Freres)
Medoc 09 (Unimedoc A. F.)
Ch Kirwan
10 Best Buy WE
09 68%CS-32%Merlot
Margaux GC Classe 03-10
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Very silky, refined, long WW 06
02 Excell F&W 06
09 ST=87
08 WS=86
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=86
05 WS=89
04 WS=88
10 RC=87
10 $12 Costco
10 WS=84
10 WE=85
10 $7 WE
09 RC=87
09 $9 Costco
09 CellarT 86.5 (24)
09 CostcoBlog 86
10 JJB=92
09 Decanter=4.5star
09 WE=94
09 $55 K&L
09 WS=90
09 ST=88
09 $50+ ST
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=88-90
08 $43 Zachys
07 WE=91
07 $45 WE
07 RP=89-92
07 $36-50 RP
07 WS=86-89
07 $47 K&L
07 ST=87
07 $50 Zachys
07 C$67 BCLS
06 WD=16-17/20
06 RP=88
06 $28-51 RP
06 WE=91
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=90
06 $47 WS
05 $70 B&M
05 WS=93
05 WE=93/93
05 ST=91
05 RP=91-94
05 $60-157 RP
05/04 WE=93
04 WS=88
04 ST=88
04 RP=90
03 WS=92
03 ST=89
03 RP=93
03 WD=16.5/20
02 WS=89
02 RP=88
01 WS=90
01 RP=90
See their second wine: Les Charmes de Kirwan
108
Kressman
Bordeaux Monopole Eleve 06/07/08/09/10
Medoc Grande Reserve 04/05
Medoc Ch David Cru Bourgeois 09
05 Bruxelles 06
09 Bronze IWC 12
05 £4.50 Dec
Graves Grande Res 05/07
Ch la Pierriere 05
Ch Labadie
Ch Labat
Ch Labegorce
05 Comm’d IWC 07
Bordeaux 09/10
09 Couer Selection Hachette 13
04 €5-8 Hach
10 RP=89
10 $18 RP
09 Hachette=3 star
07 WE=88
06 WS=86
05 WS=90
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 03-12
Ch Labegorce-Zede
Margaux 05/06/07/08
Ch Labesse
Ch Clos Labory
St-Estephe 5th Cru Classe 03-10
07 $25 WE
06 $26 WS
05 $17 WS
12 $24 JJB
11 $25 JJBFuture
11 NM=91-93
11 JS=90-91
10 45%CS-45%Merlot-6%CF-4%PV 10 RP=87
10 $21-32 RP
10 ST=87
10 JJB=88
09 WE=95
09 $25 K&L
09 ST=88-90
09 $25+ ST
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
08 WS=88
08 ST=87
08 WBlB=86
08 $14-28 WBlB
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=82-84
08 $19-24 RP
07 WE=90
07 RP=83-85
07 $21-26 RP
07 WS=82-85
07 ST=85
06 RP=87
06 $24 RP
06 WS=90
05 $33 WS
05 Smart Buy WS 06
05 WS=89-91
05 $28 Zachys
05 RP=87-88
05 $29-32 RP
05 ST=89
05 WE=93/94
04 WE=92
04 WS=90
04 RP=80
03 WS=90
08 RP=81-83
07 WE=90
07 RP=85-87
07 $21-32 RP
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=88
06 $30 RP
06 WS=85-88
10 WS=89
10 $15 WS
10 65%CS-35%Merlot
10 ST=87
10 JJB=92+
09 ST=86
09 RP=87-88+
08 ST=88
08 RP=84-86
09 $36-52 RP
08 $25-32 RP
109
05 Comm’d IWC 07
Ch Lachesnaye
Haut-Medoc 05/06
Ch Lacombe Noaillac
Medoc 04/05/06/07/10
Lacroix
Bordeaux Sup 05
Lafite
Medoc Res Speciale 09
Paulliac PGC 99-10
06 WS=85
05 WS=87
10 WE=86
09 CF-CS-Merlot
07 WE=84
06 WE=87
06 NM=87
06 WS=83
05 WE=88
05 WS=85
05 Outstanding Value QRW 06
04 WE=87
04 WS=80
03 WS=87
05 WS=80-84
09 70%CS-30%Merlot
09 Sh-L’s best selling red
Paulliac 06
Ch Lafite Rothschild
08 WBlB=87
07 RP=86-88
07 ST=85
07 WS=85-88
06 ST=88
06 WS=86
06 RP=89-91/77
05 WE=89
05 ST=88-90
05 WS=87
04 WS=88
04 RP=89
03 WS=89
03 RP=87
06 WE=88
05 WE=87
05 RP=88-91
04 WE=88
04 RP=89
03 RP=87
10 87.2%CS-12.8%Merlot
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Elegant, very refined, long WW
06 $30 WS
10 $18 WE
07 $17 WE
06 $20 WE
06 $16 LCBO
03 $20 WS
09CellarT=86.7 (7) 09 $19 Sh-L
05 WW=88
06 WW=89
06 $30 B&M
10 ST=95
10 $1195+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19.5/20
09 WE=96
09 ST=96
09 $1450+ ST
09 RP=98-100
09 $1450+ RP
09 JJB=95-97
08 WS=87
08 ST=92
08 RP=98-100
08 $1601+
08 WBlB=96
08 $450 Zachys
07 RP=94
07 $460+ RP
07 WE=94
07 $455 WE
07 ST=90
07 $430 K&L
07 WS=89-92
07 $500 Zachys
07 C$ 899 BCLS
06 WE=96/96
06 $600 B&M
06 RP=97
06 WBlB=96
06 ST=92-95
06 $464+ RP
06 WS=95
06 $590 WS
06 AG=94
06 C$899 AG
05 W&S=98
05 WS=98
05 RP=94-98
110
05“Coup de Coeur Hachette 09
05 ST=97
05 WS=92-94
05 WE=97/99
05 WW=98-100
04 WE=96
04 WS=93
04 RP=92-94
04 ST=93
04 WW=96-98
04/03 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 08/07 03 RP=100
03 WE=97
03 WS=96
03 ST=93+
02 WS=95
02 RP=94
02 ST=92+
01 WS=96
01 RP=94
00 WS=100
00 RP=100
99 Cellar Selection WS
99 WS=95
99 RP=95
See also their second wine: Carruades de Lafite
See also: Pensee de Lafleur
Ch Lafleur
Pomerol 02-10
10 62%CF-38%Merlot
09 53%CF-47%Merlot
07 Wonderful WS
Les Pensees de Lafleur Pomerol 06/07/08/09/10 10 62%Merlot-CF
St-Emilion 08
Ch Lafleur-Gazin
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09/10
09=80%Merlot-20% CF
10 ST=96
10 $1299+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19.5/20
09 ST=95
09 RP=94-97
09 $1338+ RP
09 RP=94-96+
08 ST=92
07 WS=90-93
07 ST=90
07 RP=90
07 $462-899 RP
06 RP=95
06 $799+ RP
06 ST=92-94
06 C$999 BCLS
06 WS=95-100
05 ST=95
05 $1499 K&L
05 WS=100
05 $2000 WS
05 RP=94-96
05 $1895 RP
04 WS=94
04 ST=91
04 RP=94
03 WS=97
03 RP=95
02 ST=89
02 RP=89
02 WS=89
10 ST=87
07 ST=85
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=85-88
05 ST=88-91
05 WS=92-94
04 RP=87
04 $70 RP
04 WS=89-91
03 RP=86-88
03 RP=84
08 $44 Zachys
10 ST=88
09 WE=90
09 ST=88
09 RP=87-89
08 RP=88-89
10 $44+ ST
09 $15+ ST
09 $36-45 RP
111
Ch Lafleur-Petrus
Pomerol 08
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=83-85
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=88
07 W&S=NR
06 RP=86
06 WE=87
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=86
05 W&S=1½stars
05 WS=91
05 ST=86-88
05 RP=85-87
04 WS=88
04 RP=86
08 JJB=91-93
Ch Lafleur Pensee Lafleur
Pomerol 07 (62%Merlot-CF)
07 ST=85
Lafleur Quinault
St-Emilion Kosher 05 (Quinault l’Enclos)
Ch Lafon Menaut
Pessac-Leognan 05
Ch Lafon-Rochet
St-Estephe PGC 03-10
05 Very refined WS
05 RP=89-91
07 $25-35 RP
07 $54 W&S
06 $23-30 RP
05 $51 WS
05 $37 RP
02 $26 RP
05 WS=85
07 60%CS-35%Merlot-CF-PV
06 Good Character WD
05 Good WD
10 ST=90
10 JJB=91
09 WE=89
09 ST=91
09 RP=91-93
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 RP=87-90
08 ST=87
07 RP=87
07 WE=88
07 ST=85
07 WS=84-87
06 WD=16-17/20
06 RP=88
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=85-88
05 WE=90
05 WD=16-17/20
05 WS=90
05 ST=91
05 RP=90-93
04 WS=88
04 ST=87
04 RP=90
10 $45 ST
09 $43+ ST
09 $43-60 RP
08 $28-43 RP
08 $40 Zachys
07 $32-38 RP
07 $35 WE
07 $37 Zachys
07 $43 B&M
06 $66 B&M
06 $30 JJB
06 C$55 BCLS
05 $64 B&M
04 $30 B&M
St-Estephe les Perlerins 08
03 WD=16.5/20
03 RP=90
03 WS=88
08 WS=87
Ch Lafon Tuillerie
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=91
Ch Lafont Fourcat
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=82
05 IWR=88
10 $20 WE
05 $12 IWR
Ch Lafont Menaut
08 WS=86
08 $19 WS
Ch Laforge
St-Emilion GC 03-09 (Merlot-CF)
09 RP=91-94
08 RP=92-94
07 RP=89
07 ST=88
06 WE=91
06 WS=87
06 RP=93
07 $70-75 RP
06 $50 WE
112
Ch de Lagarde
Ch Lagarosse
Bordeaux Le de Garde 07/09 (org grapes)
Bordeaux Sup Grand Millesime Vieilli 06
07 Best Buy BTI
06 Bronze Paris 09
Prem-Cotes-de-Bordeaux Les Comtes 04/05/06 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09
Ch Lagnet
Bordeaux Sup Les Secrets 10
10 Gold LA 12
Ch Lagrange
Graves 05
05 Cuted Wine Hachette 09
Ch Lagrange
Pomerol 04/06
Ch Lagrange
St Julien 3rd Cru 03-10
10 75%CS-25%Merlot
09 73%CS-27%Merlot
06 Top Pick K&L
06 Good WD
06 ST=87-90
05 WS=86
05 WE=89/91
05 ST=90
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=87
04 WE=90
04 ST=88
03 RP=90
09 WE=85
07 BTI=85/82
06 WE=87
06 WS=85
06 WE=87
06 WS=86
05 WE=87/89
05 WS=85-88
04/03 WS=86
05 $62 WS
09 $13 WE
07 $15 BTI
06 $15 WE
06 $28 WE
10 LA=92
10 ST=88
09 WE=94
09 ST=89
09 RP=90-93
08 WE=91
08 RP=90-92
08 ST=89
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=90
07 WE=90
07 ST=90
07 WS=84-87
09 $57+ ST
09 $50 81 RP
08 $35-52 RP
08 $42 Zachys
08 $35 K&L
08 $46 ST
07 $34-48 RP
07 $45 WE
07 $44 Zachys
07 $56 B&M
07 C$75 BCLS
06 $70 B&M
06 C$75 BCLS
06 WE=93/92
06 WS=90
06 WD=14.5-15.5
06 RP=91
06 $29-70 RP
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=93
05 WE=94
05 $80 B&M
05 W&S=94
05 $55 K&L
05 ST=91-92
05 RP=91
05 WS=92-94
05 WW=91-93
05 WW=92-94
04 WS=89
04 $32 B&M
04 RP=89
04 WW=90-92
04 WE=92
04 ST=87
03 One to avoid WD 10/05
03 ST=89
03 RP=91
03 WD=13/20
02 Excell F&W 06
02 #35 top 100 WS 05
113
Prem-Cotes-de-Bordeaux 05
02 Smart Buy WS
09 CF-CS-Merlot
99 RP=88-90
See their second wine: Les Fifes de Lagrange
Ch Lagrange les Tours
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Ch Lagrave-Aubet
Ch Lague
Fronsac 05/06/09
Ch la Lagune
Haut Medoc 03-10
09/08 Bronze LA 12/10
10 WS=89
05 WS=80-84
04 WS=85
09 $11 JJB
08 Great Value WBlB
08 Classic Bordeaux JJB
Ch Lajarre
Moulin de la Lagune 03
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 Gold LA 12
Bordeaux Sup Elenore 10
Dom Lalande
Bordeaux 10
Ch Lalande
St-Julien Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05/09/09
Listrac-Medoc 04/05
Ch Lalande-Borie
10 $22 WS
06 WS=85
05 WS=83
10 ST=88
10 JJB=91
09 ST=89
09 RP=94-96
08 WBlB=92
08 RP=92-94
08 ST=90
08 JJB=91-93
07 AG=87
07 RP=90
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=88
06 RP=91
06 ST=90-91
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=91
05 ST=92
05 WE=93
05 RP=92-94
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=87
04 ST=87-89
04 RP=90
03 WS=87
03 RP=90
10/ 09 50%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF
09 $55+ ST
09 $53-82 RP
08 $40 WBlB
08 $40-45 RP
08 $46 Zachys
08 $45 K&L
07 C$79 AG
07 $37-49 RP
07 $50 Zachys
07 C$79 BCLS
06 $32-65 RP
06 $45 K&L
06 $79 BCLS
05 $50 WS
05 $55 Zachys
05 $40-55 RP
10 LA=92
10 WE=85
10 $13 WE
10 RP=87
10 $23 RP
05/04/03 Cited Wine Hachette
St-Julien 03-11
10 $65+ ST
05 €15-23 Hach
05 €5-8 Hach
11 WE=92-94
10 RP=87
10 ST=86
09 WE=92
09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90
08 WS=89
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=86
07 RP=83-85
07 WE=89
11 $23 JJBFuture
10 $21-34 RP
09 $25 K&L
09 $25+ ST
09 $22-40 RP
09 $27.50 Sh-L
08 $25 WS
08 $16-25 RP
07 $21 WS
07 $17-26 RP
07 $21 Zachys
114
07 $22 Sh-L
Ch Lalande Moulins(Y Mau) St Julien 05
Ch Lalaudey
Ch de Lamarque
Moulis-en-Medoc 05/06/07
03 Cited Hachette 07
05 Delightful WC
Ch de Lamouroux
Graves 05
Ch Lamothe
Cotes de Bourg Grand Res 04/05/06/07/08
Ch Lamothe-Bergeron
Haut-Medoc 09/10
06 $23-30 RP
06 $23 WS
05 $23 WS
05 $20-23 RP
05 C$30 WC
06 WS=86
05 WS=85
10 RP=87
10 $22 RP
09 RP=86-88
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter-3star
08 RP=85-86
06 RP=85
06 $25 RP
06 WS=85
05 WE=91
05 WS=87
05 $32 WS
04 WE=86
03 WS=85
05 WS=85
08 Gold Paris 09
09 50%Merlot-CS
Ch Lamothe-Cissac
Haut-Medoc 09/10
Ch Lamothe de Haux
Bordeaux 08
08 Very Successful Hachatte 11
Ch Lamothe-Vincent
06 WE=88
06 RP=87
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=87
05 WS=85
05 RP=85-87
05 WE=90
04 WS=85
03 WS=87
05 WC=4½stars
05 NM=90
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Valentine 05/08 08 Bronze Decanter 10
Bordeaux Cuvee Selection 04-10
10 Best Buy WE
10 Gold Paris 11
09 Gold Bordeaux 10
06 Gold Bordeaux 07
05 Gold Bordeaux 06
05 Bronze Paris 06
04 Paris, Bordeaux 05
04=Merlot-CS
Bordeaux Merlot-Cab Sauv 06/08/10
10 Gold Paris 11
Bordeaux Merlot 11
10 WS=90
10 $24 WS
10 RP=87
10 $18 K&L
10 WE=91
10 JR=15.5 (86)
10 Decanter=16 (88)
09 ST=87
09 $17 K&L
09 WS=88-91
10 WS=87
10 $25 WS
10 WE=87
08 $30 Dec
05 $10 Dec
05 €8-11 Hach
10 $12 WE
08 WS=88
08 $20 WS
10 JR=16 (88)
11 JR=16 (88)
115
Bordeaux Intense 05-10 (CS-Merlot)
Ch Lanbersac
10 Gold Paris 11
06 WE=88
05 WE=89
10 JR=16 (88)
06 WE=85
05 Gold Challenge 07, Bordeaux 06
Bordeaux Sup Heritage 05/06/08/09/10
10 WE=88
09 Silver Paris 11
06 WE=89
06 WS=87
05 Gold Bordeaux 07, Challenge 07 05 WE=86
05/04 Vin remarquable Hachette 08/07
04 Gold Challenge, Bordeaux, London 06
03 Gold Bordeaux 05
Puisseguin-St-Emilion 09/10
10 WS=89
10 WE=86
Prisseguin-St-Emilion Cuvee Vieilles Vignes 10
10 WE=90
Ch Landat
Haut-Medoc 10
10 WS=86
Ch Landereau
Bordeaux Sup Prestige 09
Ch Landonnet
Bordeaux Sup 08
08 Silver LA 10
Ch Lanessan
10 RP=87
09 Gold LA 12
08 RP=88-90
06 RP=88
06 WS=84
05 WS=86
05 RP=90-92
Ch Langlet
Graves 08/09/10
06 $13 WE
10 $15 WE
08 $15 Dec
06 $16 WE
05 $10 WE
10 $20 WS
10 $30 WE
10 $20 WS
09 LA=93
09 RP=90-92
06 $13 WE
05 $10 WE
04 RP=87
03 WS=84
10 WS=89
10 $14-30 RP
10 $25 Zachys
09 $14-23 RP
09 $18 K&L
08 $12-18 RP
06 $14-18 RP
06 $17 WS
06 $18 Sh-L
05 $20 WS
05 $20 Zachys
05 $18-24 RP
05 $25 TW&M
10 $18 WS
08 WS=88
Ch Langoa-Barton
St-Julien 3rd Cru 03-10
06 Bronze Paris 09
05 WS=82
10 ST=88
09 WE=95
09 ST=87
09 RP=90-92+
08 WS=91
08 ST=89
08 RP=88-90+
08 WE=96
07 Good price:qual ratio QRW Aut 08 07 RP=87
07 WE=91
07 ST=87
07 WS=92
06 Good WD
09 $61-75 RP
08 $33 K&L
08 $39 Zachys
08 $35-44 RP
08 $70 K&L
07 $38-65 RP
07 $55 WE
07 $45 K&L
07 $75 Zachys
07 $70 B&M
06 WE=91
06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 $90 B&M
116
06 Top Pick K&L
Ch Laniote
St-Emilion05/06/ 08
Dom Lapalu
Medoc Famille Lapadu 07/10
Medoc la Patache 07/10
06 RP=89+
06 ST=89-90
06 WS=91
05 Almost 95-100. Great value WW 05 WS=92
05 Favorite vintage Langoa RW 3/06 05 ST=90
05 Super potential WD 4/06
05 RW=18-19/20
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WD=18-19
05 NM=90
05 WE=89/92
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=91
04 WE=90
04 ST=88
04 RP=90
03 Good claret, well done WD 10/05 03 ST=89
03 RP=90
03 WD=16+/20
08 WS=90
08 RP=75-78
10 WE=85
07 WE=84
10 WE=85
07 WE=85
Ch Lapelletrie
St-Emilion GC 09
Clos Larcis
St-Emilion 05
09 CF-Merlot
04 Silver IWC 07
03 Comm’d decanter 06
02 WS=85
05 WS=87
Ch Larcis-Ducasse
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 85%Merlot-15%CF
06 Good WD
05 Great wine SS in Decanter 06
04=M89%-CF15%
Ch Larmande
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
10 ST=90
10 JJB=93
09 ST=91
09 RP=91-94
09 JJB=96-98
08 RP=95-97
08 JJB=93-95
08 WS=90-93
07 RP=92
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=89
05 $140 B&M
05 C$129 NM
04 $50 K&L
10 $12 WE
07 $12 WE
10 $12 WE
07 $12 WE
10 $85+ ST
09 $50-80 RP
08 $70-97 RP
08 $125 Zachys
08 $75 K&L
07 $36-70 RP
07 $46 K&L
07 $55 Zachys
07 C$88 BCLS
06 WD=14-15/20 06 C$85 BCLS
06 RP=91
06 $33-78 RP
06 AG=90
06 C$85 AG
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=90
06 $52 WS
05 SS=18/20
05 WD=15.5-16.5
05 ST=94
05 WS=95
05 $210 WS
05 RP=96-100
05 $150-316 RP
04 WS=91
04 RP=92
03 WS=89-91
03 RP=90
02 WS=92
01 RP=90
09 RP=86-88
08 WS=87
07 WS=86
07 $28 WS
07 RP=83-85
07 ST=84
07 $28 K&L
117
Ch Laroche Beaulieu Aster Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 09
Ch Laron-Rochet
St-Estephe 04/05/06
Ch Laroque
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09 (Merlot)
Ch Larose-Perganson
Ch Larose-Trintaudon
Ch Laroze
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch Larrivaux
Ch Larrivet-Haut-Brion
Pessac-Leognan 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
06 RP=75
06 WS=88
05 Full-bodied, long, caressing WW 05 WS=92
05 WE=89/89
05 ST=87-88
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=88
04 WE=86
03 WS=86
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=91-94
06 WS=85-88
05 Good RW 3/06
05 RW=16-17/20
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=88
09 RP=87-88
08 Gold Paris 09
08 WS=87
08 RP=80-83
07 Comm’d IWC 10
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
05 WE=91/91
04 WS=88
03 WS=85-88
10 RP=88
09 CS-Merlot
08 Gold Paris 11; Bordeaux 10
04 WS=87
03/02 Gold Brussels 06
03 WS=86
03 Gold Brussels 07
10 WS=87
10 RP=89
09 Dec 16.75 (91)
09 CS-Merlot
09 JR=15.5 986)
07 WE=87
06 WS=84
06 NM=88
05 Silver IWC 07
05 WS=84
05 NM=89
03 Gold Brussels 06
03 WS=85
01 RP=85-86
01 WW=86
00 WR=88
Merlot
10 ST=87
09 RP=86-88
08 WS=90
07 Silver IWC 10
07 WS=83-86
06 Gold Brussels 09
06 WS=87
06 Comm’d IWC 10
05 WE=88
05 WS=90
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=89
10 WS=88
10 RP=86
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=86
CS
10 ST=90
09 WE=91
06 $35 RP
05 $30 WS
09 $18 JJB
04 $27 WS
05 $90 WS
10 $19-25 RP
10 $20 WS
10 $13-17 RP
09 $22 WClub
07 $20 WE
06 $23 WS
09 $37 RP
05 $28 RP
10 $16 WS
10 $11-16 RP
09 $14-16 RP
05 $17 K&L
118
09 RP=91-93
08 ST=87
08 RP=90-92
08 WS=87-90
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=88
07 ST=87
04 Very Siuccessful Hachette 08
04 Bronze IWC 09
Ch Larroque
Bordeaux Eleve en fut de Chene 05/07/10
06 WS=87
05 WE=93
05 RP=89-91
05 WS=88
04 WS=90
04 RP=84-86
04 ST=86-88
03 WS=88
03 RP=86
02 WS=86
02 RP=87-88
01 WS=88
01 RP=90
10 WE=88
09 $29-42 RP
08 $28-44 RP
08 $28 K&L
07 $22-27 RP
07 $40 K&L
07 $27 Zachys
06 $30 WS
05 $37 WS
10 $15 WE
07/ 06 Very Successful Hachette 10/09
07 Gold Bordeaux 09
Ch Lartau
Bordeaux 09
Bordeaux Sup Grand Vin 08/09
Ch Lascombes
05 WE=86
05 NM=89
09 RP=86-87
Margaux 2nd Cru Classe 03-10
09 Gold LA 12
08 Bronze LA 11
05 Great aroma, great intensity WW
05 $15 WE
05 C$18 NM
09 LA=92
10 ST=88
10 JJB=94
09 WE=93
09 ST=90
09 RP=94-96+
09 WS=92-95
09 JJB=96-98
08 WS=87
08 RP=91-94
08 WE=92-94
08 JJB=89-90
07 RP=91
07 WE=90
07 WS=88
07 AG=90
07 W&S=88
07 ST=89
06 WE=90
06 RP=90
06 ST=90-91
06 WS=90
05 RP=94-96
05 ST=89-92
05 WS=93
05 WE=92/91
05 W&S=94
04 WS=88
04 WE=88
04 ST=91
04 RP=93
03 WE=90
03 WS=91
03 ST=91
03 RP=92
03 WD=17/20
02 RP=93
09 $90 K&L
09 $32-112 RP
08 $50 K&L
08 $50-84 RP
08 $60 Zachys
07 $63-80 RP
07 C$109 AG
07 $100 W&S
06 $46-90 RP
06 C$115 BCLS
06 $79 WS
05 $69-112 RP
05 $85 Zachys
05 $85 WS
05 $119 B&M
05 $100 W&S
03 $65 WClub
119
02 WS=87
01 WS=90
01 RP=92
00 WS=89
See also: Chevalier de Lascombe
Ch Lassegue
St-Emilion 03-09 (09=60%M-20%CF-20%CS)
09 WE=88
09 ST=88
09 RP=90-92
07 ST=89
06 RP=89-91
06 ST=89-91
05 ST=89+
05 RP=90-92
04 WE=92
04 ST=88
04 RP=90-91
03 RP=87-89
Ch Lathibaude
Bordeaux Sup 09
09 Bronze LA 11
Ch Latour
Paulliac PGC 02-10
10 90.5%CS-8.5%Merlot-0.5%CF & PV10 ST=96
10 $1199+ ST
09 91%CS-5%Merlot
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19.5/20
09 WE=97
09 ST=97
09 $1299+ ST
09 RP=98-100
09 $1380+ RP
09 JJB=96-98
08 ST=92
08 RP=96-98
08 $1250+ RP
07 RP=92+
07 $420-799 RP
07 WE=95
07 $500 WE
07 ST=92
07 $550 Zachys
07 WS=89-92
07 $430 K&L
07 $556 B&M
07 C$649 BCLS
06 WE=96
06 Top Pick K&L
06 RP=93-96
06 $700 B&M
06 ST=93-95
06 C$949 BCLS
04=89% CS-10%M-1% PV
04 Top 10 WW 06
03 Vin Exceptionnel Havhette 07
02 #20 Top 100 WS 05
90/96/99 Cellar Selection WS
Pauillac de Ch Latour 10
10 55%CS-44.5%Merlot-0.5%CF
06 WS=95
05 RP=96-99
05 WS=99
05 W&S=100
05 ST=98
05 WW=99-100
05 WE=99/100
04 WS=95
04 RP=94-96
04 WE=97
04 ST=94
04 WW=96-98
03 WS=98
03 ST=97
02 RP=96
02 ST=94+
02 WS=96
01 RP=95
01 WS=95
01 ST=92+
00 RP=98
00 WS=100
00 ST=97
99 WS=93
99 RP=94
99 ST=93
98 ST=91+
10 ST=86
05 $800+
05 $1110 WS
05 $2000 WE
120
See their second wine: Les Forts de Latour
Ch Latour Martillac
Ch Latour a Pomerol
Pessac-Leognan 02/03/04/05/06/07/08/09
Pomerol 03-10
Ch des Lattes
Medoc 10
Ch Laubet
Bordeaux 07
Ch Lauduc
Bordeaux Sup Tradition VV 09
10 JJB=92
09 WE=89
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=90
08 RP=87-88
08 JJB=86-88
07 RP=87
07 WE=89
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=86
06 WE=87
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
05 ST=88
05 WS=89
05 WE=92
04 WE=89
04 WS=88
02 WS=86
10 ST=91
09 Merlot-CF
09 WE=93
09 ST=91
09 RP=92-94
08 ST=88
08 JJB=91-93
08 RP=90-92+
08 SY=88-91
08 WE=89-91
07 RP=88
07 WS=90
07 ST=86
06 WE=92
06 RP=89
06 WS=90
06 ST=87-90
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 RP=90
05 ST=91
05 WE=91/90
05 WS=93
04 WE=91
04 RP=87-88
04 WS=90
04 ST=88
03 RP=86
03 WS=93
03 ST=88
02 RP=85
02 WS=89
02 ST=87
01 RP=88
01 WS=91
01 ST=89
01 TA=5stars
00 RP=91
00 WS=95
00 ST=90+
99 RP=89
99 WS=86
03 WS=78
10 WE=91
10 WS=86
09 $28-47 RP
08 $29 WS
08 $20-31 RP
07 $21-48 RP
06 $44 RP
05 $30 Zachys
05 $31 WS
09 $100+ ST
09 $100-130 RP
08 $50 K&L
08 $50-83 RP
07 $43-75 RP
07 $50 K&L
07 C$69 BCLS
06 $61-192 RP
05 $54-102 RP
05 $85 K&L
05 $102 WClub
05 $89 WS
04 $43-79 RP
04 $45 WS
10 $20 WE
07 $16 Andys
09 Bronze LA 11
121
05 Silver Paris 07
04 Silver IWC 07
04 All for only $10 WR
Bordeaux Classic 10
04 WS=81
03 WR=88
10 WE=85
04 $13 WS
10 $16 WE
Bordeaux Superieur Prestige 09
09 WE=90
09 WS=88
09 UWS=89
09 $15 Zachys
09 $17 WS
10 $20 RP
Ch Laulan Ducos
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=87
L-Aura de Cambon
Bordeaux 07
07 RP=87-88
Ch Lauretan
10 WS=84
10 $20 WS
Ch des Laurets
Puisseguin-St-Emilion 07/08/09/10
10 WS=90
09 ST=87
08 WS=88
07 NM=88
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=89
05 WS=84
10 $23 WS
08 Merlot-CS
Ch de Laussac
Castillin Cotes de Bordeaux 08/09
Ch la Lauzette-Declercq
Haut-Medoc 05
Ch Laville
Bordeaux Sup Eximus 09/10
Bordeaux Sup L’Insolent de Laville 09/10
10 Gold LA 12
09 Silver LA 11
10 Bronze LA 12
09 Gold LA 11
06 Gold LA 10
08 $25 WS
07 C$19.30 NM
08 $30 WS
10 LA=92
09 LA=92-
Ch Laville Haut Brion
Pessac-Leognan 05
05 WS=95
05 $355 WS
Ch Leboscq
Medoc 04-10
10 RP=88
10 WE=88
10 $20 RP
10 $19 WE
07 WE=86
06 WE=87
06 WS=84
05 WS=88
05 WE=86
03 WS=86
04 WS=84
07 $15 WE
06 $19 WE
05 $46 WS
09 Gold Paris 11
Medoc Vieilles Vignes 03/05
05 Comm’d IWC 07
05 $25 WS
04 $15 WS
Ch Lecuyer
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09/10
Leo de la Gaffeliere
Le Medoc No. 3 – 05
05 WS=86
05 WS=85
St-Emilion le Saint-Emilion no. 4 – 05
05 WS=87
Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 10
10 WS=88
10 $17 WS
10 WS=86
10 $12 WS
Ch Leone
Graves 05
05 WS=85
Ch Leoville-Barton
Ch Leon
08 Great Value WBlB
10 ST=93
10 JJB=96
10 $115+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 WE=97
09 $100 K&L
09 ST=91
09 WS=92-95
09 RP=93-95+
09 $87-150 RP
08 WBlB=92
08 $47 WBlB
122
08 WE=96
08 ST=90
08 RP=92-94
08 WS=90-93
08 JJB=92-94
07 WE=94
07 Good price/qual ratio QRW Aut 08 07 RP=89+
07 ST=90
07 WS=92
08 $51-92 RP
08 $54 Zachys
07 $65 WE
07 $46-75 RP
07 $60 K&L
07 $90 Zachys
07 $82 B&M
07 C$104 BCLS
Ch Leoville-las-Cases
06 WD=16-17/20
06 RP=91+
06 ST=91-93
06 Highly Rec’s WS
06 WS=94
05 W&S=2-2½star
05 Great future WD 4/06
05 WD=17-18/20
05 Fantastic aromas, big, velvety WW 05 WS=96
05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 ST=94
05 WE=96/97
05 WW=91
05 WD=17-18+/20
04 WS=91
04 WE=94
04 ST=91
04 RP=92-94
03 WE=95
03 ST=92-93
03 Good Substance and potential WD 03 WD=17+/20
02 ST=90-93
01 TA=4stars
00 WS=97
00 RP=96
00 WE=96
10 ST=94
09 76%CS-15%Merlot–9%CF
09 Onr of Top 15 Decanter
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 WE=97
09 ST=94
09 RP=96-100
09 One of 32 Top JJB
09 JJB=98-100
08 RP=95-97+
08 WE=94-96
08 WS=91-94
08 ST=92
07 RP=91+
07 WE=94
07 ST=92
07 AG=91
07 WS=89-92
08 $70 K&L
06 Cellear Selection WE
04 Top 10 WW 06
06 WE=95/95
06 RP=95
06 ST=92-94
06 WS=95
05 WS=100
05 WE=96
05 W&S=98
05 RP=98
05 ST=95+?
05 WW=94-96
04 WS=95
04 WE=95
04 ST=90+
04 WW=94-97
05 $80 B&M
00 $170 WClub
10 $280+ ST
09 $350+ ST
09 $300-420 RP
08 $135-263 RP
08 $225 Zachys
08 $130 K&L
07 $122-195 RP
07 $160 WE
07 $150 K&L
07 C$249 AG
07 $160 Zachys
07 $190 B&M
07 C$249 BCLS
06 $240 B&M
06 C$339 BCLS
05 $342 B&M
05$340 K&L
123
99 Cellar Selewction WS
03 ST=93+
03 WS=97
02 ST=93+
02 WS=94
01 ST=93
01 RP=93
99 WS=94
04 $200 B&M
10 61%CS-30%Merlot-6%PV-3%CF
09 60%CS-20%M-6%PV-CF
10 ST=90
09 WE=94
09 ST=92
09 RP=97-100
08 WBlB=92
08 ST=89
08 RP=92-94
08 WS=90-93
08 ST=89-92
08 JJB=91-93
07 WE=93
07 RP=89
07 ST=90
07 WS=86-89
07 RC=92
10 $135+ ST
See their second wine: Clos du Marquis
Ch Leoville-Poyferre
08 Great Value WBlB
05 Alluring flavors, lusty end WW
03 Very good indeed WD 10/05
05 Coup dr Coeur Hachette
09 $108-224 RP
08 $44 WBlB
08 $55 ST
08 $55-111 RP
08 $50 Zachys
08 $48 K&L
07 $60 WE
07 $43-170 RP
07 $65 K&L
07 $75 B&M
07 $60 Zachys
07 C$89 BCLS
06 WE=93/94/93 06 $80 B&M
06 WD=16-17/20 06 C$109 BCLS
06 RP=91
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=90
05 W&S=95
05 ST=93
05 WS=92
05 WW=92-95
05 WE=93/94
04 WS=90
04 WE=93
04 ST=90
03 WE=93
03 ST=91-93
03 WD=17+/20
02 Hachette=3 stars
02 ST=90
02 RP=90
02 WS=89-91
02 WW=91
02 JR=15.5 (86)
02 JMQ=93
02 Decanter=17.5 (93)
02 CellarT=91 (107)
01 TA=4stars
See their second wine: Moulin Riche
Ch Lescalle
Bordeaux Sup 10
Ch Lesparre
Bordeaux Sup 09
Ch Lespault-Martillac
Bordeaux 10
Ch Lestage
Listrac-Medoc 05/06/08/09/10
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
09 Silver LA 11
08 Merlot
07 Bronze IWC 10
06 Comm’d IWC 09
Ch Lestage-Simon
Haut-Medoc 05/06/08/09/10
10 WS=88
10 $17 WS
10 RP=89-91
10 $22-37 RP
10 RP=87
08 WE=87
10 $18 RP
06 WE=87
06 WS=83
05 WE=88
10 RP=86
10 $20 RP
124
Ch Lestruelle
Medoc 08/09//10
09 Comm’d Decater 11
08 WE=88
06 WS=82
05 WS=88
10 WE=87
09 WS=90
09 UWS=90
08 WS=87
10 $25 WE
09 $15 K&L
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
10 Best Buy WE
10 WE=87
10 Silver LA; Comm’d Decanter, IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
06 WS=85
05 WS=75
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
05 Cited
10 WE=90
07 WE=88
06 WE=86
06 WS=83
05 WS=84
05 Gold Brussels 07
05 WE=87
04 WE=86
01 WS=74
12 WS=86-89
12 WE=91
11 WS 89-92
10 RP=88
10 WS=89
10 JS=90-91
10 WE=94
09 Outperformed Price
09 JJB=92-94
09 WE=93
09 RP=84-86
09 WS 92-95
08 WS=89
08 WE=90
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=82-84
07 WS=88
06 WS=90
05 Silver Paris 0705 WS=85-88
05 WS=91
04 WE=89
04/03 WS=90
03 WE=88
02 WS=87
10 RP=87
08 WS=88
08 RP=82-84
06 RP=87
06 WS=86
08 Bronze LA 12
08 Bronze LA 12
Ch L’Isle Fort
Bordeaux Sup 09
09 Gold LA 12
09 LA=92
Ch de Listrac
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 03/04
03 WS=82
03 $17 WS
Ch Listran
Medoc Cuvee Prestige Cru Bourgeois 05 (CS+)
05 NM=88
05 C$25 NM
Ch Livenne
Blaye 06
06 WS=84
Ch Liversan
10 RP=86
Ch Leydet-Valentin
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Lezin (Dourthe)
Bordeaux Sup 10
Liber Pater
Graves Denarius 05/06
Ch Lieujean
Haut-Medoc Cuvee Prestige 08
Haut-Medoc 06/07/10
Ch Lilian Ladouys
Ch Lion Beaulieu
Ch de Lisennes
Bordeaux 06/08/10
10 $12 WE
06 $25 wine.com
10 $20 WE
07 $17 WE
06 $24 WE
10 $16-32 RP
10 $32 WS
10 $27 Zachys
10 $11/375 JJB
09 $19 JJB
09 $20 K&L
09 $18-24 RP
00 C$58 BCLS
10 $16 RP
06 $20 RP
10 $24 RP
125
Haut-Medoc Cuvee Sophie 05/06
04 Comm’d IWC 07
Ch Livran
Bordeaux 10
Ch la Longua
Fronsac 07/08
Haut-Medoc 04
Ch Loudenne
Clos Louie
Ch Louis
Ch Lousteauneuf
Cotes de Castillon Vieilles Vignes 04-08
St-Emilion 06/07/09
04 Silver IWSC 07
04 Bronze Decanter 07, Bordeaux 07
Medoc 05/06/09/10
Ch la Louviere
10 WE=91
09 WS=89-91
09 RC=88
09 CostcoBlog=89
07 WE=89
06 WE=89
06 WS=85
05 WS=85
05 W&S=90
05 WE=90
05 SS=15.5/20
04 WE=89
03 WS=88
10 $20 WE
09 $12 Costco
06 WE=90
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
10 RP=88
06 $40 WE
10 $20 RP
07 WE=87
07 $19 WE
10 WS=88
10 RP=85
10 WE=88
10 $24 WS
10 $16 RP
07 WS=80-83
06 WS=84
05 WS=90
04 WS=83
03 WS=85
02 WS=85-88
07 RP=87-89
07 ST=85
06 ST=86-88
05 ST=89-91
05 RP=89-91
04 RP=88
09 JJB=92-94
09 ST=87
07 RP=89+
07 ST=89
06 RP=90
06 WBlB=87
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=80-84
10 RP=89
10 WE=87
09 WS=89-91
06 WS=82
05 WS=85
10 RP=85-87
10 ST=88
10 JJB=92
09 WE=90
09 ST=88
08 RP=84-86
07 RP=87
07 WS=86
06 RP=87
06 ST=85-87
06 WS=86
05 WE=90/89
07 $18 WE
06 $20 WE
03 $20 WS
05 $22 K&L
03 $26 WS
06 $31-32 RP
04 $49 RP
09 $50+ ST
07 $55 RP
10 $11-15 RP
10 $16 WE
09 $13 JJB
06 $14 WS
05 $24 WS
10 $23-24 RP
07 $35-42 RP
06 $62 RP
06 $57 WS
126
Ch Du Lort
Bordeaux 06
Ch Luchey-Halde
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
05 WS=90
05 ST=87-89
04 WS=88
03 Merely good WD 10/05
03 WD=15/20
06 Silver BinCl IWSC 08
06 WE=82
06 Silver Decanter 08; Bordeaux 07
06 UWS=84
09 RP=87-88
08 RP=85-86
07 RP=87-89
06 ST=87-89
05 RP=88-90
04 RP=84-86
03 RP=89
05 $44 WS
04 $40 WS
06 $20 WFoods
05 $27 JJB
See their second wine: Les Haldes de Luchey
Ch Lucia
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
Ch de Lugagnac
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Bordeaux Sup EOS de Bordeaux 08/09
Clos les Lunelles
Cotes Castillon 05-09
09 Silver Decanter, LA 12
08 Silver LA 10
09 Bronze LA 12
08 Silver LA 11
10/09=80%M-10%CF-10%CS
Ch de Lussac (Yvon Mau)
Lussac-St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09
04 Bronze IWC 07
01 Gold IWC 06
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=88
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=90-92
07 ST=90
06 RP=85
06 ST=87-90
09 $39-47 RP
07 $44 RP
07 $46 Zachys
07 C$64 BCLS
06 $36-62 RP
06$43 K&L
06 $33 JJB
05 $58 WS
05 $60 Zachys
05 WS=87
05 ST=90+?
04 ST-90
09 WE=84
09 $15 Wine-s
09 Gilbert&Gaillard=86
10 RP=91
10 ST=87
09 ST=88
09 RP=92-94
09 WS=87-90
09 RP=92-94
09 ST=88-91
08 ST=87
08 JJB=89-91
08 RP=90-93+
07 RP=90
07 ST=88
07 RP=90-92
07 ST=87-89
06 ST=89-90
06 RP=91
06 ST=87-90
05 ST=89-90
05 RP=91-94
05 ST=91
04 RP=92
04 ST=88
03 WS=85-88
10 $24-41 RP
07 ST=85-87
06 WS=87
06 ST=87-89
05 ST=89
05 WS=85-88
07 $20 Dec
09 S30 K&L
09 $27-35 RP
09 $30 K&L
04 WS=87
03 WS=89
127
Ch Lusseau
St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/09/10
01 Comm’d IWC 07
10 75%Merlot-25%CF
Ch Lynch-Bages
Ch Lynch-Moussas
10 RP=85
10 TWCI=89-91
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=90-92
07 WS=87
07 ST=85
06 RP=90
06/05 ST=88-90
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=88/92-94
05 RP=89-91
04 ST=87
04 WS=85-88
10 $21-28 RP
09 $28 RP
07 $22 WS
07 $25 Zachys
05 $31 JJB
Graves 04/06
Paulliac GC 00-10
10 79%CS-18%Merlot-2%CF-1%PV 10 ST=90
10 $155+ ST
10 JJB=94
09 76%CS-M-CF-PV
09 WE=96
09 $170 B&M
09 ST=90
09 $120+ ST
09 RP=94-96+
09 $103-252 RP
09 WS=96-99
09 JJB=94-96
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 WE=94
08 RP=91-93+
08 $55-154 RP
08 ST=89
08 $125 Zachys
08 WS=89-92
08 $100 K&L
08 Decanter=4star
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=89
07 $57-122 RP
07 WE=93
07 $75 WE
07 ST=88
07 $70 K&L
07 WS=85-88
07 $65 Zachys
07 $94 B&M
07 C$89 BCLS
06 WE=94/94
06 C$115 BCLS
06 Top Pick K&L
06 RP=92
06 ST=89-91
06 $115 B&M
06 WS=92
05 WS=93
05 $101 B&M
05 WE=96
05 W&S=96
05 #3 Top 100 Wines WE 08
05 ST=91+?
05 Oustanding for price QWR
05 WW=91-92
05 $101 B&M
04 ST=89
04 WW=90-92
04 WS=89
04 WE=94
03 Silver IWC 07
03 ST=90
03 WE=94
03 RP=88-89
03 WS=92
03 WW=91-94
03 Good mid-term drinking WD 10/05 03 WD=16+/20
02 Excell F&W 06
02 ST=89+
02 WS=91
01 ST=90
01 $60 B&M
01 WS=90
10 JJB=91
09 WE=95
09 RP=88-90
09 $32-45 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
08 RP=88-89
08 $13-33 RP
08 JJB=85-87
Paulliac GC Classe 03-10
128
08 JJB=84-86
07 RP=87
07 WE=88
07 WS=80-83
06 WE=86
06 RP=89
06 WS=88
06/05 ST=87-89
05 WS=86/89-91
05 WE=90/89
04 WS=88
07 $23-38 RP
07 $35 WE
07 $35 B&M
06 $25-39 RP
06 $30 WS
05 $37 Zachys
05 $38 WS
05 $54 B&M
Lynsolence
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09/10
09 100%Merlot
Ch Lyonnat
Lussac-St-Emilion Emotion 08
09 Comm’d IWC 12
10 ST=86
09 ST=87
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=91
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=85-87?
06 RP=90+
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=92-94
05 WS=90
04 RP=90
03 WS=90
03 WS=90
08 WS=86
10 ST=87
09 WS=92-95
08 ST=85
06 WS=84
09 $29-37 RP
06 $34-80 RP
05 $70 Zachys
05 $65 K&L
05 $65 WS
08 $25 WS
09 $21 JJB
06 $26 WS
Ch de Macard
Clos de la Madeleine
St-Emilion 03-10
09 75%Merlot-25%CS
10 WS=88
09 WS=90
08 WS=72
10/09 ST=87
07 WS=89
07 RP=90-92
Ch Magdelaine
St-Emilion PGC 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
06 RP=87
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=80-84
10 ST=88
09 ST=91
09 RP=92-94+
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
09 JR=16+/20
08 ST=90
08 RP=92-94
08 JJB=86-88
08 JJB=84-86
07 RP=87
07 WS=87
07 WE=89
07 W&S=85
07 ST=88
06 WE=91
06 RP=90+
06 ST=90
06 WS=87
05 WS=92
05 WE=92/93
04 WE=92
10/09/08 $15 WS
08 $30 K&L
07 $30 WS
07 $21-29 RP
07 $29 K&L
07 $21 Zachys
06 $30 RP
09 $50+ ST
09 $72-89 RP
08 $64-80 RP
08 $65 Zachys
07 $45-64 RP
07 $28 WE
07 $99 W&S
07 C$79 BCLS
06 $56-74 RP
06 $65 WS
05 $79 WS
129
Ch Magnan-Figeac
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Magnol (B&G)
04 WS=91
04 ST=88
06 WS=88
05 WS=88
10 WS=83
10 WE=85
06 $27 WS
10 $25 WS
06 Bronze IWSC 09
Ch Magrez Fombrauge
St-Emilion GC 04-10
07 80%Merlot-20%CF
Ch Magrez Tivoli
Medoc Cuvee d’Exception 04/05/06/07/09
10/07 50%Merlot-50%CS
05 Siulver Brussels 10
04 Silver IWSC 07
Mahler-Besse
Bordeaux Sup Ch Bire 07/08
07 WE=87
06 WE=89
05 WS=81
10 ST=88
10 TWCI=95-96
09 RP=92-95+
08 RP=92-94+
07 RP=90
07 ST=87
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=92
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=90
05 ST=91
05 WE=90
05 WS=93
05 RP=93-95
04 ST=90
04 WS=89
04 RP=91
03 WS=92
03 RP=94
02 RP=90
02 WS=91
10 ST=91
09 RP=91-93
07 ST=87
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=85-88
05 ST=90
05 RP=90-93
04 RP=90
08 WE=84
07 WE=85
06 $25 WE
05 $18 WS
09 $113-167 RP
08 $130-165 RP
07 $110-136 RP
06 $126-166 RP
06 $160 WS
05 $225 Zachys
05 $208 WS
05 $192-292 RP
04 $135-150 RP
06 $35 RP
08 $13 WE
07 $12 WE
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux Blavia 07
07 WE=88
07 $16 WE
Bordeaux Arte 07
07 WE=87
07 $16 WE
St-Emilion Ch Cheval Noir 07/08
08 WE=88
07 WE=84
08/07 $20 WE
08 WE=90
07 WE=89
08 WE=88
07 WE=87
08 WE=85
07 WE=85
08 WE=85
07 WE=85
06 WS=87
08/07 $25 WE
Haut-Medoc Ch dArche 07/08
St-Emilion Ch la Couronne 07/08
St-Estephe Ch Picard 07/08
St-Emilion Ch Cheval Noir le Fer 07/08
Ch Maine Gazin
Prem Cotes de Blaye Livenne Vieilles Vignes 06
Ch Maison Blanche
Medoc 06/08/09/10
Silver Bruzelles 11
09 Bronze Paris, Challenge Int’L 11
10 WE=88
09 WS=91
08 $25 WE
07 $24 WE
08/07 $25 WE
08 $40 WE
07 $50 WE
10 $30 WE
09 $15 K&L
08 WS=87
Maison Bouey
Bordeaux Collections Derenoncourt 10
10 WS=86
10 $18 WS
130
Bordeaux Parcelles Stephane Deneoncourt 10
Bordeaux Sup Ch Belrose Portraits Maucaillou 10
10 WS=83
10 $20 WS
Haut-Medoc Ch Moulin de la Bridaire Portraits 10
10 WS=87
10 $24 WS
Haut-Medoc Parcelles Stephane Derenoncourt
Maison Sichel
Ch Majean
`0 Comm’d Devcanter 12
St-Emilion GC Parcelles Stephanes Derenoncourt 10 Comm’d Decanter 12
Bordeaux 07 (Merlot-CS)
07 Gold LA 10
Bordeaux M Claret nv
Comm’d IWC 12
Graves 06/07/08/09
09 RP=85-87
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=88
06 ST=86-88
Malagar
Premieres Cotes de Bordeaux 10
10 50%Merlor-50%CS
Ch Malaire
Medoc 05/06/07
07 WE=87
06 WS=83
05 WS=81
10 45%Merlot-45%CS-8%CF-2%PV 10 ST=86
10 JJB=91
09 59%CS-38%M-3%PV
09 WE=94
09 ST=91
09 RP=93-95+
09 ST=91-94
09 IWR=92+
08 RP=91-94
08 WE=93
08 ST=87
08 IWR=94
08 WS=88-91
07 RP=90
07 WS=87
07 WE=90
06 WE=92
06 RP=90
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=88
05 WE=92/90
05 WS=90
05 RP=91-93
05 ST=89
04 WS=87
04 WE=90
03 Good for mid-term drinking WD
03 WD=15.5/20
03 WS-86
06 RP=89
10 ST=87
06 Comm’d IWC 10
Ch Malartic-Lagraviere
Le Sillage de Malartic 06
Ch Malbec
Bordeaux Rouge 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 CF-CS-Merlot
07 $35-40 RP
10 WS=88
07 $19 WE
06 $20 WS
09 $57 K&L
09 $60+ ST
09 $54-87 RP
08 $34-45 RP
08 $36 K&L
08 $40 IWR
07 $29-38 RP
06 $34-54 RP
06 $39 WS
06 $33 RP
10 $14 WS
09 $15 WFoods
08 Bronze Decante,r Bordeaux, IWC 10
08 Comm’d IWC 10
06 Silver Paris, Bordeaux, Brussels 0706 WS=85
05 60%Merlot 40%CS
06 $15 WS
131
Bordeaux Sup Huppos Cuvee Fut de Chene 09
Ch Malene
Bordeaux 10
10 WS=81
Ch Malescasse
Haut-Medoc 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 WS=90
10 $17 WS
09 WE=88
09 ST=87
08 WBlB=86
08 $14-28 WBlB
08 ST=87
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 WS=87-90
08 RP=83-85
08 WE=87
07 C$29 BCLS
06 RP=86
06 $12-16 RP
06 WS=87
06 $16 WS
05 WS=88
05 WE=87
04 WE=84
04/03 WS=88
02 WS=81
10 JJB=94+
09 WE=89
09 $120 K&L
09 ST=91
09 $86+ ST
09 RP=95-97
09 $79-127 RP
09 WS=97-100
09 JJB=96-98
08 RP=91-93
08 $40-73 RP
08 WS=90-93
08 $43 Zachys
08 WE=90-92
08 $50 K&L
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=89
07 $36-67 RP
07 WS=90
07 $50 K&L
07 ST=88
07 $85 Zachys
07 $60 B&M
07 C$75 BCLS
06 WE=92
06 $60 K&L
06 RP=91+
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=92-94
05 ST=93
05 WS=97
05 WE=92
05 WW=93-95
04 ST=90
04 WS=88
03 WS=92
03 WD=17+/20
02 WS=90
01 WS=88
01 $37 WW
00 WS=93
10 RP=87
10 $14-18 RP
Ch Malescot-St-Exupery
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Fabulous, best ever WW 06
Ch de Malleret
Haut-Medoc 03-10
10 $9 WS
Ch Malmaison
Moulis-en-Medoc 06/07/08/09/10
06 WS=84
05 WS=87
04 WS=81
03 WS=84
10/09 WS=87
08 WS=88
07 WS=86
06 WS=90
Moulis en Medoc Baronne de Rothschild 08
05 WS= 91
04 WS=85
03 WS=85-88
10 $25 WS
09 $18 K&L
08 $20 Sh-L
06 $18 WS
05 $25 WS
132
Ch Malronne
Bordeaux Sup 08
08 Bronze LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee AdeleToulouse Lautrec 08 Gold LA 11
08 LA=92
08 WS=88
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
Manoir de Gay
Pomerol 09/10/11
10 RP=88
09 WS=89-92
05 WS=87
Ch Manoir du Gravoux
Cotes de Castillon Terra Burdigala 06
Cotes de Castillon Terra burgigala La Violette 06
Clos Manon
Medoc 05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch Marac
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Pourquoi Pas Moi 05
Ch Marbuzet
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05/06
Ch Marceau
Bordeaux 06
Cl les Marcottes
Bordeaux 10/11
Clos Margalaine
Margaux 03/05/06/07/09/10
06 WS=85
04 WS=85
03 WW=88
03 WS=86
06 WS=86
06/04 $19 WS
10 RP=90
09 RP=89-91
09 WS=89-92
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=90
06 RP=90
06 WS=86
05 WS=87
10 WE=85
10 $20-32 RP
09 $23-27 RP
09 $25 K&L
08 $17-25 RP
07 $17 RP
06 $22-40 RP
06 $28 WS
05 $34 WS
10 $15 WE
09 $12 Astor
06 $26 WS
08 Silver LA 10
05 Gold BofShow BofClass LA 10
06 Bronze LA 10
11 Bronze LA 12
10 Gold LA 11
Ch Margaux
11 $23 JJBFuture
10 $23-33 RP
09 $25 K&L
Margaux PGC 02-09 (09=87%CS-9%M-CF-PV) 09 One of Top 15 Decanter
06 Top pick K&L
06/05/04 WS=85-88
06 ST=85-87
05 WE=92/91
05 WS=85
04 WE=86
03 WS=87
10 LA=93
10 RP=89
10 $20-33 RP
09 WE=91
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 ST=86-89
06/03 WS=85-88 06 $17-20 RP
05 RP=90-92
05 $24-25 RP
03 WS=89-91
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=20/20
09 ST=97
09 $900+ ST
09 JJB=97-99
08 WS=87
08 WE=96
08 ST=91
08 JJB=91-93
08 RP=95-97
08 $325 Zachys
08 JJB=91-93
08 $600 K&L
07 WE=93
07 $450 WE
07 RP=92-94
07 $408-465 RP
07 WS=89-92
07 $440 K&L
07 ST=93
07 $650 Zachys
07 JJB=90-92
07 $525 B&M
07 C$599 BCLS
06 WE=95/95
06 WD=12-13/20 06 $540 K&L
06 RP=94
06 $436-626 RP
06 WS=95
06 $650 WS
133
06 ST=93-95
06 JJB=90-92
05 Great to Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=94
05 Great aroma, balanced, long WW 05 RP=98-100
05 WS=100
05 ST=98+?
05 WE=98/98
05 WW=99-100
04 WE=96
04 WS=93
04 Top 10 WW 06
04 RP=92-94
04 ST=94
04 WW=93-95
04 WW=94-96 ?
04/03 Vin Exceptionnel Hach 08/07
03 RP=99
03 WS=98
03 WE=96
03 WW=94-97
03 ST= 96
02 RP=93
02 WS=92
01 RP=93
01 WS=92
00 RP=100
00 WS=100
99 WS=92
06 C$899 BCLS
05 $1800 W&S
05 $799-900 RP
05 $1080 WS
04 $210 K&L
04 $189-453 RP
04 $125 ST
See their second wine: Pavillon Rouge
Ch Marin
Bordeaux 10
Ch Marjosse
Bordeaux 03-12
10 Silver LA 11
10/09 78%Merlot-11%CS-11%CF
08 Comm’d IWC, Decanter 10
05 Bronze IWC 07
Cotes de Catillon Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Maro de St-Amant
St-Emilion Cuvee leo 06
Marojalla
12 JR=16.5 (90)
11 JR=16 (88)
10 RP=85
10 ST=88
10 JR=16 (88)
09 ST=87
09 JR=16 (88)
08 ST=86
08 JR=16.5 (90)
07 WS=82-85
07 JR=14.5 (82)
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
05 IWR=87
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=83
09 RP=87-88
08 RP=87-89
08 JJB=84-86
10 $8-17 RP
09 $11 ST
09 $11 JJB
06 $10-17 RP
06 $13 WS
05 $17 Zachys
09 $9-12 RP
08 $8-14 RP
08 WS=87
07 WS=83-86
05 WS=88
Margaux 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 ST=89
09 WE=89
08 WS=90
08 RP=88-90+
07 WS=89-91
07 RP=89-91
06 RP=91
06 WS=88
06 ST=89-91
05 WE=90
05 WS=93
04 WS=91
03 WS=92
08 $66-82 RP
07 $61-76 RP
06 $58-100 RP
06 $86 WS
05 $125 Zachys
05 $146 WS
134
Margaux Clos Margalaine 08
08 WS=88
Ch Marot
Bordeaux 05
05 IWR=85
05 $12 IWR
Ch la Maroutine
06 WS=83
05 IWR=85
06 C$20 BCLS
05 $11 IWR
05 C$20 BCLS
Clos du Marquis
St-Julien 02-10 (Ch Leoville-las-Cases)
09 70%CS-20%M-8%CF-2%PV
07 Value< $500/case QRW 08
05 Very solid, silky, long WW 06
Ch Marquis d’Alesme
Margaux 09
Marquis d’Alesme-Becker
Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
10 ST=86
09 WE=93
09 RP=91-93
09 ST=89
08 RP=90-93
08 WS=90
08 ST=89
07 RP=89
07 WE=91
07 ST=87
07 WS=87-90
06 WE=91
06 RP=90
09 $50-67 RP
08 $34-56 RP
08 $37 K&L
08 $43 Zachys
07 $32-50 RP
07 $40 WE
07 $40 K&L
07 $39 Zachys
07 $52 B&M
07 C$59 BCLS
06 $65 B&M
06 C$75 BCLS
06 NM=92
06 ST=90-91
06 WS=92
05 WS=92-94
06 $75 B&M
05 ST=90
05 WS=93
05 W&S=2-2½stars
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=91
04 ST=88
04 WE=90
04 RP=87-89
03 WS=90
03 ST=90
03 RP=90
02 RP=89
02 WS=90
02 ST=88
07 Editor’d Choice WE
05 Very silky, very classy WW 06
09 RP=81-83
08 WS=89
08 RP=83-85
08 JJB=85-87
07 WE=01
07 RP=72-75
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=78
06 WS=89-91
05 WS=91
05 WW=89-92
09 $30-45 RP
07 $29 RP
06 $27-28 RP
05 $50 B&M
Marquis de Bern
Bordeaux 10
03 WS=91
02 WS=87
01 WS=88
10 WS=81
Marquis de Calon
St-Estephe 05
05 WW=90
05 $45 B&M
Marquis de Chasse
See: Ginestet
Ch Marquis de Terme
Margaux 4th Cru Classe 03-10
10/09 ST=88
09 WE=89
09 $39+ ST
09 CS-Merlot-PV
09 Bronze IWC 12
10 $12 WS
135
Ch de Marsan
Ch Marsac-Seguineau
Bordeaux Sup 08
03 Not a success at all WD 10/05
09 RP=89-91
08 WS=88
08 RP=85-87
07 RP=72-75
06 WE=88
06 RP=82
06 WS=80-84
05 WE=87
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=88
03 WD=13/20
09 $35-51 RP
08 $23-38 RP
07 $26-33 RP
06 $34-36 RP
10 €5-8 Hach
10 WS=90
10 $24 WS
Margaux 05/06/09/10
10 WS=90
09 WS=90-93
10 $21 WS
09 $19 K&L
09 $18 JJB
06 WS=83
05 WS=87
Clos Marsalette
09 60%Merlot-CS-CF
07
Ch Marsau (Dourthe)
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
Bordeaux Cote de Francs 06-10
09 Merlot
Ch Martinat
Cotes de Bourg 10
05 60%M-30%CS-10%Malbec
Cotes de Bourg Cuvee Epicurea 05
Bordeaux 09
09 Bronze LA 12
Ch Martinens
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05
Ch Marzelle
Pomerol 07/09
Ch la Marzelle
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09
06 Gold Paris 09
11 $23 JJB Fut
10 $21-40 RP
09 $25.50+ ST
07 $16-20 RP
06 $19-25 RP
06 $25 WS
05 $27 WS
05 $35 K&L
05 $23-30 RP
07 $35-50 RP
09 RP=87-89+
08 WS=87
09 $16-19 RP
08 $17 WS
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
10 $23 WS
10 $16-27 RP
06 RP=88
06 WS=87
05 WE=89
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=86
10 WS=65
05 RP=90
06 $27-29 RP
06 $27 WS
05 RP=90
05 WS=87
Ch Martinot
Ch Marzin
10 RP=89
09 ST=88
07 RP=85-87
07 ST=85
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=90
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=85
05 WS=85
05 ST=90
05 RP=90-92
04 ST=88
04 RP=87
07 RP=90
05 WS=79
04 WS=86
04 WE=85
01 WS=86
04 $17 WS
10 $18 WS
05 $23 WC
05 $28 WClub
04 $18 WS
04 WS=78
09 WE=92
08 WS=89
07 RP=84-86
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=85
136
Ch Massieu Boutet
Bordeaux 07
Ch Matras
05 ST=89
05 WS=90
04 WS=85
03 WS=86
07 Good Value W&S
07 $11 W&S
07 ST=87
05 ST=89
10 RP=86
10 ST=85
09 WE=92
09 ST=87
08 WS=86
08 ST=87
08 Decanter=3star
08 SS=15.5/20
08 RP=85-87
06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 05 ST=85-87
05=Cab Sauv
05 SS=15/20
05 WE=88
05 WS=90
02 WS=82
05 WS=88
Ch Maucaillou
Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 05-10
Moulis No. 2 – 05
Ch Maucamps
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 07/08/09
08 Cab Sauv
10 $19-34 RP
08 $21 WS
08 $17-23 RP
05 $34 wone.com
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 Comm’d IWC 10
Haut-Medoc Ch Dasvin-Bel-Air 10
Ch Maurac
Haut-Medoc 09/10
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CS-Merlot
Haut-Medoc Vignes de Cabaleyran 04-08( CS)
10 WS=90
10 $25 WS
10 WS=90
10 RP=87
10 $25 WS
10 $18 RP
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
06 Vin Remarquable Havhette 10
06 Comm’d IWC 09
05 WS=83
La Mauriane
Puisseguin-St-Emilion 04/05/06
Mauvais (Thunevin)
Bordeaux Garcon Bad Boy 09/10/11/12
Ma Verite
06 WS=87
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=87
02 RP=86-88
12 WS=88-91
11 WS=87-90
10 WS=90
09 WS=90
09 JS=93
09 WE=88
09 RP=87-89
09 ST=88
09 RP=90-92
08/07 WS=88
08 RP=88-90
06 RP=88
06 ST=87-90
Haut Medoc Cuvee d’Exception 06/08/09
06 $40 WS
10 $16 WS
10 $20 Zachys
09 $16WS
09 $20 Zachys
09 $17 JJB
09 $16 K&L
08 $18 WS
06 $35 RP
See: Gerard Depardieu Haut-Medoc Ma Verite
Ch Mayne Guyon
09 $7 TrJ
08 Hachette=1 star
05 WSW=86
137
Ch Mayne Lalande
Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05/08
Mayne Sansac
Bordeaux 08
Ch Mayne-Vieil
Fronsac Cuvee Alienor 09
08 WS=86
05 SS=15.5/20
08 Bronze LA 10
05 €15-23 Hach
09 $15 Sh-L
Ch Mayne-Vieux
Fronsac 06
Ch Mazeris
Canon-Fronsac 04/05/06/07/08
06 WS=84
Ch Mazeries
Pomerol 04/05
08 Gold Bordeaux, Brussels 10
07 Bronze Paris 09
Ch Mazeyres
Pomerol 03/04/05/06
06 C$20 LCBO
04 WS=88
06 WS=89
Ch Mejean
Clos des Menuts
Graves04/ 05/06/07
St-Emilion GC 06/08
St-Emilion l’Excellence 08
05 RP=84-86
05 WS=89
05 W-Plus=86
04 RP=87
04/03 WS=88
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/0703 RP=87-89
07 RP=87-89
07 ST=87
06 RP=89
08 WS=85
08 WS=90
Merlot de Lyne
Bordeaux 08/09
Les Merlots de Baudet
Bordeaux Sup 08
09 Gold LA 11
08 Silver LA 10
08 Silver LA 11
Ch Mercier
Cotes de Bourg 09
Ch du Merle
Cotes de Bourg Cuvee Prestige 05/06/07/08/09 09 Bronze Decanter 12
Bourdeaux Grand Vin 05
Ch Messile-Aubert
Montagne-St-Emilion 04/06/07/08/09/10
Montagne-St-Emilion Cuvee Prestige 03/05
Montagne-St-Emilion Heloise Aubert Sel 06
Ch de la Meuliere
11 50%Merlot-CabSauv
04 $20 RP
06 $32 RP
09 LA=92
05 WE=88
05 Silver LA 10
10 RP=87
10 ST=87
09 RP=88-90
06 $50 WS ?
06 $18 RP
05 $22-25 RP
05 $37 WS
08 WS=87
07 RP=87-88
07 ST=87
06 RP=88
06 ST=86-88
04 WS=85
05 WS=89-91
03/01 WS=86
06 WS=89-91
08 WW=89
10 $24 RP
09 $25 RP
09 $23 Sh-L
06 $25 RP
05 $23 Zachys
08 $10 B&M 5¢
138
05 Rec’d WineShelf
Emotion Grand Res 09
Ch Meyney
03 Smart Buy WS 06
Ch Meyre
Margaux 03-09 (CS)
08 RC=86
08 CellarT 86.7 (3)
06 WW=89
06 RC=96
06 WW=89
05 WW=89
04 AG=85
05 WW=91
05 AG=85
09 WW=91
09 $30 B&M
11 WS=90-93
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=86-88
08 JJB=82-83
08 RP=89-91
07 WE=91
07 RP=78-82
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=84
06 WS=90
06 RP=85
05 SS=16/20
11 $16/375 JJB
09 $28-43 RP
08 $20-34 RP
07 $25 Sh-L
07 $20-25 RP
07 $25 Zackys
06 $49 B&M
06 $23 Zachys
05 $46 B&M
05 WS=90
04 WS=90
04 ST=85-87
03 WS=91
06 $15 RP
05 Bronze IWC 09
03/02 Comm’d Decanter 06/07
03 Bronze IWC 07
Michel Lynch
Bordeaux Merlot 05
Michel Rolland
Episode 1 – 05
Ch Mille-Roses
Haut-Medoc 04-10
Margaux 09
Ch Milon
St-Emilion 04/05/06
Mirambeau
Bordeaux 09
Ch Mirefleurs
Bordeaux Sup 06/09
Ch la Mission-Haut-Brion
03 WE=88
10 WS=89
10 $20 WS
06 Silver Paris 09
06 WS=85
05 WS=85
05 Best Buy WE
05 WE=87
05 $11 WE
05 RP=92-94
05 $39-45 RP
06 Very Successful Hschette 10
05 3 Discoveries of Vintage QWR
04 WS=84
10 ST=86
05 WS=87
05 $33 WS
04 $34 Andys
06 WS=83
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=85
09 RP=87-89
04 $22 WS
09 $13 RP
09 WE=88
09 $15 WE
06 WE=83
06 $16 WE
10 ST=94
10 $700+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 WE=96
09 $900 K&L
09 ST=93
09 $800+ ST
09 RP=98-100
09 $750+
09 JJB=96-98
139
08 ST=90
08 WE=95-97
08 RP=94-96+
08 WS=91-94
07 RP=92
07 WE=93
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=90
06 Top Pick K&L
06 WE=95/96
06 RP=95
06 WS=95
06 ST=94-96
05 WS=97
05 RP=96-100
05 W&S=97
05 WE=94/97
05 ST=94 +?
05 WW=93-96
04 WE=94
08 $190 K&L
08 $189-330 RP
08 $225 Zachys
07 $199-395 RP
07 $360 WE
07 $200 K&L
07 $399Zachys
07 $400 B&M
06 $645 WS
05 $500 K&L
04 $140 B&M
04 WS=91
04 RP=89-91
04 ST=91
03 WS=94
03 RP=94
03 ST=93
02 RP=89
02 WS=91
02 ST=91+
01 WS=92
01 RP=91
01 ST=92+
00 WS=93
00 RP=100
00 ST=95
99 RP=91
99 WS=88
99 ST=90
99 WW=91
See also their second wine: La Chapelle
Graves 02/03/04/05
Ch Moine-Martin
Fronsac 10
Ch Moine Vieux
St-Emuliom Blue Label 05
St-Emilion Prestige GC 06
Clos des Moiselles
Ch Monbousquet
05 Georgeous perfume, powerful WW 05 ST=93-96
05 WS=95-100
05 WW=93-96
04 ST=92-94
03 ST=94
02 ST=91+01
01 RP=88
10 WS=88
05 $230
10 $18 WS
05 WS=88
06 Gold Brussels 09
Cotes de Bourg 10
10 WS=87
10 $13 WS
Merlot Bordeaux 10
10 WS=87
10 $14 WS
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=87
10 $22 RP
09 JJB=94-96
09 ST=89
09 RP=92-94
08 RP=92-94
08 WS=89-92
09 $40-57 RP
08 $37-56 RP
08 $45 K&L
St-Emilion 01-10
10 ST=88
09 60%Merlot-30%CF-CS
140
Ch Mondesir-Gazin
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=90
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=89
06 WE=87
06 WS=89-91
06 RP=92
06 ST=89-90
05 Wonderful complexity Decanter 06 05 SS=17.5/20
05 ST=93
05 WS=91
05 WE=89
05 RP=94-96
04 WS=89-91
04 ST=89
04 RP=90
03 ST=90
03 RP=93
03/02 WS=90
02 ST=90
02 RP=90
01 WS=89
01 RP=91
10 ST=86
09 ST=88
09 WE=89
08 ST=87
08 SS=16+/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=84
07 WE=89
07 RP=90-93
06 RP=88
06 WE=87
06 WS=87
05 WE=91
05 WS=91
04 RP=84
04 WS=90
04 WE=90
03 RP=86
03/02 WS=85
01 WS=86
07 WS=87
Ch les Mondines
Bordeaux sup 12
10 Silver LA 12
Ch les Mondons
Bordeaux 10
10 Silver LA 12
Ch Mondorion
Ch Monbrison
St-Emilion Etoiles de Mondorion 10
Mondot
Ch la Mondotte
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
09 80%Merlot-20%CF
06 $32-49 RP
05 $75 Zachys
05 $75 WS
09 $32+ ST
07 $25 WS
06 $53 B&M
09 $15 JJB
07 $25 Dec
06 WS=90
05 WS=91
10 WS=88
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08 (Ch Troplong-Mondot)
St-Emilion GC 03-10
07 $34-51 RP
07 $46 Zachys
07 C$75 BCLS
05 WW=91
10 ST=93
09 ST=91
09 RP=95-98+
08 ST=90
08 RP=93-95+
07 RP=91
07 WS=90
07 ST=93
06 RP=97
06 WS=93
06 ST=91-93
10 $25 WS
08 $33 Zachys
05 $70 B&M
09 $340-475 RP
08 $130-170 RP
07 $144-180 RP
07 $150 K&L
07 C$259 BCLS
06 $228-304 RP
06 $250 WS
06 C$399 BCLS
141
Ch Mongravey
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 02/03/04/05/06/07/09 09 Silver Decanter 12
07 Bronze Paris 09; Decanter 10
07 Comm’d IWC 10
Margaux Cuvee 3 D 09
09 Bronze IWC 12
Margaux Cuvee Speciale 09
09 Gold IWC 12
09 CS-Merlot
09 Silver LA 11
05 ST=96
05 SS=19/20
05 WS=97
05 RP=96-100
04 ST=90+
04 WS=93
04 RP=93
03 ST=93
09 WE=85
06 WS=87
05 WS=89
03 WS=87
02 WS=88
06 $27 WS
05 $35 WS
05 IWR=88
05 $11 IWR
Ch Monicord
Bordeaux Sup Modern 09
Ch de Monrecueil
Bordeaux Sup 09/10
Ch Monroze
Bordeaix Superieur 05
Ch Montcabrier
Bordeaux Sup 06/09
Ch Montcanon
Canon-Fronsac 06
06 WS=84
Ch Monte Christo
St-Emilion Cuvee Edmond Dantes 05/08
05 WS=86
10 Silver LA 12
09 Bronze LA 11
06 Silver LA 10
06 $20 JJB
Ch Montet (Haut Guillebot) Bordeaux 08/09
09 Bronze LA 11
08 Gold BofShow BofClass LA 10
05 IWR=87
Ch Montfollet
Bordeaux Sup 08
08 Bronze LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 08/09
09/08 Silver LA 11/10
Cotes de Blaye 04/05/06
06/05 WS=85-88
04 WS=87
Prem Cotes de Blaye Vieilles Vignes 08
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
Blaye le Valentin 05/06/07
Prem Cotes de Blaye Vielles Vignes 03/04
Bordeaux Sup 07
07 Silver LA 10
Montirius
Cotes-du-Rhone 05
05 Bargaain SFCh 8/17/07
Ch Montlabert
St-Emilion GC 07-10
Ch Montlandrie
10 70%Merlot-30%CF
09 75%Merlot-25%CF
Bordeaux Sup Hors Serie 09
06 WS=86
04 WS=89
03 WS=87
Ch Montiau
Ch Montlau
05 $9 IWR
03 $15 WS
05 $11 SFCh
10 WS=92
07 RC=91
11 NM=90-92
10 ST=87
09 ST=89
09 RP=88-89+
10 WE=87
10 $20 WS
11 $22 JJBFuture
10 $17 WE
09 Bronze LA 12
08 Silver LA 11
09 Silver LA 12
Ch Montlisse
St-Emilion 05
05 WS=92
Ch Mont-Perat
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 03-10
10 RP=86
10 JR=16 (88)
09 WE=89
09 Merlot
10 $16-26 RP
142
08 “Sleeper of the category” JJB
Ch Montrose
St-Estephe 2nd Cru 99-10
10 53%CS-37%Merlot-9%CF-1%PV
09 65%CS-M-CF-PV
09 Onr of Top 32 JJB
07 Serlected by Vine Talk TV
99 Spectator Selection WS
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=86
08 JJB=87-89
06 WS=82
05 WS=80-84
05 RP=85-87
04 RP=83
04 WE=89
03 RP=87
03 WS=81
09 $18 RP
10 ST=91
10 $195+ ST
06 $17 WS
04 $22 B&M
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 WE=96
09 $250 K&L
09 ST=94
09 $175+ ST
09 RP=96-100
09 $160-266 RP
09 WS=97-100
09 ST=94-97
09 JJB=98-100
08 WE=94
08 $73 K&L
08 RP=95-97
08 $85-153 RP
08 ST=88
08 $130 Zachys
08 $100 K&L
07 RP=91
07 $53-100 RP
07 ST=88
07 $85 K&L
07 WS=87-90
07 $75 Zachys
07 $95 B&M
07 C$129 BCLS
06 WE=94/94
06 $139 B&M
06 RP=94+
06 C$139 BCLS
06 ST=88-89
06 WS=93
06 AG=91
06 C$139 AG
05 WS=94
05 $150 B&M
05 ST=93+?
05 RP=96
05 WW=94-96
04 WS=92
04 $50K&L
04 WW=93-95
04 $80 B&M
04 RP=91
04 ST=91
03 RP=97-100
03 WS=96
03 WE=95
03 ST=96-98
03 WW=93-96
02 WS=92
02 ST=91+
99 WS=90
See also their second wine: Dame de Montrose
Ch Montviel
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 TWCI=86-88
09 WE=89
09 ST=87
09 RP=87-90
08 WS=90
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=84-86
07 WS=86-89
06 WS=88
05 RP=87-89
05 WS=89
04 WS=88
04 RP=86
06 $37 WS
05 $40 RP
05 $44 WS
143
Ch Mouchet (Ginestet)
Ch Moulinet
Puisseguin-St-Emilion Cuvee
Fernand Ginestet 03/04
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 RP=87-90
04 WS=82
03 Gold Blaye & Bourg 05
03 WS=86
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/10
Ch Moulinet-Lasserre
Pomerol 05
Ch la Mothe du Barry
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 ST=87
07 WS=84-87
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=89
05 WS=91
05 ST=89-90
04 WS=88
05 WS=88
03 $14 WS
06 $21-23 RP
05 $33 WS
05 $23-24 RP
04 $31 WS
05 €15-23 Hach
10 WS=87
10 WE=86
10 WE=89
10 $16 WS
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee le Barry 10
10 WE-90
10 $20 WE
Ch La Mouliniere
Bordeaux 06
06 WE=84
06 $11 WE
Ch le Moulin
Pomerol 06/07/08/09/10
10 TWCI=87-89
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=90
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=85-87
06 RP=90
05 WS=92-94
05 RP=90-93
04 WS=88
04 RP=87-89
03 RP=88
06 $55 RP
Bordeaux Sup Vieilles Vignes 10
`
Ch la Moulin
Moulis en Medoc Cru Bourgeois 07
Ch des Moulins
Medoc 04/05/06
Ch Clos du Moulin
St-Estephe 05
Ch du Moulin
Haut Medoc 04/05/06
Ch Moulin de Beausejour
Bordeaux Superieur Cuvee Tradition 06
Ch Moulin du Cadet
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09
Ch Moulin de Clotte
Cotes de Castillon 05/06/09/10
05 W&S=86
06 WS=88
05 WS=87
11 RC=85
11 WE=86
06 RC=86
09/08 RP=87-89
07 WS=82-85
06 WE=87
06 WS=86
05 WS=88
10 Merlot
10 WS=88
10 WE=88
Moulin de Duhart Rothschild Paulliac 05
Ch Moulin-Haut-Laroque Fronsac 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 $21 WE
05 $46 RP
04 $45-46 RP
03 $55-62 RP
05 $20 W&S
11 $7 TrJ
06 $60 WS
10 $17 WS
10 $19 WE
09 $19 Astor
06 WS=85
05 WE=90
05 $45 WE
05 WS=89
10 RP=90+
10 $18-29 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5/20
09 RP=90-92
09 $21-27 RP
08 RP=87-89
144
Ch Moulin de Lagnet
St-Emilion 05
Ch Moulin Pey-Labrie
Canon-Fronsac 04/05/06/09/10
08/06/03 Bargains Snooth.com
Ch Moulin de Mallet
Bordeaux 10
10 Best Buy WE
Ch Moulin Riche St-Julien 08 (Leoville-Poyferre’s second wine)
05 One of 8 Top “Seconds” QWR
04 Cited Wine Hachettew 08
Ch Moulin de la Rose
07 RP=89-91
07 ST=87
06 RP=90
05 WS=90
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=86
04 RP=90
05 WE=88
10 ST=86
09 RP=90-92
06 WS=88
05 WS=80=84
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=90
04 RP=85-87
03 WS=89
03 RP=90
00 WR=90
10 WE=87
08 WS=88
05 WS=88
03 WS=88
10 WS=90
09 WE=91
St-Julien 09/10
07 $17-26 RP
07 C$39 BCLS
05 $25 WS
05 $26 Zachys
05 $50 WE
09 $21 RP
04 $27 RP
10 $12 WE
05 $22-26 RP
10 $25 WS
Ch du Moulin Rouge
10 WS=87
10 RP=88
09 Gold Bordeaux 11
Ch Moulin-St-Georges
St-Emilion GC 03-10
Ch Moutin
Graves 05
Mouton Cadet
See: Rothschild
Ch Mouton Rothschild
Paulliac PGC 99-10
09 JR=15 (84)
09 Dec=15.5 (86)
08 SS=15.0/20
08 $15 Zachys
08 Decanter=3star
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
10 ST=88
09 WE=91
09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=90
07 WE=87
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=87
06 WE=90
06 RP=90
06 ST=90
06 WS=88
05 ST=91
05 RP=91-93
05 WS=92
04 RP=89
04 WS=91
04 ST=89
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 WS=90
05 Very Sussessful Hachette 09
05 WS=84
10 94%CS-6%Merlot
09=88%CS-12%Merlot
10 $14 WS
10 $11-20 RP
10 $20 Zachys
10 ST=95
10 $60+ ST
09 $40-52 RP
08 $33-50 RP
07 $32-44 RP
07 $42 WE
07 $40 Zachys
07 $50 B&M
06 $35 JJB
10 $700+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 ST=95
09 $800+ ST
145
09 WE=98
09 RP=96-98+
09 JJB=96-98
08 RP=94-96
08 WE=95-97
08 ST=92
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=92
07 WE=95
07 ST=93
07 WS=90-93
05 Von Exceptionnel Hachette 09
03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07
09 $750+ RP
08 $784+ RP
08 $325 Zachys
08 $260 K&L
07 $400+ RP
07 $450 WE
07 $430 K&L
07 $550 Zachys
07 $555 B&M
07 C$1999 BCLS
06 C$999 BCLS
06 WE=97/97
06 ST=93-96
06 WE=97
06 WS=94
06 RP=98+
06 ST=94-95
05 RP=93-95
05 WS=93
05 $687 B&M
05 W&S=2½stars 05 C$1100 BCLS
05 WE=95/95
05 ST=95
04 WE=93
04 RP=91-93
04 ST=92
04 WS=93
03 RP=95
03 WS=94
03 WE=91/94
03 WW=91-94
03 ST=93
02 RP=93
02 WS=91
02 ST=94
01 RP=89
01 WS=94
01 ST=91+
00 RP=97
00 WS=95
00 WS=93
00 ST=94
99 RP=93
99 ST=90
99 WS=90
99 AG=90
See also their second wine: Le Petit Mouton
See also: Aile d’Argent
Ch Munch
10 WS=87
Ch de Musset (Yvon Mau)
Lalande de Pomerol 07
07 WE=87
Ch Mylord
Bordeaux 08
08 Veru Successful Hachette 11
Cuvee Milady 05/06/08/09/10
Ch Myon de L’Enclos
Moulis 10
Ch Nardian
St-Emilion 09
10 $24 WS
08 Bronze LA 10
10 WS=88
10 RP=86
09 RP=86-88
08 RP=84-85
06 RP=86
05 IWR=89
10 WS=88
10 $10 WS
10 $6-15 RP
09 $10 RP
09 WS=88
09 $18 WS
06 $14 RP
05 $14 IWR
10 $18 WS
146
Ch Nardou
Cotes de Bordeaux Bois Meney 10
Bordeaux Sup 10
Ch Narjan
Bordeaux Sup Traditional 08
Ch Nenin
Pomerol 01-10
10 WS=84
10 Gold LA 12
10 LA=91
10 82%Merlot-18%CF
09 80%Merlot-20%CF
10 ST=87
09 ST=89
09 WE=92
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=89
07 WE=89
07 ST=87
07 WS=87-90
06 RP=91
06 WE=93/90
06 WS=91
05 WE=91
05 WS=93
05 ST=89
05 RP=90-92
04 WS=88
04 WE=92
04 ST=87
04 RP=89
03 RP=87
03 WS=87
01 Gold IWC 07
02 ST=86
02 WS=90
10 $16 WS
09 $70+ ST
09 $57-77 RP
08 $35-56 RP
08 $44 Zachys
07 $32-45 RP
07 $45 WE
07 $45 Zachys
06 $44-83 RP
06 $68 WS
05 $75 Zachys
04 $29-40 RP
See also: Fugue de Nenin
Ch Noaillac
Medoc 03/04/05/07/10
10 RP=88
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
10 $18 RP
99 RP=85-86
98 WS=75-79
Ch le Noble
Bordeaux 10
03 Hach=1star
10 WE=87
10 $18 WE
Ch Normandin le Clos
05 IWR=87
05 $12 IWR
Ch Olivier
10 60%CS-40%Merlot
09 83%CS-17%Merlot
L’Orangerie de Carignan
10 ST=86
10 JJB=92
09 WE=92
09 ST=88
08 WS=88
08 ST=88
07 RP=70-73
07 WS=88
06 WE=89
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
05 WE=87
05 WS=88
05 RP=86-88
04 WE=92
04 WS=87
04 RP=85
06 WS=83
08 $26 WS
06 $30-37 RP
06 $30 WS
05 $30 Zachys
05 $30 WS
05 $26-30 RP
04 $30 WS
04 $40 RP
06 $13 WS
147
Clos de l’Oratoire
St-Emilion GC 03-10
10 95%Merlkot-5%CF
10 ST=87
09 RP=91-93
08 95%M-5%CF
08 WE=91-93
08 RP=89-91
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=88-90
08 JJB=86-88
07 RP=90
07 WS=86-89
07 ST=88
06 RP=91
06 Not a great effort WD
06 WD=14.5-15.5
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=91
05 Powerful, excellent fruit, long WW 05 WS=93
05 Outstanding for ptice QWR
05 ST=91
05 WW=93-96
05 WE=91
05 RP=92-94
04 WS=90
04 ST=87-89
04 RP=90
03 ST=87
03 TA=4½stars
03 RP=88
09 $36-50 RP
08 $30 K&L
08 $23-35 RP
07 $24-30 RP
07 $34 Zachys
06 $33-54 RP
06 $33 K&L
06 $41 WS
05 $38-64 RP
L’Oratoire de Chasse-Spleen Moulis
Oriel
Iconic 05
Ch les Ormes-de-Pez
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Except 02-11
05 WE=88
05 $25 WE
11 WE=92-94
11 $17 JJB Fut
11 JS=90-91
10 57%CS-34%Merlot-7%CF-2%PV 10 ST=88
10 JJB=92+
09 WE=91
09 RP=88-90
09 $32-86 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17/20
08 WS=88
08 $26 WS
08 WE=91
08 ST=87
08 $25 K&L
08 RP=89-91
08 $22-32 RP
08 Decanter =4star 08 $26 Zachys
08 SS=16.5/20
07 WE=91
07 $28 WE
07 RP=86-88
07 $21-32 RP
07=56%CS-36%Merlot-6%CF-2%PV 07 ST=86
07 WS=84-87
07 $21 B&M
06 WE=91
06 $29.37 B&M
06 RP=87
06 $29 JJB
06 ST=85-88
06 WS=86
06 JR=17 (92)
06 G&M=17 (92)
06 B&D 16 (88)
05 W&S=1½-2stars
05 RP=86-88
05 WS=88
05 WE=92
05 ST=84-87
05 SS=16.5/20
04 WS=89
04 WW=91-93
04 WE=91
04 RP=85
04 ST=85-88
03 RP=86
03 ST=87-89
148
03 Merely quite good WD 10/05
Ch Les Ormes-Sorbet
Medoc 05/06/07/08/09/10
Ormiale
Brodeaux 10
Les Pagodes de Cos
St-Estephe 04-10 (Ch Cos d’Estournel)
10 62%CS-38%Merlot
09 69%CS-30%M-PV
03 Bronze IWC 07
Ch de Paillet-Quancard
Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 09/10
Ch Palatin
St-Emilion 06/08
Ch Palmer
Margaux 3rd Cru 00-10
03 WS=88
03 WW=86-88
03 WD=14.5/20
02 ST=86
02 WE=90
10 RP=87
08 WE=87
07 WE=86
06 WE=87
06 WS=80
05 WS=87
10 $16-22 RP
10 RP=86
10 $22 RP
10 ST=88
09 ST=86
09 RP=91-94
08 WE=91
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=83-85
06 RP=88
06 WS=86
06 WE=89
05 WE=90
05 ST=87-89
05 WS=89
05 NM=90
05 RP=88-90
04/03 WS=88
04 RP=86-88
03 RP=88
02 RP=89
10 WS=89
09 $50-72 RP
08 $35 K&L
07 $38 RP
07 $34 Zachys
06 $33-40 RP
06 $38 WS
06 $30 JJB
05 $43 Zachys
05 $43 WS
05 C$59 NM
02 $28 WClub
10 $15 WS
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
08 WS=89
10 ST=90
10 $290+ ST
09 52%Merlot-41%CS-PV
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 ST=88
09 $325+ ST
09 WE=99
09 RP=94-96
09 $295-449 RP
09 JJB=96-98
08 RP=95-97
08 $155-259 RP
08 WE=93-95
08 $160 Zachys
08 ST=91
08 $140 K&L
08 JJB=90-92
07 RP=89
07 $167-230 RP
07 ST=91
07 $200 K&L
07 WS=90
07 $190 Zachys
07 C$269 BCLS
06 Top Pick K&L
06 RP=92
06 $190 K&L
06 WE=94
06 AG=93
06 C$379 AG
06 ST=91-93
06 $125-225 RP
06 WS=93
06 $215 WS
06 C$329 BCLS
05 RP=95-100
05 $230
05 Opulent, big, chewy WW 06
05 WE=95/96
05 $275 Zachys
05 W&S=96
05 $350 W&S
05 WS=95
05 $271 WS
05 ST=94
05 C$449 BCLS
04 WE=90
04 WS=91
04 $124 WS
04 ST=92
03 WS=90
149
03 WE=94
03 ST=89
02 WS=91
02 ST=92+
01 ws=94
00 WS=97
00 TA=5stars
99 WS=91
See also their second wine: Alter Ego
Ch Paloumey
10 65%CS-35%Merlot
08 Silver Paris 11
Margaux 09
09 Bronze Paris 11
Ch Panigon
Medoc 10
Ch le Pape
Pessac-Leognan L’Excellence 05
Ch Pape Clement
04/03 Vin Remarq.Hachette 08/07
10 WS=91
10 RP=87
10 ST=86
10 WE=92
10 JS=89
10 JR=15.5 (86)
09 WS=90-93
09 WE=92
09 JR=16.5 (90)
08 WE=90
08 WS=86
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WE=89
07 ST=87
06 WE=89
06 WS=88
05 SS=15.5/20
05 WS=87
05 RP=80-84
04 WS=85
10 $17 WS
10 $14-23 RP
10 $23 Zachys
09 $20 K&L
08 $25 WE
06 $17 WS
03 WS=82
10 WS=88
10 WE=88
05 WS=89
10 $25 WS
10 $20 WE
10 ST=94
10 JJB=96
09 WE=93
09 $140 K&L
09 ST=93
09 $150+ ST
09 RP=95-97+
09 $125-179 RP
09 WS=94-97
09 ST=93-96
08 RP=94-96
08 $90-144 RP
08 ST=90
08 $110 K&L
08 WS=90
08 $115 Zachys
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=92
07 $92-138 RP
07 WE=91
07 $130 WE
07 ST=92
07 $130 K&L
07 WS=88-91
07 $130 Zachys
06 RP=95
06 $100-150 RP
06 WD=16.5-17.5+
06 ST=91-93
06 $124-140 RP
06 WS=91
06 WE=92
05 RP=98
05 $150-287 RP
05 WE=93
05 W&S=94
05 ST=94
05 WD=18-19/20
05/04 WS=96
04 ST=91
04 RP=91
03 WS=93
150
La Serenite Bernard Magrez Pessac-Legonan
Le Clementin de Pape Clement 02-10
10 55%CS=45%Merlot
03 RP=94
03 ST=92
02 WS=89
02 ST=91
06/05 RP=90-92
04 RP=90
10 ST=87
06 WS=80-84
02 Silver IWSC 05
Ch la Papeterie
La Parde de Haut-Bailly
Pessac-Leognan 10
Ch de Parenchere
Bordeaux Sup 08/09/10 (CS)
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Raphael 08/09/10
Esprit de Parenchere 08/09
Ch Pas de l’Ane
10 WS=88
10 WE=85
09 CF-CS-Merlot
08 Comm’d IWC 12
10 WS=87
08 Silver LA 11
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 CS-Merlot
08 Comm’d IWC 12
08 CF-CS-Merlot
St-Emilion 05/06/10
Ch Pasquet
10 WE=84
Bordeaux 10
10 $16 WE
Ch Passe Craby
Bordeaux Sup 07
Cab Sauv Medoc 05
Ch la Patache
Medoc Cab Sauv 10
Ch Patache d’Aux
10 $23-41 RP
10 $17 WS
10 $24 WS
10 ST=87
06 ST=87-89
05 ST=90
07 Silver LA 10
09 ST=89
09 RP=89-91
05 WS=85
Pomerol 05
06 $27 RP
05 $32-42 RP
03 $24-51 RP
06 $24 WS
04 $15 WS
03 RP=87-90
02 WS=85-88
10 45%Merlot-45%CabSauv-5%PetiteVerdot)
Dom de Passion Haut Brion Pessac-Leognan 09
Patache
06 WS=79
04 WS=85
03 WS=86
10 RP=87
05 WS=88
05 $73 RP
04 $90 RP
06 WE=85
06 WS=84
05 WE=86
05 WS=80-84
04 WE=85
03 WS=85
06 $12 WE
10 WS=90
10 RP=89
10 WE=87
10 $25 WS
10 $18 RP
10 $20 WE
Bronze Decanter 09
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WE=85
06 WE=87
06 WS=85
05 WE=89
05 RP=87
05 WS=89
05 SS=16/20
07 $19 WE06
06 $25 WE ?
06 $12 RP
05 $12 RP
151
04 Above average HJ
Ch Patris
Medoc Cuvee Flora 05/06
06 Vin Remarqiable Hachette 10
St-Emilion 05/06/08/09/10
10 90% Merlot
08 Merlot
06 Bronze IWC 10
Ch Pauillac
08=45%CS-55%M
Pauillac de Ch Latour
Pauillac 04/05/06/09
Ch Paveil de Luze
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 04/05/06/08/09/10
Ch Pavie
10/09 70%Merlot-20%CF-10%CS
04 WE=90
04 $17 RP
04 RC=89
03 Hach=1star
03 WS=86
03 WE=85
02 WE=85
06 WE=87
06 $40 WE
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
10 WS=89
10 $25 WS
10 RP=88
10 $23 RP
10 TWCI=87-89
08 WS=88
08 $25 WS
06 RP=86
06 $35 RP
06 WS=86
06 ST=85-88
05 WS=87
05 $23 RP
03 WS=88
09 RP=91-93
08 JJB=88-91
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=88
07 $45-50 RP
06 RP=88
06 $50 RP
09 Decanter=3star
09 Decanter=16/20
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=90
04 WS=85-88
03 WS=88
06 WS=85-88
05 ST=86-89
05 $150 Zachys
05 WS=92-94
05 ST=87-89
05 RP=90-92
05 $60-184 RP
04 WS=87
04 $65 WS
04 ST=87-89
04 RP=87
04 $29-80 RP
03 ST=87-89
03 RP=87
03 $42-179 RP
03/02 WS=85-88
02 ST=87-91
10 RP=92
10 $22-44 RP
09 WE=88
08 WE=90
08 ws=87
08 JR=16 (88)
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
06 RP=87
06 $22-33 RP
05 WS=83
05 $25 WS
05 $17-28 RP
04 WE=86
05 $25 Zachys
10 ST=93
09 ST=94
09 WE=96
09 RP=96-100
09 JJB=97-99
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 RP=96-98
08 WS=92-95
08 ST=92
08 JJB=93-95
07 RP=94
07 WE=93
07 WS=89-92
07 ST=93
09 $295+ ST
09 $260-375 RP
08 $150-216 RP
08 $215 Zachys
08 $160 K&L
07 $146-240 RP
07 $210 WE
07 $200 K&L
07 $215 Zachys
152
07 C$349 BCLS
Esprit de Pavie 12
Ch Pavie-Decesse
St-Emilion GC 02-10
06 WE=95
06/05 WS=95-100
06 RP=96
06 ST=92-94
05 Profound, extraordinary purity WW 05 RP=98-100
05 Monumental flavors Decanter 06
05 SS=19/20
05 WE=89
05 ST=96
05 WS=100
05 WD=14.5-15.5
04 WS=89-91
04 ST=93
03 WS=96
03 ST=92+
03 RP=98
02 WS=93
02 ST=92
01 WS=92
12 JR=15.5 (86)
10/09 90%Merlot-10%CF
10 ST=91
09 ST=93
09 RP=93-96
09 JJB=95-97
08 RP=94-96
08 WS=89-92
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=93
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=92
06 WS=89-91
06 RP=94+
06 ST=94
05 WS=96
06 $169-682 RP
06 C$449 BCLS
05 $405 WS
01 $190 B&M
09 $215+ ST
09 $165-225 RP
08 $120-173 RP
08 $165 Zachys
08 $120 K&L
07 $139-185 RP
07 $165 Zachys
07 C$299 BCLS
06 $154-236 RP
05 $300 WS
05 $275 Zachys
05 C$399 BCLS
Ch Pavie-Macquin
04 WS=89-91
04 ST=92
03 WS=93
02 WS=89
10/09 ST=91
10 $124+ ST
10 JJB=93
09 WE=92
09 RP=94-96+
09 $73-158 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 WE=94
08 RP=93-95
08 $52-90 RP
08 ST=90
08 $70 Zachys
08 WS=90-93
08 $70 K&L
08 JJB=91-93
07 WE=90
07 $55 WE
07 RP=91
07 $40-81 RP
07 WS=88-91
07 $57 K&L
07 ST=91
07 $60 Zachys
07 $72 B&M
07 C$89 BCLS
06 WE=92
06 Good WD
06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 $80 B&M
06 WS=93
06 $72 WS
06 RP=92+
06 $53-102 RP
06 ST=91-93
06 C$99 BCLS
05 Noble, great future SS in Decanter 05 SS=18/20
05 $180 K&L
05 RW=14.5-15.5
05 WE=92/94
05 RP=98
153
04=M75% CF25% CS5%
Ch Pavillon Bel Air
Lalande-de-Ponerol le Chapelain 08
Pavillon Rouge
Margaux 01-09 (Ch Margaux’s second wine)
(09=67%CS-29%M-4%PV)
08 Silver Paris 11
06 Cited wine Hachette 10
07=58%CS-37%Merlot-5%PV
05 Gorgeous aromas, silky WW 06
Ch Peby-Faugeres
St-Emilion GC 04-10
Pedesclaux
Paulliac 06/09
Ch Penin
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 Bronze LA 12
Bordeaux Sup Tradition 08
08 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Sup Grande Sel 08/09
09 Bronze Decanter 12; LA 11
05 W&S=94
05 WS=96
05 ST=95
04 WS=90
04 ST=91
03 WS=96
02 WS=92
08 WS=87
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=91-93
09 $160-326 RP
09 ST=90
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=18/20
08 RP=90-92
08 $229=300 RP
08 WS=87-90
08 $47 Zachys
08 WE=89-91
08 $45 K&L
08 ST=87
07 RP=88
07 $211-280 RP
07 ST=87-88
07 $65 K&L
07 WS=85-88
07 $65 Zachys
07 C$79 BCLS
06 WE=90
06 RP=86
06 $112 B&M
06 WS=88
06 WW=87-88
05 WE=91/92
05 ST=89-92
05 WS=92
05 RP=91-93
05 $120 B&M
04 WS=88
04 RP=89-91
04 ST=91-93
04 WW=90-92
03 WE=90
04 $78 B&M
03 RP=92
03 WS=92
03 ST=93
02 RP=87
02 WS=86
01 RP=87
01 WS=89
01 WS=91
10 ST=88
09 RP=93-96
09 $82-119 RP
08 RP=92-94
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=90+
07 $125-135 RP
07 WS=87-90
07 $95 Zachys
06 RP=93+
06 $67-85 RP
06 WS=92
06 $84 WS
05 WS=94
05 $94 WS
05 $145 Zachys
04 WS=91
04 $63 WS
04 RP=91-94
04 $71 RP
03 RP=93
09 JJB=92-94
09 $28 JJG
09 WE=91
09 WS=90-93
09 RP=85-87
09 $28-51RP
154
08 Coeur Delection Hachette 11
08 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Sup Les Cailloux 10
08 €8-11 Hach
10 Bronze LA 12
Les Pensees de Lafleur
Pomerol 05-09 (07=62%Merlot-CF)
Ch de Perenchere
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=89-91
07 ST=85-88
07 WS=85-88
05 WS=94
04 IWR=87
Cuvee Raphael Bordeaux Superieur 03
03 IWR=91
Ch Perenne (Magrez)
Prem Cotes de Blaye 05/06/08/09/10
08 Silver Paris 11
06 Gold Paris 09
10 $16 RP
06 $18-20 RP
05 $15 K&L
04 $30 WR
10 $13 WE
10 $22 RP
Ch des Perligues
Graves 10
Ch Perron
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=86
Graves 05
05 WE=86
Ch Petit Bocq
05 $145 WS
10 RP=84
08 RP=87-89
06 WS=85-88
06 RP=88
05 RP=89-90
04 WR=90
10 WE=87
04 Exceedingly enjoyable WR
09 $183 RP
08 $150 Zachys
07 C$139 BCLS
10 RP=88
09 Merlot
07/06 Bronze Decanter 10
04 Gold Bruxelles 06, Bordeaux 07
04 Silver MVini 06, IWC 07
10 75%Merlot-25%CF
09 65%CF-35%Merlot
10 $15-21 RP
09 $19 JJB
08 WS=87
08 RP=86-87
08 JJB=86-88
05 SS=16/20
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=85
05 $19 Zachys
Ch Petit-Figeac
St-Emilion 06
03 WS=87
10 ST=87
09 ST=89
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=90-92
07 ST=89
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
05 WE=90
05 WS=89
08 RP=85-87
07 WS=84-87
06 WS=89
05 WS=89
05 NM=92
04 WS=85
03 WS=83
06 WS=87
Ch Petit-Freylon
Bordeaux Cuvee Michael 10
10 WS=86
10 $11 WS
Ch Petit-Gravet-Aine
St-Emilion GC 04-09 (07=80%CF-20%Merlor)
09 RP=88-91
09 $30 RP
Le Petit Cheval
St-Emilion 04-10 (Cheval Blanc’s 2nd wine)
Ch Petit-Faurie-de-Soutard
St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/08
1- $230+ ST
09 $159-200 RP
08 $85 Zachys
07 $92-226 RP
07 $99 Zachys
05 $137 WS
05 C$209 NM
06 $45 WS
155
Le Petit Haut Lafitte
Pessac-Leognan 09
La Petit Lion
09
Ch Le Petit Mouton
Pauillac03-09 (Ch Mouton’s 2nd wine)
Ch Petit-Village
Pomerol 04-10
La Petite Eglise
Pomerol 05/06/07
Ch Petrus
Pomerol 99-10
08 RP=89-91
07 ST=87
06 RP=84
06 WBlB=86
06 ST=87-89
05 ST=91
05 RP=89-91
04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 04/03 Hach=1star
03 WS=85-88
09 WS=90
06 $45 RP
06 $14-28 WBlB
04 $42-50 RP
09 $30 Costco
09 RP=87-89
09 RP=90-92
08 ST=87
08 RP=89-91
08 JJB=88-90
08 JJB=86-88
07 WE=87
07 ST=88
07 RP=84-87
07 WS=85-88
06 WE=89
06 RP=90
06 WS=87
05 ST=87-90
05 WS=89
05 RP=90
03 WS=88
10 ST=90
09 ST=88
09 WE=92
09 RP=88-90
08 ST=89
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=78-82
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=88
06 WE=91
06 RP=88
06 Interesting WD
06 WD=14.5-15.5
06 ST=88-89
06 WS=88
05 WE=90/93
05 WS=92
05 ST=89
05 WD=15-16/20
05 RP=86-88
04 WS=90
04 ST=87-89
04 RP=87
03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 ST=86
03 RP=86
03 WS=90
07 WW=87-88
10/09 100%Merlot
09 $100-159 RP
08 $217-266 RP
07 $75 WE
07 $187-230 RP
07 $70 Zachys
05 $95 B&M
05 $89 WS
05 $60-97 RP
09 $55-78 RP
08 $44-46 RP
07 $51-64 RP
06 $63 RP
06 $47 K&L
06 $49 WS
05 $56 WS
05 $53-60
04 $52 WS
04 $50 RP
07 $35 B&M
06 $30 WClub
05 WS=86
10 ST=96
10 $2699+ ST
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=19/20
09 WE=98
09 ST=97
09 RP=96-100
09 $2475+
08 ST=93
08 RP=98-100
08 $3362+ RP
08 JJB=97-99
08 $3000 K&L
08 JJB=92-94
07 RP=91
07 $1494+
156
07 WS=89-92
07 ST=92
06 WE=96/97
06 RP=93+
06 ST=92-94
06 WS=94
05 RP=98-100
05 Great wine W&S 4/06
05 W&S=3stars
05 WE=96/100
05 WS=100
05 ST=96+?
04 RP=90-93
04 WS=93
04 ST=93
03 RP=95
03 WS=98
03 ST=93+
02 RP=90
02 WS=93
02 ST=92
01 RP=95
01 WS=95
01 ST=92+
01 TA=5stars
00 RP=100
00 WS=98
00 ST=96
99 RP=94
99 WS=90
99 ST=91-93
07 $1300 K&L
07 C$1800 BCLS
06 $1388+ RP
06 $2000 WS
05 $3488+
05 $4975 WS
See also: Ch La Fleur-Petrus
Ch Petrus Gaia
Bordeaux Superieur 08/09/10
09 Outperformed Price JJG
Ch le Peuy-Saincrit
Bordeaux Sup Montalon Vieilles Vignes 06/10
Ch le Pey
BordeauxCru Bourgeois 08 (CS-Merlot)
Ch Pey la Tour (Dourthe)
Bordeaux 08/09/10
08 Gold Paris 10
08 Classic Character G&M
10 CF-CS-Merlot
10 ST=86
09 JJB=92-94
09 RP=88-90
09 WS=88-91
08 RP=87-89
08 JR=15.5 (86)
06 WS=69
08 G&M=89
08 C$18 LCBO
10 WE=85
10 $13 WE
09 JR=14.5 (82)
08 JR=15 (84)
10 RP=86-88
10 TWCI=86-88
Bordeux Sup 08/09/10
09 $16 JJB
09 $16-19 RP
09 $19 K&L
10 $16 RP
Bordeaux Sup Res de Ch 04-10 (org grapes)
10 Silver LA; Bronze IWC 12
10 CS-Merlot-PV
09 Merlot-CS
09 Comm’d IWC 10
08 Gold Paris 09
08 Silver Brussels 10; Decanter 09
07 Gold Brussels 09; Challenge 10
07 Bronze IWC 09
07 Comm’d IWC 10
08 AG=84
08 WS=83
08 NM=87
07 WE=87
07 NM=87
05 RP=87
04 RP=84-86
10 RP=87
09 RP=87-89
09 WS=85-88
08 WS=87
07 NM=87
08 C$14 LCBO
08 $13 WS
08 C$19 BCLS
07 $18 WE
07 C$14 LCBO
10 $22 RP
08 $15 WS
07 C$20 LCBO
07 C$24 BCLS
157
06 Gold Paris, Bordeaux 07
06 Bronze IWC 09
06/05 Comm’d IWC 07/06
06 Bronze IWSC 07
05 Silver IWS 07, Brussels 07
05 Bronze Decanter 06, IWC 06
05 Gold Brussels 06
Ch Peychaud
Cotes de Bourg Maisonneuve 06
Bordeaux Cuvee Spec 05
Peyfaures
Ch Peymouton
06 WS=83
06 AG=88
06 $13 WS
06 C$27 BCLS
06 C$18 AB
05 WS=89
05 $18 WS
05 W&S=86
06 WS=81
05 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=88/87
10 $20 RP
Dame de Coeur 10
10 RP=88
10 $24 RP
St.-Emilion GC 06
Ch Peynaud
Bordeaux Sup 09
Ch Peyrabon
Haut Medoc 02-10
06 WS=89
03 Bronze East 06
09 Silver LA 10
$13 East
09 LA=92
10 WS=91
10 RP=86
Ch Peyrat-Fourthon
Haut-Medoc 09/10
Ch la Peyre
St-Estephe 04/05
09 CS-Merlot-PV
07 Comm’d IWC 10
06 Bronze IWC 09
05 RP=84-86
04 Bronze IWC 07
03 WE=89
02 WE=88
10 RP=88
Haut-Medoc 06
Ch Peyroutas
St-Emilion Terra Burigala 06
Ch de Pez
St-Estephe Cru Beorgeois 04-09
06 WS=82
10 52.5%CS-47.5%Merlot
09 47%CS-47M-PV
05 Comm’d IWC 10
Bordeaux Cru Bourgeois Sup Except 04/05
Ch Pezat
Bordeaux Rouge Sup 04-10
04 Silver IWC 07
10 ST=86
09 ST=90
08 Decanter=4star
08 SS=16.5/20
07 WS=85
07 RP=87-88
07 W&S=NR
06 WE=91
06 RP=88
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
05 NM=91
05 W&S=90
04 WS=85
04 WE=91
03 WS=87
10 RP=88
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=85-87
10 $25 WS
10 $12-17 RP
09 $15 JJB
10 $22 RP
06 $33 WS
07 $46 W&S
06 $28-32 RP
06/05 $39 WS
05 $40 K&L
05 C$64 NM
04 $30 WS
04 $36 B&M
03 $36 WS
05 $50 Dec
10 $9-16 RP
09 $12 JJB
158
05 Gold Brussels 07
Ch Phelan-Segur
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Exceptionel 03-10
10 59%Merlot-42%CS
06 Decent WD
Ch Pibran
Paulliac Cru Bourgeois 04-10
10 50%Merlot-50%CS
09 60%Merlot-40%CS
06 Not impressive WD
05 12 outstanding Values QRW 06
04 Editor’s Choice WE 05
Ch Picampeau
Ch Picard
St-Estephe 05/06 (06=CS)
03 Smart Buy WS 3/31/06
05 Best Buy W&S 10/08
06 Comm’d IWC 09
Ch Picau-Perna
06 WE=87
05 WE=85
04 WE=87
10 ST=88
10 JJB=90
09 WE=90
09 ST=87
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=87
08 WE=90
08 RP=88-90
08 JJB=82-83
08 SS=16+/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WE=90
07 RP=86-88
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=85
06 RP=88
06 WE=88
06 WD=15-16/20
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=88
05 WE=92/91
05 ST=87-89
05 WS=89
05 SS=16.5/20
05 RP=89-91
04 WS=88
04 WE=89
04 ST=86=88
04 RP=87
04 WW=88-91
06 $20 WE
05 $22 WE
10 ST=87
09 WE=91
09 ST=88
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5
08 SS=16+/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=86
07 ST=86
06 WD=13-14/20
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=90
05 WS=92
05 WE=89
05 ST=87-89
05 RP=86-88
04 WE=91
04 WS=87
04 ST=86-88
03 WS=92
03 RP=87-89
03 ST=86-89
05 W&S=84
10 $49+ ST
08 $25-37
08 $29 K&L
07 $33 WE
07 $26-35 RP
07 $35 K&L
07 $32 Zachys
06 $29-40 RP
06 $33 WS
05 $42 WS
05 $35-45 RP
04 $28 WS
04 $25-48
07 C$45 BCLS
06 $24 RP ?
06 $56 WS
05 $25 WS
04 $29-30 RP
05 $18 W&S
05 $15 JJB
06 WS=86
06 $17 WS
05 WS=87
05 $18 WS
St-Emilion 11
Ch PichonLongueville Baron Paulliac 2nd Cru 03-11
09 $35-52 RP
08 $29 WS
05 WE=84
11 RP=90-92
11 WS=92-95
11 WE=93-95
11 $17 Astor
05 $15 WE
159
Paulliac les Tourelles de Longueville 08/10
Ch Pichon-Longueville
Comtesse de Lalande
Paulliac GC 02-10
11 ST=91-93
11 JS=92-93
11 NM=93-95
10 79%CS-21%Merlot
10 ST=93
10 JJB=100
09 67%CS-Merlot
09 WE=96
09 ST=93
09 RP=93-95
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08 WS=91
08 ST=90
08 RP=92-94
08 WE=91-96
08 JJB=89-91
08 JJB=97-89
07 WE=93
07 RP=90-92
07 ST=91
07 WS=88-91
07 WS=88-92
06 WE=93/93
06 Top Pick K&L
06 WS=92
06 RP=92
06 ST=91-93
05 WS=94
05 W&S=96
05 WE=96/93
05 Geogeous intensity, powerful WW 05 RP=94
05 Balanced, elegant RW 3/06
05 RW=17-18/20
05 Could be very good indeed WD
05 WD=17-18/20
05 ST=94+?
05 WW=92-94
04 WE=86
04 RP=93
04 WS=91
04 ST=89-93
03 WD-17.5/20
03 ST=93
03 WS=95
03 WE=93
02 Highly Rec’d WS
02 WS=93
02 ST=92+
10 60%Merlot-40%CS
10 ST=86
08 WS=87
10 66%CS-24%Merlot-7%CF-3%PV 10 ST=85
10 JJB=94
09 75%CS-20%M-PV
09 WE=95
09 ST=93
09 RP=96-98
09 WS=95-98
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08=88
08 RP=94-96
08 WE=94
08 WS=89/91
08 JJB=92-94
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=89
07 WE=91
07 ST=89
07 AG=88
07 WS=88-91
06 WE=94/94
06 RP=95
10 $205+ ST
09 $140+ ST
09 $125-180 RP
08 $69 K&L
08 $66-137 RP
08 $80 Zachys
07 C$109 BCLS
07 $73-105 RP
07 $93 Zachys
07 $115 B&M
07 $90 K&L
06 $135 B&M
06 C$159 BCLS
06 $65-150 RP
05 C$225 BCLS
05 $190 WClub
04 $60 B&M
10 $190+ ST
09 $190 K&L
09 $172-241 RP
08 $93-168 RP
08 $75 Zachys
08 $110 K&L
07 $85-123 RP
07 $120 B&M
07 $100 K&L
07 C$129 AG
07 $150 Zachys
07 C$129 BCLS
06 $200 B&M
06 $100 K&L
160
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Fine intensity, perky finish WW
03 A success WD
06 ST=91-93
06 WE=94/94
06 WS=92
05 WS=93
05 WE=95
05 ST=90
05 WW=93=94
05 RP=88-90
04 WE=94
04 WS=90
04 ST=90
04 RP=92
03 ST=93
06 C$199 BCLS
05 $160 B&M
05 $150 K&L
05 C$245 BCLS
05 $119-200 RP
04 $70 B&M
03 WD=18+/20
03 WE=94
03 WS=93
03 RP=95
02 ST=92+
See also their second wine: Res de la Comtesse
Ch Picque Caillon
Pessac-Leognan 04/06/09/10
10 JS=91-92
10 CellarT 88 (6)
09 WS=90-93
09 ST=87
10 $27 Zachys
10 $?? JJB Fut
09 $18 JJB
09 $30+ ST
Ch Pierhem
Pomerol 04/08
Ch Pierrail
Bordeaux Sup 10
Pierre Dumontet
Ch Pierre de Lune
08 RP=82-84
10 Silver LA 12
10 WE=89
10 $30 WE
St-Emilion Fleur de Roc 10
10 WS=87
10 $20 WS
St-Emilion 03/04/05/06/07/09
09 RP=92-94
07 RP=91
07 ST=86
06 RP=92
05 ST=89-92
05 RP=94-96
04 RP=86
04 WS=75-79
03 RP=92
10 WE=89
09 $35-40 RP
07 $60-75 RP
07 $47 K&L
06 $45-47 RP
Ch Pierre de Montignac
Medoc 10
Medoc Cuvee Fernand Ginestet 03/04/05
Medoc Eleve en fut de chene 04/05/06
Ch le Pin
Pomerol 04-10
05 WS=89
04 WS=86
04 Gold Regional Trophy decanter 06 03 WS=87
03/02 Bronze Blaye & Bourg 05
10/09 100%Merlot
10 ST=94
09 ST=93
09 RP=95-98
08 WS=93
08 ST=93
08RP=94-96
07 RP=89
07 ST=87
07 WS=90-93
06 Gold Paris 07
06 RP=93
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=93
05 WW=98-100
10 $25 WE
03 $16 WS
05 €5-8 Hach
09 $2199 RP
08 $1811+ RP
07 $1095+ RP
06 $1260+ RP
06 $2500 WS
161
Ch le Pin Beausoleil
05 ST=91-93
05 WS=94
05 RP=94-96
04 WS=92
04 RP=95
02 WS=93
01 WS=95
10 RP=85-87
10 JR=14.5 (82)
Bordeaux Sup 03-10
05 $2500 WS
10 $19 RP
Ch Pin de Graves
Bordeaux Merlot 08
08 Bronze LA 10
Bordeaux Rencontre 08
08 Bronze LA 10
Ch Pind Fleurs
St-Emilion GC 06/07
06 Gold Brussels 09
Ch Pindefleurs
Ch de Piote
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Sup 10 (org grapes)
Ch Pipeau
St-Emilion GC 03-12
Ch Pique-Caillou
Ch di Pitray
Ch Plaisance
Cuvee Alix 05/06/07/10
Bordeaux 08
10 Silver LA 12
08 WS=87
06 ST=85-87
05 ST=89
05 RP=88-90
03 RP=87
03 WS=80-84
05 $19 RP
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=88-90
10 WS=90
09 RP=88-90
10 $25 WS
12 $25 Zachys
11 RP=87-89
11 $25 Zachys
09 RP=90-92
09 $24-27 RP
08 RP=89-91
07Gold Brussels; Comm’d Decante 10 07 WS=87
07 $26 WS
06 RP=88
06 $23-40 RP
06 WS=90
06 NM=88
06 C$29 LCBO
06 ST=87-90
06 $23 JJB
05 Nothing special SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=14/20
05 $31 Zachys
05 #45 Top 100 Wines of 2008 WS
05 WS=92
05 $30 WS
05 RP=90-92
05 $23-26 RP
04 WS=91
04 RP=90
02 Gold Brussels 07
03 Smart Buy WS 06
03 WS=90
03 RP=88
10 JS=93
10 $27 Zachys
09 WE=94
05 WS=85-88
06 $15-17 RP
05 WE=91
05 $16-30 RP
05 WE=91
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=84
04 $25 WS
04 WS=84
04 $25 WS
04 RP=85
04 $17-26 RP
03 RP=86
03 $15 RP
03 WS=86
02 WE=87
09 RC=87+
09 $10 Costco
09 RP=87-89
10 RP=88
10 $22 RP
07 RP=86-88
05 ST=89
05 $20 K&L
05 RP=90
05 $20 WClub
08 JR=16 (88)
08 €8-11 Hach
162
Montagne St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09/10
07 Bronze Paris 09
Cotes-de-Bourg 05/06/09
09 Gold Paris 11
St-Emilion 05/06/08
05 WS=83
05 $20 K&L
05 $18 WS
03 WS=75-79
10 WE=89
10 $25 WE
05 WE=88
05 €8-11 Hach
05 WS=88
05 $14 WS
05 snooth=3½ stars 05 $17 snooth
00 WS=89
05 WE=89
05 $20 WE
08 WS=89
06 WS=85
St-Emilion Vieux Ch des Moines 08
Plaisir du Siurac
08 WS=87
07 WE=86
08 $20 Dec
07 $22 WE
07 $15 K&L
Ch Plant de Maune
St-Emiliom 05
05 WS=87
Ch Plantey
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=89
10 $25 RP
Les Plantiers de Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 05
05 WS=88
05 $60 WS
Clos de Plince
09 WS=91-94
09 $25 JJB
09 $30 Zachys
Pomerol 03/04/05/09
Clos des Prince
Ch Plince
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch le Plume Blanche
Bordeaux 09
Le Plus de Fleur de Bouard
See Ch la Fleur de Bouard
Ch la Pointe
Pomerol 04-10
04 WS=87
03 WS=88
09 WS=91-94
08 WS=89
10 ST=86tt
09 WE=89
09 ST=87
09 JR=16.5/20
08 RP=85-87
08 JJB=87-89
08 JR=16/20
07 RP=79-82
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=84
07 JR=15.5/20
06 Gold Paris 09
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=89
06 JR=16.5/20
05 WS=85-88
04 ST=87
03 WS=86
08 Bronze LA 10
09 85%Merlot-CF
10 ST=87
09 ST=91
09 RP=88-90
08 ST=87
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=87
06 WE=89
03 $45 WS
09 $25 JJB
08 $25 K&L
07 $29-38 RP
07 $25 K&L
06 $28 JJB
09 $35-46 RP
08 $22-33 RP
07 $21-27 RP
163
Dom la Pointe
Pomerol 06
Ch Poitevin
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 09/10
06 RP=88
06 WS=90
05 Full-bodied, soft and long WW 06 05 WS=91
05 WE=92
05 RP=85-87
04 WS=88
04 RP=87
03 RP=86
10 Merlot-CS-PV
06 $30 RP
05 $80 WS ?
10 WS=90
10 $15 WS
10 RP=85
10 $14 K&L
10 WE=90
10 $16 Zachys
10 CellarT 89 (11)
10 JR=14.5 (82)
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 CS-Merlot-PV
05 WS=86
Ch Pomeaux
Pomerol 04/05/06/08
Ch Pomys
Ch Pontac-Lynch
Haut-Medoc Moulis 07/09
St-Estephe 04/06
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 06/08
Margaux Quintessance 10
Pontac Monplaisir
08
Ch Pontet Bel Air
Bordeaux 09
Ch Pontet-Canet
08 RP=87-89
06 RP=88
05 WS=
06 $50 RP
09 WE=88
09 $12 JJB
08 SS=15.5/20
08 Decanter=3star
06 WE=85
06 WS=84
08 RP=88-90
09 C$14 LCBO
10 65%CS-30%M-4%CF-1%PV
06 Top Pick K&L
05 Best ever! WW 06
05 Very good indeed RW 3/06
10 ST=94
09 WE=99
09 ST=91
09 RP=97-100
09 WS=95-98
09 JJB=95-97
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08 WE=95
08 RP=96-98
08 ST=91
08 WS=90-93
08 JJB=93-95
08 JJB=90-92
07 WE=94
07 RP=91-94
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=92
06 WE=92
06 RP=95+
06 ST=91-94
06 WS=93
05 ST=95
05 WS=96
05 WE=93/94
05 WD=16.5-17.5
05 RP=93-95
09 $160 K&L
09 $30+ ST
09 $108-325 RP
08 $75-142 RP
08 $125 Zackys
08 $90 K&L
08 $75 WE
07 $56-110 RP
07 $83 K&L
07 $90 B&M
07 C$119 BCLS
06 $130 B&M
06 $56-233 RP
164
oiio
Pailliac les Hauts de Pontet-Canet 08
04 WS=93
05 WE=93
05 WW=95-98
05 WD=16.5-17.5
04 RP=90-93
04 WS=93
04 WE=93
04 ST=91+
04 WC=4½stars
03 RP=95
03 WS=94
03 WE=91
03 WD=17/20
02 RP=88
02 WS=92
02 ST=91
01 RP=89
01 WS=90
01 ST=90
00 RP=92
00 WS=93
00 ST=93
00 WE=90
99 RP=88
99 ST=88
08 WS=88
Ch Pontey
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=86
10 $16 RP
Ch Pontoise Cabarrus
Haut-Medoc 10
Ch Portillon
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=90
10 WS=89
10 RP=89
10 WE=86
10 $19 WE
10 $19 WS
10 $11-16 RP
10 $14 WE
Ch Potensac
Medoc Delon 02-11
11 JR=90
11 $23 JJB Fut
11 $23 Zachys
04 Highly Rec’d WS 2/15/07
03 #39 Top 100 wines of 2006 WS
03 Very good WD 10/05 03 ST=93
01 Gold IWC 07
03 $60 B&M
02 $60 K&L
00 $120 WClub
08 $27 WS
10 WE=90-92
10 RP=88
10 $21-49 RP
10 TWCI=88-90
09 Merlot-CS-CF
09 ST=89
09 $25+ ST
09 WE=92
09 $25 K&L
09 RP=89-91
09 $24-38 RP
09 Decanter=3star 09 $25 JJB
09 Decanter=16/20
08 RP=90-92
08 ST=87
08 $29 WClub
08 WE=91
08 WS=87
08 SS=16+/20
08 $26 WS
08 Decanter=3star
07 WS=85
07 $25 WS
07 WE=90
07 ST=85
06 WE=90
06 ST=86-88
06 RP=88
06 WS=86
06 JR=15.5 (86)
05 WE=92
05/04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=90
05 WS=88
05 RP=85-86
04 WE=91
04 WS=88
04 ST=86
04 WR=88
04 RP=84-86
04/03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08/07 03 WS=88
165
Medoc Chapelle de Potensac 06/08
Ch Pouget
Ch Poujeaux
Ch Poumey
Margaux 4th Cru Classe 02-09 (Cab Sauv)
Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 04-10
Moulis 10
03 ST=89
03 RP=89
02 ST=85
02 RP=85
08 WS=85
07 WE=87
06 WE=86
09 RP=85-87
09 WS=93-96
08 WS=87
07 WS=86
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=93
04 WS=88
02 WS=88
01 WS=87
10 RP=90
10 ST=88
10 TWCI=91-93
10 JJB=90
09 WE=91
09 ST=90
09 RP=90-93
08 RP=89-91
08 WS=87
08 SS=16+/20
08 Decanter=3star
07=65%CS-30%Merlot-5%PV
07 WS=88
07 WE=90
07 ST=85
06 Not a great success WD
06 RP=89
06 WE=92
06 WS=89
06 WD=12-13/20
06 ST=87-89
05 Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 W&S=1star
05 Full-bodied, fine tannins, long WW 05 WE=93
05 WS=88
05 ST=87-90
05 RP=89-91
05 SS=16/20
04 WE=92
04 WS=90
04 RP 90.
04 ST=86-89
04 RP=90
03 WS=88
03 RP=88
02 WE=91
02 RP=87
10 WS=87
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
Ch la Prade
Bordeaux Cotes de Francs 04-10
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=87-88
07 ST=84
06 ST=85-88
05 WS=92-94
05 RP=87-89
05 ST=89
04 WS=90
04 RP=86-88
03 WS=84
03 RP=84
10 WS=90
10 RP=86+
10 TWCI=89-90
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=85
09 $43 K&L
08 $24 WS
05 $50 WS
10 $25-57 RP
09 $27-50 RP
08 $20-31 RP
08 $27 WS
08 $24 K&L
07 $28 WS
07 $31 B&M
07 $28 K&L
06 $20-48 RP
06 $27.57 B&M
05 $44 B&M
04 $30 B&M
04 $32 K&L04
10 $20 WS
10 $17 WS
10 $12-20 RP
09 $16-18 RP
08 $20 WS
166
06 Simple WD
Premius
See: Yvon Mau
Premya
Presidial (Thunevin)
05 Very Successful Hacjette 09
Puissequin-St-Emilion 05/06
Bordeaux 04/05
08 RP=88-89
08 JJB=85-87
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
06 WD=13-14/20
06 ST=86-89
05 IWR=87
05 WS=89-91
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=81
04 RP=89
08 $19-20 RP
06 $25 RP
06 $15 WS ?
05 $23 Zachys
05 $23 IWR
ST=86-89
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=86-87
04 WS=83
See also: Thunevin Presidial and Calvet-Thunevin Presidial
Ch de Pressac (B Magrez)
Ch Preuillac (Yvon Mau)
St-Emilion GC 03-10
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03-10
Ch de Prieur
Cuvee Res 10
Ch du Prieur
Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 07/08/09
Ch le Prieure
Mouillac 06
08 Gold Brussels 10
05 Gold Brussels 07, Challenge 07
04 Silver Paris 07
10 CS-Merlot
09 Silver IWSC; Bronze Decanter 12
08 Merlot
10 RP=89
10 ST=87
10 $22-39 RP
09 $25 JJB
08 WS=90
07 WS=85-88
06 WS=90
05 WS=92
05 $45 WS
05 $24 RP
04 WS=90
03 WS=85
10 RP=88
10 $18 RP
08 WS=89
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 Bronze Paris 09; Decanter 10
07 Comm’d IWC 10
06 NM=91
06 WE=90
06 WS=87
05 WS=86
05 Comm’d IWC 07; Hachette 09
05 WE=90
05 NM=90
04 Gold Bordeaux, Challenge 06
04 WE=89
04 Bronze Paris 06
04 Approved MondusVini 06
03 Great Gold Brussels 06
03 WS=82
03 Bronze IWC, Decanter, Bordeaux 06
02 Gold Brussels 06
10 Best Buy WE
10 WE=87
09 IWR=87
07 JR=14.5 (82)
06 ST=86-89
06 C$30 NM
06 $30 WE
06 $34 WS
05 $23 WS
05 $21 WE
05 $30 NM
10 $12 WE
09 $10 IWR
167
St-Emilion GC 03-09 07=85%Merlot-15%CF
St-Emilion Delice du Prieure GC 07
09 RP=89-92
08 WS=90
08 RP=88-90
07 WE=89
07 ST=87
06 WS=86
05 WS=89
04 WS=85-88
03 WS=88
07 WE=87
Prieure-Canteloup
09
09 RP=87-89
Ch Prieure-Lichine
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
03 #63 Top 100 WS 06
Ch Prieurs de Commanderie Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08
06 Very Succeaaful Hachette 10
Promesse de Soleil
Ch la Providence
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08/09/10
05 Coup de Ceour Hachette 09
10ST=86
09 WE=93
09 ST=88
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=88-91
08 JJB=83-85
07 RP=88
07 WE=90
07 WS=87-90
07 ST=88
06 WE=88
06 RP=90
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=89
05 WE=93
05 WS=92
05 ST=90
04 WS=87
04 WE=91
04 ST=88
03 WS=92
02 WS=88
01 WS=87
00 WS=91
99 WW=89
99 WS=82
03 WD=15.5/20
03 ST=89
96 WW=89
08 RP=87-88
07 WS=83-86
07 WS=88-91
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=87
05 WS=89-91
04 WS=88
06 WS=81
10 ST=92
09 ST=89
09 RP=92-95
08 WE=92
08 RP=95-97
08 JJB=93-95
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=89+
07 ST=87
07 AG=86
06 RP=93
06 WE=92
06 WS=89
05 WE=90
05 ST=89
05 WS=95
09 $38-47 RP
07 $42 WE
06 $30 WS
07 $35 WE
10 $68+ ST
09 $45-65 RP
08 $37 Zachys
07 $31-47 RP
07 $40 WE
07 $40 Zachys
06 $32-55 RP
06 $40 K&L
06 $41 WS
05 $55 Zachys
05 $50 WS
04 $35 WS
06 $21 RP
09 $130+ ST
09 $94-117 RP
08 $81-100 RP
08 $90 K&L
07 $75-93 RP
07 C$119 BCLS
07 C$119 AG
06 $88-136 RP
06 $103 WS
05 $93 WS
168
Ch Puisseguin la Rigodrie
Clos Puy Arnaud
Cotes de Castillon 05/06/07/08/09/10
05 RP=90-92
03 WS=85-88
03 RP=87-90
ST=89-92
09 WS=88
05 $90 RP
09 $14 WS
10 RP=87
10 $22-36 RP
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5/20
09 RP=89-91+
09 $27 RP
08 RP=88-91+
08 $21 RP
07 WS=90
07 $21 WS
07 RP=80
07 $17-21 RP
07 ST=86
07 $22 Zachys
Ch Puy-Arnaud
Cote de Castillon 04/05/06/07/08
08 JBB=87-89
05 RP=88
05 WS-89-91
04 RP=88
04 WS=82
03 RP=90
03 WS=85
Ch Puy-Blanquet
St-Emilion GC 06/07/08/09/10/11
09 Bargain Snooth.com
Ch Puy Castera
Haut-Medoc 03/04/08
Ch Puyfromage
Bordeaux
Ch Puygueraud
Bordeaux-Cotes-de-Francs 03-10
10 ST=86
10 RP=88-90
09 ST=87
09 WE=90
09 JS=90
09 JR=15.5 (86)
08 JJB=87-89
06 WS=82
02 WW=87
02 WS=80-84
08 WS=87
04 WE=89
06 $18-20 RP
05 $24-30 RP
05 $28 Zachys
05 $25 WClub
04 $23 RP
11 $19 Zachys
11 $20 wine.com
10 $25 Zachys
09 $20+ ST
09 $24 K&L
06 $18 WS
08 $30 WS
C$14.25 LCBO
10 80%Merlot-15%CF-5%Malbec
Cotes de Francs Cuvee George 01-10
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
10 TWCI=87-89
10 JS=92
09 RP=90
09 WS=89
09 JS=92
08 WS=87
08 JJB=87-89
07 WS=85
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
06 ST=88
05 WS=92
05 ST=87-90
05 RP=89
04 WS=80-84
04 ST=87
03 WS=89
03 ST=86
10 WS=91
10 RP=89
06 RP=83
06 WS=90
06 ST=87-90
10 $17 WS
10 $11-25 RP
10 $20 wine.com
09 $14-22 RP
09 $17 K&L
08 $18 WS
07 $11 WS
06 $11-18 RP
06 $15 WS
06 $18 K&L
06 C$22 LCBO
05 $17 Zachys
05 $25 K&L
05 $25 JJB
10 $20 WS
10 $14-19 RP
06 $15-20 RP
06 $22 WS
169
06 AG=86
Ch Puy Guilhem
Fromsac 09
09 90%Merlot-10%Malbec
09 Gold Paris 12
Ch Puynard
04 WS=85-88
04 ST=89
03 WS=88
02 ST=87
01 WS=87
01 TA=4stars
09 JS=93
09 WSJ=91
09 CellarT 88 (3)
06 WS=84
Ch Puynormond
Montagne-St-Emilion VV 04/05/06/07/08/09
06 C$39 AG
09 $21 Zachys
10 $13 Sh-L
06 $18 WS
05 $19 Dec
03 BTI=86
03 $18.50 BTI
Bordeaux Res 07 (Merlot-CS)
08 NM=87
08 NM=87/89
07 NM=87
08 C$14 NM
07 C$14 NM
07 C$20 NM
Ch Quancard
Merlot-Cab Res 05
05 WW=88
05 $13 B&M
Ch Quinault L’Enclos
St Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
09 WE=91
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=90-92
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=91-93
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=89
06 RP=90
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=88
05 RP=92-94
09 $28-40 RP
08 $27-44 RP
08 $34 Zachys
07 $35-41 RP
07 $40 K&L
07 $40 Zachys
06 $32-54 RP
06 C$65 BCLS
06 $41 WS
05 $36 B&M
05 WS=92
05 ST=93
04 WS=87
04 WE=92
04 ST=90
04 RP=91
03 RP=89
03 WS=90
00 RP=92-94
00 $59 B&M
Ch Puy la Tour
Bordeaux 07/08 (Merlot-CS)
05 Elegant, intense flavor WW 06
Cuvee Lafleur Kosher 06
06 RP=88
06 ST=89-91
L’Absolute de Quinault St-Emilion 07
07 ST=87
06 $45 RP
See also their second wine: Lafleur de Quinault
Ch Rahoul
Graves 05/06/08/09
05 Bronzr Decanter 10
Ch Ramafort
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 04/05/06/07
09 WE=91
09 ST=87
09 RP=82-85
08 RP=85-87
06 RP=74
06 WS=82
05 WE=88
05 WS=85
07 WE=84
06 $30 RP
06 $25 WS
05 $30 Dec
07 $26 WE
06 $20 Dec
05 WS=83
170
04 WE=89
03 WS=88
Ch Ramage la Batisse
Bordeaux 09
09 Comm’d IWC 12
09 CF-CS-Merlot
Haut-Medoc 09/10
Ch la Rame
Bordeaux 09/10
Ch Rauzan-Despagne
Bordeaux Grand Vin de Bordeaux 03-10
10 RP=88
06 WS=85
05 WS=88
10 $21 RP
10 WE=90
09 WE=84
10 WS=85
09 RP=88-90
10 $16 WE
09 $17 WE
10 $15 WS
09 $17 JJB
06 RP=86
06 WS=84
05 RP=88-90
05 WE=88
05 WS=80-84
05 Hach=2stars
05 RP=89-90
05 $17 RP
04 WS=83
03 WS=84
03 RP=89
10 WE=90
06 $20 RP
06 C$16 LCBO
05 $17 JJB
08 WS=86
Ch Rauzan Gassies
Bordeaux Res 10
10 Best Buy WE
Ch Rauzan-Segla
10 60%CS-35%M-3.5%PV-1.5%CF
09 58%CS-Merlot)
10 ST=88
09 WE=91
09 ST=88
09 RP=89-91
08 JJB=85-87
08 RP=88-90
07 WE=86
07 RP=81-84
06 WE=87
06 RP=89
06 WS=87
05 W&S=1½stars
05 WE=92
05 WS=85-88
05 ST=85-87
05 RP=89-92
04 ST=84-87
04 RP=87
03 WS=88
03 RP=89
02 WS=89
02 RP=87
01 WS=87
01 RP=88
10 ST=91
10 JJB=93
09 WE=95
09 ST=90
09 RP=92-95
09 WS=93-96
09 JJB=94-96
08 WS=86
08 ST=88
08 RP=91-93
08 JJB=87-89
07 WE=92
07 RP=89+
05 $14-15 RP
04 $10-25 RP
10 $15 WE
09 $41-59 RP
08 $26-34 RP
07 $35-46 RP
06 $27-45 RP
06 $34 WS
05 $44 Zachys
05 $40 K&L
05 $37-83 RP
09 $100 K&L
09 $87-126 RP
08 $53-79 RP
08 $70 Zachys
07 $70 WE
07 $48-80 RP
171
06Comm’d Decanter 12
05 Certainly has potential WD 4/06
03 Excellent potential WD 10/05
07 ST=91
07 WS=88-91
07 $70 K&L
07 $75 Zachys
07 $78 B&M
06 RP=93
06 WE=93/93
06 WD=16-17+/20
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=92
05 W&S=96
05 WS=97
05 WE=94/96
05 ST=92
05 RP=94
05 WD=16-17/20
04 WE=93
04 WS=90
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
06 $115 B&M
06 $150 WClub
05 $150 W&S
05 $800/3L K&L
05 $85-144 RP
03 ST=89
03 RP=88-92
03 WS=92
03 RP=88
03 WW=90-92
03 WD=17.5/20
02 WS=89
02 ST=88+
02 RP=90
01 RP=89
01 WS=91
00 WS=95
00 C$299 BCLS
Ch La Rauze Lafargue
Prem Cotes Bord 08/09
Raymond
Bordeaux Les Hauts de Lagarde 10
00 RP=90
99 WR=94
99 WS=89
99 RP=88
09/08 WW=89
06 WW=89
05 WW=89
10 WS=81
Ch Real
Haut Medoc 09
09 Decanter=16(88)09 $17 Costco
Reaut
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=85
Reclos de la Couronne
08 WS=90
Ch Recougne
Bordeaux Sup 10
Ch de Reignac
Bordeaux Balthus 03/04/05/06/10
10 WE=82
06 WS=83
03 WR=89
10 TWCI=88-90
06 RP=91
06 WS=88
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=88
03 WS=88
08 WS=88
05 ST=89-91
04 WS=88
04 ST=87-89
03 ST=88
02 WS=88
02 ST=89
11 JR=15 (84)
10 JR=16.5 (90)
07 JR=14.5 (82)
Bordeaux Sup Balthus 03/04/05/08
Bordeaux 10/11
09 $8.52 B&M
10 $13 WS
10 $16 RP
10 $19 WE
06 $14 WS
06 $25-30 RP
04 $80 WS
04 $80 WS
172
Bordeaux Sup 02-10
Merlot
09 Gold Paris 11
08 Gold Bordeaux 10
07 Gold Paris 09
05 Silver Paris 07
Ch Renard Mondesir
Fronsac 08/09/10
Clos Rene
Pomerol 04/05/07/08/09/10
Res de Comtesse Lalande
Pauillac 01-09 (Pichon-Lalande’s second wine)
07=46%CS-41%Merlot-13%CF
03 Bronze IWC 07
La Res de Leoville Barton
St-Julien 05
La Reserve de Louis
08/09
Ch Respide-Medeville
Graves 06/07/08
Ch du Retout
Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 08/09/10/121/12
10 HOT BUY WBB
10 ST=87
09 RP=87-89+
09 WS=88-91
08 WS=87
08 RP=90-93
07 ST=88
06 RP=91
06 WS=85
06 ST=86-88
05 ST=88-90
05 WS=85-88
05 RP=90
04 WS=87
04 RP=86
03 ST=89
03 WS=81
03 RP=89
10 WS=89
08 WS=87
09 $20 RP
08 $21 WS
08 $19 K&L
08 $19 JJB
08 C$25 LCBO
£20 Dec
04 $35 WS
10 $22 WS
08 $23 WS
05 $15 B&M
10/09 ST=87
09 RP=88-90
09 $27-42 RP
08 ST=86
08 RP=88-90
08 $25-27 RP
07 RP=85-87
07 $20-25 RP
05 WS=90
05 $30 WS
05 RP=88-90
05 $27-34 RP
04 WS=86
03 RP=84-87
09 RP=91-93
09 $39-57 RP
08 RP=88-90
08 $31-40 RP
07 RP=87
07 $25-35 RP
07 ST=85
06 RP=89
06 $45 RP
06 ST=86-89
06 $40 K&L
06/05/04 WS=85-88
05 WS=89
05 ST=87-89
04 RP=88-90
03 WS=84
03 RP=88
03 RP=89
02/01 WS=85
05 WS=90
05 WW=91
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=87-88
08 WS=87
06 WE=86
05 $80 B&M
08 $30 WS
06 $35 WE
12 JR=16 (88)
11 JR=16 (88)
10 WS=91
10 $18 WS
10 RP=88
10 $12 Costco
10 JS=90-91
10 $?? JJB
10 CellarT=89 (11) 10 $30 TW&M
10 JR=16.5 (90)
10 Wine-S 87
09 JR=16 (88)
09 $11 JJB
09 JR=15 (84)
08 SS=15.5/20
08 JR=15 (84)
08 Decanter=3star
06 WS=87
173
Ch Reverdi
Ch la Reverence
05 WS=88
10 WS=88
Listrac-Medoc 09/10
St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch Reynier
Boirdeaux Cuvee Heritage Res 07
07 Silver LA 11
Ch Reynon
Bordeaux Rouge 09
09 Silver LA 11
Cadillac Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 03-10
09 Silver Decanter 12; Cpmm’e 11
Ch Reysson
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup Res de Ch 05-10
10 $25 WS
10 WS=90
10 $30 WS
10 $25 Zachy
09 WS=90
09 $42 WS
09 $18 JJB
08 WS=88
08 $40 WS
08 B&D 16.5 (90) 08 $28 WClub
07 WS=87
07 $40 WS
06 WS=84
06 $41 WS
05 WS=88
10 WS=90
10 RP=86
10 ST=87
09 ST=87-90
09 WS=90
09 WA=88-89
09 JR=16 (88)
08 WS=89
08 ST=85
08 JJB=87-89
06 RP=87
10 $20 WS
10 $8-17 RP
09 $15 JJB
09 $16 K&L
08 $16 WS
06 $14 RP
05 RP=85-87
05 $13-14 RP
03 BTI=93
03 WS=80-84
03 RP=87-89
10 RP=86
10 $18 RP
09 CS-Merlot
Ch de Ribebon
Ch Richelieu
Fronsac 04/ 05/06
Canon-Fronsac 05/06
Ch Rigaud
Puisseruin-St Emilion 09
Ch Ripeau
Ch de la Riviere
Fronsac 05/06/07/08/09/10
06/05/04 Vin Remarquable Hachette
09 Gold Paris 11
08 Bronze Bordeaux 10uui
08 WS=86
06 WS=85
05 WS=87
05 SS=16/20
05 RP=84-86
04 WS=88
08 $30 WS
06 $27 WS
05 $24 WS
04 $18 WS
04 $16 RP
10 WS=87
09 WS=89
08 WS=88
06 RP=90
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=90-93
10 $15 WS
09/08 $16 WS
06 $35 RP
03 RP=88-90
06 WS=86
06 RP=89
05 RP=87-88
09 RC=88
06 $25 RP
10 RP=86
08 WS=87
05 ST=88
10 WS=91
10 RP=85
10 $23-31 RP
10 $23 WS
10 $20 RP
09 RP=85-87
08 WS=90
07 WS=88
09 $19 RP
08 $24 WS
07 $24 WS
174
07 JR=15.5 (86)
07 $15 TrJ
06 Silver Paris 09
Fronsac Aria 10
Ch Robin
Cotes-de-Castillon 05/06/07/08/09
09/08 Comm’s Decanter 12
04 Gold Bordeaux 07
04 Silver Decanter 07, Brussels 07
05 WS=86
04 WE=87
04 WS=82
03 WS=87
02 RP=87-88
10 TWCI=90-92
02 $15 TrJ
05 €38-46 Hach
07 WS=87
06 WS=85
07 $25 Dec
06 $23 WS
06 C$18 LCBO
05 WS=85-88
04 WS=82
04 Hach=1star
03 WS=84
Ch Roc
09 WS=91-94
09 $16 JJB
Roc de Calon
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=88
10 $24 RP
Ch Roc de Cambes
Cotes de Bourg 03-10
St-Emilion 05
10 ST=90
10 TWCI=88-90
09 ST=90
07 ST=85
06 ST=88-90
05 ST=90
04 ST=88
03 RP=86-88
05 WS=89-91
Ch Roc Grand Antoine
Bordeaux 08
08 WE=83
Ch Roc de Levraut
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 Best Buy WE
Roc de Lussac
Lussac-St-Emilion 06/07/09
Roc du Manoir
Ch Roc Meynard
09 70%Merlot-25%CS-Malbec
09 Gold LA 11
07 Silver LA 10
Ch Roc de Segur
Bordeaux 10
Ch Roc Valentin
St-Emilion 06
Ch Roche-Beaulieu
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux Aster 10
Ch Rochebelle
Ch de Rochemorin
Pessac-Leognan 04/05/06/07
Ch la Roche-Pressac
10 WE=88
06 WS=85
09 WS=88
08 WS=87
10 WE=82
09 LA=93
08 WE=87
07 WS=79
10 WS=85
10 WE=85
06 WS=90
10 WS=90
10 ST=88
06 WS=88
05 WS=89
05 RP=87-89
04 WS=83
03 RP=86-88
03 WS=91
07 WS=86
06 WS=82
05 WS=89
04/03 WS=88
09 WS=86
06 $47-48 RP
05 $46-80 RP
04 $31-55 RP
10 $13 WE
09 $17 Sh-L
09 $18 WS
10 $16 WE
07 $15 WE
10 $12 WS
10 $10 Sh-L
06 $45 WS
10 $20 WS
05 $45 WS
05 $45 RP
05 $45 K&L
07 $32 Dec
06 $33 WS
05 $18 WS
04 $23 WS
09 $12 WS
Ch Rocher Bellevue Figeac St-Emilion 03/04/05/06
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=88-90
05 WS=90
05 $22-27 RP
05 $24 WS
175
04 WS=84
05 $22 Zachys
See new name Ch la Croix-Figeac-Lamarzelle
Ch Rocher Corbin
Ch Rocher-Lalon
06 RC=87
03 $20
06 $13 TrJoes
Ch la Rocheraie
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux le Paradoxe 10
10 WS=87
10 $20 WS
Ch les Roches Blanches
St-Emilion 06
06 WE=94
Roland la Garde
Bordeaux 09/10
Ch Rol de Valentin
Blaye Cores de Bordeaux 10
10 RP=85-76
09 RP=87-88
10 WS=84
St-Emilion GC 05/07/08/09/10
10 ST=88
09 JJB=95-97
09 WE=91
09 ST=89
09 RP=87-90
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=16.5
08 RP=87-89+
07 RP=89
07 ST 90.
10 $8-10 RP
10 $15 WS
09 $39+ ST
09 $34-47 RP
08 $27-35 RP
07 $27-48 RP
07 $27 K&L
07 C$59 BCLS
Ch Rolland de By
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03-11
09 Gold Paris 11
11 WS=90
11 RP=90
10 RP=90
09 RP=90-92
08 WS=90
08 RP=87-88
07 RP=87-88
06 Gold Paris 09; Bronze Decanter 1006 RP=89
05 Gold Brussels 09
05 WS=88
05 Very Successful Hachete 09
05 WS
04 WS=85
03 WS=86
Ch Rolland-Maillet
St-Emilion GC 03-10
Ch Rol Valentin
St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
10 RP=87
09 WE=89
09 WS=89-92
09 ST=87
09 RP=87-88
08 WS=91
08 RP=86-88
06 WS=90
06 ST=87-90
05 WS=85
ii04 WE=89
04 RP=87
10 TWCI=91-93
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=90-92+
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=88-91
06 RP=87
06 ST=89-91
06 WS=89-91
05 ST=93
11 $20 wine.com
10 $15-50 RP
09 $18-24 RP
09 $22 Sh-L
08 $30 WS
08 $12-19 RP
07 $12-19 RP
05 $21 WS
04 $15 WS
03 $17 WS
10 $18-20 RP
09 $18 JJB
09 $18 RP
08 $30 WS
05 $49 WS ?
04 $18-20 RP
07 $30-46 RP
07 $43 K&L
07 $46 Zachys
06 $25-60 RP
05 $80
176
05 Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09
Romfort
Cotes de Bourg 09
Romulus
Pomerol 05
Ch la Roncheraie
05 WS=95
05 RP=91-93
04 WS=92
04 ST=89
04 RP=89
09 Gold Concours Grands Vin France
05 $75 WS
05 $56-94 RP
04 $41 WS
04 $16-41 RP
09 $13 Sh-L
05 ST=89
Bordeaux Cuvee Paradon 10
10 $25 RP
10 RP=88
10 IWCI=89-91
10 RP=89-91+
Ch Roquebrune
Lalande-de-Pomerol Cuvee Reine 10
10 WS=89
10 $25 WS
Ch Roquefort
Bordeaux Sup Roquefortissime 05/06
10 JR=14.5 (82)
09 90%Merlot-10%CF
09 $14 Sh-L
05 IWR=90
St-Emilion GC 06/08
Ch Roques Mauriac
Pessac-Leognan 07
Bordeaux Damnation 06
06 Bronze LA 10
Bordeaux Sup Classic 08/09/10
Ch Roquetaillade Grange Graves 05/08/09 (Cab Sauv-Merlot)
Ch Roquevieille
Ch la Rose Bellevue
06 Silver LA 10
09 Silver Decanter 12; Bronze IWC 10
07 Bronze IWC 10
08 Bronze Bordeaux `0
Prem Cotes de Blaye Cuvee Tradition 02
04 Bronze Aquitaine 05
02 Best Buy WE 05
Prem Cotes de Blaye Cuvee Prestige 05/06/08 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11
Lussac-St-Emilion 04/06/08/09/10
08 Gold Brussels 10
06/04 Very Successful Hachette 10.08
Ch la Rose du Pin
Ch la Rose Trimolet
06 NM=89
06 WS=83
05 NM=90
05 WS=90
05 WE=89
08 WS=87
St-Emilion 05/09
07 C$26 BCLS
06 C$22 LCBO
02 WE=84
02 $8 WE
08 Hachette=2 star
08 WS=85
06 WE=87
06 $15 WE
05 WS=75-79
10 RP=87
09 RP=87-89
08 WS=90
08 RP=87-89+
Bordeaux 10/11
Bordeaux Sup 10
05 $14 IWR
10 JR=14.5 (82)
08 JR=15.5 (86)
Ch la Rose Perriere
10 $27 Zachys
10 WE=86
10 WE=89
10 $18 RP
11 $8 WClub
10 $13 WE
10 $16 WE
09 WE=87
Ch la Rose des Tuileries
10 WS=87
10 $20 WS
Dom Roses Camille
Pomerol 05/06
Cg Les Rosiers
Bordeaux 10
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
10 WS=84
10 $10 WS
Baron Edmund de Rothschild Haut-Medoc 06
06 Second wine of Ch Clarke
06 $15 Sh-L
177
Dom Barons de Rothschild Bordeaux Reserve Speciale 10
10 WE=85
10 $15 WE
10 $16 wine.com
06/05 $17 IWR
Paulliac Reserve Speciale 06
06 IWR=87
06 WE=85
05 WE=87
05 IWR=85
10 WS=84
10 WE=85
10 Cellar=84.5 (7)
06 WE=81
05 WE=86
05 W&S=84
04 IWR=86
06 WE=86
05 $19 W&S
04 $19 IWR
06 $45 WE
Moulin de Duhart 05
05 WE=90
05 $45 WE
Bordeaux Selection Prestige 10
Ch Paradis Casseuil Entre Deux Mers 10
Baron Philippe Rothschild Mouton Cadet 07/08/09/10/11 (Merlot-CS-CF)
10 Silver Critics, IWSC 12
10 Bronze LA; Comm’d Decanter 12
09/08 Silver LA 11/10
07 Best Buy BTI
06/05 Silver SD 08
05 Comm’d IWC 07
05 Silver IWSC 07
04 Bargain SFCh 8/17/07
05 Bronze IWSC 07
10 $16 WS
10 $20 Cost+
11 $10 Sh-L
10 WS=84
10 $10 WS
10 WE=84
10 $8 TrJ
10 CellarT 82 (30) 10 $8 B&M
10 $11 wine.com
08 WS=83
08 $11 WS
08 BTI=85
07 BTI=87
07 $10 BTI
07 AG=86
06 RC=86
06 WE=84
06 AG=85
05 WS=82
05 WE=82
04 WR=86
05 WE=85
05 $15 WE
Mouton Cadet Reserve Graves 05
05 WE=85
05 $15 WE
Mouton Cadet Reserve St-Emilion 05
05 WE=85
05 $17 WE
07 W&S=84
09 $16 Cost+
07 $18 W&S
RC=87
$6 Tr Joes
Mouton Cadet Res Medoc 05
Bordeaux Res Special 07/09
Rothschild
Le Belier 00
Ch Roudier
Momtagne-St-Emilion 07
07 $13 TrJ
05 WS=89
Ch Rouget
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=90-93
07 ST=88
07 RP=88
07 WS=85-88
06 Top Pick K&L
09 $40-71 RP
08 $32 K&L
08 $38 Zachys
07 $38 K&L
07 $27-50 RP
07 $40 K&L
06 WS=88
06 RP=90
06 ST=86-89
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=90-92
05 WS=92
04 WS=87
04 RP=89
06 $38 WS
06 $40 RP
10 RP=87
10 $24 RP
05 $40-42 RP
Ch de Rouillac
06 Cab Sauv
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=89-91
178
01 Gold Brussels 06
Ch de Rougerie
Bordeaux Sup 04/06
Ch la Rouselle
Fronsac 04/05/06/08/09
Ch la Rousselle-la Riviere
Cotes de Bourg Prestige 06
04 Silver IWC 07
Ch Roustaing
Bordeaux Vieilles Vignes 10
10 Silver Challenge Int’l du Vin 11
10 Bronze Bruxelles 11
Bordeaux 08
08 Gold Bordeaux 09
Ch Roux de Beauces
Grand Vin de Bordeaux 09/10
10/09 Bronze LA 11/10
Ch Roylland
St-Emilion 05/06/07
Dom des Sabines
Lalande de Pomerol 05-10
05 WS=88
04 WS=85
03 WS=86
01 RP=88
06 WS=80-84
04 WS=84
09 WS=91-94
08 WS=87
05 $19 WS
05 WS=88
05 $18 WS
06 WS=86
04 WS=88
03 WS=87
06 RP=88
06 WS=80-84
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=85
03 WS=89
10 WE=89
10 JR=14.5 (82)
10 UWS 86
06 WS=82
05 IWR=85
06 $25 WS
04 $20 WS
$20 JJB
06 $25 RP
05 $18-19 RP
10 $15 WE
10 $10 K&L
10 $12 Sh-L
05 $12 IWR
07 WE=90
06 WE=90
06 WS=86
07 $33 WE
06 $33 WE
06 $25 WS
10 RP=87
08 WS=87
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=80-84
09 WS=89
09 Cellart=88 (1)
10 $24 RP
Ch Saincrit
Clasic Bordeaux Superieur 09
Ch Saint Ahon
Haut-Medoc 10
Ch St Andre Corbin
St-Emilion StGeorges 08 (75%M-25%CF)
10 WE=90
09 $15 WS
09 $13 Sh-L
10 $15 Sh-L
10 $23 WE
08 NM=90
08 ST=86
06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 06 NM=90
10 WS=86
10 $10 WS
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Leo 10
10 WS=88
10 $10 WS
Ch Saint-Aubin
Bordeaux 10
10 RP=86
10 $18 RP
Ch Saint Barbe
Bordeaux 07
Ch St-Florin
Bordeaux 10
10 WS=87
Saint-Genes
08
08 RP=87-88
Ch Saint-Georges
St-Emilion Cote Pavie05/08/09 (Merlot+)
09 RP=88-91
08 RP=82-84
Ch St-Antoine
Bordeaux Sup 10
07 Gold LA 10
Ch St-Germain (Calvert)
Bordeaux Sup 05/06/08/09 (Merlot)
08 C$22 NM
06 C$28 NM
08 <$15
05 WS=89
05 NM=90
10 $10 WS
09 $32-42 RP
08 $28 RP
06 C$35 LCBO
05 C$35 NM
179
05 Bronze IWSC 07
Ch Saint-Hubert
05 WS=84
09 RP=87-89+
07 WS=83-86
Sain Julian
05 WS=92
04 WS=86
09 Cellart 86 (5)
Ch Saint-Michel
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 WE=85
Saint Paul
Haut-Medoc 04/05/09
09 RP=90-92
09 $13 Sh-L
09 $13-18 RP
09 $13 JJB
Ch Saint-Pierre
St-Julien 4th Cru Clase 03-10
09 81%CS-Merlot
04/03 Vin Remarq. Hachetten 08/07
Ch Saint Robert
Graves 05/06
Ch Saint-Sulpice
Bordeaux 05/07
Saintayme
St-Emilion GC 03-10
10/09 100%Merlot
05 Incredible price WW 06
10 ST=88
10 JJB=87
09 WE=96
09 ST=91
09 RP=94-98
09 ST=91-94
08 WE=93
08 ST=90
08 RP=92-94
08 JJB=90-92
07 WE=90
07 RP=90-92
07 ST=89
07 WS=87-90
06 WS=90
06 ST=88-90
06 RP=93
05 WS=93
09 $90 K&L
08 $50 Zachys
07 $55 WE
07 $66 B&M
07 $50 K&L
07 $75 Zachys
07 C$79 BCLS
06 $80 B&M
05 $140/1.5 K&L
05 ST=92
05 RP=92-94
04 ST=86-88
04 WS=90
04 RP=92
03 RP=93
03 WW=87-88
05 WE=88
07 WS=82
07 W&S=NR
05 WE=83
10 ST=86
09 ST=87-89
09 WS=90
08 WS=88
07 WW=88-89
07 WS=83-86
06 WS=90
06 WW=87-89
05 RC=89/89
05 ST=88-90
05 WS=89
05 WE=90
05 RP=87
05 B&B=88
05 WW=89-91
05 Decanter=16
05 JR=16
05 $20 WE
07 $15 WS
09 $18 ST
09 $20 K&L
07 $19 B&M
05 $22 WS
180
05 JMQ=14
05 CellarTracker=88
04 WW=87-89
04 WS=88
03 WW=88-89
03 WS=89
Clos Ste-Anne
Ch Sainte-Anne
Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 05/07 (90% Merlot) 07 Comm’d IWC 10
04 Silver Paris 07; Brussels 10
Dom de Bourdieu 10
Ch Sainte Barbe
10 Gold LA 12
10 WE=89
10 $17 WE
10 LA=93
10 RP=85
10 WE=84
09 RP=87-89
10 $12-17 RP
10 $18 WE
07 Gold Brussels 09
07 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Merlot 08/09/10
Ch Sainte Colombe
10 Gold LA 12
Cotes de Castillon 05-08( Merlot-CF-CS)
Ch de Sainte-Gemme
Haut-Medoc 05/06
Ch Sainte Marie
Bordeaux Sup Res 07-10
06 WE=83
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
05 WE=87
10 LA=92
06 $15 WE
06 $16 RP
06 WE=84
05 WE=85
08 JJB=84-86
07 ST=87
06 RP=84
06 ST=85-86
05 ST=87
06/05 $12 WE
05 $15 WE
07 C$20 BCLS
06 $8-16 RP
06 $16 wine.com
05 $9-13 RP
99 C$20 BCLS
06 WS=82
05 WS=84
10 RP=87
10 $12 RP
07 W&S=82
10 WE=89
07 $17 W&S
10 $20 WE
10 WE=90
10 $11 WE
Cotes de Bordeaux le Moulin 08/09/10
Ch Saintongey
Bordeux Superieur Vielles Vignes 07/08/09/10 10 Best Buy WE
Bordeaux 09
09 Gold LA 11
Bordeaux Vieilles Vignes 10
Ch de Sales
10 Gold LA; Silver Decanter 12
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
Pomerol 05/06/07/08/09
09 LA=92
10 LA=90
09 ST=87-90
08 ST=86
Samion
Sancrit
Bordeaux Superieur Vieilles Vignes 10
Ch Sanctus
St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/08/09
10 100%Merlot
06 WS=87
02 WS=85-88
10 ST=87
09 $24+ ST
09 $30 WClub
08 $21 Zachys
08 $20 K&L
07 $20 Zachys
06 $25 WS
05 $20-30 RP
$15 Sh-L
09 WE=93
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=91-94
07 RP=89+
07 ST=87
09 $25-32 RP
08 $28-35 RP
08 $35 Zachys
07 $55-65 RP
181
Ch Sansey
Ch Sansonnet
Graves 05/06/07
07 Silver Paris 09
St-Emilion GC 02-10
05 Coup de Coeur Hachette
04 Bronze IWC 07
06 RP=88
06 ST=87-89
05 ST=90-92
05 RP=92-94
04 ST=88
04 RP=90
06 $36-40 RP
06 $33-40 RP
05 $45 K&L
05 $45-58 RP
05 WS=88
05 WE=89
10 ST=90
09 RP=90-92
09 WA=88-91
08 WS=87
07 RP=85-87
07 WS=82-85
07 ST=85
06 RP=84
06 WS=87
06 ST=86-89
05 WS=92
05 $15 WS
04 RP=87
04 WS=88
03 WS=90
03 RP=87-90
02 WS=87
10 RP=91
04 $40 RP
10 $28+ ST
09 $23-28 RP
09 $25 JJB
06 $32 RP
05 $33-40 RP
04 $25 RP
Saransot-Dupre
Bordeaux 10
Sarget de Gruard-Larose
St-Julien 03-10 (Ch Gruard Larose)
Ch le Sartre
Pessac-Leognan le S de Sartre 05/06/07/08/09
05 WS=87
05 WR=88
05 $11 WR
10 Best Buy WE
10 WE=88
10 $12 WE
Ch Sauman
Cotes de Bourg Cuvee Tradition 05/06
10 $22 RP
10 ST=86
10 WS=90
10 $25+ ST
10 $27 Zachys
10 $25 K&L
10 $26 Sh-L
09 WS=89
09 $25 WS
08 WS=89
08 $19 WS
08 CellarT 85.3 (11)
06 WS=85
05 WS=85-88
07 $19 Dec
See also Langloise-Ch Sauman
Schroder & Schyler
Chartron la Fleur Merlot Cab 10
Secret de Cardinale
St-Emilion 05/07/08 (Ch Fleur Cardinale)
Segla
Margaux 05
Ch Segonzac
Bordeaux 06/08
Prem-Cotes-de-Blaye 07/08/09/10
Prem-Cotes-de-Blaye VV 07/08/09/10
Ch Seguin
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=88
05 ST=91+?
05 WS=89
08 Silver IWC; Bronze IWSC 10
08 CS
07 Silver Paris 09
10 Comm’d IWC 12
10 CS-Malbec-Merlot
07 Silver Paris 09
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05/06/07/08/09/10
06 WW=89
06 $10 B&M 5¢
09 $14 Sh-L
10 RP=90
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=90-91
07 RP=85-87
06 RP=89
10 $28 JJB
09 $26-32 RP
08 $32 RP
07 $21 RP
06 $23 RP
182
Ch de Seguin
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 04-10
10 Gold Bordeaux, Paris 12.
10 WS=89
10 $15 WS
10 Silver Challenge Int’l, Paris 12
10 WBB=??
10 $11 TrJ
09 Gold Paris, LA 11
09 LA=93
09 WS Blog 85/86 09 $15 MSRP
09 Bronze LA 11
09 CellarT 85 (15)
09 JR=16 (88)
09 G&M 14 (80)
08 Gold Bordeaux, LA 10
08 Bronze Challenge, Paris 10
07 Gold Challenge (FR) 09
07 Silver Paris 09
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Carl 09/10
06 RP=87
05 WS=85-88
05 W&S=87
05 RC=87
05 $15 W&S
10 WS=91
10 $25 WS
09 WS=90
09 WS=88
05 WS=85-88
08 WW=89
05 RC=86
05 WW=88
09 $24 WS
08 $22 WS
09 Silver LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Carl Cru Except’l 08/09
Ch du Seguinier
Ch Senailhac
Bordeaux Sup Marquerite 05/08
St-Emilion 04/05/06
Ch Senejac
La Serenite Bernard Magrez Pessac-Leognan 05/06/07/08 (50%CS-Merlot)
08 $10 B&M 5¢
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
04 WS=82
03 WS=80
06/05 WS=85-88
04 WS=87
03 WS=89
10 WS=88
10 RP=89
09 RP=89-91
08 65%CS-27%M-7%CF-1%PV
08 ST=87
08 RP=88-90
08 WS=88
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 WE=89
07 ST=87-89
07 WS=83-86
06 RP=86
06 WS=88
06 ST=87-89
05 Very Successful Wine Hachette 09 05 SS=17/20
05 Deanterc=4star
05 ST=85-88
05 WS=90
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=82
04 RP=88-89
03 WS=82
03 RP=89
08 RP=89-91
07 ST=86
06 ST=88-91
06 WS=89-91
06 RP=90
06/05 RP=90-92
03 $20 WS
10 $19 WS
10 $13-28 RP
09 $15-29 RP
08 $12-21 RP
08 $21 WS
08 $25 Sh-L
07 $17 WE
07 $17 Zachys
06 $13-24 RP
06 $19 WS
06 $15 K&L
05 $28 Zachys
05 $30 TW&M
05 $27 WS
05 $21-23 RP
04 $14 WS
04 $15-16 RP
06 $35 RP
05 $90-92 RP
183
05 WS=90-92
05 ST=90
04 RP=90
09 RP=91-93
07 RP=90
Cuvee d’ Exception 07/09
La Serenite de Poumey
Ch Sergant
Pessac-Leognan 05
04 $60 RP
07 $40-48 RP
05 WS=87
05 RP=88-90
03 RP=90
03 WS=90
10 WS=87
03 $52-70 RP
03 $60 WS
10 $20 WS
06 WS=84
05 WS=88
06 $28 WS
05 $28 WS
Lalande-de-Pomerol Res de la Famille 05
05 WS=87
05 $40 WS
10 ST=86
09 RP=87-89
08 WS=89
08 RP=86-88
07 RP=87-88
07 ST=86
06 RP=88
06 ST=86-88
06 WS=86
05 WE=87
05 WS=91
05 RP=87=89
04 WS=87
07 Silver Paris 09
04 Cited Winr Hachette 08
Ch la Sergue
Ch Serilhan
St-Estephe 03-10
07 $20-26 RP
06 $32 RP
05 $27 WS
10 WE=92
10 $23 WE
10 WS=89
10 $25 WS
10 RP=87
10 $17-33 RP
10 WE=92
10 ST=86
09 RP=87-88
09 $17-26 RP
08 55%CS-43%M-CF
08 WBlB=87
08 $15-30 WBlB
08 WS=89
08 ST=87
08 RP=85-87
05 Comm’d IWC 07
Ch la Serre
St-Emilion GC 04-10
09 48%CS-45%Merlot-CF)
06 WS=87
05 WS=83
05 RP=82-84
04 WS=87
03 WS=89
03 RP=85-87
10 ST=87
09 WE=91
09 ST=87-89
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=87-89
08 ST=86
08 JJB=89-91
07 RP=86
07 W&S=87
07 WS=85-88
06 RP=84
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
05 NM=90
05 RP=89-91
04/03 WS=87
04 RP=87
03 RP=87-89
06 $15 RP
05 $17 RP
03 $20 WS
03 $20 RP
09 $44+ ST
09 $40-53 RP
08 $34-42 RP
07 $33-41 RP
07 $36 W&S
07 C$45 BCLS
06 $39-58 RP
05 $37 WS
05 C$58 NM
05 $37-56 RP
184
Servitude Volontaire
Haut Medoc 06/07/09 (Second wine of Ch la Tour Carnet)
Cuvee Exception 06
Ch du Seuil
Graves Rouge 09
04 Comm’d IWC 07
03 Silver/Bronze Challenge 06
04 Silver IWC 07
04 Comm’d IWC 07
Graves Rouge Heritage 03/04
Prem Cotes Rouge Dom de Seuil 04
Ch Siaurac
08 Gold Paris 11
09 RP=90-93
07 RP=89
06 RP=90-92
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=91-93
06 RP=89
07 $35-50 RP
06 $32 RP
08 €5-8 Hach
05 WS=81
04 $15 RP
03 $25 RP
03 WS=85
03 $25 RP
10 WS=90
10 RP=86
09 RP=89-91
09 WS=88-91
08 WS=89
08 RP=87-88
10 $25 WS
10 $11-18 RP
09 $16 JJB
09 $14-18 RP
07 WE=89
06 WS=84
07 $31 WE
06 $21 WS
06 $13 RP
05 WS=87
05 RP=85-87
03 WS=87
05 $25 WS
05 $17 RP
See also: Plaisir de Siurac
Signature du Clos St-Vincent St-Emilion 05/06/07
Ch Simard
Ch Siran
St-Emilion 06/08/09
Margaux Cru Bourgeois Except 03-10
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=86
05 WS=90
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=87-88
06 WS=89
10 ST=88
10 RP=86
10 JJB=91
09 WE=90
09 ST=88
09 RP=87-88+
08 WS=88
08 Decanter=4star
08 SS=16.5/20
07 WS=87
07 WE=85
07 RP=79-82
06 RP=86
06 WE=89
06 ST=85-88
06 WS=87
05 WE=93
05 ST=87-89
05 SS=15.5/20
05 WS=91
05 RP=91
05 ST=87-89
04 WE=89
04/03 WS=90
04 ST=86-88
04 RP=89
04/03 WS=90
08 $20-25 RP
10 $30+ ST
10 $24-42 RP
09 $30+ ST
09 $26-43 RP
08 $28 WS
08 $19-24 RP
07 $24 WS
06 $22-30 RP
06 $28 WS
05 $64 B&M
185
Margaux S de Siran 08
03 ST=87
03 RP=87
02 WS=87
02 RP=87
01 WE=91
01 WS=87
08 WS=86
Bordeaux Sup St-Jacques de Siran 08
08 WS-85
`
01 Editor’s Choice WE 05
La Sirene de Gisgours
Margaux 03/05/07
Ch Smith Haut Lafitte
Grave 01/02/03/04/05
Ch Sociando-Mallet
Haut-Medoc 03-10
07 WW=85-87
05 WS=84
03 WS=89
10 64%CS-30%Merlot-5%CF-1%PV 10 ST=88
10 JJB=96
09 WE=94
09 ST=92
09 RP=96-98+
08 ST=87
08 RP=93-95
08 WE=93
08 WS=88/91
08 JJB=91-93
07 RP=91
07 WE=90
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=91
06 WE=90
06 WD=13-15/20
06 RP=93
06 ST=92
06 WS=92
06 NM=94
05 Real success WD 4/06
05 WD=17-18/20
05 W&S=94
05 Coup de Cour Hachette 09
05 RP=93-95
05 WE=88/90
05 WS=93
05 ST=93
04 WS=90
04 ST=90
04 RP=93
05 Prodigious, great intensity WW 06 05 RP=93-95
05 ST=91-94
05 RW=17-18/20
04 ST=90
03 ST=91
02 ST=91
01 TA=4stars
10 ST=85
09 CS-M-CF
09 ST=89
09 RP=90-92+
08 ST=91
08 RP=87-89+
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=88
08 $20 WS
07 $26 B&M
05 $39 B&M
10 $110+ ST
09 $91-130 RP
08 $48-63 RP
08 $80 Zachys
08 $60 K&L
07 $40-65 RP
07 $60 WE
07 $57 K&L
07 $65 Zachys
06 $45 K&L
06 $79 WClub
06 $36-68 RP
06 $60 WS
06 C$84 NM
05 $75 B&M
05 $105 W&S
05 $65
10 $39+ ST
09 $39-62 RP
08 $28-41 RP
07 $53 B&M
07 $47 Zachys
07 C$49 BCLS
06 $66 B&M
06 C$69 BCLS
06 AG=86
06 WD=15.5-16.5
06 RP=90
06 NM=90
06 C$65 NM
06 ST=88-89
06 WS=85-88
05 Very good with potential RW 3/06 05 ST=92
05 $65 B&M
05 WS=88
05 Vin Remarquabke Hachette 09
05 RW=16.5-17.5
186
04”Coup de Coeur” Hachette 08
Ch Soleil
Puissequin St-Emilion 05/06/07/09/10
Ch Soleil le Rival
09/10
Dom de la Solitude
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05
La Sonate
St-Emilion 05/06
Ch Sorbey
Haut-Medoc 06/10
Ch Soudars
Haut Medoc 05/06/07/08
10 90%Merlot-10%CF
05 RP=91-93
04 ST=89
04 RP=90
04 WS=90
03 ST=91
03 RP=94
02 WE=88
02 ST=89
02 RP=89
02 WS=84
10 RP=89
10 TWCI=86-88
09 RP=87-88
07 WS=84-87
07 ST=85
06 ST=84-87
06/05 WS=85-88
05 ST=87-88
05 RP=86
10 TWCI=90-92
09 RP=89-91
05 $42-72 RP
04 $40 B&M
04 $43-100 RP
10 $20 RP
05 $35 Zachys
05 C$56 BCLS
05 WS=84
04 WC=4stars
04 WS=87
05 $25 WS
04 C$33 WC
06 WS=87
05 WS=83
10 WE=88
06 WS=86
05 WS=87
08 WE=91
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=87
06 $42 WS
10 $15 WE
06 $18 WS
08 $24 WE
05 WS=89
Les Sources du Ch Riviere
Fronsac 05
05 WS=81
Ch de Sours
La Fleur d’Amelie 10
10 WE=84
10 $15 WE
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=88
10 $21 WE
La Source 09/10/11/12
12 JR=16 (88)
11/10 JR=15.5 (86)
09/08 JR=15.5 (86)
07 WE=84
07 $17 WE
Ch Soussac
Bordeaux Sup 07
Ch Soutard
St-Emilion 05/06/07/08/09
09 RP=88-90
08 WS=88
08 RP=91-93+
07 RP=86-88
07 ST=85
06 RP=84
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=88
05 ST=87-88
09 WW=88
05 $36 WS
05 $32-33 RP
09 $9.52 B&M
10 $23 WS
08 $20 WS
07 $21 WS
Sphere
Ch St-Andre Corbin
St-Georges-St-Emilion 08/09/10
Ch St-Dominque
10 WS=90
08 WS=88
07 WS=86
Ch St-Georges
St-Emilion 08
08 WS=88
Ch St-Hubert
St-Emilion 10
10 WS=88
08 $29-36 RP
07 $25-32 RP
06 $27-36 RP
10 $20 WS
187
Ch St-Julian
Bordeaux Sup 06/07
07 WS=85
Clos St Julien
St-Emilion 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
09 RP=91-93+
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=92
07 ST=87
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
05 ST=92
05 RP=90-92
04 ST=90+
04 RP=90
07 $15 WS
06 $18 win.com
09 $35-40 RP
07 $50-65 RP
06 $50 RP
04 $43-52 RP
Clos St-Martin
St-Emilion GC 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
09 RP=92-94+
08 RP=93-95
08 JJB=91-93
08 JJB=87-89
07 RP=89+
07 WS=87-90
06 RP=92-94
05 WS=91
05 ST=88-91
05 RP=96-98
04 WS=89
04 RP=90
03 RP=88
06 RP=87
10 WS=86
09 WS=89
10 WS=89
Ch St-Michel
06
Bordeauz Sup 09/10
Ch St-Paul
Haut-Medoc 10
St-Pierre
Bordeaux 09
Ch St-Robert
Graves Poncel-Deville 08
08 WS=85
Ch St-Sulpice
Bordeaux 07/10
10 WS=84
07 WS=82
Clos St-Vincent
St-Emilion GC 06/10
Clos St-Vincent, Signature
St-Emilion 05/06
09 $60-84 RP
08 $49-73 RP
08 $55 K&L
07 $40-51 RP
06 $51-65 RP
05 $70-72 RP
06 $28-94 RP
10/09 $18 WS
10 $15 WS
09 JJB=94-96
10 $16 WS
07 $15 WS
10 Comm’s Decanter 12
06 WS=85
Ch Ste-Marie
Ch du Taillan
Haut-Medoc 06-10
Ch Taillefer (Moueix)
Pomerol 02-10
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 CF-Merlot
Ch Talbot
St-Julien 4th Cru Classe 99-10
04 Silver Bordeaux, Brussels, IWC 07
04 Bronze Paris 07
04/03 Comm’d Decanter 07/06
02 Bronze IWC 07
09 CS-Merlot-PV
08 WS=88
07 JR=15.5 (87)
10 WS=83
06 WS=82
05 WS=83
10 $23 WS
10 WS=91
10 RP=85
10 $24 WS
10 $22-29 RP
09 WE=90
08 WS=89
07 RP=78-82
06 WS=88
05 WS=91
05 WE=91
04 WS=88
04 RP=84
10 ST=86
10 JJB=93
09 ST=88
09 WE=94
09 RP=92-94
08 $15 WS
05 $22 WS
07 $37-49 RP
07 $26 JJB
06 $56 WS
05 $42 WS
05 $56 WE
04 $42 WS
04 $34 RP
10 $40+ ST
09 $60+ ST
09 $60 K&L
09 $53-74 RP
188
06 Not inspiring WD
06 Very Suyccessful Hachette 10
09 WS=92-95
08 RP=89-91
08 ST=88
07 RP=86
07 WE=89
07 ST=86
07 WS=91
06 WD=13.5-14.5
06 RP=89
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=91
05 Very rich, big tannins, long WW 06 05 WS=92
05 $90 B&M
St-Julien Connetable Talbot 08
Ch Tanesse
05 WE=94/93
05 RP=88-90
05 ST=88-91
04 WS=89
04 WE=92
04 RP=87-88
03 WS=91
03 RP=90
03 A success after weak 02 WD 10/05 03 WD=16+/20
02 WS=87
02 RP=78
08 WS=86
08 $37-60 RP
08 $41 Zachys
07 $35-56 RP
07 $45 WE
07 $45 Zachys
07 $56 B&M
06 $70 B&M
06 C$69 BCLS
Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 08/09/10
Ch Tauzinat L’Hermitage St-Julien 05/06/07/08/09
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/09/10
Ch Tayac
Margaux Cru Bourgeois 05/06/07/08/09
Ch Tayac-Plaisance
Margaux 09
Terra Burdigala
Bordeaux Superieur Roc de Jean Lys 08/10
09 Bronze IWC 12
09 CD-Merlot
04 $40 B&M
04 $30-65 RP
10 WS=89
10 WE=89
08 WS=87
10 $14 WS
10 $25 WE
08 $15 WS
06 WS=82
06 $40 WS
05 WS=86
04 Silver Paris 07; Comm’d Decanter 1004/03 WS=87
10 RP=85
09 WS=90-93
06 Gold Brussels 09
04 Silver IWC 07
04 Bronze IWC 06
03 Gold GrandVinsDeFrance(Macon) 03 GH=1star
05 WS=87
09 WS=88-91
04 $35 WS
10 $12-20 RP
09 $16 K&L
05 $23 WS
09 $25 K&L.
10 WS=90
08 WS=88
06 WS=84
06 WS=84
10 $17 WS
08 $16 WS
06 $17 WS
06 $14 WS
Castillon Ch Manoir Gravoux Roc du Manoir 08
10 WS=90
09 WS=88
07 WS=88
08 WS=87
10 $20 WS
09 $18 WS
07 $27 WS
08 $18 WS
La Terrasse de la Garde
Pessac-Leognan 05
05 WS=83
Ch Terrefort-Quancard
Bordeaux Sup 05/06/07/08 (Merlot)
Merlot-Cab Sauv Bordeaux Causse 06
Castillion Cotes de Bordeaux Ch Manoir 07-10
08 Silver LA 11
08 WW=87
08 $10 B&M 5¢
08 WE=85
08 WS=84
08 CellarT=87 (5)
189
06 WW=88
06 NM=87
05 WW=87
04 Bronze France-Macon
03 RC=87
03 WS=81
See also: Cheval Quancard
Ch Terrey-Gros-Caillou
St-Julien 05
05 “Discoveries of Vintage” QWR
05 WS=85-88
Ch du Tertre
10 ST=91
10 JJB=93+
09 WE=93
09 ST=89
08 JJB=87-89
07 WE=91
07 RP=87-89
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=88
06 RP=86
06 WE=93
06 WD=15.5-16.5
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=82
05 ST=88-91
05 WD=16-17/20
05 WS=88
05 WW=90-92
05 WE=88
05 RP=91=93
04 WS=88
04 WE=88
04 RP=88
04 ST=87
09 CS-M-CF-PV
06 Pretty good WD
05 Excell aroma, fruit, flavors WW
05 Very good WD 4/06
Ch Tertre Daugay
St-Emilion GC 03-10
03 Good WD 10/05
03 WS=88
03 ST=88
03 RP=90
03 WD=16+/20
02 WS=81
02 WS=87
02 RP=89
10 80%Merlot-20%CF
10 RP=88-90
10 ST=87
09 RP=89-91
Ch le Tertre Roteboeuf
St-Emilion 03-10
09 80%Merlot-CF
08 WS=89
08 JJB=88-90
07 RP=85-86
07 WS=86-89
06 WS=87
05 RP=85-87
05 ST=89
05 WS=92
04 WS=89
03 RP=88-90
03 WS=85
10 ST=94
09 ST=93
09 JJB=97-99
08 RP=94-96
07 ST=89
06 RP=87
06 ST=89-92
06 WS=92-94
05 ST=94
04 $18-19 RP
09 $32 ST
08 $30 Zachys
07 $35 WE
07 $25-44 RP
07 $37 Zachys
07 $35 Sh-L
06 $23-50 RP
06 $59 B&M
06 $30 JJB
06 C$49 BCLS
06 $37 WS
05 $37-51 RP
05 $46 WS
04 $28 WS
04 $28-56 RP
10 $23-34 RP
09 $28-31 RP
09 $29 WClub
05 $30-32 RP
05 $35 WS
09 $230+ ST
08 $130 K&L
06 $125-229 RP
05 $250 ST
190
Ch Tertre de Viaud
Cotes de Bourg 10
Ch Teynac
St-Julien 05/06/09/10
Ch Teyssier
09 70%CS-Merlot
Bordeaux Sup Pezat 10/11
Puissequin St-Emilion 04/05
St-Emilion 03-11
04 Comm’d IWC 07
11 85% Merlot-15%CF
Bordeaux 05/06/07/08/09/10
08 Gold Paris 09
Ch Thieuley
Bordeaux Francis Courselle Res 04-10
05 12 outstanding values QRW 06
05 Bronze Paris 07, Bordeaux 07
Bordeaux Rouge 04-12
10 Merlot-CS
09 Gold Paris 11
08 Gold Challenge
04 $96-160 RP
10 $20 WS
10 $25 WE
05 WS=87
10 WS=88
10 RP=92
05 WE=88
04 WS=85
04 WE=87
11 RP=89-91
09 ST=87
09 WE=89
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=88-90
07 WS=84
07 RP=87
06 RP=90
06 WE=88
06 ST=85
06 WS=80-84
05 ST=88
05 WE=88/87
05 WS=90
04 WS=85
03 RP=85-87
03 WS=87
03 Cited Wine Hachette
Ch Thebot
04 ST=90
04 RP=89
03 WS=93
10 WS=87
10 WE=87
10 ST=86
09 ST=87
10 $20 WS
10 $10-27 RP
04 $35 WS
11 $18 JJB Fut
09 $11+ ST
09 $15-20 RP
07 $12 WS
07 $20-25 RP
06 $10-33 RP
06 $30 WE
05 $23 RP
05 $30 WS
05 €11-15 Hach
04 $30 RP
03 WS=80-84
02 WS=84
10 JR=15.5+ (86+)
08 JR=16.5 (90)
05 IWR=87
05 $11 IWR
05 NM=87
10 WS=89
10 $20 WS
10 RP=87-89
10 $17 RP
09 RP=87-89
09 JR=15.5 (86)
08 WS=87
08 ST=87
08 JR=16 (88)
06 RP=88
05 WS=80-84
05 WE=88
09 $13 RP
06 $25 RP
05 $28 WE
04 WE=90
03 RP=87-88
03 WS=80
01 WR=89
12 JR=16+ (88+)
11 JR=15.5 (86)
10 WS=88
10 $13 WS
10 Hachette=2 star
10 RP=86
10 $10-12 RP
10 ST=86
10 $15 Astor
10 JR=15.5 (86)
09 RP=87-88
09 $10 RP
08 WS=86
08 $14 WS
191
Ch le Thil
Pessac-Leognan Comte Clary 05-10
07 Gold Brussels 09
07 JR=15 (84)
06 Bronze Brussels 07, Decanter 07
05 IWR=91
05RP=87-89
04 WE=87
03 WS=85
10 RP=91-93
10 WS=91
09 JJB=91-93
09 Merlot-CS
09 WS=89-92
08 WS=91
08 RP=90-92
07 RP=86-87
07 ST=86
06 RP=89
06 ST=86-89
05 WS=87
Thomas Barton
See: B&G Barton & Guestier
Thunevin
Presidial Bordeaux 05/06/07 (70%Merlot-CS-CF)
10 $19-30 RP
10 $25 WS
$16 JJB
08 $18 WS
08 $18 K&L
06 $25 RP
05 $18 WS
St-Emilion Clos Badon 07
07 JR=14.5 (82)
05 RP=86-87
05 $15 samswine
05 WS=85-88
05 1855.com=86-87
03 WS=78
10 RP=88
10 $16 RP
10 TWCI=88-90
07 WS=88
07 RP=87-88
07 JR=15.5 (86)
06 RP=86
06 $20 RP
06 WS=91
06 $17 K&L
06 C$30 LCBO
07 WS=85
St-Emilion 3 de Valandraud 08
08 WS=86
Bordeaux Mauvais Garcon Bad Boy 06/07/10
Ch Timberlay
06 $10 Dec
05 $13 IWR
05 $11-14 RP
Bordeaux 07/08 (Merlot)
08 Comm’d IWC 10
07 NM=87
07 C$16 NM
09 $20 wine.com
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Marie Paule Prestige 06
06 WS=79
Tirepe
08/09
Ch Toumilon
Petit Toumilion 10 (CS)
10 Bronze IWC 12
Graves 05/08 (CS-CF-Merlot)
08 Bronze IWC 10
Ch Tour Bayard
Montagne St-Emilion 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
09 RP=88-90
08 RP=89-91
05 WE=85
05 NM=88
10 RP=88
05 $20 WE
05 C$22 NM
10 $18-20 RP
07 WS=89
07 $20 WS
10 RP=88
10 $25 RP
10 WS=88
09 WS=91-94
10 $20 WS
09 $20 K&L
09 $20 JJB
Ch Tour Bayard-l’Angelot
Bordeaux 10
Ch la Tour de Bessan
Margaux 09/10
Ch Tour Blanche B. Magrez Medoc Cru Bourgeois 03/04/05/08/09
09 Silver Paris 11
08 RP=83-85
05 RP=88-90
05 W-Plus=86+
05 $55 Zachys
192
03 Gold Brussels 06
Ch la Tour-de-By
Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 05/06/08/09/10
09 Cab Sauv
05 12 outstanding Values QRW 06
Medoc Ch La Roque de By 10
Ch Tour Carnet (Magrez) Haut-Medoc 03-10
09 CS-Merlot
05 Good value WD 4/06
Haut-Medoc Cuvee les Douves 09
04/03 Gold Brussels 07/06
03 WR=90
03 $30 WR
10 RP=86
10 $13-20 RP
10 JJB=89
09 WE=88
09 $19 K&L
09 ST=88-91
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
08 RP=85-86
06 WS=87
05 WE=87
05 RP=87-88
05 WS=86
04 RP=86
05 $26 WS
04 $18 RP
03 WS=84
10 WS=86
10 $14 WS
10 ST=87
10 TWCI=89-91
09 WE=91
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=90-93
08 ST=87
07 RP=89+
07 WS=83-86
07 ST=88
06 RP=91
06 WS=90
05 WD=16-17
05 WS=90
05 WE=93
05 RW=16-17/20
05 RP=90-93
04 WS=88
04 RP=90
06 $17 WS
05 $16 RP
10 $37+ ST
09 $30-46 RP
08 $33-46 RP
08 $29 JJB
07 $30-44 RP
07 $29 Zachys
07 C$45 BCLS
06 $23-53 RP
06 $33 WS
05 $36 Zachys
05 $36 WS
05 $30 K&L
05 $29-37 RP
04 $25 WS
04 $23-33 RP
03 TA=4½stars
See also their second wine: Servitude Voluntaire
Ch Tour Chapoux
Bordeaux 09/10/11
11 CF-CS-Merlot
10 WS=83
10 WE=86
10 $12 WS
09 Bronze LA 11
Ch Tour Coutain
St-Estephe 07
Ch la Tour Figeac
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/07/08/09/10
07 WE=89
10 75%Merlot-25%CF
10 ST=88
09 JJB=92-94
09 WE=93
09 RP=91-93
08 WS=90
08 RP=90-92
07 WE=90
07 RP=90-92
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=90
06 RP=91
06 WE=93
06 ST=87-90
05 W&S=2stars
09 $33-45 RP
08 $28 WS
07 $24-30 RP
06 $27-38 RP
06 $30 K&L
05 $41 Zachys
193
05 balance & elegance Decanter 06
Ch Tour des Gendres
Bergerac 10
Ch Tour de Guiet
Cotes de Bourg Eleve en Futs de Chene 05-07
Ch la Tour-Haut-Brion
Pessac-Leognan 03/04/05
Medoc 05/06/10
Ch Tour-du-Haut-Moulin Haut-Medoc 03/04/05
Ch Tour Maillet
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/08/09
05 $41 WS
10 $14 WE
Ch Tour Haut-Caussan
05 SS=17/20
05 WS=90
05 ST=87-90
05 WE=93/93
05 RP=91-94
04 WS=88
04 ST=87-89
04 RP=85
04/03 WE=91
02 WE=90
10 WE=87
05 WE=87
04 WS=85
03 RP=88
03 WS=88
05 RP=89-91
05 ST=90-92
05 WS=93
05 WE=91/89
04 RP=87-89
04 WS=90
04 WE=91
04 ST=90
03 RP=88
03 WS=89
03 ST=88+/90
02 RP=88
02 WS=89
02 ST=88+
01 WS=90
01 RP=89
01 ST=89
00 WS=90
00 RP=92
00 ST=91
99 WS=90
99 RP=90
99 ST=88+
10 RP=90
10 WE=90
05 WS=88
05 Vim Remarquable Hachette 09
05 RP=88-90
09 RP=86-88
09 WS=90
09 Decanter 16.8
08 RP=86-88
07 RP=86-88
06 RP=86
05 WS=89
05 RP=87-88
03 WS=89-91
09 RP=90-92
08 RP=87-89
07 RP=87
12 JR=15.5 (86)
11 JR=15.5 (86)
10 RP=89
10 JR=15.5 (86)
08 WS=86
05 12 outstanding values QRW 06
06/05 WS=85-88
05 $29 WE
05 $59-86 RP
05 $70 Zachys
05 $73 WS
04 $36-59 RP
04 $45 WS
10 $13-18 RP
10 $22 WE
05 $20 WS
05 $21 Zachys
09 $30-37 RP
09 $20 K&L
06 $38 RP
05 $38 WS
La Tour Martillac
07/08/09
Ch Tour de Mirambeau
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Passion 02-12
09 $28-47 RP
08 $20-31 RP
07 $21-48 RP
10 $20 RP
08 $16 WS
06 $20 RP
194
Bordeaux Rouge 06/07/08/09/10
Bordeaux Grand Vin 05
Bordeaux Res 10
Ch la Tour de Mons
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
05 Silver IWC 07
05 Gold Bordeaux 07
10 CF-CS-Merlot
Ch Tour du Moulin
Fronsac Cuvee Particuliere 05
Fronsac 05/06
06 Vin Rematquable Hachette 09
Tour du Pas St-Georges
St-Emilion 08
Ch les Tours de Peyrat
Prem Cotes de Blaye Vieilles Vignes 04/05/06
Ch Tour Peyronneau
St-Emilion GC 04/05/06/08/09
05 RP=87-89
04 WS=82
03 RP=89
03 WS=87
02 WE=91
10 WS=87
08 JR=16.5 (90)
07 JR=15 (84)
06 RP=89
05 WE=88
10 $15 WS
06 $10 Dec
05 $15 WE
10 WE=90
10 $17 WE
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
09 WS=92-95
08 RP=87
07 RP=83-85
10 $21 WS
10 $17-25 RP
09 $19 JJB
08 $25 WS
07 $14-22 RP
07 $20 Zachys
06/05 $20 WS
05 $25 Zachys
05 $19-25 RP
03 $21 WS
01 $15 WS
06 WS=83
05 WS=90
05 RP=86-88
03 WS=88
01 WS=87
05 WS=86
08 ST=85
06 $15 K&L
09 Merlot
04 WS=88
08 WS=89
07Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 10
06 WS=87
05 WS=90
04 WS=85
02 Bronze IWC 07
01 Silver IWC 07
Ch Tour de Pez
11 $20 wine.com
Ch la Tour de Pin
St-Emilion GC 05/06/07/08/09/10
09 WE=90
08 WE=92
08 SS=15.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
02 Gold Brussels 06
05 RP=87-88
04 RP=84-86
03 RP=87
10 ST=87
09 WE=93
09 RP=92-94
08 WS=87
08 RP=90-93
07 WS=85-88
04/03 €15-23
04 $18 RP
09 $39-54 RP
06 $22-23 RP
Ch la Tour de Pin Figeac
St-Emilion 09
05 WE=86
09 WE=90
195
Ch la Tour a Pomerol
Ch Tour de Pressac
Pomerol 04/05/06
06 ST=87-90
05 WE=91
04 ST=88
04 WE=90/91
03 WE=88
06 Silver Paris 09
04 Gold Brussels 06
04 Silver Paris 07
Ch Tour-Prignac (Castel)
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 05/06/07/08/09/10
09 Bronze Paris 11
08 Silver France-Macon 10
04 $47 ST
06 WS=87
05 WS=87
04 WS=87
10 WS=82
10 $18 WS
08 WS=88
08 JR=16.5 (90)
08 G&G=86
08 $30 WFoods
05 WS=87
05 WE=89
Medoc Prem Grande Res 05/06/08/09/10 (CS) 10 Bronze Decanter 12
08 Bronze Challenge, Decanter 10
Ch Tour de Roc
Bordeaux 10
06 WS=87
05 WS=87
10 RP=87
Ch Tour St-Andre
10 WS=87
10 $21 WS
Ch Tour St-Germaine
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 10
10 WS=85
10 $12 WS
Ch Tour St Bonnet
Medoc Cru Bourgeois 06/08/09/10
10 RP=90
10 CellarT 88 (2)
10 JR=14.5 (84)
09 RP=88-90
08 SS=15 (84)
08 Decanter=3star
06 RP=86
10 $9-24 RP
10 $15 Zachys
07 WE=85
05 NM=89
10 WE=90
07 $25 WE
Ch Tour Saint-Joseph
Ch Tour Saint-Vincenr
Medoc 10
Tour Salvet
09
Ch les Tours Seguy
Cotes de Bourg Mirandole 05/06/07/09
Ch Tour Seran
Ch Tour des Termes
Ch des Tours
Medoc 05/06/07/08/09/10
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 03-10
06 $22 WS
10 $16 RP
09 $11-14 RP
06 $10-16 RP
10 $18 WE
09 RP=87-88
05 RP=88
10 RP=89
09 Gold Paris 11
09 RP=89-91
08 RP=85-86+
07 Bronze Paris 09
06 RP=88
05 Gold Brussels 09
05 WS=87
10 ST=87
09 WS=92-95
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
06 WS=80-84
05 WS=91
05 RP=85-86
04 WS=88
03 WS=86
09 RP=87-88
06 $15 RP
05 $14 WC
10 $21-27 RP
09 $18-26
08 $19 RP
06 $20-22 RP
05 $25 WS
10 $21+ ST
09 $23 JJB
05 $27 WS
05 $19 Zachy
05 $16 RP
196
Ch les Tours Seguy
Bordeaux 10
05 Very Succesful Hachette 09
Les Tourelles Longueville
Ch Tournefeuille
03 Bronze IWC 07
Ch Tourteran
Haur-Medoc 07
Ch Toutigeac
Bordeaux Riuge 10
10 Bronze LA 11
Ch les Traverses
Medoc la Franque 09
09 Gold Paris 11
Botdeaux 10
Ch Trianon
St-Emilion 05/06
Clos Trimoulet
St-Emilion 05
Ch Trimoulet
St Emilion GC 04/05/06
05 $60 WS
04 $37 WS
10 ST=86
08 WS=89
06 WS=87
05 WS=88
06 $38 WS
05 WS=87
09 ST=88
10 Silver IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
10 $15 RP
07 WE=85
Ch Tresor du Grande Moine Lalande de pomerol 09
Ch Treytins
10 RP=86
05 RP=88
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=90
05 WE=88
04/03 WS=88
06 WS=83
10 Bronze IWC 12
10 CF-CS-Merlot
06 Silver Paris 09; Comm’d Dec 12
04 Gold Bordeaux 07
04 Silber MVini 06
04 Bronze IWC 07
04=60%M35%CF 5%CS
06 WS=88
05 WS=87
05 WS=87
06 WS=87
05 WE=87
05 WS=89
06 $40 WS
05 $37 WE
05 $30 WS
04 WE=90
04 WS=83
08 UWS=85
08 CellarT 88 (1)
08 G&G 85
04 $15 WE
04 $12 WS
10 $10 WClub
05 WE=85
04 WE=83
10 RP=87-89
09 RP=87-88
08 RP=86-88
05 $12 WE
04 $10 WE
10 $16-26 RP
09 $17-33 RP
08 $16 RP
08 $35 Andys
06 $15-19 RP
06 C$30 BCLS
05 $25 WS
05 $21 Zachys
05 $20-21 RP
05 $17 K&L
See also: Emilius de Ch Trimoulet
Ch Trocard
Bordeaux Sup Monrepos 06/07/08/09
09 SilverLA 12
07 Bronze LA 10
06 Very Successful Hachette
08 Gold Paris 10
07 Gold Brussels 09
Ch les Trois Croix
Fronsac 05/06/08/09/10
06 Very Succesasful Hachette 10
04 Coup de Coeurs Hachette 08
03 Vin Cite Hachette 07
06 RP=87
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
05 ST=87
05 RP=87
05 RC=87
03 WS=80-84
03 RP=86-88
197
Ch Trois Moulins
Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 08/09/10
04 Sehr Gut (Bronze ) MVini 06
10 WS=88
08 WE=88
Ch Trois Origines
St-Emilion 07 (07=90% Merlot)
07 ST=87
Ch Tronquoy-Lalande
Bordeaux Cru Bourgeois Sup 03-09
09 RP=90-93
08 WS=86
08 RP=89-91
07 RP=87
07 ST=85
St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 05-10
09 51%Merlot-CS
Tronquoy de Ste-Anne
08/09
Ch Troplong Mondot
St-Emilion GC 02-10
09 90% Merlot-7%CS-CF)
05 Rec’d W&S 4/06
05 Velvety, flavorful, seductive WW
05 Great wine SS in Decanter 06
04 Top 10 WW 06
04=85% M- 8% CF- 7% CS
03 Very Good WD 10/05
Ch Trotanoy
Pomerol 03-10
09 ST=95
10 $22 WS
08 $16 WE
06 RP=88
05 RP=87-88
09 $33-51 RP
08 $30 WS
08 $25-33 RP
07 $22-27 RP
07 $33 Zachys
07 C$39 BCLS
06 $28-35 RP
05 $25-28 RP
04 RP=85
04 $20 RP
10 ST=87
09 WE=92
09 ST=88
08 SS=16.0/20
08 Decanter=3star
07 RP=86-88
07 $22-33 RP
06 WS=85-88
05 WS=87
05 $22 WS
03/02 WS=85
09 RP=87-89
08 RP=85-86
10 ST=90
10 $145+ ST
10 JJB=95
09 ST=
09 $124+ ST
09 Hachette=2 star
09 WE=94
09 RP=94-97
09 $124-178 RP
09 JJB=97-99
09 Decanter=5star
09 Decanter=18.5
08 ST=90
08 RP=95-97
08 $68-141 RP
08 WE=93-95
08 WS=91-94
08 $70 K&L
08 JJB=87-89/84-86
07 RP=93
07 $61-87 RP
07 WE=89
07 $80 WE
07 ST=91
07 $80 K&L
07 WS=90
07 $125 Zachys
07 C$130 BCLS
06 RP=93
06 $82-186 RP
06 WE=95/94
06 C$199 BCLS
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=91
06 $135 WS
05 W&S=1star
05 WS=96
05 SS=19/20
05 RP=96-100
05 $216-348 RP
05 ST=96
04 ST=89
04 $75 B&M
04 WS=90
04 RP=89
04 WW=95-97
03 ST=92
03 WD=16.5/20
03 RP=92
02 ST=88
02 RP=88
09 $355+ ST
09 WE=96
198
08 90%Merlot-10%CF
05 Cellar Selectio WE
Ch Trotte Vieille
09 67%CF-31%M-2%CS
Ch la Tuilerie
Ch la Tuilerie des Combes
Bordeaux Sup Emotion 08
08 Silver LA 12
Cotes-de-Bourg 07/08
07 Gold Paris 09
07 Silver Paris 09
05 Gold Paris 07
Montagne-St-Emilion 03/04/05/06
09 RP=97-100
09 JJB=97-99
08 ST=92
08 RP=96-100
08 JJB=95-97
07 RP=89+
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=90
06 WE=94/95
06 RP=93
06 WS=93
06 ST=91-93
05 WE=94/96
05 WS=95
05 ST=94+?
04 WS=92
04 WE=94
04 ST=90+
03 ST=90
03 WS=91
02 WS=91
10 ST=86
09 WE=95
09 ST=88
09 RP=91-93
09 Decanter=4star
09 Decanter=17.5
08 WS=89
08 RP=90-93
07 RP=89+
07 WS=88
07 WE=88
07 ST=87
06 WE=93/93
06 RP=89+
06 WS=90
06 ST=86-88
05 WE=92/93
05 WS=92
05 ST=91
05 RP=93-95
04 WS=87
04 RP=89
04 ST=87
03 RP=90
03 WS=93
09 $375-546 RP
08 $249-336 RP
07 $105-140 RP
07 $95 Zachys
07 $150 K&L
07 C$149 BCLS
06 $119-176 RP
06 $137 WS
05 $175 Zachys
05 $250 WE
05 $190 WS
04 $80 WS
09 $97-130 RP
07 $100 RP
06 $74-98 RP
06 $110 WS
05 $106 WS
05 $96-143 RP
04 $58 WS
04 $67-80 RP
05 WS=80-84
Montagne-St-Emilion Cuvee Rubens 03/04/05
Ch Tuilerie Pages
Bordeaux 10
Ch la Tuilerie du Puy
08 Bronze LA 10
Ch les Tuileries
Bordeaux 06/07/08/09/10
10 Bronze LA 11
09 Gold Bordeaux 10
05 WS=80-84
03 WS=85
05 WS=80-84
04 WS=84
03 WS=87
10 WE=85
04 $25 WS
10 $14 WE
199
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Grand Chene 10
09 Silver LA 10
08 Silver Bordeaux, Paris 09
07 Silver Paris 09
10 Bronze Decanyer 12
Ch Turcard
Bordeaux 10
10 Best Buy WE
Ch Turcaud
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Majeure 08/10
Medoc 04/06
05 IWR=86
05 $9 IWR
10 WE=88
10 $12 WE
10 WE=87
10 $18 WE
10 RP=85
10 $16 RP
05 WE=87
05 $10 WE
05 W&S=84
05 $14 W&S
Cited Wine Hachette 11
Turon la Croix
Bordeaux 10
Union Producteurs
St-Emilion
Ch la Vaisinerie
St-Emilion GC Aurelius 09
St-Emilion GC Lidi 09
St-Emilion GC Cotes Rocheuses 09
Puisseguin St-Emilion 10
10 CF-Merlot
05 Best Buy W&S 10/08
Puisseguin St-Emilion Quercus 10
Ch Valandraud
07 Silver Brussels, Paris 09
St-Emilion GC 04-10
09 80%Merlot-CF
3 de Valandraud St-Emilion 10
10 ST=91
09 ST=91
09 WE=95
09 JJB=96-98
08 ST=89
07 RP=90-93
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=91
06 RP=92
06 ST=90-92
06 WS=92
05 WE=91
05 ST=94
05 WS=95
05 RP=93-95
09 $320+ ST
07 $180-274 RP
06 $156-240 RP
06 $225 WS
05 $ 299 Zachys
05 $315 WS
05 $200-242 RP
05 C$384 BCLS
04 WS=90
04 ST=88-90
04 RP=91
03 WS=93
04 $133-145 RP
03 C$314 BCLS
03/02 WE=90
10 ST=87
10 $27+ ST
08 WE=86
08 $25 WE
06 RP=87
06 $25 RP
See also their second wine: Le Virginie
Ch des Valentons
Bordeaux Sup 08/09
Bordeaux Sup L’Excentrique 08
09 Silver LA 12
08 Silver LA 11
08 Bronze LA 11
Ch Valentons Canteloup
Bordeaux Sup L’Exceintrique 09
09 Bronze LA 12
Ch du Vallier
Dom de Valmengaux
Bordeaux 05/06/09
Ch de Valois
Pomerol 04/05/06
06 WS=88
200
05 WS=89
Ch Valrose
Bordeaux 10
07 WS=81-84
06 WS=88
05 WS=92
10 JR=15.5 (86)
De Vaud
07
07 RP=87-88
Ch Venus
Graves 05/06/07/08/09/10
Ch Verdignan
St-estephe Cuvee Alienor 05/06/07
06 Silver Parid 09
03 Gold Brussels 06
08 Gold LA 10
06 WE=84
06 WS=85
05 WS=86
08 WE=89
07 WE=87
07 WS-80-83
06 WS=85
05 WS=90
05 RP=87-88
04 WE=87
05 $33 WS
06 $35 WE
07 $30 WE
05 $30 WS
05 $18 RP
03 WS=88
Ch les Vergnes
Bordeaux 08/09/10
Ch la Verriere
Bordeaux Sup 10
10 WE=81
10 $20 WE
Ch Veyry
Cotes de Castillon 05/06/07/08/09/10
10 RP=87
09 RP=87-88
08 RP=87-89
07 ST=85
06 RP=87
06 WS=87
05 ST=89
10 $25 RP
Ch de la Vieille Chapelle
Bordeaux Treaditional 08
Ch la Vieille Cure
Fronsac 03-11
08 Bronze LA 11
11 RP=90-92
11 WS=89-92
10 RP=91
TWCI=90-93
09 WE=92
09 RP=90-93
08 RP=88-90
07 RP=87-89
Clos de la Vieille Eglise
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07/09 (Merlot)
06 $25 RP
06 RP=90
05 ST=87-89
05 WS=90
$22 Zachys fut
10 $22-36 RP
09 $22-28 RP
09 $23 JJB
09 $25 Zachys
07 $23 RP
07 $23 Zachys
07 $25 Sh-L
06 $18-24 RP
05 $25 WS
05 $32 WS
05 $26 Zachys
04 RP=90
04 WS=88
03 Hachette=1star
03 RP=92
03 WS=90
09 Bronze Paris 11
07 WS=83-86
05 Gold Paris 07, Brussels 07
04 Gold Brussels 07
06 WS=87
05 WS=87
05 RP=87-89
05 WE=90
04 WE=91
05 $100 WE
04 $59 WE
201
Ch de la Vieille Tour
Vieille Tour la Roche
Bordeaux 06
Vieille Tour la Rose
Bordeaux 07/08
Vieux Ch L’Abbaye
St-Emilion 05
03 Gold Brussels 06
09 Silver LA 12
08 Silver LA 11
Pomerol 03-10
Vieux Ch Champs de Mars
Cuvee Johanna 06/08
Vieux Ch Landon
Medoc 04/05/06
Vieux Ch Palon
10
Vieux Clos St-Emilion
Montagne St-Emilion 07/08/09
Ch Vieux-Maillet
Pomerol 05/06/07/09
Ch Vieux Manoir
Bordeaux 10
Vieux Ch Mazeret
St-Emiliom 07/08/09/10
Vieux Ch Palon
Montagne St-Emilion 03-10
04 $60 WS
05 W&S=87
06 RC=86
05 $15 W&S
06 $6 TrJoes
08 C$24 BCLS
07 C$24 BCLS
Ch Vieux Cardinal Lafaurie Lalande-de-Pomerol 10
Vieux-Chateau-Certan
04 WS=87
03/02 WS=88
05 WS=87
10 WS=88
09 84%M-8%CF-8%CS
10 ST=94
09 ST=92
09 RP=96-99
08 RP=92-94
08 ST=91
07 RP=89
07 WS=88-91
07 ST=89
06 WE=96
06 RP=96
06 ST=91-93
06 WS=95
05 WS=97
05 Intense aromas, balanced, long WW 05 ST=92+?
05 Top 10 WW 06
05 WW=98-100
04 ST=93
04 WW=96-99
99 WS=91
08 RP=89-90
06 RP=87
06 WS=86
05 WS=82
04 WS=83
03 WR=88
10 TWCI=85-87
10 WS=88-91
09 RP=85-87
08 RP=89-90
07 RP=89-90
09 WE=88
09 RP=89-91
06 WS=88
05 WS=90
10 Bronze Decanter, IWC12
10 WE=86
10 CF-CS-Merlot
10 65%Merlot-35%CF
10 ST=88
09 WE=92
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=93-95
08 RP=92-94
07 RP=91
10 RP=87-88
08 Gold Paris 11
08 WS=88
07 Gold Bordeaux 10
07 ST=88
07 75%Merlot-CF
06 ST=87-89
10 $25 WS
09 $250+ ST
09 $220-325 RP
08 $94-149 RP
08 $80 Zachys
07 $80-120 RP
07 $100 K&L
07 $130 Zachy
07 $131 B&M
07 C$179 BCLS
06 $170 B&M
06 $137-243 RP
05 $220 B&M
06 $26 RP
06 $30 WS
04 $25 WS
10 $26 Zachys
09 $31-40 RP
07 $32 Dec
05 $56 WS
10 $10 WE
08 $175 Zachys
07 $125 RP
10 $16-26 RP
202
Vieuz Ch St Andre
Vieux Ch les Templiers
Pomerol 05/06
10/09 85%Merlot-CF
06/05 WS=85-88
05 RP=87-88
04 WS=85
03 RP=88
€15 Hachette
10 ST=86
09 ST=88
08 ST=88
06 $20 WClub
05 WS=84
07 RP=87-88
06 RP=87
07 WS=82-85
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=86-88
05 WS=80-84
04/03 WS=87
Vieux Clos St-Emilion
06/07
Ch Vieux-Maillet
Pomerol 03/04/05/06/07
Ch Vieux Robin
Medoc 10
04 Bronze IWC 07
03 Gold Brussels 06
Ch Vieux Taillefer
St-Emilion 10
02 WS=88
10 WE=90
10 WS=89
10 RP=87
10 ST=91
Vignobles Chaigne & Fils
Ch Ballan-Larquette
10 WE=88
10 $15 WE
Vignobles Raymond
Bordeaux L de Lagarde 09
09 Silver LA 10
Bordeauz les Hauts de Bellevue 09
09 Silver LA 10
06 $30 RP
05 $33 RP
10 $20 WE
10 $9-12 RP
Ch au Vignobles
Bordeaux Sup 06
06 WC=4 stars
06 C$16 WC
Ch Vignot
St-Emilion GC 04-09 (53%Merlot-27%CF-CS)
09 ST=87
07 ST=86
06 ST=87+
05 ST=87-90
04 WE=91
06 $49 Andys
Ch Vilatte
Bordeaux Sup Eleve en Futs 08
Ch Villa Bel-Air
Graves 04/05/06/07/08/09 (Cab Sauv)
Ch de Villambis
Haut Medoc 10
Ch Villars
Fronsac 03-11
08 Silver LA 11
09 CF-CS-Merlot
08 WS=85
07 Gold Paris 09
07 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 10 06 WS=83
05 WS=88
05 W&S=2stars
04 WS=75-79
03 WE=89
03 WS=79
10 RP=90
10 JR=15 (84)
10 RP=90
09 RP=90-92+
Ch de Villegeorge
Haut-MedocCru Bourgeois Sup 05-10
08 WS=60
08 RP=87-89
07 WS=60
07 RP=87-88
06 RP=88
05 WS=87
05 RP=88-90
03 RP=88-90
10 RP=86
08 $25 WS
06 $25 WS
05 $25 WS
05 $14-24 RP
10 $17 Zachys
11 $15 JJB Fut
10 $12-25 RP
09 $15-19 RP
09 $18 K&L
08/07 $24 WS
07 $24 WS
07 $11-14 RP
06 $28 RP
05 $19 WS
05 $19 Zachys
05 $20 RP
10 $13-17 RP
203
Ch Villemaurine
04 WE=86
03 WE=87
10 ST=87
Ch Villhardy
St-Emilion 05/06/07
Vingt Mille
06/07/09
Vinum Natura
Bordeaux 08/09
09 Bronze LA 11
08 Silver LA 10
Ch la Violette
Pomerol 06/07/08/09/10
10 100% Merlot
05 $38 WS
07 $156-218 RP
10 ST=90
10 TWCI=86-88
09 ST=88
09 JJB=96-98
09 RP=92-94
08 WS=87
08 RP=96-98
08 ST=92
07 RP=90
07 WS=85-88
07 ST=90-92
06 RP=92
06 WS=86
06 ST=89-92
06/05 WS=85-88
Bordeaux 10
10 WE=88
10 $20 WE
10 WS=88
10 $16 WS
05 WE=82
10 RP=87
08 $12 Dec
05 $10 WE
10 $18-22 RP
09 Merlot
Ch De Virecourt
08 WS=87
05 WS=89
07 RP=88-90
07 WS=84-87
05 WS=90
09 RP=89-91
07 RP=91
06 RP=91
Ch de Virecourt Pillebourse Bordeaux Sup 08/10
10 Merlot
08 Gold Brussels 10
Virginie Rhunevin
Boedeaux 10
Le Virginie de Valandraud
St-Emilion 05-09 (Ch Valandraud’s second wine)
(70%Merlot-30%CF)
Ch le Vivier
Medoc 03/04/05/06/07
Ch Vrai Canon Bouche
Canon Fronsac 03-12
09 ST=87
08 RP=89-91
07 ST=87
06 RP=88+
06 ST=87-89
06 WS=89
05 WS=88
10 95%Merlot-3%CF-2%Malbec
09 Merlot-CF
04/03 WS=87
07 WE=85
06 WS=82
05 WS=85
04 WS=86
03 WS=88
12 RP=90-92
11 RP=87-89
10 WS=89
10 RP=92
10 TWCI=88-90
09 RP=91-93
08 RP=91-94
07 100% Merlot
07 RP=89
07 ST=89
07 JMQ=87
06 RP=91
09 $170-234 RP
08 $190 K&L
08 $96-98 RP
07 $157-207 RP
06 $163-215 RP
06 $202 WS
06 $40-54 RP
05 $53-70 RP
06 $50 WS
05 $62 WS
04 $37 RP
04 $35 WS
07 $20 WE
03 $15 WS
10 $25 WS
10 $24 RP
09 $25 RP/K&L
09 $23 JJB
08 $22 RP
08 $24 Zachys
08 $26 WClub
07 $22 Zachys
06 $32 RP
204
Ch Vray-Croix-de-Gay
Winemakers’ Collection
Ch Yon-Figeac
06 ST=88-90
06 WS=85-88
05 RP=89-91
05 WS=80-84
05 W-Plus=87-90
03 RP=88-90
Pomerol 04/05/06/07/08/09
09 RP=90-93
08 WS=89
08 RP=87-89
07 WE=88
07 WS=87
07 ST=87
06 ST=87-90
06 WS=88
05 WE=91
05 WS=91
05 RP=88-90
04 WS=89
04 RP=86
03 RP=89
Pomerol l’Enchanteur Vray Croix de Gay 07/09 09 Bronze Decanter 12
07 WE=88
Denis Dubourdieu Cuvee No.2
RP=91
Stephane Derenoncourt Cuvee No.4 – 08
08 Comm’d Decxanter 11
05 $21 Zachys
09 $54-67 RP
07 $67 WE
06 $48 WS
05 $114 WS ?
05 $34 RP
04 $70 WS
07 $53 WE
$15 Zachys
08 RP=89-92
08 $15 Zachys
08 CellarT 89 (18) 06 $30 TW&M
08 JR=16.5 (90
08 WS=86
Yvon Mau
Yvecourt Bordeaux 04/05/09
Bordeaux Premius 07/08/09/10
Bordeaux Mauregard 08/09/10 (Merlot)
05 Bronze France (Macon) 06
04 Comm’d IWC 06
04 60%Merlot 20%CS 20%CF
07 Comm’d IWC 09
05 Gold Brussels 07
05 Silver Brussels 06)
05 Comm’d IWC 07
10 Comm’d IWC 12
06 WE=92
06 WS=87
05 WS=87
09 WE=83
05 WE=83
06 $36 WE
05 $10 WE
04 WE=85
06 WE=84
05 WE=84
Graves Ch des Proms Cuvee Bellevue 08
08 JR=15 (84)
08 WE=86
Seigniers de Bergerac 08
08 WE=84
06 $10 WE
08 $11 WE
See also:
Ch Brown
Ch Ducla
Ch Lapellatrie
Ch de Lussac
Ch Preuillac
Ch Taillefer
Ch Tauzinat
Ch Trimoulet
*Alpabetical by family/main name
6/4/13
205

BORDEAUX REDS – FRANCE

Transcription

Documents pareils

2016 Girls Division 1 Basketball Schedule

Mannschaftswertung Team

Liste des écoles classées par circonscriptions - SNUipp

sparkling white wine RED wine

best buys rhone red, france