Title of the measure: FRA31 Zero-rated eco-loan “éco
Transcription
Title of the measure: FRA31 Zero-rated eco-loan “éco
Last update: September 2015 Title of the measure: FRA31 Zero-rated eco-loan “éco-prêt à taux zéro” General description The zero-rated eco-loan scheme (eco-prêt à taux zéro) has been introduced by the “Finance law 2009” (loi de finance 2009) to allow landlords to get a loan to fund energy efficiency works (insulation, heating or water heating using renewable energies) for their main residence (if built before January, 1st 1990). The maximum amount of this loan is €30,000 refundable for 10 years (15 years in cases of heavy works or “3-action bunches”). It is granted by banks which have concluded specific agreement with the French State under conditions fixed in the General Taxes Code (Code Général des impôts). This scheme is available until the end of 2015 but the project of Finance law 2016 (loi de finance 2016) has planned its extension until December, 31st 2018. Who can benefit from this scheme? This loan is granted to landlords (occupiers or lessors) without any income condition. It could be also used by co-owners in the limit of €10,000 per flat (or until €30,000 if the co-owners union launches 3 different works). Refurbished dwellings located in mainland France have to be a main residence built before the 1st January 1990. Houses located in French overseas territories and departments (Guadeloupe, Martinique, Guyane and at La Réunion and Mayotte) have to be the main residence of owners who have applied for a building permit before May, 1st 2010. What kind of works can be eligible? To benefit from the zero-rated eco-loan, households must either: implement a “bunch of work”; achieve a minimum level of “overall energy performance” through the implementation of energy efficiency measures; or rehabilitate an individual sewerage system by a device which doesn’t consume energy. Type and technical characteristics of works are described in decree (arrêté du 30 mars 2009 modified by arrêté du 2 décembre 2014). Nota Bene: only one loan can be granted per dwelling (there are some exceptions for co-owned flats). What is a “bunch of work” "A bunch of work" is the combination of at least two actions implemented to improve the energy performance of a dwelling. These actions must belong to 2 different categories among the following items: Outdoor walls insulation; Roof insulation; Outdoor window and door insulation; installation or replacement of heating or hot water equipment; installation of heating or hot water equipment, relying on renewable energy sources. These actions shall be implemented under a single year or over two consecutive years and made by professionals certified « RGE» (Reconnu Garant de l’Environnement) from September, 1st 2014 (and from December, 31st 2015 in French overseas departments). Nota Bene: For certain types of works (that cannot be included in a “bunch of works”), requirement to professionals certified « RGE» is not mandatory. Last update: September 2015 What is the minimum level of energy performance required? Rather than carrying out by themselves the bunch of works, households (whose house has been built after January, 1st 1948) can benefit from a detailed thermal study performed by a consulting firm to better identify refurbishment works to do in order to reduce the energy consumption to: 150 kWh / m² / year, for dwellings consuming over 180 kWh / m² / year1 before works; 80 kWh / m² / year, for dwellings consuming less than 180 kWh / m² / year1 before works. Nota Bene: these values can vary in function of the climatic zones and altitude of the building. Bunch of works 2 actions Maximum amount of the loan (in €) 20,000 3 actions or more 30,000 Overall energy performance Sewerage system 30,000 10,000 Table 1- Maximum amount of the zero-rated eco-loan Only banks which have signed a convention with the French State are allowed to offer these types of loan. About 20 banks have signed such a convention mid-2015. Impact evaluation The SGFGAS (Society of Management of Funds for Guarantee of home purchasing – Société de Gestion des Financements et de la Garantie de l’Accession Sociale à la propriété) is the organism which manages both 0% rate loans to support households in purchasing housings, and the zero-rated eco-loan from the French State. Since 2009, it has collected different types of data such as the type of works financed with the eco-loan, the year of construction, the owner category (occupier or lessor), the amount of the loan, and the duration of reimbursement. Nota Bene: raw data for 2014 are available online (https://www2.sgfgas.fr/web/guest/eco-pret-a-tauxzero1) but graphs were not yet published when we updated this measure description. Number of zero-rate eco-loans from 2009 Graph 1 – Number of zero-rate eco-loans between 2009 and 2014 (graph made from SGFGAS data) In 2009 71,098 loans have been granted. The Grenelle objectives were 200,000 loans between the beginning of 2009 and the end of 2010; 240,000 more in 2011; 320,000 more in 2012; and 400,000 more each year from 2013. 1 in primary energy Last update: September 2015 Type of works and average lent amount In 2009, the average amount of loans was €16,500€ (€14,300 for a bunch of 2 types of works, €23,200 for a bunch of 3 types of works or more and €19,100 for the over-all energy works). The average amount spent for works was €18,900. 2009 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 70,933 2010 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 78,484 2011 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 40,755 2012 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 33,861 Last update: September 2015 2013 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 32,464 2014 Total number of zero-rate eco-loan: 31,196 Graph 2 – Distribution of loans (at final stage) per type and average lent amount in 2009(graph made from SGFGAS data) Focus on 2009 Number of works Distribution among all the funded by the Type of works works funded by the zerozero-rate eco-loan rate eco-loan scheme Roof 34,200 48% Walls 19,300 27% Windows 53,000 75% Boilers- Heat pumps 31,500 44% Renewable heating 14,700 21% Renewable hot water system 7,600 11% Table 2 – Number of works per type in 2009 Windows represented 75% of the works financed by the zero-rate eco-loan in 2009 even if it was one of the less efficient type of works. This can be explained by the fact that window insulation requirements to benefit from a zero-rate eco-loan were lower than the others. The most common bunches were: - for 2-work-bunches Windows and space heating (or heat pump) (27%) Windows and roof (22%) Windows and renewable heating (13%) - for 3 or more-work-bunches Windows and roof and walls (31%) Windows and roof and boiler (or heat pump) (13%) Windows and roof and walls and heat pump (9%) Type of works Roof Walls Number of works with funded by the zerorate eco-loan scheme Total number of works made in France 34,200 (21%) 19,300 (12%) 395,000 (11%) 1,088,000 (29.5%) Percentage of works benefiting from the zero-rate eco-loan scheme out of all other works 9% 2% Last update: September 2015 Windows 53,000 (33%) 1,285,000 (35%) 4% Heating + Renewables 53,800 (34%) 900,000 (24.5%) 6% Total 160,300 3,668,000 4% Table 3 – Comparison between works benefiting from the 0% eco-loan and others (reference year: 2009) Percentage of works benefiting from the Total amount invested Type of works zero-rate eco-loan in works in France scheme out of all other works Roofing €744M (7%) €157M (13%) 21% Walls €2,033M (20%) €137M (12%) 7% Windows €4,124M (40%) €427M (36%) 10% Heating + Renewables €3,371M (33%) €466M (39%) 14% €10,273M (100%) €1,187M (100%) Total 12% Table 4 – Comparison between amount funded by the 0% eco-loan and the total amount invested (reference year: 2009) Cost of works funded by the zero-rate ecoloan Zero-rate eco-loan has funded in 2009 around 4% of operations carried out in France and 12% in amount. It has supported some works three times as expensive as the average works in France and mainly more complex. Who were the beneficiaries of those loans in 2009? Those loans mainly concerned individual houses (94%) and owner occupiers (94%). Only 1% concern coownerships. People benefiting from zero-rate eco-loan are mainly rather wealthy: - 20% of the richest households benefit from 60% of those loans; - 60% of the poorest households benefit from 20% of those loans. Environmental impact & energy saved per type of operation (2009) The impact of this measure has been estimated for 2009 using the standardized operation sheets elaborated within the framework of the white certificate scheme (see FRA45 Energy Saving Certificates for more information) for each type of works. Energy savings during the year 2009 950 GWh CO2 savings during the year 2009 0.18 MtCO2 CO2 savings during the whole life span of the works 5.8 MtCO2 (27 years in average, depending on the works) Table 5 – Environmental impact and energy saved in 2009 Kind of operation Bunches of works Roof Walls Windows Number of operations 34,173 19,315 52,816 CO2 savings during the whole life span of the operation (tCO2) 5,773,599 1,961,894 1,845,628 634,896 Energy savings per year (MWh) 945,377 253,605 218,688 75,276 Last update: September 2015 Energy efficient heat system - condensing boiler 13,485 367 862 - low temperature boiler 1,710 28 683 - heat pump 16,209 580 913 Renewable heat system - wood boiler 2,391 151,696 - stove, fireplace insert 12,283 179,558 Renewable hot water system 7,599 22,469 492 20,808 Over-all energy works 1,640 Water purification system with low energy consumption ( for housings which are not connected to the public network) Total 70,933 5,794,406 Table 6 – Environmental impact in 2009 100,781 6,182 165,535 41,163 74,818 9,329 6,763 952,140 Economical impact in 2009 Kind of operation Bunches of works Roof Walls Windows Energy efficient heat system - condensing boiler - low temperature boiler - heat pump Renewable heat system - wood boiler - stove, fireplace insert Renewable hot water system Over-all energy works Water purification system with low energy consumption ( for housings which are not connected to the public network) Total Total lent amount (M€) Gross public cost (M€) (*) 1149 166 145 449 287 Gross public cost per tCO2 (M€) 50 Net cost per tCO2 (M€) (**) -265 -241 387 94 9 225 -82 -25 35 37 71 55 9 2 -72 72 1,987 -52 12 3 1,168 293 112 -14 (*) The gross public cost is the money given by the government to the banks (thanks to tax credit): it is the difference between a zero-rate eco-loan and a classic loan. (**) The net cost is the investment corresponds to the money lent deduced from the cost of the energy savings during its whole expected lifetime. A negative net public cost means that the operation is profitable (the cost of energy savings is higher than the investment). Table 7– Economical impact in 2009 Last update: September 2015 Opinion polls (2013) Since 2013, the opinion poll institute TNS SOFRES used to conduct yearly for ADEME a study analysing the behaviours of 10,000 households regarding energy efficiency within their dwellings. Graph 3- Have you heard of the Zero-rated eco-loan? Graph 4- Do you expect to benefit from the Zero-rated eco-loan within the next 2 years? Graph 5- Why do you expect not to take advantage of the Zero-rated eco-loan within the 2 next years? Last update: September 2015 Potential and effective energy savings (2013) In September 2013, since the beginning of the measure 235,000 loans had been granted for an average works cost of €19,200. Energy saved and potentially saved thanks to this scheme within 2020 has been assessed from the SceGES2 tool from the French General Direction for Energy and Climate (DGEC) thanks to a bottom-up approach describing the physical determinants of this credit tax measure. Energy savings (Mtoe) 2013 (ex post) 0.18 2016 (ex-ante) 0.19 2020 (ex-ante) 0.19 According to ADEME3, the final energy consumption of the residential sector was around 39.6 Mtoe in 2013. By assuming that 0.18 Mtoe (0.45%) was saved in the residential sector thanks to this scheme, this measure can be assumed to have a medium impact on the residential sector energy consumption. Measure Impact Level low medium high Definition of impact: Low: energy savings < 0.1% of the overall residential sector energy consumption Medium: between 0.1 and 0.5% High: > 0.5% Interaction of measures FRA16 Local energy information centres FRA34 Energy performance audits FRA 7 Tax credit for works on energy efficiency, energy efficiency materials and renewable energies FRA5 VAT Reduction on energy efficiency investments Historical data This measure launched in 2009 through the “Finance law 2009” (loi de finance) has been adjusted in December 2014 (see decree n° 2014-1437 from December 2nd, 2014) in order to, from January, 1st 2015: Transfer the responsibility of works certification to companies which perform works; Ensure that documentary invoices given by the borrower include induced works; Modify the administrative penalties for companies that do not respect their duties. Another legislative text has been put into forced at the end of 2014 (arrêté du 2 décembre 2014 modifying the arrêté du 30 mars 2009) to converge technical eligibility criterion of the eco-loan on those of the tax credit scheme for building energy performances. In addition, the arrêté from December 2014 modifying the arrêté from May 2011 has updated conditions to apply for zero-rate eco-lane in French overseas territories and departments. 2 SceGES comes from « GHG emissions scenarios» (Scénarisation des Emissions de Gaz à Effet de Serre) 3 Chiffres Clés Climat Air Energie 2014 (data source : CEREN, Parcs et consommations d’énergie du résidentiel, décembre 2013) Last update: September 2015 References Legislative and administrative acts Loi de Finance 2009 et 2015 Article 244 quater U du code général des impôts Arrêté du 2 décembre 2014 modifiant l’arrêté du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux conditions d’application de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Arrêté du 2 décembre 2014 modifiant l’arrêté du 25 mai 2011 relatif à l’application en outre-mer de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Arrêté du 22 décembre 2014 modifiant l’arrêté du 25 mai 2011 relatif à l’application en outre-mer de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2014-1437 du 2 décembre 2014 relatif aux avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2014-1438 du 2 décembre 2014 relatif aux avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Arrêté du 16 juillet 2014 relatif aux critères de qualifications requis pour le bénéfice du crédit d’impôt développement durable et des avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Arrêté du 16 juillet 2014 modifiant l’arrêté du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux conditions d’application de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens et modifiant l’arrêté du 25 mai 2011 relatif à l’application en outre-mer de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n°2014-812 du 16 juillet 2014 pris pour l’application du second alinéa du 2 de l’article 200 quater du code général des impôts et du dernier alinéa du 2 de I de l’article 244 quater U du code général es impôts Arrêté du 27 décembre 2013 modifiant l’arrêté du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux conditions d’application de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2013-1297 du 27 décembre 2013 relatif aux dispositions particulières à l'octroi aux syndicats de copropriétaires d'avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d'améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2013-205 du 11 mars 2013 relatif à l'emprunt collectif de copropriété Arrêté du 25 mai 2011 relatif à l’application en outre-mer de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêts destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Last update: September 2015 Arrêté du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux conditions d’application de dispositions concernant les avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2009-344 du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2009-346 du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux avances remboursables sans intérêt destinées au financement de travaux de rénovation afin d’améliorer la performance énergétique des logements anciens Décret n° 2009-347 du 30 mars 2009 relatif aux obligations déclaratives et aux modalités de détermination et d’imputation du crédit d’impôt en faveur des établissements de crédit qui accordent des avances remboursables ne portant pas intérêt pour le financement de travaux d’amélioration de la performance énergétique des logements anciens For further information Governmental websites: - www.economie.gouv.fr/cedef/eco-pret-a-taux-zero - www.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/L-eco-pret-a-taux-zero-en-14.html - www.territoires.gouv.fr/l-eco-pret-a-taux-zero-coproprietes - www.territoires.gouv.fr/l-eco-pret-a-taux-zero-eco-ptz SGFGAS (Society of Management of Funds for Guarantee of home purchasing – Société de Gestion des Financements et de la Garantie de l’Accession Sociale à la propriété) website: https://www2.sgfgas.fr/web/guest/eco-pret-a-taux-zero1