docJules Carrière School of Management University of Ottawa 136
download 
Plainte Transcription
Jules Carrière School of Management University of Ottawa 136
Volume 28, Division 6, 2007 Edited by • Édité par Hari Bapuji Asper School of Business, University of Manitoba Winnipeg, MB Canada AND Carole Donada ESSEC Business School Paris Strategy Stratégie Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Administrative Sciences Association of Canada Actes du Congrès annuel de l’Association des sciences administratives du Canada Ottawa, Ontario June 2 – 5, 2007 Ottawa, Ontario 2 – 5 juin, 2007 Copies of these Proceedings may be ordered from: Des exemplaires de ces Actes peuvent être obtenus auprès de : Jules Carrière School of Management University of Ottawa 136, Jean-Jacques Lussier Ottawa, ON Canada K1N 6N5 Telephone: (613) 562-5800 (4744) Fax/Télécopieur: (613) 562-5164 E-mail/courriel: [email protected] 1 PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I still remember the evening of June 4, 2006, in the hilly surroundings of Banff, when I was asked to serve as the Academic Reviewer for Strategy Division. Having been in the profession for a relatively few years, I was not ready to take on the responsibility. However, I accepted the responsibility with one thing on my mind: my colleagues will help me deliver. It turned out to be true. Almost everyone that I approached about ASAC agreed to help. Not surprisingly, we had 64 reviewers who provided as many as 120 reviews on 35 English papers submitted. As a result, we have a great program this year…! On behalf of all those who helped put together this program, I take great pleasure to introduce the 2007 ASAC Strategy Division Proceedings. This year we received a total of 47 papers, of which 35 were English submissions. Of these, nine full papers (English) were accepted for presentation and inclusion in the proceedings. Ten papers (English) were accepted only for presentation and inclusion of their summaries in the proceedings. The author of one full paper opted to not publish the paper in the proceedings. The papers in this proceedings deal with a range of topics that seek to advance our understanding on a variety of topics, including new methodologies to address strategy research questions, ownership effects, mergers & acquisitions, knowledge/learning, stakeholder theory, executive compensation, diversification, contingencies/fit, social capital, new product development, and economic liberalization…! I would like to thank the authors who submitted their work to make this program possible. I congratulate them for their excellent accomplishments. I am grateful to the session chairs and discussants who agreed to steer the sessions. This year’s program marks the 50th anniversary of ASAC. We planned special sessions to commemorate that occasion, including (i) a research panel that will reflect on the past and future of Canadian management research; (ii) a practice panel of stakeholders of management research to reflect on the relevant issues to them which need research attention; and (iii) a paper development workshop. I wish to thank all those who made these sessions and the rest of the program possible. I would like to especially thank Dr. Elizabeth Croft, University of Northern British Columbia, Dr. Irene Henriques, York University, Dr. Carole Donada (ESSEC Business School), Dr.s Glenn Rowe, Mary Crossan, Paul Beamish, and Tima Bansal of The University of Western Ontario, and Dr. Parshotam Dass, University of Manitoba for their constant support and encouragement. I would like to thank the members of the Best Paper Adjudication Committee: (i) Dr. Shamsud Chowdhury, Dalhousie University; (ii) Dr. Jaana Woiceshyn, University of Calgary, and (iii) Dr. Elie Matta, HEC, Paris. I would also like to thank Dr. Andrew Delios, National University of Singapore for taking lead in organizing the Paper Development Workshop. I would like to thank all the reviewers who extended their services. Particularly, I would like to thank Marina Apaydin, Nikhil Celly, Shamsud Chowdhury, Balaji Koka, John Philips, Natalia Totskaya, 2 Suhaib Riaz, and Jaana Woiceshyn, for providing excellent reviews that were helpful to the authors. More importantly, I would like to thank all my friends and colleagues at Ivey Business School and Asper Business School who offered their services as reviewers and discussants in this year’s program. Finally, every time I take up a major project, I swear to complete it without taking any help from my wife, Sunita. And, I fail every time…! So, let me at least thank my wife and best friend, Sunita for her help in putting the reviews together. Hari Bapuji Academic Reviewer – ASAC Strategy Division (2006-07) Assistant Professor Asper School of Business, University of Manitoba Winnipeg MB Canada R3T 5V4 Phone: 204-474-8432 Fax: 204-474-7545 Email: [email protected] 3 STRATEGY DIVISION REVIEWERS – 2007 Each of the Division’s submissions underwent a double-blind review process and 24 papers were ultimately accepted for the program. The papers in this volume represent the reviewers’ evaluations of the eleven best submissions. Much effort was taken to match the manuscripts with reviewers’ interests. The latter resulted in authors receiving, according to the feedback we received, excellent comments. We would like to thank the following reviewers for having taken time out of their busy schedules to help make this year’s ASAC Strategy Division program a success…! Hari Bapuji and Carole Donada Reviewer University Marina Apaydin Mourad Attarca University of Western Ontario IUT - Mantes Anne Bartel-Radic Université de Savoie - Annecy Jérôme Barthélemy Samia Belaounia Soumaya Ben Dhaou Arjun Bhardwaj Martin Bliemel Virginia Bodolica Kevin Boeh Jean-Philippe Bonardi Bourgeon Laurent Sofy Carayannopoulos Sergio Carvalho Nikhil Celly Chris Chang Shamsud Chawdhary Abdulrahman Chikhouni Hong-Jen Charles CHIU Yan Cimon Valérie Claude-Godillat Chirita Mircea-Gabrielle Parshotam Dass Robert Demarteau Carole Donada Bruno Dyck Catherine Elliott Adam Fremeth Darcy Fudge Mark Fuller Jijun Gao Manpreet Hora Jack Ito Frank Jiang Kam Jugdev Egide Karuranga Balaji Koka ESSEC Business School - Paris ESC - Rouen University of Quebec in Montreal University of Western Ontario Simon Fraser University Université du Québec en Outaouais University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario ESSEC Business School - Paris Wilfrid Laurier University University of Manitoba University of Western Ontario Flordia International University Dalhousie University Concordia University National Taiwan University Bishop's University AUDENCIA - Nantes HEC Montréal University of Manitoba Université du Québec à Montréal ESSEC Business School - Paris University of Manitoba University of Ottawa University of Minnesota University of Manitoba York University University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario University of Regina University of Western Ontario Athabasca University Virginia State University Arizona State University 4 Reviewer Andre Laplume Hervé Laroche Stephanie Lavigne Emmanuelle Lenagard Dominic Lim Christian Mahieu Sudha Mani Cara Maurer Daina Mazutis Lassaad Mezghani Raza Mir Valérie Moatti Caroline Mothe John Nash Paul Ngobo Na Ni Gwénaëlle Nogatchewsky Fréderic Nlemvo Alidou Ouderaogo Marielle Payaud George Peng John Philips Serge Poisson Bertrand Quélin Nafouel Remili Suhaib Riaz Glenn Rowe Akbar Saeed Camille Saussois-Madelon Eric Simon Subbu Sivaramakrishnan Natalie Slawanski Karan Sonpar Richard Soparnot Chris Street Sujit Sur Jianyun Tang Carol-Ann Tetrault Sirsly Natalya Totskaya Krishna Udayasankar John Usher Constance Van Horne Dusya Vera Olivier Vidal Kent Walker Huanglin Wang Taiyuan (Terry) Wang Brian Wixted Jaana Woiceshyn Yuanyuan Wu University University of Manitoba ESCP-EAP - Paris Groupe ESC Toulouse ESSEC Business School -Paris University of Western Ontario IAE de Bretagne University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario FSEG Sfax William Patterson University ESCP-EAP - Paris Université de Savoie Annecy University of Ottawa Université d’Angers University of Manitoba Université de Paris Dauphine Groupe ESC Troyes University of Moncton IAE - Université Jean-Moulin de Lyon University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario Université Laval à Québec HEC Paris Université du Québec à Montréal University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario HEC - Paris ESCA - Angers University of Manitoba University of Western Ontario University of Manitoba ESCEM - Tours University of Manitoba Concordia University University of Western Ontario Concordia University Concordia University National University of Singapore University of Lethbridge Université Laval University of Houston Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Cachan University of Manitoba University of Western Ontario University of Western Ontario Simon Fraser University University of Calgary McGill University 5 Yan Fei Zhao University of Toronto 6
