Charlier P, Huynh-Charlier I, Poupon J, Keyser C

Article :
Charlier P, Huynh-Charlier I, Poupon J, Keyser C, Lancelot E, Favier D, Vignal JN,
Sorel P, Chaillot PF, Boano R, Grilletto R, Delacourte S, Duriez JM, Loublier Y,
Campos P, Willerslev E, Gilbert MT, Eisenberg L, Ludes B, de la Grandmaison GL.
Multidisciplinary medical identification of a French king's head (Henri IV). BMJ
2010;341:c6805
L’ICMJE, recommande que l’attribution de la qualité d’auteur repose sur les
4 critères suivants :
1. Contributions substantielles à la conception ou aux méthodes de la recherche
ou à l’acquisition, l’analyse ou l’interprétation des données ; ET
2. Rédaction préliminaire de l’article ou sa révision critique impliquant une
contribution importante au contenu intellectuel ; ET
3. Approbation finale de la version à publier ; ET
4. Engagement à assumer l’imputabilité pour tous les aspects de la recherche
en veillant à ce que les questions liées à l’exactitude ou l’intégrité de toute partie
de l’œuvre soient examinées de manière appropriée et résolues.
Outre son imputabilité pour les composants de la recherche qu’il ou elle a
effectués, un auteur doit être en mesure d’identifier quels coauteurs sont
responsables d’autres parties spécifiques de l’œuvre. De plus, les auteurs doivent
avoir pleine confiance en l’intégrité des contributions respectives de leurs
coauteurs.
Authors : name, address and contributorship
in the BMJ
Philippe Charlier, forensic medical examiner
and osteo-archaeologist, Paris
PC conceived and headed the project, did the
anthropological and paleopathological
analyses, and the microscopic and endoscopic
examinations. PC wrote most of the
manuscript, with critical input from LE, JP,
GLDLG
Isabelle Huynh-Charlier, radiologist, Paris
IHC did the radiological examinations and three
dimensional computed tomography
reconstructions
Joël Poupon, biological toxicologist, Paris
JP and LE did the elemental analyses. PC wrote
most of the manuscript, with critical input
from LE, JP, GLDLG.
Christine Keyser, specialist in forensic genetics,
Strasbourg
PFC, EW, MTPG, CK, and BL did ancient DNA
extractions and analyses. CK is guarantor?
Eloïse Lancelot, elemental toxicologist
Authorship criteria
ICMJE
1
yes
2
yes
3
yes
4
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
Retraction
agreement
No
BMJ Letter
http://www.
bmj.com/co
ntent/341/b
mj.c6805/rr/
669664
No
(email)
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
no
no
no
Identification tête Henri IV, Contribution des 20 auteurs, 31 décembre 2013
No
(email)
Page 1/2
Dominique Favier, organic molecular analyst
DF did the molecular organic analyses.
Jean-Noël Vignal, doctor in anthropology
JNV did the three dimensional facial
reconstructions.
Philippe Sorel, arts historian
PS provided data about historical face
moulding.
Pierre F Chaillot, resident, Lyon
PFC did cranial measurements from computed
tomography reconstructions.
Rosa Boano, anthropologist
RG and RB provided comparative data about
the Italian embalming process.
Renato Grilletto, professor of anthropology
RG and RB provided comparative data about
the Italian embalming process.
Sylvaine Delacourte, perfumer SD and JMD
performed professional olfaction.
Jean-Michel Duriez, perfumer
SD and JMD performed professional olfaction.
Yves Loublier, palynologist
YL carried out botanical (pollen) observation
from oral deposits.
Paola F Campos, specialist in paleogenetics
PFC, EW, MTPG, CK, and BL did ancient DNA
extractions and analyses.
Eske Willerslev, professor in paleogenetics
PFC, EW, MTPG, CK, and BL did ancient DNA
extractions and analyses.
M T P Gilbert, specialist in paleogenetics,
Copenhagen
PFC, EW, MTPG, CK, and BL did ancient DNA
extractions and analyses.
Leslie Eisenberg, forensic anthropologist,
Wisconsin, US
JP and LE did the elemental analyses. PC wrote
most of the manuscript, with critical input
from LE, JP, GLDLG
Bertrand Ludes, professor of legal medicine,
Paris
PFC, EW, MTPG, CK, and BL did ancient DNA
extractions and analyses.
Geoffroy Lorin de la Grandmaison, professor of
legal medicine, Paris
PC wrote most of the manuscript, with critical
input from LE, JP, GLDLG
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
?
Honorary
(English editing)
Yes
BMJ Letter
http://www.
bmj.com/co
ntent/341/b
mj.c6805/rr/
668615
?
Honorary
No
Yes
No
?
Identification tête Henri IV, Contribution des 20 auteurs, 31 décembre 2013
yes
BMJ letter
http://www.
bmj.com/co
ntent/341/b
mj.c6805/rr/
668615
Page 2/2