5_Benchmarking commercial paints

BENCHMARKING
WITH COMMERCIAL PAINTS
TESTS WITH DIFFERENTS CAPSTONE ®
BENCHMARKING STUDY WITH
15 COMMERCIAL PAINTS
REFERENCE
MARQUE / GROUPE
CATEGORIE
TYPE APPLICATION
LABELS
RESINES
CODE EMB
ONIP Pursoie
ONIP
Batiment intérieur & Extérieur Brillant
?
Ecolabel
alkyde uréthanne
27666
ONIP L'eaunip satin velours
ONIP
Batiment intérieur & Extérieur
Satin
?
NF Environnement
acrylique
27666
Monocouche
LUXENS (groupe Adéo)
Murs & Plafonds intérieurs
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
acrylique
27666
Lumière & Couleurs
DULUX VALENTINE - ICI PAINTS
Boiseries
Brillant
Monocouche
NF Environnement
Acrylique
?
Couleurs Intérieures Brillant Ultra
LUXENS (groupe Adéo)
Murs & boiseries intérieures Brillant
Monocouche
Ecolabel
EN 71-3
Acrylique
80570
Haute Résistance Murs et boiseries
RIPOLIN
Murs & Boiseries
Brillant
Monocouche
NF Environnement
?
80570
Expression Déco facile
ASTRAL (AKZO NOBEL)
Murs et boiseries
Satin
Monocouche
acrylique
60414
Peinture murale satin
Groupe Adéo
Intérieur
Satin
Bi-couche
acrylique
57630
Architecte
DULUX VALENTINE - ICI PAINTS
Murs & Boiseries intérieures
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
Alkyde émulsion
Styrène Acrylique
?
Avis 3000
AVI (PPG AC retail Europe)
Murs et boiseries
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
acrylique
80750
Ultra Resist Cuisine
DULUX VALENTINE - ICI PAINTS
Murs Cuisine
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
acrylique
?
Acrylique Brillant
Meffert France SAS
Brillant
?
acrylique
57630
Supercrème
RIPOLIN
Murs & plafonds
Satin
Monocouche
NF Environnement
? (90% origine naturelle)
80570
Perspective Cuisine & Bains
TOLLENS (MATERIS)
Murs Cuisine
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
acrylique
?
Monocouche 4 en 1
LUXENS (groupe Adéo)
Murs & Boiseries intérieures
Satin
Monocouche
Ecolabel
EN 71-3
Teflon ®
acrylique
39199
Protocol :
-Application of 200µ of humid paint in 1 layer on Leneta support
-Drying : 7 days
Tests done :
- Contact angle with water & oil after 1 minut
- Blocking 4h and 24h
- Gloss at 60°
- Dirt Pick-up Resistance (DPR)
- Cleanability and stain resistance
Résistance à l'eau et à l'huile
80,0
78,0
78,3
C
B
74,6
70,0
66,8
67,1
67,4
67,9
70,0
64,5
61,4
60,0
62,0
56,9
54,7
47,9
Angle (°)
50,0
40,0
30,6
29
30,0
25,2
20,0
17
10,0
0,0
H
A
F
I
K
D
L
J
M
Water & Oil contact angle
G
E
O
N
Blocking Test (ASTM D- 4946 modified)
200 µm humid
30 minuts at 50oC
4 or 24 hours at controlled temperature & humidity
Bad blocking Résistance
Good blocking Résistance
BLOCKING TEST COTATION
cotation
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Description de la sйparation
pas d'adhйrence
trace d'adhйrence
trиs lйgиre adhйrence
lйgиre adhйrence
faible adhйrence
collant
collant sans arrachement
5 а 25% d'arrachement
25 а 50% d'arrachement
50 а 75% d'arrachement
75 а 100% d'arrachement
Performance
parfait
excellent
trиs bon
bon/ trиs bon
bon/ trиs bon
assez bon
mauvais а assez bon
mauvais а assez bon
mauvais а assez bon
trиs mauvais
trиs mauvais
Blocking
10
9
4h
24h
8
Cotation
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
D
N
C
O
M
K
J
B
A
E
H
F
L
G
I
Test ‘’Cleanability’’ (modified ASTM D - 4828)
DURING 5 CYCLES
Test ‘’Cleanability’’ (modified ASTM D - 4828)
0%
100 %
Stain retention
Lavability
L initial
L after wiping
L after wiping and scrubing
L after wiping and scrubing– L after wiping
Lavability =
X 10
Cotation from 0 to 10
L initial – L after wiping
L initial – L after wiping and scrubing
X 100
Stain retention =
L initial
Result in %
Stain rétention
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
M
K
L
J
G
A
F
I
D
N
O
C
E
B
H
TEST ‘’DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE’’
Artificial Dirt: Literature showed that dirt is usually composed of
SOOT, DUST and INORGANIC CRYSTALLITES.
DuPont DIRT COMPOSITION :
19.35% SiO2: silica gel, 5 – 25 µm
19.35% Al2O3: aluminum oxide, <10 µm
9.7% Fe3O4: natural black, <45 µm
1.6% Lamp Black: 90-120 nm – (SOOT)
50% Soil: dried, grounded soil from lab
L initial – L final
X 100
DPR =
L initial
Dirt pick up resistance
16,0
14,0
12,0
10,0
8,0
6,0
4,0
2,0
0,0
M
A
K
N
L
D
O
E
F
C
J
G
H
B
I
80
70
60
Brillant à 60°
50
40
30
20
10
0
F
N
G
I
O
K
J
H
Gloss at 60°
M
L
B
A
D
C
E
CLASSEMENT
MOYENNE (./20)
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
20,0
18,0
16,0
14,0
12,0
10,0
8,0
6,0
4,0
2,0
0,0
H
E
I
B
F
G
I
J
A
O
C
D
K
N
M
CLASSEMENT
PEINTURES
PRIX (€/kg)
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
note (./20) = angle / 3
note (./20) = blocking 24h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
MOYENNE (./20)
H
11,6
15,0
10
18
18
14
E
34,8
13,8
10
16
17
12
I
14,76
13,3
0
20
16
17
B
27,06
11,3
0
12
18
15
F
2,78
11,3
0
18
15
12
G
9,96
11,3
0
18
13
14
I
18,6
9,8
0
18
10
11
J
15,45
9,3
0
12
11
14
A
2,34
9,0
0
14
15
7
O
32,22
8,8
0
6
17
12
C
31,8
8,5
0
4
17
13
D
31,8
7,5
0
2
17
11
K
18,56
7,5
0
12
9
9
N
29,8
7,5
0
2
17
11
M
21,96
6,8
6
8
8
5
GLOBAL COTATION
RAPPORT PERFORMANCE / PRIX
20
18
16
H
14
E
I
Note (./20)
12
G
F
B
10
I
J
A
O
C
8
K
N
D
M
6
4
2
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
€ / kg
RATIO PERFORMANCE / PRICE
30
35
40
RAPPORT PERFORMANCE / PRIX
20
18
16
H
14
E
I
Note (./20)
12
F
G
B
10
I
J
A
O
C
8
K
N
D
M
6
4
2
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
€ / kg
RATIO PERFORMANCE / PRICE
30
35
40
OPTIMISATION STUDY ON 5 COMMERCIAL PAINTS
O
K
N
D
M
Conclusions
OPTIMISATION STUDY
PAINT O
WITH CAPSTONE ® FS-61, FS-64 ET FS-81
Blocking 24h
Blocking 4h
10
10
Initial
Initial
9
FS 61
9
FS 64
8
FS 61
FS 64
8
FS 81
FS 81
7
7
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
O
O
Water repellency
Oil repellency
80
80
Initial
Initial
FS 61
70
FS 61
70
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
FS 81
60
60
50
Angle en °
Angle en °
50
40
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0
O
O
Stain resistance
Lavabilité
10,0
Initial
FS 61
9,0
10
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
9
FS 64
FS 81
8,0
8
7,0
7
6,0
6
5,0
5
4,0
4
3,0
3
2,0
2
1,0
1
0,0
0
SR
Lavabilité
Dirt pick up resistance
10,0
Initial
FS 61
9,0
FS 64
8,0
FS 81
7,0
6,0
5,0
4,0
3,0
2,0
1,0
0,0
DPR
ANGLE CONTACT EAU ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
MOYENNE (./20)
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = blocking 4h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
O
10,4
18
1
4
17
12
O + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
16,8
17
17
10
20
20
O + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
14,4
17
12
6
19
18
O + 1% Capstone FS-81
13,4
13
17
4
18
15
ANGLE CONTACT EAU
100
80
60
40
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
20
0
STAIN RETENTION
BLOCKING
O
O + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
O + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
O + 1% Capstone FS-81
OPTIMISATION
PAINT K
WITH CAPSTONE ® FS-61, FS-64 ET FS-81
Blocking 4h
Blocking 24h
8
8
Initial
FS 61
Initial
7
7
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
FS 64
FS 81
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
K
K
Water repellency
Oil repellency
90
90
80
80
70
70
60
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
50
40
30
Angle en °
Angle en °
60
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
50
40
30
20
20
10
10
0
K
0
K
Stain resistance
Lavabilité
4,0
12,0
Initial
Initial
FS 61
FS 61
3,5
FS 64
FS 64
10,0
FS 81
FS 81
3,0
8,0
2,5
2,0
6,0
1,5
4,0
1,0
2,0
0,5
0,0
0,0
Lavabilité
SR
Dirt pick up resistance
Initial
10,0
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
8,0
6,0
4,0
2,0
0,0
DPR
ANGLE CONTACT EAU ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
MOYENNE (./20)
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = blocking 4h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
K
8,0
15,0
1
6
9
9
K + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
15,0
14,0
14
14
17
16
K + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
14,6
17,0
14
6
17
19
K + 1% Capstone FS-81
13,0
14,0
20
6
12
13
ANGLE CONTACT EAU
100
80
60
40
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
20
0
STAIN RETENTION
BLOCKING
K
K + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
K + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
K + 1% Capstone FS-81
OPTIMISATION
PAINT N
WITH CAPSTONE ® FS-61, FS-64 ET FS-81
Blocking 24h
Blocking 4h
10
10
Initial
Initial
FS 61
9
FS 61
9
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
FS 81
8
8
7
7
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
N
N
Water repellency
Oil repellency
80
90
70
80
70
60
60
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
40
Angle en °
Angle en °
50
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
50
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0
N
N
Lavabilité
Stain resistance
10,0
7,0
Initial
Initial
9,0
FS 61
FS 61
6,0
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
8,0
FS 81
7,0
5,0
6,0
4,0
5,0
3,0
4,0
3,0
2,0
2,0
1,0
1,0
0,0
0,0
Lavabilité
SR
Dirt pick up resistance
10,0
Initial
9,0
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
8,0
7,0
6,0
5,0
4,0
3,0
2,0
1,0
0,0
DPR
ANGLE CONTACT EAU ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
MOYENNE (./20)
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = blocking 4h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
N
10,0
19,0
1
2
17
11
N + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
14,6
13,0
16
6
19
19
N + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
17,4
17,0
20
10
20
20
N + 1% Capstone FS-81
10,0
7,0
17
2
14
10
ANGLE CONTACT EAU
100
80
60
40
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
20
0
STAIN RETENTION
BLOCKING
N
N + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
N + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
N + 1% Capstone FS-81
OPTIMISATION
PAINT D
WITH CAPSTONE ® FS-61, FS-64 ET FS-81
Blocking 4h
Blocking 24h
9
9
Initial
Initial
FS 61
8
FS 61
8
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
FS 81
7
7
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
D
D
Oil repellency
Water repellency
80
80
70
70
60
60
50
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
40
Angle en °
Angle en °
50
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0
D
D
Stain resistance
Lavabilité
10,0
4,5
Initial
9,0
FS 61
Initial
FS 61
4,0
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
8,0
FS 81
3,5
7,0
3,0
6,0
2,5
5,0
2,0
4,0
1,5
3,0
1,0
2,0
0,5
1,0
0,0
0,0
Lavabilité
SR
Dirt pick up resistance
9,0
Initial
FS 61
8,0
FS 64
FS 81
7,0
6,0
5,0
4,0
3,0
2,0
1,0
0,0
DPR
ANGLE CONTACT EAU ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
MOYENNE (./20)
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = blocking 4h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
D
9,3
15,5
1
2
17
11
D + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
18,2
18
18
16
19
20
D + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
15,2
16
16
6
19
19
D + 1% Capstone FS-81
10,5
8
17,5
4
10
13
ANGLE CONTACT EAU
100
80
60
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
40
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
20
0
STAIN RETENTION
D
D + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
BLOCKING
D + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
D + 1% Capstone FS-81
OPTIMISATION
PAINT M
WITH CAPSTONE ® FS-61, FS-64 ET FS-81
Blocking 4h
Blocking 24h
8
8
Initial
Initial
FS 61
7
FS 61
7
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
FS 81
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
M
M
Water repellency
Oil repellency
80
90
70
80
70
60
60
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
40
Angle en °
Angle en °
50
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
50
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0
M
M
Stain resistance
Lavabilité
12,0
Initial
10,0
Initial
6,0
FS 61
FS 61
FS 64
FS 64
FS 81
FS 81
5,0
8,0
4,0
6,0
3,0
4,0
2,0
2,0
1,0
0,0
0,0
SR
Lavabilité
Dirt pick up resistance
14,0
Initial
FS 61
FS 64
FS 81
12,0
10,0
8,0
6,0
4,0
2,0
0,0
DPR
ANGLE CONTACT EAU ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
BLOCKING
STAIN RETENTION
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
MOYENNE (./20)
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = angle / 4
note (./20) = blocking 4h x 2
note (./20) = 20 - SR
note (./20) = 20 - DPR
M
8,0
17,0
4
6
8
5
M + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
14,6
14,5
16,5
10
14
18
M + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
11,4
13,0
17
6
13
8
M + 1% Capstone FS-81
10,8
4,0
20
6
16
8
ANGLE CONTACT EAU
100
80
60
40
DIRT PICK UP RESISTANCE
ANGLE CONTACT HUILE
20
0
STAIN RETENTION
BLOCKING
M
M + 0,2% Capstone FS-61
M + 0,2% Capstone FS-64
M + 1% Capstone FS-81
CONCLUSIONS
O
FS-61
K
FS-61 for blocking or SR
FS-64 for SR or DPR
N
FS-64
D
FS-61
M
FS-61