Evaluation : nouvelle approche avec juges - Cedric

Evaluation : nouvelle approche avec juges - Cedric

! " #$
!
*
&
!"! # $
" #
*+
!
% &'(()
% &'( "
*
#
$
"
% &'
!
" (
,$- ,
$
+,
0
" .
,
0
,
00 *
"
*)
0 3
4
0 !
/
5 6
4 4 , !
0 ,
2
1 ,+1"
/ ,
0
,
*
, - ./
!
, ,
1
,!
!
0
,
. . ,+ !
)
* 0 ,
"4 3
0
0
*
)
$
*
, 0
20
!
,
,
!
0
0 ,+ "
4
7,
,
,
00 0 0
00 . , +
*
0
0
0 0
, ,
"
!
,
"
0
4 0
3
2, 0 0
. , "4
, 0
2 .
,
*)
,
%$
00 3
2
, 1
0 3
4
3 ,
$
, 5 6
)
* 0
0
, 0 ,
0 ,
1 ,+1"
* +" ,
,+
,
"
, !!
00 . ,
0 0
8
*
!
0 0
., " , 0
0 3/
0 !4 ,
. .
,7 !
*
#5
"
#
.
* $
,
,
!
" !
0
,
*
!
, !
0 !
. 3 6
0 *
.
.
.
.3
- "
, , +
9 00- "
:8," ;
* . 00 0 0
9 00
. !
*
9 ,
" .
!
,
" (
!
0
! 9* . 9
,
9
. %$
9. .
! $
, 3 6
0
,
9 00- "
4
*
-9 0 0
. , "-!
*
1
00
.
8"
%#
.
#+
# +
/
0 #1 +
2
2 2
3
+
# 4
.3
4
+
2
+ #+4 /
5
6
#
+ 5+#
#
+ 54
+ 55 +
#
+
+
+ #
+ 5
78
90
&": 44 #
# ; 24 <# + *%
#
<#
0
#1
#
#9# 32# +
0
6
4 +
5 0+4
<#
5+ 1 4
+3
6 +
=
#
44
5# !'
7$5 > ?
!(( :
+
+ +
5
4
42
+ #
5+
+ #9# 5
@
4
#6 ++
4
#1 9+
1
@ . *%
# 5 A
5 5 4 4 <#
45
#6
#1 0
+ +#
5 0+ 3 4
# 6 # 31
#
+ 4 #+
54 4 B
#
+
4
+ + #+
#
5 #6
4 <#3# 4 #+
;
#
#
54 + ++
#6 #
# 5 0+
45
/ 0
5
+ <# + 4
#
1
+
#
346 +#
# 5 +
C 2 <#3++
#
2 2
3
+
#
4
+
++
#6 4 +
#
42 +
<# 5
#
+
+ 4
#
+
#
#
4#
46 +#
+
4
+3 09 3# 5 5
4
+ 5 0+4
<#
+D
46 +#
<# +
+ 5 544
+ *%
#
E
+346 +#
'
54 #1 09
#+ 4
%
&'
.
4
+ +
#64 2
#F 1
#
52+
54
+ 5
5 #1
5
2 2 3
.
) 15
+D
4
+D 5 #
# 1
5A 6
+; 4
# 15
#
#6 ++
55 2
<# 5
3 4
+
1
9#
()
F+
3 F 4
9# +
0+ 5
#
#
6
52+ 52<#
+ G 0
<#
#1
3
+# H
4
2
A
4
4
+
+
<# 3 5# =
+#
F1
3
<#
+32
<#
+ # 4
#
6
+
+3 4
I
. 5
A 4
+
&J& 7*4 # &J&: .
F+
3 55 K 5 # + 5
A
+
<#A 4
#
+3 4
* I
&"J 7
&"J:
# +
4
L
0#
+
#6
#
M .
F 4
3 31
5
+
+3 4
I
#
F 4
3B 5 #
4
+ 4
4
+3
4
4
#+ 4 #+
6
#
> =
L <# + 4
0#4 /# 09 M
4
+
4
4
+ L 5A + 5+# 4 4 +
<#
45 #
5+ M +
#5
# =
0+
4+4
5 2
4
0
1 4
3# 5
6# 52+ 52<# ++
5
+
6 + F
5 3 55 4
#1/ #1
;2
6 #+
<# # N
4
5
5
5
#6
H 3#
#6
52+ 52<# +
O
+ +
; + #P
5 1 5+
#
#
0
# #0
4
4
5 +
+
!
5
52
3
#
##
#
,
#%# <
5
#
+32
<#
#1
+ #
()
)
4
+3
3
# #
4
# 24
24
+
5 44 0+
#
(
4
+3
#
4 #+
<# 5 A
4
<#
#
4
4+
5 +30
3
24
2 .3 +
64
+
5 4 0 +4
# 5
#
4
0
#F
0
3 6 +#
0
(
+
+
5 0+
<#
#6 +
+34
+
# B 5#
4
# 5 5
4
5
#
4 <#
3 .
5
# ++
#
0+
# + 4 #+
#5
4+4
55 2
+ 5 4
6 +
;2
5
3
/
#
5 5
+ 6+ #
++
0
;
4
+
0
45
5 0+
5
++
+3 0+
3# 46 +#
2#
.355+
#
2 2 # 3 ++
++ /#
4
+30
<#
* ) '
5 +
44
45
A
+
3#
5
=
5 #6
+%
#
4
55 2
5
0+
+
42
#
+
+
346 +#
#
*
+% , * - *(
.346 +#
0 # ##
4 <#
(
5#
+
4+4
7$
&(:
6 +3
9#
4<#
4 +
+346 +#
+% /
- ;A
#64
.
/
# +
3;
4
+3 5 4
A #09
5
#
+3#
4
#+
/#
+
#
#+ 5
46 +# +
1
#
'
5 # 45
01'
+ +
<#=
# 4 #+
4 4 +#
A+
R
54
0+ #
S
2#
+3
S 3
3+,
+3 6 + 5S
#
+ E
3#
+
55 + S
+
+
#
Q +
R0
R
R0R R S
+ #+
S
+,
+3
+3+ +,
+
54
+
6
#S
,
3+,
4 S
#
3+
+3+ +,
+ 0# S
+
+
#1
3
+3
4 4 + 4S
0
#
# #4 Q .
+ 5
+
S % 55 + S
+
+3+
#6
0R
+
# 4 #+
#
5
Q > $
6
<# +3# +
# +
5
2
5
0
#5 5 4
#64 #
5 5 4
5
0+
#
4 A
+
(
9 4
#
0
+
#1 =
0 4 5#
/+ 5 4
#
)
00
55 +
5
+ 5+# 4+A0
# *S
.
4
+ *%
8"
#
78
#
RTU V 4
V
5+# #
90
55 +
#
; 2A
44
TUV 4
R 55 +
6 TU S
# 0 6 <#
#
5
5
5 + 5
# #
A+ 0
# 45
0
# #
+
+346 +#
+
2
+
+ *%
#
#
# 4 #+
+ 0 +
# + 4 5 # 46 +# + 5
3#
#
2 #
+
7#
# +
;
"
+
;
;
+ #+ #
;
+ 0 +
<# +
;
;
#
2 <#
4
7W
""": 7$ 0
!((E: 5
; 2A #6
6
π=
=
=
55 +
ρ=
=
3#
++
"J:
"
+ #+
5
B
.
+
+
6
)
)+ )
=
44
&":
π=
π
=
)
) +
ρ=
=
ρ
=
=
=
=
)
)+ )
)
)+
+%+
2 3
4
+ #+ + 5 4
+ 0 +
#+
55 + 3# +
2
##
0+
#
@ 7$ +
"J):# +
#
#
55 2 5 +
42
5
;
X > 6
7? 2 "J: /5
+
++ # 6 + #
54
55 +
2 <#
2
55 + 6
(/
5
4
( (
5
1 5+
7
2 !((): 15
4 +
+ #+ .3
# + 0 +
/ #6 +
#5+ Y+
#1
#
1 4
+ # 6+ #
<#
+%5
7
('
# Z!((): 0
+ <#
+
4
<#
A + 0 + +
6
4
<#
D
#
4
+
# 9#
+
#6 /#
4 #
# 4 + /#
5
4
4 +
# #6
4
<#
7
> !(():5 5 #
#+ 4 4 <#
+ #+
4
<#
<#
4
#
K +
+
[# 7? !(():5 4
5+# #
#
5
#+
#
0 4 # +
4+
+
7. #
!((':
#+
+
.6 2
+ 5 9
# + .#
7X#
>; !(( :
5
<
4
<# +
#
\
$ %B 3 7\
""J:0 4 #
+
0
2
+
#
.
>
2
7.
>
""J:0 4 # + 5+# # 2
+
#
>7
> ""':
4 #+ 6 #
3
#
+
#
?
2 7?
""&: + #+4 # +
5 0 0 + 4 355
3# +
7. ""J:<#
# #
4 +
+
0
+
++ # 4 #+
6 +
#+
?
2 7? %W#
!((E:
+D
#+ 2 1 +
#
+
D
# 4
0 #O
44 4
5 +D
#
D
#
+ #+4
+ +
0
+
+
;
+D 0
2;5 ; %2;5 ;
+
# +D
#+
#
0
+
#
4
<#
+
+
4
+ 7X # <# !(():# +
#
4
<#
5 9
+
#+
1
+ $ B
E
,
+%6
#%# <
3 .
#
'
78 2
!(():# +
#
54
<# 5 #
+;
+
4 #+
+
4
]+
0
=
Q
=
#
54
+
0
45
1
#
=
<#
#+
<#
0
L
5 6+4
+
5 5
5
+
#6
5 # 0+ 4
+346 +#
LG2
Q
#
@M
9#
45
3#
+
4
1
+ P
M 3#
++
<#
0
""^ M 5 #6
#
4
#1 # ; A
""^ M @ 7
6 !((E:
+; 4 +
+
#
#
+346 +#
2#
46
+34
+
5
+3 5
#9#
+
5+ 1 4
55
.
#
+ +D 6 #
4
<# 5 #6 =
!(( : + 4
9#
D1
#
4
+
# + X
; 45
+315+
# 05 +
#+
5%
&
# 0 _
+; 4
#
<#
#
+
0
45
++
15
2#
/ +
5A
LP
M
]# +<# 9#
6+ 4
# 0
45
L'
<#
L (E
0
0
0
#
6 ++ ++#
2
4
#1 2#
5+#` <#
<#
_ 7X
%.
+
+D
#
+
0 5#
+
01!
# 6
4
4
# 5
5 <# + *%
#
5
;
2
<#
+ 54
# 55 + 5# 0 64
5 544 . 5
5
5 4 + 54
# # 55 +
6# 4 4 +
.
#
!V 4
V 55 +
4
R 55 +
/#
A T
6
.36
S
2 1
<# + <# + 5 4
4 + # 55 +
4
55 + S * %
#
+ + + #
2 2 / 1
#
1
#+ 4
+ 54
+
55 +
+3 5
#
FX > 6
3
+ 6
+ 355 4
# +
2 <#
# 0
54
#
#6
55 + # 6
4
+
)+
)V
;
2
<#
+ 54
# 55 +
!
=
)
0
+ *%
+ #+ #
#
+
!V ) V
=
)+
!
#
<# + * %
# 3 <# +
;
2
<#
+ 54
# 55 +
9#
+
4
+
;
2
<# 5 A # <# + 4 <#
0
+ <# +3#
5
A
0
D
=
9 4 + <# +
#15
A
5 2
#1 #
4
4+ 64
5 5 4 4 54 +
+
+
2
<# 4
+ 54
#+
55 + #+D
# 1 +# 6
# 4
+D#
+ * %
#
4
5 544
# 6 * S!V V
R
6 54
S
55 +S
$S R
S %
5 0+A
6
5
+ *%
# 5 # <#D++
5
+ <#
1
$
+
54
Q +
55 +
+
6
5 2
# 6
U− U = +
− S )+ +)− × )+ − )−
= !) × ! = E)
!
=
=
+#
)V
)+
=
+
=
!V )V
)+
=
U− U
U
a
= −
!
! !
15+ <# 5 # <# + *
#
'
00
.
8"
K <# $ #
4 K <#
# +
52<# #6
Y +3
4 4 <#
2 4 <#
# 0
#6
#
5 +
6
<# + #
5+# 4 4 6 +
5
0+ +
# 346 +#
# 5 A # # 5 544
. *%
# #
55 +
#
+
TUV 4
R 55 + . 4 #+
+3 6 ++ 7( : + #
#+ 5+
#+
+ *
#
# 5 #6
0
6+ # #
6 #5
A TU ()
6% 4
+
= +
+#
( #
4
^
#
# 5 #6
2
346 +#
<#
# 0
1=
(
+
4 4
+
<#
15
46
# 6
4
2 2 3
# + 5+# 2
3#
4
# 36
+ 4 #+
4
+
+3 5
0 6
<# 6
5
+
+
5 544
;
<#
( (!(
+3#
0+
++ 5
3
+
4
+ #+
5
+ # 4 # 5
6 + 5
)
5+#
5
/+ 5 4
#
+
R
( TUR
# <#
TUR
+
#
5 544
7
+
4
5#
;
+
)
1'
4
+
+
#
+
++
+
#
4#
C 2 46 +#4
+
<# +
+ 3; # #
# 5 5
+
3# 5 0 + 4 <# ++ 3# +
# ;A 0
#1 # 6
. *%
# 5 A
5 544
A
54 4
78 2 !((): 7
6 !((E:
#9# 78
90
&":; 45
A 5 ++
,
#
#%# <
3 .
#
+ 5
A b
# # 6 0+
5
/+3# +
#
# 6 #
54
#
55 + $# +
52<# #6
2 <#
#0
# 55 + 6
( /
2 + *
# 4 #+
#
<#
+
0+
6 # 54
# 55 + 0
+
#0
<#3#% +/ (E + ; A
6 5 <#
+ 4
31
54
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
0.1
B # #+
4
A
+ *%
0.2
0.3
# + 9#
#
#6
5 <#
#
1!
0.4
$
6
46 +#
# 6
#
+
0.5
5#
. *
#64 #
1!
8 9:;< 4 (
<=
0.6
4
#
0.7
#
5
0.8
54
5
#+ <# 5
>
0.9
? :;<4 (
##
#
1
55 +
0
('
3 4
9=
#
+ 5 544
+ P%
#
5
+ # #
cS
# 0
+ *%
#
6
+ 5+#
5+A
5
# 0
+ *%
#
5
+ 5+# # # ++ . P%
#
0+
+ *%
#
# +32
<# 5 # =
64
<#
5
B0 6
+ 5 544
+ P%
#
5
A c ( ! ^ 6 TUS
<#
TUS
#
cS
+
6
#
+
+
#
#
31
<# 5+# + 5
A c #
5+# +
6 # 31
#9#
1 5+
6
S S(E + *
# 6 # (E +
<# + P%
# 6#
( ) 5# cS ^
4 #+
44
#6
+ <# + *%
+
A
;
# 5 #6
+
#
6 #
#9#
&
00
.
8"
8
+ 6+ # 0 # 6 + 5
6
+ 54
+ 55 + (/ 5 5
5 # + P%
#
=
0
0.1
0.2
B0
# 6
J
6
A c (
(
<#
!
#
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1
0.1
10%
13%
15%
16%
17%
17%
18%
18%
18%
18%
0.2
13%
20%
24%
27%
29%
30%
31%
32%
33%
33%
0.3
15%
24%
30%
34%
38%
40%
42%
44%
45%
46%
0.4
16%
27%
34%
40%
44%
48%
51%
53%
55%
57%
0.5
17%
29%
38%
44%
50%
55%
58%
62%
64%
67%
0.6
17%
30%
40%
48%
55%
60%
65%
69%
72%
75%
0.7
18%
31%
42%
51%
58%
65%
70%
75%
79%
82%
0.8
18%
32%
44%
53%
62%
69%
75%
80%
85%
89%
=
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.2
0.1
4%
6%
7%
8%
9%
10%
10%
11%
11%
11%
0.2
6%
11%
14%
16%
18%
20%
21%
22%
23%
24%
0.3
7%
14%
19%
22%
26%
28%
31%
33%
35%
36%
0.4
8%
16%
22%
28%
32%
36%
39%
42%
45%
48%
0.5
9%
18%
26%
32%
38%
43%
47%
51%
55%
58%
0.6
10%
20%
28%
36%
43%
49%
54%
59%
64%
68%
0.7
10%
21%
31%
39%
47%
54%
61%
66%
72%
77%
0.8
11%
22%
33%
42%
51%
59%
66%
73%
79%
85%
=
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.6
0.1
1%
1%
2%
2%
3%
3%
4%
4%
4%
5%
/5 4
^
+
TUS
0.9
18%
33%
45%
55%
64%
72%
79%
85%
90%
95%
TUS
0.9
11%
23%
35%
45%
55%
64%
72%
79%
86%
93%
TUS
0.2
1%
3%
4%
6%
7%
8%
10%
11%
12%
13%
0.3
2%
4%
7%
10%
12%
14%
16%
19%
21%
22%
0.4
2%
6%
10%
13%
17%
20%
24%
27%
30%
33%
0.5
3%
7%
12%
17%
22%
26%
31%
36%
40%
44%
0.6
3%
8%
14%
20%
26%
33%
38%
44%
50%
55%
0.7
4%
10%
16%
24%
31%
38%
46%
53%
60%
66%
0.8
4%
11%
19%
27%
36%
44%
53%
61%
70%
78%
+ 5 0 + 4 36
+ 54
64
#9# 6 c S ( ! ^
0.9
4%
12%
21%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
79%
89%
TUS
#
6 + # #6
1
1
18%
33%
46%
57%
67%
75%
82%
89%
95%
100%
1
1
11%
24%
36%
48%
58%
68%
77%
85%
93%
100%
1
1
5%
13%
22%
33%
44%
55%
66%
78%
89%
100%
# 4
TUS)
# 55 +
,
#
5 544
# 5 #6
+3
=
<#3
6
5 0+ 4
6
+3# 1
6+ #
0 6 + 4 +
6+ #
#5
#%# <
64
#
A b 4
0
#
=
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1
0.1
10%
11%
11%
11%
11%
11%
11%
11%
11%
11%
0.2
18%
20%
21%
21%
21%
21%
22%
22%
22%
22%
0.3
25%
29%
30%
31%
31%
32%
32%
32%
32%
32%
0.4
31%
36%
39%
40%
41%
41%
42%
42%
42%
43%
0.5
36%
43%
47%
49%
50%
51%
51%
52%
52%
53%
0.6
40%
50%
55%
57%
59%
60%
61%
62%
62%
63%
0.7
44%
56%
62%
65%
67%
69%
70%
71%
72%
72%
0.8
47%
62%
69%
73%
75%
77%
79%
80%
81%
82%
Beta=
3
0.9
1
50%
53%
67%
71%
75%
81%
80%
87%
83%
91%
86%
94%
88%
96%
89%
98%
90%
99%
91% 100%
a=
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.2
0.1
4%
5%
5%
6%
6%
6%
6%
7%
7%
7%
0.2
8%
11%
12%
13%
13%
14%
15%
15%
15%
16%
0.3
12%
16%
19%
20%
21%
22%
23%
24%
25%
25%
0.4
16%
22%
25%
28%
30%
31%
32%
34%
35%
35%
0.5
20%
27%
32%
35%
38%
40%
42%
43%
45%
46%
0.6
23%
33%
39%
43%
46%
49%
51%
53%
55%
56%
0.7
26%
38%
45%
50%
55%
58%
61%
63%
65%
67%
0.8
28%
43%
52%
58%
63%
67%
70%
73%
76%
78%
Beta=
3
0.9
1
31%
33%
47%
52%
58%
64%
65%
72%
71%
79%
76%
85%
80%
89%
83%
93%
86%
97%
89% 100%
a=
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.6
0.1
1%
1%
1%
2%
2%
2%
2%
2%
3%
3%
0.2
2%
3%
4%
5%
5%
6%
7%
7%
8%
8%
0.3
3%
5%
7%
9%
10%
11%
12%
14%
15%
16%
0.4
4%
8%
11%
13%
16%
18%
19%
21%
23%
25%
0.5
6%
11%
15%
19%
22%
25%
27%
30%
32%
35%
0.6
7%
14%
19%
24%
29%
33%
36%
40%
43%
46%
0.7
9%
17%
24%
30%
36%
41%
46%
50%
54%
58%
0.8
10%
20%
29%
37%
44%
50%
56%
61%
66%
71%
Beta=
3
0.9
1
12%
13%
24%
27%
34%
39%
43%
50%
52%
60%
59%
69%
66%
77%
73%
85%
79%
93%
85% 100%
3 .
#
+
=
/
# 5 #6
#5
A c # 6+ #
5
('
/
<#
bS
+ 4 #+ 5 #
6
#54 # / . 6 + #
5#
##
4 # / ('
+ 5 544 4 4
5+#
5 4
- 6+ #
<# 0+
5#
4
c S ('
"
00
# 0
54
6 <#
S 55 +
+#
•
•
•
/
8"
6+ # 5
<#
5
+ P%
# 5
++
# #
++ 5
++ 5
+ 3
#+ 4
.
A
0+
54
54
3#
9#
#+
5 6+4
/+355 2 #FX
+3
> 6
5 5 4 4 <# +
4
+ *
#
6 +
# 6 # 31
#9#
4 +
+ X > 6
<# + 4
6
3# #
# +
3
0+
<# +3
4
55
2
)
5 5 4
5 0+
+
<#3+
3#
+
5
1 5+# + 24
+
( +
'(((
5 0+
+3
#
5 0+ 4 . 5 0
54
55 +
# +
# 3#
4
5
[#6 #
#
+
+
+
24
2<# +
#
+ 54
# 55 + 5 4
#
2
5+# +
#
+346 +#
#6
+
+
+
# 6 #E
#
5
<# 5
30
# 6 # 3 6 #+
49/ A
#+
6 #' + # +
#6 + 0
5
' (((
0+ 4
#6 + 0
6
+
5+#
0+
4 +
5+# 0+
4 4 +
5
5
5#
4 # <# + 5 4
+
( + <# +
6 # 24
2
K
5# +
4
4 /# 6 # A 0
24
2 6 9# #
# # +
24
2
5 <#
+
3# *
# ++
#
6
7X#
#
?
>; !(( :
2
$
S
9
6 +
54
4
S
XS
5+#
S
4
4 <# +
! S ! + 5+
! S 5+#
$ +3
F3
+ 55 + 5 #6
+
4
S X
55 + S
0
+
5
5 5
+4
5 5 4
5
5 2 # % 5#
X6
0
34+4
5 5 4
#
*
(
++ #
1'
4 #+
! %+ 5
#
#5
6
S
+
55 +
<#3#
6
45
6 #
44
4
0
#
6
+
+
+
+#
+
R+ 5 !
#
+
#
4
5
<#
5
+
+
+
%
# F3
4
6 +
0+
,
5 5
4
<#
+
3 0
+3 09
42 +
31
+
2 2 3
0
45
A
2 2
3 .
3# +
+ 24
2 5#
+ <# + 4
+346 +#
6+ #
54
55 +
5+# 5 2
2 24 5 +
[#6 3#
# 346 +#
+ P%
#
5# 5
15
/+
5 1 4
*) '
.
#%# <
# 4 0+ #
#
4 + 4 B
#+
#
6 #
+
#=
5
#
#
4
.355+
0+
#
+
+
5
+
4
++
<#
#+
5 +
#
3#
4 5 78 2
=
!(():
#
=
54
+
0
45
1
#
]+
0
=
<#
<#
+
54
+ 4
#6
Poids de chaque réponse selon Voohrees pour 273 réponses
1.20
1.00
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
0
50
# 5 #6
<# +
45
+
45
_ + #
5A
2 2
45 / 0
9 =
+
+
+
6 >
45
−6V
+
− +
6 +
++#
>S ' +S(&
−
+
=
50
100
A
5 544
# 6
150
200
−6×
+
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
150
54
# 6 # D1
5+# 5
# +
#+
55 2 0 +4
5 <#
# 6
#64
−6V −
#15
46 +#4
B0
100
250
300
200
250
#9#
1 5+
5
A 5
+ 4
5 #
#
300
_9 6 #1 0 +#
45
)(
O +
5 4
G <#
−6
− +
−
5
4 # >S ' +S(&
5
4<#
S!&)
54
6
+
+D
#1 5
+
A
+
>
+ 5#
# 0 6
5 5 4
+
45+
+ 5
00
.
+
45
<#
D + 1
8"
+
# D55 K 5
+ '( 5
A
45
4 6
<#
#+ # +/
'( . 5
A
<#+ 5
A >
+ 6 # D +
>S ' +S
>S ' +S('
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
>S ' +S(!
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
300
>S^ +S('
50
100
150
200
250
300
0
>S ' +S('
100
.
#1 5
5 6+4
200
A
+
# + #+ +3
5
0 +4
+ 9# 5 #
0
300
5
5 5
5
#
+ + #
+
D
#
5# # 0
45
# 5#
100
200
300
4 4
3 5
<# +
+ 0
45
#+ 5+
#
+ 5
<#
(
+ 0 + D
46 +#
6
+
=
=
0
250
100
200
6 # D1
× +
+
− 6×
9
=
!
200
+ 45
G 5
6 #
# 5 #6
#+
# + <#
+
D
# 46 +#
2#
)
.D
150
300
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.2
0.1
0
0
100
1
0.9
0.8
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
50
>S)( +S('
1
1
0.9
0.8
+
−+
−
−6
300
,
#%# <
3 .
#
@%
+
#
6
46
+ <#
4
+
+
.34 #
+ *%
3
5 4
#
#
# + P%
#
31
+3# +
+ P%
# 5# +
# + 4 #+
2 2 3
4 +
+ 5 0+
. P%
6
D# 5
#
+
1
+
6
#
+ #
+ 5
#
4
+
5 0+
# ;A
#
#
0
#
+
6
#6
D
# 5
++ 5 4
#
4
#
+ *%
#
8
90
+ 0 > 6 5
? 2
++ 5 A
5 544
24
<# <# +# 5
#
; 2A /5
D 5
<# ++
#
#
A+
<# +D
#2
0+
++ 5
D 4
+D55 2
$
6
6 #1 D1
+ 9#
+ D
D
#
# <#
/+
55 2
4 # +
#+
##
34 #
++
A% = '
4# 5
5
6 #1
5 #6
5+
#1
#
6 #1 31
3 4
#
6
5
+
#
3154
#
346 +#
9#
#
0 4
5
#+
'
.
6 + 54
4
5 9
Q$ 24
+
#5
5
++
#
/
- +3
Q
-
B#
54
5# + #
+ 5 9
# +
# ? >; PBP
6
+
4
#
P X .
? <# QB
#
+
3+
*
5# + #
3
+4
# 54
#
-
4
5
<#
#
44 + ; !'
346 +#
5# + 0
46 +#4
.3 +;
+ 5 0+4
<# # 5
3
# #
#6 ++
<#
# #
0+
+ *%
#
5 0+ 3 4
6 #1
#
# 6 4 +
1
4
+4
5 0+ 3# +
+
#
4
+
+ 4 #+
0 #
# 5 5
#
# 54 <# #1 5 0+A
<# 5 6+4
+
5
+ 0
45
6
4
#+ + 6 # 31
+#
#+
5
<#
+
45 +
Q
+
#
#+ A
# +
+
# ?
+ 0
*
I
#
*
4
+
#
)
00
.
8"
B% 2
7
&"J:
.D
4
I
'2
&"J
5&^&
25
+ #2
#
7X
%.
+ !(( :Q X
%. ? \ + B . +
dQ2 $
G 0d
$
!((
7X # <# !((): X # <#
? #+
. XZ
#+
e
+ ;
6
0
5
#
+ ;
5#
d
!(()
7X#
>; !(( :
X#
>;
f \
e$
G
15
+ 55+
%
6 +#
6
# d 5
5#
$
- 6 Q
7
6 !((E: ;
6
P# 2
> Q Z6
f 6 eG 0 G 0
#
+
6 2
da
$PB !((E
Q2 J 2
+
2
+$
;
P
+
B
Z
25
#
>2
2
+
6 % > !((E 5
7#
+ ""J:$ #
? +
\ >
$2
e # 6 .
+
2
5
Q1
Z
d
2
6 2
+
P
+
P D"J EJ% ''
""J
7*4 # &J&:?%* *4 # L
<#
+ + #
I M
++
;
&J&% &JJ
. $$ *
QB
E'J 2 5
+ #2
#
7\
""J:f \
$ %B
""J e. 1 + 2
5
1
2
+ 5 5
d * ++0 # ""J 55 )('g))!
7?
""&:? ; ? ?
6 G
2 ""& e$
+ ;0
5#
+ 1 + 1
;d
2
5#
+
. #
Q
7? %W#
!((E:2 5
#
+ h
*Q^!'' . 2 +
7? !(():i ?
X
0 2 e$
$ + ;
2
%X
++ 0
6 *+
d
Q2 !
$Q
+
P
+
$2
$
+
Z
6 0 !(()
7? 2
""J:Q ? 2
eQ 1
Z
2$#55 8
2
.
2
; + 6 * # d
2 Q 2 # 5
2
.
.D
"J
#
2
7. #
!((':? %
. Q _5 9 .#
_25
25
5 >
+ 2
7.
> ""J: + # .
>
2
e
0
+ +
1
G
+ ;
d * ++0 # ""J 55 !^'g!J)
7.
""J: >
.
""J e
%2
+ ;d
2 '2
+
2 .
G
7
2 !(():
2 e
#;
5
+ 5
#
2 Q1
+
d - 6 ;
!' 2 X $% $f # 5
6+
2
3()
# ++
#h 1 (!(E((
() 5
E
,
7
> ""': 2+ 5
2 E2
+
> !(():? *
7
+
#
7
+
> e-
#%# <
3 .
6 +#
+?
>P \
2 $ + ;
$
#Z
?
+
+
0;
8
_ 0# 8 +# _
$ !(()
+
2
_
_
Q
+ ;d
5 EEJgE')
++
;
#
$
2 Q
;%$ 12
# + !(()
+ ;
P
+
5#
# Z!(():
; +
!(()
7$ +
"J):f $ +
?
f ++ e
#
f
\ ++
5# $
f
\ ++
W > "J)
7$ &(:Q > $
6 e
#
$
d
% '
X >
"&( 2 5 ) Q2
5
_ + 6
_
6
7$ 0
!((E:* $ 0
eQ 1
Z
d%
+
j
55+
G Q
$ #2 5
-P * 2
7$5 > ?
!(( :P $5 > ?
e#
+ #
2 >
6 +#
d
# +. #
& !"gE^ !((
78
90
&":P 8
90
e
6 +d !
.
+
#>P 2
2 +
78 2 !(():
8 2
e 6 +#
2 6 +#
d
5
55 J % JJ
\.Q%
.!(()
7W
""": W W
e
6 +#
+ 55 2
1
?# +
6+ 8 +
! 55^&%%JJ """
6 +d
W >
2
+
Q1
5
X#
2
;%?# !(()
Z
d
'