PDF file, 0.5 MB

Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 45 (1979) 435-444
GEODETIC EVIDENCE FOR RIFTING IN AFAR:
A BRITTLE-ELASTIC MODEL OF THE
BEHAVIOUR OF THE LITHOSPHERE
A. Tarantola, Jean-Claude Ruegg, and Jean-Claude Lépine
/ u \ u I o r t r r . L U ' r s .u i i q . n r L l v o r . F t u e u n r . d x f
s r u r u i r n s r i n r r r o r u . q l t o r r r p i i u r p n P r "r . u . l r s p
- o i i : r r l ]l o t u r , x r l s n h r s J f n b s r s . i l r ] . r r j r p . u r r l q o
u m q i J ^ f r tl n r t . s . r t l I a t q r . tr r rn s o r l s. r . I J ^ r l . . s
o r r i . ) r t r l I I I 0 l u o l l l o r l \ c n n : r s r p( ; 1 _ s ! 6 1p u . t / 6 1
i " | u N . l q s . . u . . r i tr r p . r t r F u ' u r a J U o9.l n s . r a q l
urrp IDluauFdxS'z
3 q ri u ' I . ^ i n s r r L l o r s n
r r u r o d u r : r r l r r o :ur . n 1 1
t r r u r ^ . r d u o i r ' i i t r u r s i l q n o r l l n r t r i l o dl u r f u n I
i s r u ' 1 . l r r l o r u dz z . q i J o
n,u scn ruod arro
s r u r o d. r o u a u r ur l l r a 6 l S l q . r N l { i r l
r . , r r u D r xso. $ i i ^ r n s s | l l J [ 9 ] s F u , . r 1 li . r J r l s n f S / 6 I
r i q n r r { o N u ' P . r n ! ' r r u J rr s r u e r a a a u o zl . r r u 3 r 3 q l
i r r t ) ! r o x n s s t u r o d. r r N s r ! u . . r l ] i u r / n o l o j s r F r r o t L I
a r . r i , r t )u r i x J r u r p o a :r i r s c l . J os u r r t r i q l . u i r o J
j . d i r J ^ \ s r u r a L . n t r . r u r i r . l so / i . d n s 3 u . p o . r to . $ l
'8uotu,r{Sltue
. f r ^ 1 r l r ) jf t n o q Pr a r Nu ' : s r a ^ o ru o D e u r r o J .rpr u o r r a t
. r l l o u N . t o ^l u r n s s u^ \ . u E . r oq r r l q . ' t r p L r t - { ! r
r L t rl o r c o L Jr i u u r e q r u r L I u as s i n s s uu i d o p u Ps r l i u J
9fI oN d a d l u'i,lnquruo)
p u u o r l r o p t . r r t u r l i o d u r u r p . . n p u ' ! u e q rr . i r e l
: t n t n r ; c u J o s r u a n ao ^ { rr ! r a \ r s n . r L J l J os . I E n b
{ t u r . x r l . u e q l . a n s n | ]u r ' 8 1 6 1 - 9 . ' r q r r ! ^ o Nu o
p : r n . . o s r s u rJ U r . t o ^ p u . 3 r u r s r ilsu f x o d r u r u Y
Isl puoqeN
e n b l L t d r r : o arJn r i t s u ti ' l r e ' a u o l r J o q . o r u r d n
r n ! s e a . u o T { D . L l tl u r p u n o r n s . a r . . : r . l €s s o r . t
S u r t u . r \ e s t u r o dp : t u i u n u o u a l J o t r o ^ \ ] a u. r r ' ! o e l
u o r s r . s r d . q d r 'qr r l n i u ' r d u J s e u r f ! n o q . r . l d i L t r i e
i u u r n l r o s r s s . . o r dr q r . i f n r s o ] u o 6 a r s [ t ] u r s u . d
. : p . q r , l 3 I l p s n b N l q d! p t n l r t s u ll r t t , { q I L 6 t a r L r r s
I ' . u r . J r i d ! . . q . 1 | r t s . i e ^ r r si D r r s { q d o i tl u J r { J r (
u.rqy
1r'3r:r.rt [r r] s:INrd
p u | r r l r q D r Ya q t u : J A r . q { r r p u n o q a r r l . l ; ! r r a r J r t
aqr Jo sallo, riirlrrlo^ tEr\r ru\: iqr pLIr(uirsls
r : p r i u . p V J o J l n D ) s u ' r d . r u N . r o u J i a r r oI u l t 3 L I
suot rI ni r^ llu Iflxr l.:)|d]ir E or relLrls r$ru 3'll
p u r t J J tr o r . l v l o s r u o zi u r l t u I . u 3 r q n sI I Ni u o u P s r
I ] n o q i l ol o ] | t q n d r d . q r u r u u l . s Y i . q q n o q ) e q t
's3!rprn.q
ucrr.lr..qursrp
or
ar.td
rr
|:sn i.l plnoqs\.nssrJ rido 3urtns:rrqr q uoo
r.tur ru:ru q:h i.pou, c q.ns lrq] Flsr ni s' ]r p& .r.p.qr lt3h ir
!'l rus rqrrLu punoa.i E qrr{ i:tou
rtntrq.Jlrsqruffrlruaorts\rlt.r.qds.aroJqrloInor4x{lrqIDunF.u3qrJossiFlrnrllrsJrdrrdrdsLI.l
'3r'nJjdu.r pur i|idtrt qroq p3rnsraur3ra,{
F0t x t ro !prc
IJJ Ttrtl truldrrllo
.qr.to 5ur.rtspur ssur srLIrriPnrsor ntr. n rno !.Irrtr JrJ\ slu)0.rnstJLu r!rto.;rsltr.
n . r d n r J t r n r . t r t oI ,^r r s s ! r p u r ' t S . t d n . p , u r u ; r r u l os : ) . i b L t l J D . ' r uI r n o q r J o! u r u r J i q d s r pt n u J i i L I r r . (. r t t d
: j . o l u , a u . r t r r o u t o ; u r l r d l . l u . n r . l t 5 . r r t d u . r q r r v p u r u D r r J v . q r u 3 J . r r : qI n f u n o q . r q d i u r . h r : q r
J o u o q r s I . u U T R qi sNr t t r q ru r r t l v r s . l t r r n o s u r s ! 6 l r r q L u t r ^ o N n p , t n r t r o f n ) ] r J J o r l o s t u l t r r u . r J o d u r l u \ r
uori.^ !.s',!al
6r6l 0a ^l.l!.{I.r.r
6L6t I .unLf r:ran
nnsnt 3)q1 f au") ^r D t,rrs,i,,
l u"l,tl ca nPiJ sutJ ()titi
2q.lt nt dnb^hlJ rt rrrr4
(t6t f7)ePtala4
tunDtrrt 2t arhfnldo,t
srrnJ,f
)Pu),t 3ta)otutt1
3NI,t:]'l-J t pur SSEittI J I Y]OI_NYXYI Y
lXi| IdSOHrt'I3lt-LrtOUnOt VItt{
:lll.t :lO'l:loOll JI LSV'IS-:I'IIIIll{ Y rUYIY NI 3NI rJIU tIU-l Ef,NgCI,'{3JI-LIOO!3
Et_f
sr,nPIrJLllaN
.q.I ur trruud - rn,tr.rnuv .iurd unj iwqrJtq.J i!r1rr:rrs FrM\I] at
rfr Eai (jl6t) sr 1r,r37r1u,11s ajrbliturQloq
e l 8 u N urt o r p . r r d d N . { F n o a u . S o u rroELr it r o s u i l i q r
l u | . r r re a r o s u . t r r s r r sL r t . u rl g p s l n d r u o iu . i q
s e r l . i l o s u r r F 3 3r o Jr o s r c r u r l r l s L r t i u r . q l p u c ' ] r u
J r t . p o a ; . q r o t ) r _ r r p r o t rsrleu ! t r r J l r q n i l r r r u rs r r u u
o r u rp ! p r ^ r pu - r i qs e qu o r i r a r . q ri u o u u ' r r o J r fr q r
J o u o n r t u i s i r . l . r I s u D t u r u r u c l q o o l J 3 p r oo I
' u o ' t c r . r d r i r n i s r uo r p . a i u N . p L ' c! u r u l r - r i . r . J . i
u . s o r t .i l t r t o l u . p u e d a p u1r o us I r r r n q s r l n 5 . r
. q r j o r r n r . r d r t r r d ( o r I s a o s u o n c l u i s . r d 3 xr I l . n s
'uotrrrrrp pi:11 {r.rrrqrs l|r pL!e
pi\aJ .{J.rIq[
lLrrod
u r o t . , \ r r f t . r u o t r . r r q r i . J o e o r : a n 1 l l 3 u . . r N l d ssr e
p
p ! r u . s J r du r u o a r BI . { n s e r r r r r p o . t l o n l n s i r s r l l
uorrRrerdlitul €
'le rJ u,.rrpJ:N pu.
. I t l . , . r r a . s l op a ' l s q , ] n d
. q i l h e r . p . s a q rJ o u o r l ( l u r s i ps r a l d u o r r r o l ' {
( u o , ) e r o rl o j ; i l l : . s ) y p t ' ' N s r u r o d u r e ^ \ r e q
u t 0 5 u r L t r . . sr u r i r E uItr r ! r r l o ^ \ r . q r J o u o r r . r r )
' ! o . r L r n r u r u i resp u Ni A Jp L r rl s l u r o d u a e a l r q u r t z
S u r L F r i r' r i u r O t o r r r d I r r r u ! . t t l o u o n . u r r o l t I
Fuo'$rrxc.ir.t. !r.rsuoruip srlns.r.s.ril
' u 3 r n o q Nu r
s
q r t a . i r n r l . . r u s r s r pi q i , r o r o l r t p f f u . r s €o r I r l i r ^
, { a q , ' J i L I r n i osrl u r u r r r . s . i u r J io a l : q } ; u r l c s u r . l r r r . i
L U o rsJn l u i ^ . r d r o r o l r r t r n r u l l u i r $ . 1 i i u l p i . r x .
r o u ' s . r . u r d . r r s r pr s i r l r r F n o q l l Y 6 1 6 I r l . r . l \
p x r 8 1 6 I r r q u r i { o N r r : ) l ^ \ r . qp 3 l n t r r os n r . u l i t o t r l
I]uurstrrot InssJ s.nurdJrrslp rtrros sssllrlrrl.\ 'u:l
l u l r u u o ! ^ u a l 0 . ! u . u J D o : ; 1 r | !] \ o r l s . r n t l J r q r j o r r ' ] dj . t r o l t r r l l l L t l
jilrrrrlpu dstu Lrrlr:lsrrnollit l 3!:l
Iz] iatl.rrS uo{ rtroz rJr rrqqnoqC lusv arl J. sltnrJ r^!rr umu.'0
,on.zu
,o9"zv
,08.1I
t\\-
, . . : , " , f, - l
N
-l(
,1li
TAALT ]
C o n r t . . t t r r . dv n r l F o \ o f d , \ i n . e : b . r v . r n 1 9 i I r n d l 9 ? 8
Sssnr.nt
Dillmrclnl
00:
0.08
,0.:l
019
A!
BC
0ll
Blt
NL
CD
CE
DE
DH
DI
Lf
II
l:n"
I\1
HI
IIL
0.18
,.008
-0 t7
0:l
0.t5
0!6
007
022
058
0.1I
s.:nr.nr
llQ
H1'
]N
IQ
JL
JS
LS
LT
IIN
\IR
NQ
NR
0.01
2.12
0.11
005
-0.01
0.01
il.5l
ST
-417
0.15
0.20
0.07
0.02
0.1l
0 0,1
Tv
UV
0.03
QU
QV
laultnrS.
l U . ! r u r e dc o r l t t r c t i o n isn r h e n o r r l ) . r s lz o n e !r r c
l 3 r g e rl h ! 0 t h o J cn r t h c s o u t h i v c \ol n e s T h ^ i s
p r o b e t r l yd L r et o t h c g e o l r e l r i c r c] o l l f i S U r l r r i oonf l h e
n e l i v o r k$ h e r e t h c I r o r i h w e s t c rpno i n t s! r e c l o s c r
r . , r ] | ( .I rr ,. . u , r l .
r r \ .| . .
t o t h e s h o r tw r v e l c n g t ho f t h e d e f d n r x i i o . f h c i r o J i _
c o u l de x l c t l y a t c o u n tI o r l h e d e ' o m a t i o n o b s c e d .
l l r e . o m r u t r t i o i h a sb c c nm r d e 3 sf o l i o w s :F f o m
t h c L i e i j n i l t u no i t h e s r r r i | t e n s o r! s e g m e not f l e n g t t r
/ i s d e i o r i .c d b y ! u n i i n { n s r r a i n€ t o I l e n g l h1 + j /
e i v e nb y :
. lr e,,u't'
e x t c n s i o r ds l f t i n r o u g h l )p . r t c d i c r l r r r o l h c I r u l t
d " . ' i . , . l , . r ' . . l r ' . r. l ( J _ ^ l l , r r ,r i N
c o n t r r c l r o ni n ! t p . o \ L n r t . l y r h c s r f ) . , l i t . . r i o r . T h i i
isr v.ry i rtorlrrr polntT e c t o n i co b s e N a t i o . i\f l h c i . n . r f l o . r o l l h c l t
v r l l c y s l o $ t h r t b r i r l l ed c i o a n r t i o n( o i l l ) ' nr ) o r J f r l
i x u l t sa . d o p e nf i s s u r st r ! n d i n gN \ v - S En. ' t h c
g e n c n ld i r e c t i o no f t h e r i l i ) o i c u r si D s i d cr r r r r e r n o t
n r o r c! l t a | 3 ( x 3 5 ) k n r w i d eh t h e e m e r : c dp r r l .
'Ih.
l h r r t h i sb r i t l l c d . f o i i r r l r o e x r . n ! t \
!ssunrpticn
' . . 1 - , . r . : rr .' .' d I j
C. r
r." l
s u p p o r r eb
d y s . i s n r i cd r r u ,i . c -l o c a t i . n o t r h . n i r ' r r
s h o c kr n d p o n c , i s ' rs c i s n ) i c i tLy Sl .
I n o d d i l i o ni o t h c d i s t ! n c en r e c $ r c r l . n i s t, h u
r e l c r . l l i n !o i r l i n e c r o s s i n r! h e s u b l c r i 3Il ' l r z o ' L e
[ 7 ] s h o w su r o u g h$ b s i d . n c co f i r b o u tl 0 c r ns t l o n s l )
c o r r . l ! 1 e dw i t h l h e t e c t o r r i co b s c r v r l i o no f n o n l x l
l1l
T h c w i d t h o f I h c b r i t i l e r r e a i s s t n r l i . rt h r t h e
d i n r c n s i o nosf t h e c e n t r { lt r i s n g l . s\ ' e c ! n c o n . l u ( l '
! h , r tt w o o f f o s i t e m e c h . . i c x lb . h a v i o ! r sh a v e
o . c u r c d : 3 n e r l c r r s i o nl i m i t ! C t o t h c b r i t t l . T o n e .
I ' l , c . , r . , r i o , , r r J . I | " | o | c| | J \ | |
I n c a s u r eodr t h e l r i r n S l c si l ] t h c c c n t r u l r r t s l N ' r l ' l
b . s m r l l e rt l u n t h e r c t u . r le x r e n s i o n r t l e b r i ! t l '
l w o f r c ! s c r n b e P o l n r e do u l : l h e c o h . r c t c " f
w h 3 r e ; i s t h . L r n j tv c c t o ri n t h c d i r e c l i o no f t h ' r e g r n c n !
r h c o b s e r v esdl r a i nf i e l d r s i t i s s h o w ni n F i 8 .: . 3 n d
F o r r h o , i u o n t l ls e g n r c f t :
t h e c i e a rp h c n o r l ] c n ooni P o s r s e i : i r i . c o t r l c l i o n ,
n o ! e x p e . t . dl t r i o r i i n a d i n e n s i l cr i f t T o n e
(2j
+ eyy(u')'
c,,(u'). + 2e"{"t
;T | e s ed r l r s L r g g ctsot ! s t h a t I m c c h r n j s nor i c h s t i c
s l r e t c | i r gf o l l o w e db y s u d d . nb r . l k i n ! r l r d ' 1 ! \ t i c
K n o w i i g l h e n r e a s u . cdd! t r A r y r n d t l ' e v a l u c s
l e b o u d s i n r i h rl o t h o s .i n l t o . l u c e db v R e r d[ 9 1
," 3nd !Y Ior enchsidc of a singlctriansle,we obtain
f o r t h e i l . r p r c l r t i . i n o f t h d 1 L ) 0 6S r n f i r r n c i i c o
a s."-sler of lltrc€ cqurlions i,r th. irnknowns€jx.
rllr Pl 'u' "no
cr-rl I |,L . .
T h u s .r n e h s t i cr e b o u n dm . . h r r r i s n it s f l o r t r e d
T h u s .t h e d i r e c l i c nc n d m 3 g n i t u d .o f p i n c i ! 3 1
t o i n l e r p r . t r t et h e s ed a t r : l l . f o r e a c r i s j sJ 8 i r ' r r
h o r i z o n t r ls t r a i na r : d e t . n n j n e db l r c l a s s i c aeli g e n '
Io
r e g i o riri r n r c c r e u r r p h t e b o u n d r v i s $ b n l r d
r
r
'
I
l
_
i
r
"
u
,:' '
,'"
The re$rlts of this fomlutstion rre sholvnin
eLi\ir'
c l r i f to ai l ) . P h t . s r n d . o r r r e q u c n l l !d ' i o ' I i B
c
lr{'i
t
l
r
c
r
e
J
c
i
r
c
s
\
!
h
c
n
s
l
r
r
i
n
theexler!sionrl
rllv.
T h e . e s o r s u r o u n d i n st h e ] x i r l s r r i l s h o w s3 n
'1rrr3qrJ. rDd
t.La.qns rql 'n u$oqs.r. uoudnr: tunsl] aiu
r L r t u 1 r , , . \ i J u . n u\ r T ' r r n . ' " " . . , , - t ' - o r , , " . . . . '; " q .
v a i n ; r J . q rl o t F t h { o t . r l r u . x $ . q \ . l . r s . r i i o r ; F t r . r . P
u D l s . q r r a r r r l p r s r o t t l l r J o q r i u r l i q . L3 r u a ! ' : n r b ' t r
, D, -D o r.,'. -,r ,:. I r!i F.-rrl
. 1 r , p i . ,ttl iu L ' ' d \ . . '
llrr. roJ r.ruit urr4s.qrlo srntrr pu. suorltr.nplrdhuld
a ii'.]
m.l 0t
urErls
or *l*
e r n s s r ,u o d o
r o I t n E ]l P U . r r o u
p a l e ^t r c e u
^{o|l P^el
8l6L ^oN
o<
439
b r i r t l . r h . . s h o l d( r b o u l t . 6 X i 0 a j n o l | r c ! s ! , r \ s c
n r 3 l lr . e l , l e r ) , r l i ew c : r k . s zr o . e , i i r l r c! r n c r o o r o i
,
, ,.'
. . ) I . . . r . - .a . r ' .
:,
r r u r ! ! r g ,I ' s u n D g ,! n d n r j . c t n o f n j r s n ! ( d r k . s ) ! r
lheresultuie
{ r t r c ni l s s u r e s
4. A nuD'.ric.lnrod.l
l n o r d e rt o r e s rL t r j jh v p o t t r e s iosf e t 3 s r i c i t vr.a
h o r n . q e n e o u rsf.lf i n i t . . t i r o . r i i r n e n s i o nhaotr i T o n r 3 L
D o u e it r ? sa s s ' n e d _i v i t h i 0 : 7 p o n s o l ] . r! r l i o . . I h e
n r o d c r \ s u t t o s e di n i t j x l t ! u n n r e r s c dr J r dr f c q ! i t i b ,
n u n r .T h o r e h t j y ed r i f l o f r h c , ^ r r b r a n! n d A i r i Q n
p l a t e si s s r n u l a t e db y ! n u D i ! \ i r l s t r . r j nr 3 . h i , r g t h e
t h r e s l l o l d\ r l u e j u s t b c n ) r el h e c n s i s T
. h e c . j s i 5i t s e t l
r s r l r . l ' s ' m u l s t e db v t t r e( j p r n j n go f s o r x ef i s s L r r c 5 .
r l I l u . - r o . rJ r I I
b ,,
r e - . . Jb . r t r , I r ' [ . . i i , . ] . 'r , J I , , . I
r.
a n d s c ' ! n i c d a r a .T h e m i . n n r ! n ! n b c r o f f i l s u r e s
n e c . s s s r tvo l l t ! d e r l u a t e l yt l t d r l ! h r s b e e nf o u r r d
e q u r l t o 2 b y u s i n gl r i i r l n r o d e h .
T h e r n o l . l c o n r r i n sr . n f a r a r r c r e r st:h e , a t L t ea n u
o I | e n t a l i o io r l h e L n r i a l s l r r i I t i . t d b c f o r et h e
c n l l sl r w o f ! r s n r e t e r sa) n d l t r ec o o . d i i [ l e so l l h e
endf-onts olthe nvo fissurcs(eiglrt
tr.ametc6) (see
r r g .j l .
'l
h e s t l a i n si n o u r r s . o a t i r n e n s i o n c t , I l ohdter rl e
b e e nc o d r I u r e du s j n gr h e d l s p t ! c c m e ndri s c o r , r u r L !
n e r h o d I 1 0 . 1I I . l n t h i s t r c t | o d r h ec x ! . r s r r e $r n d
d r s f h c e n r e . l i e l d i i I l i n c r r t yc i r s i i ct i o m o g e f e o u s
n e d i u m! r e C c r i v e du, n d c rp t r n es t r r h c o d i t i o nb y
' n c r n so i t h c P l t k o v i r c hf u f c r i D i s
I r : j , t i o r nr t r e
d r s F l i c c m e ndrr s c o n l i n u i tey x i s l i n qi n a i t c g m e nqrr r h
D o l hn o n n r l r n d l r n g c n t i r l .n o n _ 7 j r oc o n s t r n rv j l u e s .
T . .^tL ^1 Jor
r ) o " .n . r - . N
o D t l n r c di r y i r n e r rc o n r b i n x r j ooni r t r ee t e J n c n I r r y
B c c a u sler e a r ed e ! t r n gw i t h s t r . l n sa . d n o r w r i n
s l r e s s ersh. e r e s u t r rsr e l n d e t e n d e nor l i h . v r l i t r
t a k . ' r f o r l h e Y o u r r q ln o d u l u s .
T h c c o n p u r r i j o no f r r i ! t , r 1 j , l . t sb y t l u sm c u r o . l
,
r e l o r t o r r ! t t s t l i r t ! t p . o . r c ht h c o b s c n , e d
strri,,
l i e l . 1N e v c J h r l e l e sssj n
, c ei h . n d r r b e ro f i n d e p e n
o c n l o l r s e n e dd r r a t \ , : l 3 ) i s l u g c r r h
anrhcnur)rber
o . I lra r'. - .., J.,.r.1
, r. r t / . 0 1 ^
. '" | .t0," I crrc,r:r..e,
c l r . u l l r er h c b . s i n o d e i t h ] r r i t s r h e
d!r,
r i ! l . ( ! ) l h e J n o n c l t u nb c i o r eL h c . , n n . r n c & j r , \ ! u
p . r r n r e r J { . l h e v r t u e sr n d o r i e n l a l i o n
oi rh. unir\irl
rc!1onxlnr)D snnuLlhg dre rclrlive drilt of ihe Afuu[n
a r d A l r i c r r p h t . \ . a h ) T h € m o d . i l u s t r r r r rl h c . . $ . l N o
'i .' ,r.
1 . d r o . , - , i n r , . f , . \i . r r , l . s , r - r r .
r.!rltnrS irnrr rbis oprnij)-!!re dedur!d I.rorntnc dirlirence
b B $ v . c nn i i . s l ! ) x n d ( b ) .I h e . i ! h l c o $ { t j n t r r . s . fo r c r o u r
p o i n r r , 1R
, , C r r d , D , ! n d t t r cl v o p t u a n . t c r so i I j g .. l r ,
a r c t h ep a r x D e r c ro f l h c n o d . l . p o i s s o . ,rsr r i o n l ] \ q r
. q u : l l ( ) 0 . 1 t , b o u r d r r i e Isd s u p p . s e d
v c r yl a r t r o m l ] j €
r r s L u $ .! D , , n . r r , i n d d r r c i h c , n m r t ! n d r r n t e n r i r l
d b p b c c e . t ! r n d s t r t s c sn n p o s . dr j b o r n J ! r y c o . d j ! o n s .
5. Remlts of the iNeNion
T h e i n v e 6 i o n ! l g o r i t h n u s c ! l i I t t r i ss t u d y i s d . cribedjn thc Attendix. Originrl d!rr for Lh. ijtreNon
a . r l " . r , J . : r I r ' r 1 . r r ' . . . . i , , r . . . . \ ' | rn _ r
g e o d c l i cn e t o f l E p o i n i s .
I n s t c l do l u b i t r r r y c h o o s j f g( l r e s s3 3 i n a e t i r
d c n t d r r r . w e l l r k ef o r ! I e i . ! . r s i o n r o u l i n cr t r . t 5 i
r e l ! r i v ed i i p l i c c l n . n r sb c r w e e nr l l I ) o i n L si n, o r J e rl o
f o r r l t p o i n r si r t h c
t r r ) i i d e t I c s J d r !w c i g h r i l r g
w c h r v . r s u ' n c d ! s t ! n d : r l dc r r o ro f 0 . 0 5 n r f d
t f i e s cd r t ! . T h . s r ! n ! n ! n r o d d f o r l h e i D r c 6 i o no . r r g
t h e h s t t r , ] l m o d . l p r e v i o u s loi b i i i n . d - I i r r . s i n
p r r r n r e t e r i5o r t h i ss r r i i g d r o d . Jh . r v cb c e i l s s u n r c d
! o b e 0 . 5 X I 0 a l o r r h c f e 8 i o r x lr r r l m , t 0 ' l o r i r s
o r i c n t r t n ) nr. n C I k t r rt b r t | e c o o r d i n r t . \o i r h .
€ n d $ ) n t t so J t h e l l v o f i s s u . e sP. t r n i r ld . r i u i i v . s r r e
c o t u t e d I l u r c r i . r l l y b y m e ! n so f t h . d i s i r h c . r r . r r
d n c o n r i n u i ! yn r . r h o d .
T h c i l r s t i n v e r i o nh r s g j v e nr n r . . . p t r b l . r . ! l t ,
r n d J r oi r e r r t i o nh a sb e e nn c e d i d .
R e s u l t so f t | e n t v c r s i o rnr c l i s r c di n T t r b l c- 1 .
.0 IiI
ta 0-
.t 3tl
ll0
ll0+
.,9' tSl
,t 9Er
"01
110
,,7111
690
t0 0+
,685
H(14
8r ' 0 -
ai 0+
rdd
100
910
Ll A+
Ni3
.I LT
0t a+
040
af a+
J,1li
If0
a00+
It 0
s00+
sl0+
900
t0 0+
.8raI
at0
.a 8II
a8 l
.t naI
t0a
800
(a)
,\Oo
.f 9!
€0 0 +
EI''+
.9lrI
0t t_
s0'0+
.8 0s
Ntir
.8 tat
9r'0
6 10 +
Iio
0t0
0l 0+
"r ' c zI
lt0
Il t.r
0t 0+
.r'as
slt
,9 8fl
1 90
c00
tt0
I 10 +
.aLal
Ia0+
900
I0 0+
t00
t0 0+
:IOJ
,at
!t 0OJfI
r60040+
IOll
"Ll
I0'0
rs'1
,t L6
ar'0-
'tHa
zt 0.661t
.8 Sl
tl a+
.t 8tr
aia'
6 10 +
nxN
9 0r +
o\r
.9119I
t0 t-
6r'0+
.0!s
810
st t+
,tL
N.13
I I 0
8I I+
(a)
(I)
910
610+
"4811
,9 08 01 +
.904t
9at.61
st0
II'I+
noN
xNll
llv
ta)
ururs l'dr)utd !,iru, .nrr ro 'or-rinF llr 'lri { !Jrrrpu' irc (F0l \) nnler
l . d t J u u d ' r r i u r r r q i D t r o I s r u i u o d L u or r. s l J r u ' 4 i r L I r o ( ? ) s i o t h l r D J L x l r F u . ( t ) t l x J u i t r r d \ a ! . a a l i q u o s i r r r d u o J
I tlllvL
tr,:t6a 9tat
tl0
a0'0
100
uri 9a I
trrl a0 a8ar
100
!00
t00
r t r ]9 9 t a z
5ar.u,tr..r itubd!u:I
Iru.I;iir lrr\In'n
iLuJ. d.r'uurlo
t6 0
(ftt{li:ia! .r!!nl
rrsrl.r) r .rs
.0 9r
a0 0
rrlfrii,
rfl\rrrn
ooaT
(" t"n,t,)1,'-).\
!rr.r pn,Prrrs u.\rurrr.rr:pul
(!ttr;)t!Iitorur^rJtrfJ
. ! , n n ) o J x , f u i a J v . ' t t r r f i u U . f s r \ u r r r u r . r q i r r r o i p u ! i r t . L r : r i L : . . . 1 s r , i rr o Ji . r t . r i ; u r r r r r s
r ! ( ( : 60 = . i d ) r r 1 0 . t { rn L lp i l r u ! r J p . i l n l r l " ' u I i r L
l . rj t ! r f u r ! L u . r i : u 1 : L | r o \ r l n ! ) I
. l { r o r P . n l d d ur . r r q\ t r L u o r r r t r ! o o
a:llrlvt
- - J p
)fo
Discontinuity
I
t
.
tO
o
sirain
10km
FiB..{. Sttrin ield ubtajnedby our mod!l, rlt.r iire*lonP r i n . i F rdl i t e . ! i o i s n . d ' a l ! c s o l t i r ' s l r r l nt t n n n r d r c
i.dicrtcd in rhe sanlc'ndner ri in tie. L
HctrvyLir.s mdicalerhe lo.xtnrn of1're t{. i$urcr
. . m f u t . d b y l h e i n v e r i o nn r c r l l r d .
'suu.ru..ro .'.r]lo
0 1 i t q ' r l u i o . s r t u r . q q n o r l 1 ) l | r s.vr i r J r ' s . u o z
i j u o j t u. ' r ' N . r c q n su r s n r r o . r n r ( t l u r F n { ^ \f u o I 3 q
.ntr:.\
r to.s.!l.r.iNu,
I
r
.
r
d
i
r
0
t
x
9 t Jo ploLts.rLt]
| ' r . . l r r \ ' r r I t J f \ . r . 1 . ,. u
0
0
i{, i.1, |.r.i
r o u a u oi n l | u q n s P ! u , | u
lr Jo rrr.l Ie'r.rqns
i L l r u i t i \ r r s q o s r . { q . r ' t a ' i u o s i u o zp i J i r s I o ^ \ r
l o u o r r r r o l i L l rs t . r t i r d I . t o r r r r L 0 s r 6 t r o r r . r o _ \
l o s L D Jr o f . u r . r i r . q u ! n t t . ) J l ) ^ . i J r a r t ( l s . r I r. r( t r
J o r n o r r ' r ' l ! qe I r r r q . n s r t a u 0 r r q r n l r i i n s ! r ) . t . i l i p
o.5IIl r|rh lrfo!u rnoJo ]u.trr:ir3.too;.rlJ
'su.:r.r4^ ;.urrsrt pri.sr.u snsrl p31ndrr.J
9 dI:I
urz
rur
u o r s n t r ! o : )3
' s r €.i p r r s L t ) u o t;ru' r u , r . q i u r
p , r r n p r ' o ri l r s t n i e r a q f i n o q s s { . ^ J n sr r r i t o . ; ' u o n
s a n Ds l q rr . r 5 u r 0 1 r . p r o L ' l r a q p . r . t r s u o r r u n r
J o r t N . s. r 1 r1 , ru o n c r u c , r s pi r l s r l r a , 1 ru E q rr . l x L ! s
. i r n r r l ; | ] l Ltro r . i u o u l rs rn l r r r u x o J r p. r r s r t d . o r s r ^
c q r n s . s r r l u f u I p : r ' r s r i r u r . q a i r _ ,uq} l ! t r r r u . .
. { r r r J o s l ! r . . . l r i s ' p. ^ r t r t . r ' a : 6 t r t t r r ' r it{u r 3 l 6 I
r c o u r i l o N u r r . r { ) p . i , ) \ r n si r . : } r t : ) r t ns r u r o dr n o . l
i r I i l u r o 3 r u o J i r t r ' r l d: i ' r r u o r r r u x o J r pt r r r s n l d . o . s r ^
s r o p l u r l x r i r x { r o 1 : u i d o s u r r l r j r rL r r r l s b y
.[8
t ' t I ] 1 u r ^ ou ! \ . n s j l u r p a r a r d
r ' r r j r L l i u u n p r u r . U r u , l rrso u i r r s t u . u a l o r u l B r u o z
. u o r l r ' r q ru { o r { ss x t S L 6 t
rii.a1.q puNI
P
U
N
9
1
6
I
' i ] l u , l i x . r t u ' l - i , , l Ns h - I rr. u l l t u l sr ' ^ l f u o r a s
[9r]
8 ! 6 r r ; q u r a i . N u r p a n J r s qxoi l t a q s r r -.t{ F ( ' r r 1 x .
5 €, $p t a u. r n s s ui r q l i l s r u : t r o r r d ' us s es { t l r o d
d n ss u o \ r J ro $ I 8 t 6 r r . q o r . r o NJ o s r s u r. r l S u n p
3 r . t u r j o o ru o r r r u r o J i pp . r n s F u n l o r t s i q l t E L j l
p J u n s s ra . \ . L.la t r 6 r f n : 1 1 6 I u s i a r i q t r u r o j
J.d i^\ sio!ot.rnsE!(.rlrto.li ou Lf,lnoqrN
' l sI r l l
s J u . p ! n o q a r r l di u r r . r : . ' r r q r u r r r r t . k r q l l
n Jo
s r r r r J o r d I f . ) ' u c r { r . ui r 1 1u o u o u r u o ] u ' s a r 6 s r u o z
i i u l l . r Li . L J r .o r p . ] r , t i r . , u r r; q u f r t r t r ' t . I o o r r n O
'3lo{dii iilnJu
lui..r r(tr,ro
s r . . d s sr u r t r o d n nl r r l : r
. . d . i n u r 0 0 ; s rt t , . r ( t $
i r u o zs n t l I . ^ r n . - \ r u . r L r { l r s u r
-ro
v
I t s r . n r s s r t. i t r
I o ( l t P ' i \ ( ! i o ! \ . u p . r n d r o . r r J t t r q q f o r t : )r q r 1 r t
q , .
I r r . , . r . I ' r ' _t . . t r , . q r o" t J . p r
J o r i p , o . L | o r s t u o d s i l o r s t ' t t o n r r r . s q ou a o r n o
t r r o r : l u r a i o r t . n b ep u n o j s rF p o r u J t I q f . r p
. r r d r l s u I n r r r r q n s . q 1 t or ! p r a N n u f u
rt{I
urz
' s r u op : r n s ! . u ' . ' l t s n s r . ^s l u r r u i . a i l d ! r p
arir.tar
t
a
r
N
l n . t . ri r l t p r o l r l J r D r rt ^ \ s J r J u l
r ' ; ' : l j o p i l l r l i i r o u . ' 0 u r p u n o j. s l r
.rr z ';rl ur pt.r-p
l . n r : $ o . q l l o s . r r D . r l n . J .llu 3
s r r r s r r . u N ' F r ' r f r ui q r p 1 r 0t l r p f : r ^ r . v l o r r l r r l r r {
I t a h I 6 L ' L * n l , n !. . r ; i ' ! i t q U . u r p . l \ r l s ) t n s i l l
- a . i ^ ! Ju !
t . s n u o r l r r r t i p\ n o r ^ a r dr L l t r t l r r i t ; u r u r ' { . e . r o J
s r n t N ru c . u ' . r 3 s , o \ u i r u r c r r s ' ; r r t u r u { o ' l s p l a t - l
u r r r r s! ' l r t . ) n J x r o r . r r q e . \ i t i p o u rI . r u s r r l ro r
t o q t . u r ' { r r n ! n u o r s r pt u ! u I . l L l s ' f J r l t r u r i t d . l y
' u r e r r ( sa : I r s . u . p Y . l o , r t n 3i q r j u s r t n u ! , j o l s u . r l
i u r l r r r i r t \ a L I q r r ^ \r u i ( ! . J r i D u ! s r ' { . n t \ i t J t o ' u
I . r ) r Uo ! r ( o r - r N c ! f J o ! n l | \ ] l l r r d J t : ^ r \ a $ p u t
( ; r l ! r L i i s l r l u p a L { irq p . u r ( ! 1 r . p i t r o o d s r u r r r r s
I r ! o i l i i J l t t . j o L , o r r I ] ] r ' . u o i L t0. it. ,x 6 s I c ) 1
I r n . 1 r l i . o ru r r q ! ' r ' l l t i r I r l r i l r r u q ' i I r s r ] . ! q r r o J
.ntfr .Lll l,! srolf tr. N s ;soI I r..u \.rl iurod
: l p ! r ( r r t r . q q n o ( 1 5I t r u r P r r g r o ls r ' N o 0 ! _rl l u '
{ u r r r i r u r ; u o iu , I I : . I o - i r n \ n r p r o . . ) s . t l LN o f : I
s (r i j . r L r / ' r\ r t ( t i i u u ; s r r l ) . U u n s s ul r ' ! i r q N s
p . i r N q o r q r - r os r \ | i r l r q r L \ s ! l t . ) t r c - rq ] r l \ i u o l
u ' l j f - r ou n s s u ! r o s r r s r o l( i . r r n l o \l . ) r a ^ u r J ' { l
W . r h r r ) k !c o 1 1 . r S ! . fso r l i c l p J " ld i s . u s n ) n ,r n l l
| r r l i . r L h r l j - F I i . C o n . t w h o t r o l i i L e dh i s F o r t n n I V
a l l o n 1 h l , t n r c o r x p u t i t n ) no f . r | ] \ l i cd . i o t n r t r c n .
C . J o b . r t f r r ' 1 . r s e i i r l. o r x n r e n Gr n d s r i g - e e s l r o n s .
I L K i ! \ s . r| ! , i ! n c s j . n t i x lf r r l j o r s i n r z r t . t t l , '
l l c l J \ v o r kr n d c o ! n m u . r c J r . dS c o d c l i rce l t s p r i o ! t o
A t f r n d i \ . l D v e B i o nr l g o r i t h n i
t s' : f i e
L e t ( j " ) b c r v e c l o rw h o s ec o 1 ) r p o n . n 3
(
'
,
b
e
!
v
c.tor
p r r r m . t c r so f s o n r ei n i l i r l m o d c l .
!nl'res
ol
some
nrcawhosc comtonents rrc the
" L . . l d r r r ,| , , ' r t L i .e c r . r ' , 1 1 .r . . i r s h i l )b e t v e e nd ! t a r n d m o d c l p a r a $ e l e r sT.h e m o d e l
C b c n r g3 n e s t i n r r t eo i t i r e { n r c m o d e la n dr h e , l a ( r
ihat their
l L , r ! i n fc x t e r i r e r t l l e ( o r s , u c r s s u n r e
co\.ln,rrce Inalricesco!(d) rnd co!L!) are knovn.
w e d e i r n e( , t ' " ) x ! d ( ) - r ) a st h e b e s tc s t i r n a l { nosf
l l i e I r u e D o d e l a n d t h c l r u e d x t . . i n t h c l e a s ts q u a r c s
s e n r ei,. e .t h e y m i n i . r i z cl h e x : f u n c t i o n
x'=(l'
+(o
r)' cov''(r.)(r
r)
v)r co!-I(t) (n. e)
(^.1)
wirhtl!' e\ac1conslra!Dt:
(A-l)
),=A.O
$ h e r eA j s t h c m r t ! j - \ h t h e l i n e ! r r e h t i o n p r c d i c ! c d
b y t h e r h c o r y( " d i r c . t p r o b l c r , i " ) .
I r c r n b e s h o r r n[ 1 9 ] t h a t l f 1 h e c o v a r i s n c e
I r r t r i c e j l L r v en o n u l l J r o ri r l l i i t e d i r g o . r l c i e m c t s .
i . c .v a r i r n . e st,h e p r o b l . n ri o r n ) L t l a t .hde r eh 3 sr l w r y s
r $ l r t r o . ( r n i 1 r u l i r c o n e ) .I t i s g i v e nb y :
, t = I A ' C o v 1 ( . r , )A + c o v - r ( e ) l - r
'(e)
1t )
el
] + cov
[Ar cov
(A.3)
C l l c u h t e d p u r a m e t e {' s, 1 , " 1h r r e I c o v r r i a n c ne r !
l r i r t h a r . a n b e d e l l n e db y :
s,l
l
i],1,
n . rf " L . r = J ; ; t
. , \ r r /r , ) +
s J,l- i n.
+l-:C l v t e ,e, , )
, r . " , ' , | | i \ r ' d . , r . . ,. ^ . r , r . r t ruu rr , ! a . _ )
( -s)
C o v ( , r , =I A t C o ! r L 1 ) A + C o v - ' ( e ) l - '
, ^ k i r n d L . c l l 0 l h a v es i v e nr n o r c c o i r f l i . I . d
e x f r . s i o l l o i t h c ! o r r r i x . c . n r x t r i x1 . r r ! c r ) ' s i i n i h !
i r l c r s c i ) r o b l c mT. h i s r sd u c I o 1 1 r f. r . ( l l r r t r f ( l , c
i , r i r i d f r o , l . l r r i s n o l t \ t l i r i t l l i . L o i - l u c . di n t h .
d e f i i i t i o n o f I h r n r n r i n r i r ! r gl u L r c t i o .X ?( . q u r r r o n
. r - l ) . l h . n l | c s e c o n dt . n n i n t h . r i g l r t - h t ' nsdn l r o l
e q u J t i o n( , \ - ' l ) i s n r i $ i n gr n d $ r c s i r f r ) l i l l c r t i osr
l e r d i n gt o e ( t u . r l i o(nA - 5 )c l on o t l s k c p h c e .
T h e " r c s o l L r l i ornl r t n x " [ ] l l i l i l l o $ 5 t o s r u d )
- . b ) J . . .\ \ ' f i l r r o
r..r.
| \r.,,
i n t r o d u c .$ h r t r v en J r n ct h c i i d e t ! ! n n r r ! ' o n
l'i'^
(A-6)
Fromcqu3tions
fA l) rnd (A.6).ncoblrjnsi
r(e)
(A r)
, = cov(,I,) cov
It c;
be sho$n {l'xl:
0 <,D""< 1
(^-8)
a n d i r i s c l c l r f r o m e q u r r i o n( , 4 - 6 )t h r t i i r " " ' s c l o s e
t o z c r c ,t h c t r r 3 n r e t e r4 r ot a k e sa v r h . i r r d . ' , 3 n d c n t
o f i h e c o r c s p o n d l u gl 3 n n l e t c r p d o f r h c i l r i l i 3 l
| -l ..., ,lt Lv r', ' r'. i c
: , . .' . . . I ' \ " 1 , l "
"
d
e
(
.
r
n
u
r
i
r t t ' p a r 3 m c r c rI.i r o a i s . l d s e
Odis. well
i o u n i l y , t h e t u r n r c l . r O d s t r o n g l yd e p e n l so r ! h e
p a r r n r . r e r9 a o f t h . i t i ! l n r o , l e l rt h c t r r x r i . l . r ' t ' "
I n f r . t , t h c p r u b l e n\r{ e s h r l l t r . . l i s n o l ! ( r ! .
l i l ] e ! r t r o l , l c r nC l i s t l a c e m e r trsr e n o t l i u c r r l r r e l r t ' d
l o o u r D a ' 3 n e t . r s )b, u ! b . c l u s . o u r i r r r l i r lt r o d e l d
is nor too lir liorD the finrl solution rf', wc crn, rs it
i s c l u s r i c r l l yd o n c ,w o r k i n ! | e i l A l . r d e r r l f r o x '
matior ("lrr.rrir.Lt!robl.nr").B! e\prnd'n: rnr
'lrvlols
s c r i . so n c o b l r i n s :
C o v ( , r =, ) [ A r ' C o v - ' ( ] ) A r C o v - t ( f ) l - r
,(,!) = co(,1,) cov-!(rj
o
-/lt)l
e = C o ( , I , ) A r C o v - ' ( -) , L L
(^ t)
(1.10)
(A.ll)
$ l . r ' , , - l , , r . - ' ,r ( ' ^ i l J r ' r r ' J : r ' r ' r
n r o d c l, ( 1 v i I ht h e n o r l i , r . r r ! 1 i r . . lp ' o b l c t r r )r.n d
(A4)
16 .l-t o|t
F r o me q u l r i o ni A , i ) i t c l n b c s h o w nr h a ! l h j s c o v r . i -
lalL(,r)'\
('\-[)
'l9I
i a l { 6 a 6 t r) ! i o s
a r . r t \ v I I r ^ q d o a ! )u o 6 r r n ur .r i u ' t 0 r$ . u r n l r r u n
-uoui{tolri o} fr.p uo!.i rlo rn' rLLtiu.\:Fr|a
o €t
'a6l
t z r ( 0 i 6 I )9 9 a
uopuo-t Jos )l sllJf xotrqd..rEp rtlrf. isorrrilen.rur
t o u o r r : 1 u 1i , l i ! r s r u . n f r d n r r i q t r c f p d r s n r j . r g c a a
'tlr.
69I (1196|)Il ros'u.rlrv f s{,td!r.ra).rrDprtrr'l
!rr.ql!
s\.f
ri{od:uht$
r
I
I
s
n
:
i
r
.
r
l
J
.
l
t
x
D
J I'
'(916t)
tZ
'18 r:)l r\rtdoJJ
r !.rtrnLl rlr! p..luroq s.nu p^Dr.
J 1 \ r Ui n N n , i u f , n o s r i s r r J p n . . . r r r L r o u ,r { r h o r r ^
I r u . 6 u r u i r p r r { ! i . , u r r ; . u r t r l o 3 c - r :tlt f , \ \ p u f r : l v t t 0 z
luolr
. r r r . i i d u , ) r i l . a - J J or I F o r . r t r u o f q ) r L r I i . r l l r . r l t J o
uorrruur.rrp.rtl or lorflrJa. slr pu'r ruliqolt is.riur
!
. i
.r.\ ..,
t,
d .a
J
')
I !$icrd v .rrr.)t .) r.trpJDql! | ,rt.rurjNt \: 6I
.!0t
f6l
( 9 1 6 r ) I t s r r ! i L ! r i . u o r r i . ll ] ! r , r : r rn r s t , i r t r r l j n r n i . , u r r
jrp rfl tr.rd
rriltD.).
\\ |] pur uon:l! :j.)t );pu.rd 1 I 8l
'8tll
6 a 0 t 1 1 l i 6 l r t 8s a Us f t t d o r r I g l a t
9 i 6 t p u D l - t l l u o \ u r r r ' r p u . . . L. l r i L dJ q rj o s r r r - r r |.|u o s
iiriqrorlL')t,u,,uoss!nlis.s.u.\uqot :).u.sulrrtt.y 1t
(6!6t) )(r
DS nury Lrrrt l!r1,.tr.rd il,:!,F rtr
ilrurp
atLx.rou rF rsrJr
r
t
i
t
\
r
i
b
r
u
o
l
r
i
r
r
8
i
6
t
1
r
u
:
u
.nriurq.! .!l
,:1n!Il ))rLru.drrt it fu'r Lx.d.rt
\'v
9l
( s r d i r t r 0 ' r u t l r r L r l Jq u . t \ I t ( t . . l t r u r n i 1 r J t J r : o r d
IqrcJ! pu.urt\ l.rlrr5iqrJ.JuruiLJo rrlt!n.il \ 9l
0 l s s 6 l ( 8 ' . 6 ! lr 8 . i u j , i L t r t . i !r ' ! l
.puroq)!rl,ritr!:rI'r
l
t
n
'
j
F
J
o
s
.
a
n r q J : ! ' r r Dt u r : r i q l t \
. o q r i lJ q r t . j u ' t r r \ ' r . i r . r r t : r . r
|.t t!cJrrrrodd.I d ti
'aai
aai liral) ta nrl ns 1:u.tiJ
'lrr. I 5ru)rr.r IDUctJrl iq trL-iiiii.ri r? J3ipu.rrtr..tro
. p r r rt . i 0 . 7 l n \ ! r r l t l . i u . ! n l o i . r i q r
I n p . u Ly
'b'u'in,idrl. ptrr.jrlJ
I.rrr runoJ..\\rrrxjno
r\ !l
d d a n ; p r p r a ( 0 1 6 t . . , ! \ ' t r ) A n J \ ' l r t J -r r j J . l \ J
{ r F r e l l J ! \ r o . ) L u! r i { p o o : )
pucolu bor|l_ d.s al
\
'
a
!-;,rttt\i
rirtr,l -qtr.)t\ ltjrtV .a
' . J r r j r r t l . t r r i r u r . i ; _ j r u r . \ \ rj6r
. i!)L iu irLrqrkjrjp
r0rtrn)td!irrr0 1q5tr{t.ur:trlrr{drr.Jlrur.J.lt I It
'trt
r0t (16r) Oi :trj qrjr.i
't
' p o q r r ! ,' i I n u D u o - \ r p
loI
lLrJui.rtLlsit
Frtriuin\
r L l t. r qs o J t . L o r.l { t h n \ c t .i u r t d t o o o r r f t o s r p t r . r J l . s 0 I
.tfi
ttr(lt6I)9
J'rr) Iun toit dio tT'\l
'r.|1nrliqrrti
l . I r o I l r p u n o { t r r r ) s . t .) q I p r . r ' I . l l 6
't6a
{616t).!i.a ns luuv
r,rir .u'lr 'tror,t'8t6I .rquirq, utr (Dno{trfarJp dru)
I n \ v r i ! t q , o L t . J r Fu . r i i r rr r s ! r ! i n u r d r \ i n I u ! 6 r s r l
n t r t i f i r r ' q r D ! . l \ ;s f t L vt " ; i ; ) . x J r ' r u r d J , l J f 8
(\FJd
u, r)i] rJl siLldol! !i.Jv u' sa!tr rntfrtnr ounrs
. qlrr
Jurjrlt.io
J
r
r
p
o
r
S
n
!
:
u
'
n
s
r
r
r
r
l
a
r
"
D
.
$
r
'jrrt)'tlttur
D t , r r u c i l r .\ / a u L J r t ' J I
iirnll.JI
a
'z1i
6 q ai 6 t 6 i l ! $ ? s r r . d
lrs pbv u J i'rn!q'kt :p iibrlq.d.u !tr rtrq.iiorLS
'E\V.t Jr;ri,u.r aprot) 'rt ris !or!rtri,tr !ururrrrn.LU rp
.rrJpr^rui ielt ;iilt .J.t tuf Jtrril t J.f.ra$.\ l! 9
. d r lj t ( t r 6 t , r r r d . t f t r o r r r !
r n i , r q d L r i . : . )r r r a 0 I l J t r L r u r ) r .r . A r . r 1 \ i . t i r p . ) r . J r p
. r r i . r t r L, l r " i i n i ) r J r t o r ;r r . \ r J t r r . t u . r r r r t r r t d r r tI
'6ar Itl6t)
l ; l ) J l n s ) r u . t J L t r r .I i r t i r l
r t , r r u r ) r o J r t rt ) u r l l ! . q o 1 r o p r v : r i r p r n o ! I r l { t
; u q l I . 3 L u I r u . d r r i f J f u 0 r N J r . r q l u u : lt . u o L l l d
rt x.i0rrlo
I t j t r n . r l n o L t Jd u r q p J r N . ( l H t
'8!l
n r s )a p r ' r . L ! . x
6al (9i61 )rr
. v p , L rr t r ; t r r.l\ ' . r k r ) r L t r ' r o r $ r r d r dr r - r v : u r . u t r
I Jl)
ruilo|il\:lltrqs
Itutrllr!)!
I u.\ur
\r 9.J I
'sat
( a / 6 t ) t t l 1 r . { O1 . 1 ! \ , { L U} _ . o . , - ) ' { . ! ( I ! ' . t ' I )
-snrl.!!s
I $ ! r . p r r u n f i n ; r t r i rJ L h r u . ! r r u o D d t t x r
I a
ifI
( ' a l 6 l ) t i a i r u r \ ' u o F s . r i l i crl r r v i , l r . r . u r ! r r ! : _ ' !
I'oLirJ ,:q;rr.5 tu. uiqr.fl l Lrir,\'t jjr7,rL Il I
s'rtrJItltu
( ! v ) o r ( I Y ) \ r r o n r n b .r r rs . i r r i d D u r' t r ' s
: r t 1r i r r i s t o { i r J . i sr . q r o l t v ' r . r J o r u . d . r l r . r r r r ' ! l \ r I
q r h \ r r r l f i r t r r p J r . l . r { rr . s . ^ i r I : l D i pl t r r r r a Jl L 0r r r