conference internationale pour l`emergence de l`afrique
Transcription
conference internationale pour l`emergence de l`afrique
Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd CONFERENCE INTERNATIONALE POUR L’EMERGENCE DE L’AFRIQUE L’EXPERIENCE DE MAURICE EN MATIèRE TRANSFORMATION ECONOMIQUE par Nikhil Treebhoohun, Président Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd. 5 mars 2015 Duclos Street, Port Louis, Republic of Mauritius [email protected] www.oxfordmu.com Page 1 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd TABLE DES MATIÈRES Acronymes ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 3 Introduction.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.0 La trajectoire économique ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 2.0 Les catalyseurs ............................................................................................................................................................................. 7 3.0 Méthodes de mise en œuvre complémentaires (MMO) ............................................................................................ 12 4.0 MMO nationales ......................................................................................................................................................................... 13 5.0 Le début d'un nouveau cycle? .............................................................................................................................................. 14 6.0 Références.................................................................................................................................................................................... 16 Page 2 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd ACRONYMES APEI/PAIE CMPHS/ECMOM BPO/STPC GATS CSO EPZ PIB PNB GFMD GM OIT COI OIM ATI ou RES PRI ONG MLIRE OCDE BPM PIO ONU PNUD Programme accéléré pour l’intégration économique Enquête continue sur les ménages aux objectifs multiples Sous-traitance des processus commerciaux Accord général sur le commerce des services Statistiques Maurice Zone industrielle d’exploitation Produit intérieur brut Produit national brut Forum mondial sur la migration et le développement Gouvernement de Maurice Organisation internationale du travail Commission de l’océan Indien Organisation internationale pour les migrations Aménagement touristique intégré ou Projet immobilier Pays à revenu intermédiaire Organisation non gouvernementale Ministère du Travail, des Relations internationales et de l’Emploi Organisation de coopération et de développement économique Bureau du Premier ministre Bureau des passeports et de l’Immigration Organisation des Nations Unies Programme des Nations Unies pour le développement Page 3 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd INTRODUCTION “Imaginez que quelqu’un ait à décrire un petit pays qui offre une éducation gratuite jusqu’à la fin de l’université pour tous ses citoyens, des moyens de transport pour les écoliers, et des soins médicaux gratuits – y compris la chirurgie cardiaque – pour tous. Vous pourriez penser qu’un tel pays est soit extrêmement riche soit destiné à être rapide frappé par une une crise fiscale. Mais Maurice, un petit pays insulaire au large de la cote orientale africaine, n’est ni particulièrement riche, ni proche d’une débâcle budgétaire. Cependant, durant les dernières décennies, il a réussi à construire une économie diversifiée, un système politique démocratique et un dispositif de protection social robuste. De nombreux pays, dont les Etats-Unis, pourraient tirer des leçons de cette expérience. ”Joseph E. Stiglitz, “The Mauritius Miracle” (Le miracle mauricien), March 2011 Le terme « miracle mauricien » a été utilisé par plusieurs universitaires et institutions internationales pour décrire la trajectoire économique de cette petite ile (2 400 kilomètres carrés) peuplée de 1,3 millions d’habitants – ‘miracle’ implique qu’une sorte de « deus ex machina » est intervenu, alors que le succès économique est le résultat d’une réflexion et d’une planification stratégiques, de l’élaboration de politiques efficaces, et du renforcement des capacités humaines et institutionnels pour mettre en œuvre ces politiques, et d’une structure gouvernementale qui stimule tous les secteurs de la population à œuvrer ensemble en vue d’un objectif partagé. Avant son indépendance en 1968 qui a suivi près de 150 années de domination britannique (et un peu moins de 100 ans de domination française avant 1880), James Mead (lauréat du prix Nobel) avait prédit un futur excessivement sombre pour Maurice qui avait toutes les caractéristiques d’une économie (coloniale) typique africaine : monoculture, croissance démographique rapide, des termes défavorables d’échange, et une tendance aux tensions ethniques. Cependant, d’après ce que Stiglitz explique, « Comme s’ils voulaient contredire Meade, les mauriciens ont augmenté le revenu par habitant qui est passé de moins de 400 USD au moment de l’indépendance à plus de 6 700 USD à l’heure actuelle. Le pays est passé d’un modèle agricole de monoculture axé sur le sucre il y a cinquante ans, à une économie diversifiée qui comprend le tourisme, la finance, les textiles, et si les plans actuels aboutissent, une technologie de pointe. Le PNB de Maurice a enregistré une hausse supérieure à 5% annuellement pendant plus de 30 ans. Il y a surement un truc derrière ces résultats. Maurice doit surement posséder beaucoup de diamants, de pétrole ou un autre bien précieux. 1.0 LA TRAJECTOIRE ECONOMIQUE La Figure 1 résume la transformation structurelle de Maurice qui est passée d’une économie basée sur la monoculture à une plateforme commerciale intégrée où les exportations de biens et services deviennent de plus en plus importants. Les différentes phases ont été les suivantes : Briser la dépendance au sucre (1970-79) Page 4 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Développer une industrialisation axée sur les exportations, plus spécifiquement dans le secteur du textile et du vêtement (1980-92) Créer les bases pour la croissance de l’économie de services (1990-2012) S’ouvrir vers la mer (2013) Figure 1: La Trajectoire économique de Maurice Source: Makoond, R. 2011 Traduction du Tableau ci-dessus : Trajectoire économique Canne à sucre Textiles et mode Accueil Fruits de mer Services financiers TIC/Sous-traitance Immobilier et PD Industrie du savoir Services médicaux Energie renouvelable Sucre Textile Tourisme Services financiers TIC/Sous-traitance IRS Fruits de mer Textiles Sucre Page 5 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Tourisme Services financiers Port franc Textiles Sucre Tourisme Industries manufacturières (locales) Sucre Industries manufacturières (locales) Economie basée sur la monoculture Industrie manufacturière et tourisme Industrie manufacturière et économie de services Plateformes commerciales Plateformes commerciale intégrée La croissance annuelle moyenne atteignait 5 % durant les années 80 à la suite du Programme d’Ajustement structurel (PAS) de la fin des années soixante-dix, pour retomber ensuite à 4 % durant les années 90. A partir de 2 000, le taux de croissance moyen se situait autour de 3,5%. Per Cent 20 15 10 5 0 -5 -10 -15 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 Figure 2: Taux de croissance du PNB 1970–2013 Year Source: Statistiques de Maurice (Statistics Mauritius), plusieurs numéros Breaking the dependence on sugar (1970–1979): The first phase started after independence and was aimed at diversifying the economy to reduce the vulnerability caused by the over-dependence on sugar for jobs and export earnings. As can be seen in Table 1 the contribution of agriculture to GDP fell from 26.1% in 1970 to 15.7% in 1982. By 1998 its share was less than 10% while manufacturing had risen to 20.5%. While the agricultural sector, which was highly labour intensive and regulated by strict labour laws, maintained its level of employment at above 50,000 (declining by some 3,000 between 1970 and 1982), the number of employees in the manufacturing sector almost trebled during that period. By the end of the second phase, the manufacturing sector had become the largest employer, with the EPZ creating the lion’s share of jobs. Table 1: Structural transformation of Mauritius 1970–1998 (US$ bn, %) Amounts (US$ bn) Economic Parameters Growth rates (%) 1970 1982 1998 70-82 83-98 70-98 Nominal GDP and GDP growth 0.42 pa ($bn) 0.95 4.45 1.52 19.1 17.2 Page 6 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Real GDP (1970$) ($bn) 0.42 0.78 2.25 GDP growth 3.2 5.9 5.1 GNP growth -4.8 6.4 2.1 2.2 1.1 1.4 -6.3 5.4 2.0 Population (mn) 0.73 0.92 1.10 GNP/capita (nominal)($000) 0.57 1.03 4.05 Real growth Share (%) Agriculture as % of GDP 26.1 15.7 8.8 Real growth -1.3 -0.6 -0.7 Manufacturing as % of GDP 12.0 20.1 25.2 Real growth 4.5 7.4 6.0 Other industry as % of GDP 8.1 9.0 9.9 Real growth 1.1 1.2 1.5 Services as % of GDP 53.8 55.2 57.9 4.5 6.6 5.8 Sources: Bank of Mauritius annual reports; World Bank Country Economic Reports; World Bank Global Development Finance Reports, 1998, 1999; and World Development Indicators 1998, 1999 Table 2: EPZ Contribution to GDP, employment, and investment (selected years) 1976 1980 1990 2000 2010 2012 Contribution in GDP (%) 2.59 4.34 11.87 11.43 6.47 Employment (number) 644 21,344 89,906 90,682 55,828 54,597 630 1,702 913 1,066 Investment (Rs million) 38 6.2% Source: Statistics Mauritius, various issues 2.0 THE ENABLERS What is an ‘enabler’? It may refer to the quality of institutions, infrastructure, factors of production (labour, technology), connectivity and integration. All of these were present in the economic and social transformation of Mauritius. In fact transformation took place because of the effective interaction between the different enablers. The quality of institutions (the civil service, the Central Bank, the banking sector) ensured that funds were channelled to infrastructure development, that the labour force was adequately educated, and that the appropriate policies were adopted to improve connectivity. Page 7 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Institutions that were set up specifically to mobilise financial resources and facilitate the flow of funds include the Development Bank of Mauritius (DBM), the State Bank of Mauritius (SBM), the State Insurance Corporation of Mauritius (SICOM), the State Investment Corporation (SIC), the Mauritius Leasing Corporation and the Stock Exchange of Mauritius (SEM). In the initial phase, investment in social infrastructure (health, education) as well as in economic infrastructure (industrial estates, the port, the bulk sugar terminal, and the airport) served to foster the diversification of the economic base into tourism and manufacturing. To kick-start the industrialisation process the DBM set up industrial estates, which were rented out at preferential rates. The necessary funds were obtained by the government mainly from the Caisse Française de Développement and from the IFC. Figure 3: FDI and GDI in Mauritius, 1980–2001 Source: Bank of Mauritius, 2001 The driving force of Mauritius’ development has been its export sector, namely the sugar industry, tourism and the EPZ. The relatively dynamic financial sector also played a crucial role in the development process. These sectors have all benefited from both domestic and foreign investment throughout their development. It is only from the mid-1980s that FDI started entering Mauritius in significant amounts, directed mostly to the EPZ and tourism. Many Mauritian specialists suggest that another key factor of the country’s development success was the large proportion of domestic investment in these leading economic sectors, in particular private domestic investment. FDI played a significant role more because of the technological know-how it brought than because of the capital inflows as such. Indeed, the contribution of FDI to gross domestic investment (GDI) remained quite low throughout the 1980s, representing 6% in its peak year (Figure 3). However, FDI in tourism and the EPZ brought in the necessary technologies and know-how to transform them into leading sectors of the economy. It also enabled local investors to acquire and assimilate these technologies and know-how and develop domestic firms in the two sectors. Table.3: Gross Domestic Fixed Capital Formation (GDFCF) (Rs million) 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2012 GDFCF 145 2,240 12,030 27,595 74,395 79,185 Private 94 1,375 7,560 19,866 59,667 60,175 Private (% of GDFCF) 65% 61% 63% 72% Public 51 865 4,470 7,729 80% 17,898 76% 19,010 Public (% of GDFCF) 35% 39% 37% 28% 24% 24% Page 8 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Source: Statistics Mauritius It must be pointed out that the government did not use the tax revenue to develop infrastructure but used it for social expenditure (financing teachers and medical professionals; subsidies on food staples like rice and flour). This helped to keep cost of living relatively low so that wages could be held at a competitive rate to enable the export sector to flourish. Loans and grants from local and international sources were used to build schools, hospitals, the Bulk Sugar Terminal and to revamp the airport. The key elements that facilitated the transformation can be summed up as follows: Factors of production: In addition to adequate infrastructure as outlined above, Mauritius always placed major emphasis on the development of its human resources. Secondary education was provided free of charge to the entire age cohort from 1975. This helped to increase girls’ enrolment in secondary school and eventually provided a sufficient number of literate and semi-literate workers for the EPZ. The education system, modelled on the British system, also catered to the needs of the civil service and produced competent cadres to implement the policies. Furthermore, there was a class of local entrepreneurs who were ready to respond to the government’s incentives to move into tourism or manufacturing. National governance: An important factor in the sustained growth of the economy has been political stability, not in terms of the political landscape, which has experienced episodic turbulence, but in terms of broadly shared beliefs among the political class and consensual adherence to an economic strategy of outward orientation, market-driven development, and the rejection of nationalisation and inwardlooking policies. This has provided continuity in the pursuit of broad objectives. The state played different roles in different phases of transformation, for instance as initiator, promoter, protector and arbiter. But it was a developmental state, committed to development of the country in which the rule of law prevails. The government was instrumental in securing access for Mauritian products and services through the negotiations of treaties (Yaoundé, Lomé, AGOA, Double Taxation Agreements) and joining regional groupings (the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA), the Southern African Development Community (SADC), the Indian Ocean Commission (IOC) and the Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA)). The government intervened positively in the early stages of development to mobilise domestic and foreign capital for infrastructure development. As domestic savings were low and sugar was the only export sector, it had to ensure that the flow of foreign exchange from sugar exports remained stable so as not to handicap investment efforts. The Commonwealth Sugar Agreement guaranteed a favourable price but was to expire when the United Kingdom (UK) joined the then European Economic Community (EEC) in 1973. Mauritius therefore imposed an export duty on sugar and a cess (a tax earmarked for a specific purpose) to fund research by the Mauritius Sugar Industry Sugar Industry Research Institute and the setting up of institutions (e.g. the Sugar Planters’ Mechanical Pool Corporation) to improve the productivity of small planters. Policy coherence: The success of Mauritius rested on its adoption of an outward-looking strategy since independence. The EPZA was passed in 1970, two years after independence. Unlike EPZs in other countries, the Mauritius EPZ did not refer to a specific geographical area, but was a legal entity which offered the holder of an export-enterprise certificate generous incentives: tax holidays, duty-free import of raw materials and equipment, free repatriation of capital and flexible labour regulations. The importance of an appropriate meso–micro incentive structure, consistent with macroeconomic objectives of stability, prudence and balance, cannot be over-emphasised. In spite of the above elements, the Mauritian economy did not really take off before the mid-1980s. The main reason was the failure to get prices right, i.e. exchange rate, interest rates, tariffs and tax policies had to be geared towards a clear goal – to achieve development by adopting an outward-looking strategy. Before the SAPs, fiscal policy was characterised by high government expenditure, financed by high taxes and external borrowing (short-term Euro-Dollar loans to finance long-term infrastructure projects). The Page 9 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd fiscal and exchange rate reforms undertaken in the context of the SAPs ensured more efficient fiscal governance (the overall budget deficit as a percentage of GDP remained at around 3% between 1985 and 1995), removed the distortions of a dual exchange rate policy and ensured that the Rupee was not overvalued. In general, however, Mauritius has used the exchange rate to have a competitive edge. From time to time there has been some overvaluation but corrective measures were quickly taken. These are illustrated in the two graphs from an IMF report on the competitiveness of Mauritius and the role of the exchange rate. Figure 4: Nominal and effective exchange rates, 1948–2007 Sources: Reinhard and Rogoff (2004); IMF annual reports on Exchange Arrangements and Exchange Restrictions (AREAER); and IMF Staff Reports from the late 1960s. Figure 5: Nominal and effective exchange rates, 1980–2005 Page 10 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Source: Reinhard and Rogoff (2004); IMF Notice System, monthly data Trade promotion: FDI was actively encouraged, and there was a general consensus that FDI was in the country’s interests. Mauritian nationality was offered to Hong Kong investors when the UK and China were discussing the fate of the then British colony in preparation for the handover in 1997. This second surge of investment from Hong Kong underpinned the remarkable growth of the textile and clothing sector in the 1980s. Institutions were set up specifically for the purpose of promoting trade and attracting investment and their boards of directors comprised more representatives from the private than the public sector. The exchange rate policy was instrumental in maintaining economic competitiveness, as shown in Figures 4 and 5. Furthermore, the private sector was also given incentives to set up industrial estates to attract foreign investors. As can be seen from Table 3, private investment has on average made up around 70% of GDFCF. The bulk of capital was in the form of loans from the local commercial banks. Until the SAP in 1979 there was credit rationing in Mauritius whereby the Central Bank imposed ceilings on various categories of borrowers. The trade sector was discriminated against while productive sectors like agriculture, import-substituting enterprises holding Development Certificates, EPZ firms and the tourism sector benefited from discounted rates. The main provider of loans to the private sector was the Mauritius Commercial Bank (set up in 1838 with the seed capital being the compensation the British paid to planters when slavery was abolished), which was the main banker of the sugar sector. Funding for social projects: The government of Mauritius is using an innovative financing mechanism to ensure that social projects are funded by the private sector. It imposes a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) levy of 2% of book profits towards programmes that contribute to the social and environmental development of the country. From January 2012, companies are required to spend 50% of their CSR Fund on the four priority areas: social housing; addressing absolute poverty and promoting community empowerment; the welfare of children from vulnerable groups; and the prevention of noncommunicable diseases. As a result CSR becomes an innovative source of financing for some of the priority areas of the government’s agenda. Page 11 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd 3.0 COMPLEMENTARY MEANS OF IMPLEMENTATION (MOI) Mauritius benefited from national and global complementary MoI. The non-financial MoI were the most important element in the transformation of Mauritius, the most significant being preferential market access and public–private sector dialogue and partnership. This section focuses on how the two sets of policies facilitated the mobilisation and effective use of finance. Global linkages: Collaboration with donors was an important enabler of structural transformation, both at the national level and in the restructuring of the sugar industry. Mauritius used bilateral and multilateral ODA relatively well, thanks to the combination of factors mentioned above. In addition, it is important to highlight the technical assistance provided by the UN specialised agencies, the Commonwealth Secretariat, AFD and the EU, among others. Many of the programmes were successful because there were consultations with local stakeholders in their conception and design. Without such technical assistance (often provided on a grant basis) it is doubtful whether Mauritius, with its limited human resource base, would have moved so fast. The flexible attitude of foreign institutions also helped. Mauritius was perhaps lucky to have interlocutors who believed in local ownership of development programmes and not in universal blueprints! Global MoI: The success of the Mauritian economy was largely dependent on preferential treatment in the main export markets for sugar and textiles. Figure 6 presents the key trade agreements which facilitated the development of Mauritius during each of its transitional phases: the Commonwealth Sugar Agreement, which provided guaranteed quotas for the UK and European markets; the Lomé Convention, which provided duty-free and quota-free access to the EU and which later became the Cotonou Convention; and the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), which in the post-MFA period gave access to the US market. The private sector was often closely involved in the negotiations. For example, in the case of the Sugar Protocol, the sugar industry had offices in London and Brussels to complement the work of the Mauritian embassies in gathering intelligence and lobbying the key players. The negotiations for the AGOA were driven by the private sector, with substantial support from the government. Table 4: International MOIs providing preferential treatment in the main export markets for sugar and textiles Period Up to 1974 1971-75 1975 2000 International MOIs Commonwealth Agreement Yaounde Convention Sugar Lomé Convention (later the Cotonou Convention) African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) Facilities provided Provided guaranteed quotas for the UK market Preferential tariff to EEC goods and duty-free and quota-free access to the EEC markets and financial aid from the European Development Fund and the European Investment Bank Duty-free and quota-free access to the European Union Access to the US market Page 12 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Figure 6: Implementing reforms Implementing Reforms 2010 2000 Fiscal Reforms MAAS Fiscal reforms Business Facilitation Opening up to skills New labour laws VRS I Open up air access Empowerment Prog TEST (Textile) Eradication of Absolute Open up telecoms Poverty (EAP) Landlord & Tenant Financial crisis Euro zone crisis Act ICT / BPO Telecoms Env 1990 Offshore activities COTONOU / Freeport POST MFA WTO EPA Blueprint for sugar EPZ Hotel Certificates 1980 COTONOU Macro economic reforms (SAP) LOME 1970 Development Certificates CSA Monocrop Economy Manufacturing & Tourism Manufacturing & Services Economy Business Platform Integrated Business Platform Source: Makoond, JEC (2011) In June 1973 Mauritius signed the Yaoundé Convention, which gave preferential tariff to EEC goods and duty-free and quota-free access to the EEC markets. This treaty also enabled the island to benefit from financial aid from the European Development Fund and the European Investment Bank. The Lomé Convention was to provide Mauritius with sufficient market openings for its growing textile industry. In addition it guaranteed a market for 505,000 tonnes of sugar per year under the EEC-ACP Sugar Protocol at a price usually higher than the world price. During the sugar boom the guaranteed price was lower than the world price but Mauritius respected the convention although it ran counter to the profitmaximising motive. The Sugar Protocol provided the government with the main means to mobilise finance. Indeed, all sugar proceeds had to be repatriated, thus providing foreign currency and liquidity to the banking sector enabling it to meet the domestic demands for funds from both the public and private sector for infrastructure and capital investment (e.g. plant modernisation, technology imports). The exports revenue was supplemented by external grants and concessional loans made available as part of the various international agreements. 4.0 NATIONAL MOI Public–Private Dialogue: A key factor in the transformation of the economic structure in Mauritius is the shared vision of the public and private sector. The close public–private sector collaboration forms part of good governance as it shows willingness on the part of political leaders to dialogue and a sense of responsibility on the part of industrial leaders to participate constructively in the policy-making process. A precondition for such effective dialogue is the existence of a structured private sector. Conscious of this, the private sector organised itself to speak with one voice in its dealings with the government and Page 13 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd established the Joint Economic Committee (JEC) which comprised all the private-sector bodies (i.e. the Chamber of Commerce, the Employers’ Federation, the Chamber of Agriculture, the Sugar Syndicate). It was headed by a previous minister, who understood the workings of the public sector. Thus, the relationship was built on trust, on the understanding that the government had social responsibilities and that the profitability of the private sector was not its sole concern. There are inevitably tensions but the existence of mechanisms for dialogue ensured that solutions were found. This dialogue was facilitated by annual meetings between the JEC and the Prime Minister and his economic ministers. It was this collaboration (at times very informal) which led to certain key initiatives, such as the EPZ being set up, the first hotels being built, successful negotiations on the Sugar Protocol with the posting of representatives of the sugar sector to London and Brussels to lobby the EU to secure favourable access for Mauritian products generally, the creation of the national airline, the establishment of a stock exchange and a freeport, investment in Mozambique, and the adoption of VAT. Many enabling institutions, support agencies, schemes or policies emerged from discussions at the level of the private and public sectors. In addition private sector institutions are represented in many governmental institutions in order to obtain consensus and buy-in in projects being developed. Through this mechanism, the private sector has the opportunity to propose, share and participate in decisions related to the priority infrastructure required for the country’s development and to define the role it could play in the necessary financing. 5.0 THE BEGINNING OF A NEW CYCLE? This paper has described the successive transformations of the economic structure of Mauritius from the 1960s, when sugar was the only industry. At independence there was a deliberate policy to develop local industrialists, and to promote export-oriented industrialisation and the tourism sector. The political and economic situation in 1975 compelled the government to adopt a SAP, overseen by the World Bank. This brought changes in policies and institutional development that took Mauritius onto a higher growth path, which effectively led to the structural transformation with the manufacturing sector overtaking sugar as the main pillar of the economy. The Mauritian economy has started to slow down since 2010 as a result of the global recession, which led to weak sugar and textile exports, a decline in the construction sector and lower margins in the tourism sector. Although the ITC and financial services continued to grow, they were unable to absorb the unemployment generated from the traditional economic sectors. As a result, unemployment has risen to 8%, putting additional pressure on the government to finance enterprise-restructuring efforts, and to finance for Temporary Unemployment Benefit (TUB) and a youth employment programme to facilitate their integration into new growth sectors. Mauritius always strived to maintain a welfare state, providing safety nets to vulnerable sectors of the population in terms of free access to education, health services, subsidised housing, and subsidies on rice and flour. Economic growth has translated into an improvement in the quality of life in terms of access to basic utilities (water and electricity), better public infrastructure (schools, hospitals, roads, highways, modernisation of the port and airport), access to concrete housing (following an increase in purchasing power), better lifestyle through access to imported products (foods, household electronics, cars, etc.) The Education for All policy has also led to a reduction in inequality and to gender mainstreaming. The development imperative has been at a clear cost to the environment (costal development pressure, claiming of land for road construction, industrial pollution and an increase in waste), leading to more controls on industrial initiatives (e.g. Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) of development projects) Page 14 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd and the development of the MID in 2008 to promote renewable energy, energy efficiency and sustainable development. Page 15 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd 6.0 REFERENCES African Economic Outlook Mauritius 2012. Tunis: African Development Bank. Bank of Mauritius (various issues) Annual Reports. Port Louis: Bank of Mauritius. EU Delegation Mauritius website, EU assistance to sugar sector Gulhati, R. and Nallari, R. (1990) Successful Stabilization and Recovery in Mauritius. Washington, DC: World Bank. International Monetary Fund (various years) Country Reports. Washington, DC: IMF. Kalamova, M., Kaminker, C. and Johnstone, N. (2011) ‘Sources of finance, Investment policies and plant entry in the renewable energy sector’. OECD Environment Working Papers No. 37. Paris: OECD. Makoond, R. (2011) Mauritius Economic Trajectory. Port Louis: Joint Economic Council. Meade, J.E. (1961) The Economic and Social Structure of Mauritius: Report to the Governor of Mauritius. London: Methuen. Ministry of Finance and Economic Development Public Sector Investment Programme 2014–2018. Port Louis: MFED. Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (various issues) Economic Indicators. Port Louis: MFED. Mistry, P.S. and Treebhoohun, N. (2008) The Export of Tradeable Services in Mauritius: A Commonwealth Case Study in Economic Transformation. London: Commonwealth Secretariat. National Productivity and Competitiveness Council (2004) Competitiveness Foresight. Port Louis: NPCC. Statistics Mauritius (2007) Poverty Analysis Statistics Mauritius (2010) Digest of Environment Statistics Statistics Mauritius (2011)Digest of Productivity Statistics Statistics Mauritius (2011) Digest of Public Finance Statistics Statistics Mauritius (2012) Household Budget Survey 2012, Preliminary Results Statistics Mauritius (2013)Digest of Energy and Water Statistics United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (2013) Report on the World Social Situation: Inequality Matters. New York: UN DESA. United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (2001) Investment Policy Review: Mauritius. Geneva: UNCTAD. World Bank (various issues) Global Development Finance Reports. Washington, DC: World Bank. World Bank (various issues) World Development Indicators. Washington, DC: World Bank. Page 16 of 17 Oxford International Consultants Mauritius Ltd Page 17 of 17