Guidelines for diagnosis and monitoring of thyroid disease
Transcription
Guidelines for diagnosis and monitoring of thyroid disease
Clinical Chemistry 188-192 42:1 (1996) Guidelines for diagnosis and monitoring disease: nonthyroidal illness R. JAN On the basis value, and of cost, assessment specificity, is at function in acutely features suggest thyroid dysfunction, estimates show specificity and poor disease. When critically ill, positive disease of both improved by using elected or to alter testing any and for initial clinical be TSH thyroid result the best rather should than apparent either diagnostic therapy either based tests abnormal results, abnormality and dysfunction. T4 of the T4 be between confirmed Such an be- miuiS: thyroid dysfunction . thyroxine . populations unselected in iodine-replete [1]. Prevalence is highest dysfunction is likely in older to be regions, is estimated of subclinical responses women. at least the Unrecognized as frequent preva- time changes Ewen Alfred Downie Hospital, Metabolic Unit Commercial and Monash Rd., Melbourne, University Vie, Department Australia 21, 1995; accepted October Il, in the will that an be considered patients. Questions the factors of under difference (1 h), leading these to critical and to indicators. and generate illness involves inhibition axes effects the normal In the case of the complicated by of medications. axis and in peripheral occur in various extensively reviewed briefly of methodology impair of [6]. These further diagnostic that large intervals. only (TSH) Many to sampling axis, is been apparently yield. pituitary-thyroid have of are used, thyrotropin uncertainty reference that if this intervals to the gonadal major thyroid [2]. However, between response evaluation the to be compelling and TSH create of and associated related of doubtful can compromise the here, with assessment will grades on elsewhere emphasis in hospi- be summarized, specificity of various of Medi3181. Fax 613 ‘Nonstandard August are relations and illness on factors 9276-3782. Received be identify features nondiagnostic.’ [3, 5], due iodothyronines of in particular cine, [2-4] standard in nutrition [3, 7, 8] and talized 1) is often pituitary- axis, nonthyroidal of to have prevalence of T4 (1 week) and metabolism thyroid at the is likely seem between pituitary-adrenal distort The to be 1-2%, dysfunction a high hormonal of the pituitary-thyroid lence of definite thyroid dysfunction with a further 2-6% showing features (Fig. activity general changes In could to illness reference relation abnormalities diagnostic The triiodothy- the half-lives nonspecific activation #{149} thyrotropin ronine show changes pituitary-thyroid INflEXING standard or uninterpretable further is commenced. that failure clinical testing laboratory conditions discordant relaof illness and (T4) the another would but nonspecific of of missing will non-steady-state and of T4-TSH Persistence should these An estimate free thyroxine the critical widespread individual dysfunction, in maximum intervention. of consequences is adopted approach Diagnosis on for reasons therapeutic presence the during Thyroid or free alone. in serious dysfunction is dysfunction unreliability disease ill patient methodology. be well-known potentially TSH thyroid testing with Whereas to an important to lead thyroid information pituitary of thyroid any abnormality therapy. unrecognized The uns- by aim identify, is to specificity, and acutely analysis value for and thyroid TSH unlikely be the principal that chronic less common. ill subjects acutely patients. of thyroid combined available dysfunction tion T4, suggest the disease- prognostic for any risk for by than of nonspecific individual that at increased followed with for features abnormal intervals available true could accept Unrecognized effect on outcome, the detection of transiently abnormal that result from nonthyroidal illness or medications is for thyroid much influenced previously adverse values true illness. sensitivity positively lack in measurements useful ill but tested for triiodothyronine, to yield be readily groups should fore reference knowledge of value TSH The management should with and value is or possible the for acute is certainly would critically thyrotropin results, predictive wider likely and function predictive abnormalities currently positive thyroid T4 populations. related not free of increases (T4) Most pa- in severely used of abnormal hypofunction possibility When thyroid the hospitalized the thyroxine hospitalization routine background prevalence have for dysfunction. of both a high STOCKIGT predictive basis or a patient’s of thyroid (TSH) positive no clinical unless patients, poor present of thyroid tients, likelihood low there of thyroid 1995. thyronine; 188 and abbreviations: FT4I, free thyroxine TSH, index. thyrotropin; T4, thyroxine; T3, triiodo- Clinical Chemistry 42, No. can then suggest recovery, B D and / samples Changes may effects quirks vitro to Measure active Hormone concentration reflects in vitro low from Reference ranges Normal response 1. Relation between normal in the common thyroid dysfunction. a heparin-treated generation during critical prolonged depends on numerous assumptions Whereas not techniques of free value potential T4 estimation of highly in critically sensitive, ill subjects and third-generation so for far HORMONE a valuable acute mone action which show and [10]. block on Although such calorie-sparing protein synthesis is beneficial direct benefit from adaptive for routine present occurs harmful. limited therapy documentation there low T3 of suggest Immunoreactive TSH often attributed also tends in to decrease part glucocorticoids [14] (either endogenous pamine [15], which, even therapy profound rapidly reversible to or exogenous), in nonpressor doses, suppression That measured immunoreactive ical activity in severe illness also of serum leads T4 production; in processing, take total account of that T4 concentra- illness [7, 25, 26]. of studying in an body TSH attempt to of information management in feedback has decisions relation, predictable for inverse in the to assay sensitivity, TSH case of primary assumptions, this [28]. of alterations when of relations of pituitary-dependent several specificity diseases concordant in the case Subject and changes e.g., relation has high However, reflect in critical discordant and T4 are considered IN HOSPITALIZED of 364 consecutive admissions, DeGroot and population, free appropriate prevalence, probable primary a further Mayor thyroxine apparent [16]. findings basis and produces TSH may show altered biologremains an important possibility to decreased of value demonstrate extreme of a study index screening, Crapo [I). nontogether. after ognized primary hypothyroidism common than FT4I those that in the general was study, or TSH, 25% but only indicative with low found based FT41 apparently whereas than expected. had abnormalities 6% the concordant thyroid had low normal of with that unrec- much more the prevalence of either T4 and TSH dysfunction or the hypothyroidism. no higher 68% cohort, It is striking of patients showed by on and TSH, of their subclinical population, their would as defined was of both was of primary Vf41, finding,” in -5% in <1%. hospital in determination conclusion apparent was In that, assessment showing of hyperthyroidism general f2J suggested or “case hypothyroidism 6% PATIENTS acute (FT.51) This Hyperthyroidism changes TSH 1). proportion Helfand or do- [17]. Lowered not critical this either adequate sensitivity diagnostic are show (Fig. and provide [13], TSH TSH or direct at illness, nutrition and no during in severe altered T4 of possible storage, do to the [27], indicators, a high On the illness. a change is due as a result free because hormone SCREENING/CASE-FINDING basis states acids pa- effect of illness is no T4 state illness lowering studies [12], this Any subnormal to improve or pituitary diagnostic short-term chronic measured ill patients. dysfunction, steady over- in severe confer whether Since replacement may abnormalities in not that that sample in gone shown these is hor- those does free thyroid these changes resemble and prediction been thyroid as restriction, [9] and response term, thyroid caloric in for T4- RELATION between that diminished that conversion short evidence T4 therapy it is uncertain or the in that Supplementary an regarded during consumption benefit, ofT3 to studies oxygen in T4-T3 ILLNESS generally at least lead mainly DURING [7, 8]. The to illness lowered hypothyroidism the (T), concentrations rests enzyme hepatic CHANGES economy, response T3 subnormal [11]. TSH calorie-sparing a normal come AND triiodothyronine affinity of medications, prognosis even critically TSFI/T4 the of serum illness. hospitalized activity. thyrotropin.-releasing prognostic Because Lowering true the assays TSH. THYROID known of which of TSH have to individual most a poor some refine that may not be lustified been during or effects lowering indicate responses illness. direct is dubious acids studies, of illness tions a low fatty in lipase All for T4 is an important delnonstrated subject below). incubation. duration relationship free of nonesterified of fatty Numerous applicable (see specificity of associated long binding or methodolog- in heparin-treated increase from in protein lack has et al. /24/ vitro levels TSH and T4 shows diagonal deviations from types of primary (A, B) or secondary (C, 0) Fig. This interpretation normal trophic-target it has increased generation or assay Distinguish in serum, heparin-induced hormone level heparin half-life), 15]. estimates on apparent Although Mendel T4 methods presence in the is often [23/. alterations With increased, longer [7, 15, 20-22], T4 [18/. hypothyroidism from free free of heparin sites T4 tients conditions result origin transiently of its much primary particular effect binding (because of medications of artifact. free also dysfunction The Steady-state become suggest available thyroid Assumptions may of T4 [19], ical of central concentrations if T4 is still subnormal currently TSH hypothyroidism TSH single T4 189 1, 1996 (Fig. TSH; 1). Of of those NACB with high TSH, uncertain the group or In have setting be lower. higher care values only 2% showed suggestive of primary reference interval abnormal values, primary patients with but TSH, TSH values whom in 13% CHOICE OF testing of their was INITIAL contentious in whether the TSH appropriate features, convenience. Lack deficiencies, is the TSH discrimination found preanalytical true free may give of case factor true from with free the T4 on assay For TSH or high but tend to give concentrain the that inhibit T4 T4 values methods free dilution, which attenuates [22/, thereby failing to show rise in free T4. are much binding With more of T4 of the often sample give one-step free T4 in the to analytical between free T4 TSH ASSAYS The concentration euthyroid artifacts, and falsely due calibrators low or variations, these the steady-state of illness difference free [30]. T4 from in mltJ/L. 33, figure ref. the the effect of the true extent mIU/L, are suppressed TSH ized subjects subjects had ill subjects TSH relation between Although values low free all by differsuch When [5, 35]. If the yet, lowering such creased as improve few effects dopamine TSH upper most of the little establish of severe illness, or the assay. on latter will as values the alone. identify in critically of TSH TSH loss clearly 0.1 that had the assays up reference in critical hypothyroidism. and be based than increases glucocorticoids, critically 0.01 is impaired limit <0.1 TSH should 12 mIUIL [2], with or values illness TSH seen hospital- all hyperthyroid between studies of primary from et al. [34] found available the the values whereas rather of separate of a third-generation TSH, Thirdlimit TSH nonthyroidal nonspecific to 8 or clearly As of values specificity transient to almost Franklyn T4 and currently subjects increased basis mIU/L, with between sensitivity from that had sensitivity to would <0.01 TSH value of samples the found TSH is a marked assays. able of hyperthyroidism hypothyroidism, mIUIL on of TSH. there well than non- subnormal TSH In an analysis physio- reflect predictive generally of patients a diagnosis the a functional in to free rather half-life short positive high true often between 2). Nevertheless, Hence, indicate medications, of the on et al. [33] with of or In contrast of hyperthyroidism, preselected Spencer primary that illness dialysis normal, of hyperthyroidism values illness. mIU/L, low, generally and 0.0 1-0.02 proteins [3, 31]. falsely abbreviated by equilibrium third-generation based T4 hyper- to protein with illness. effects those assays, in nonthyroidal be distinction generation the functional methods illness, severe occur Abnormalities and below In critical estimates a thirdmlU/L <0.1 Data also may the in specificity in vitro to true and because and to the to be due may nonthyroidal the as 4% free another [30] conditions, In considering many to with values artifacts. illness of binding largely using 0.01-0.02 therapy. deviations or in critical or T4 with responses (Fig. analog presence glucocorticoid of TSH mIU/L likely values for TSH concentrations estimates patients logical were many to measure subject one-step free sound two-step than that before T4, TSH sensitivity permission. coexists low more vulnerable raises with method- proteins theoretically falsely protein or [3, 31]. contrast, attempt free establish patients free binding and results to in euthyroid are particularly which [24], supranormal thyroidism Gc, ref. 3, with or values free T4 assays of medications two-step high of the competitor-induced methods, Various from validated methods effect it is difficult values In general, better reasons to effects of the T4 pool are normal con- precision ill subjects. serum functional preselected hyperthyroidism; from reduced with patients methodological estimates. the of assay hyperthyroidism T4 and methodological and depends is of cost suppressed hyperthyroidism it is in the absence a matter Hyper, TSH [32]. T4 estimation finding arising between due influence of sample binding competitors methods For accuracy, analytical artifacts. heparin ences of studies. illness, of free is largely in critically normal, a fraction [3, 30]. These are test. associated Classification second-generation illness, step In form illness and low, dependent factors or some limiting T4 values nonthyroidal [3, 30], two ASSAYS For assay low all of prevalence in the 1-0.1 at the found almost The 2. generation hospitalized modified range. T4 isolate values. of choice of in severe subnormal FREE the typical centrations patients, (12-14%) presence initial of clinical assays, T4 similar in receiving study et al. [26] care of ASSAY is done more intensive had higher patients 0.0 <0.01 mlU /L Fig. TSH 12% Mayor’s Rothwell total values the much of and TSH indicative was exclusion [2], subnormal TSH When concordance DeGroot admission showed increased tions after to found relation mIU/L, Mortality 200 mIU/L, 0.3-5 TSH-T4 0.2-8 showed is In et al. /26] range dysfunction. none of nonspe- abnormalities a concordant to that studied. Rothwell the TSH be limited prevalence are outside dysfunction. low of hospital or TSH extended In contrast time of T4 thyroid was thyroid dopamine. the best 8% for of either where patients, TSH remains suggested might populations care had It is appropriate [29] disease prevalence intensive intensive although Ross for thyroid will 22% the study, care when values. if any, abnormalities this ambulatory consecutive If to programs A much Ff41 nondiagnostic abnormalities found that normal investigation, response case-finding to the had further who T4. cific 70% what Symposium illness, ill to 20 interval specificity of sensitivity. whether influence can the TSH- of medications normalize Subnormal the in- T4 values Clinical Table 1. Increased Previous risk of thyroid illness. dysfunction 1, 1996 invaluable However, disease(s) Biological Irradiation of head and neck Contrast agent exposure Severe Amiodarone Hypothermia could Interleukin-2 head injury generally resolved identify only by subnormal T4 transiently during such serial and cases, but sampling, substantially recovery uncertainty because the increased from may be combination TSH of may drug-induced occur hypothyroxin- [5]. the Because steady-state therapy REFERENCE in specified in to confirm in doubt Fig. 1, critically a persistent ill abnormality we are concerned related disease, abnormalities and free patients per T4 free T4 is of reference interval for threefold upwards and of sensitivity loss 0.1-12 mIU/L underlying value can improved in critically thyroid be relation T4. he a of the in critically or than two- so that to with range the quite with a logarithmic ill patients disease, compatible ill halving be extended probably both TSH relevance limits thyroid for true for Since [33], clinical Hence, can still intervals. direct downwards might of illness- predictive reference TSH of unrecog- diagnosis documentation positive less of free the the log-linear in TSH or doubling halving se, standard vary of than estimates by widening doubling with rather 6. Reichlin likelihood in some function. of thyroid groups thyroid of has cancer dysfunction patients dysfunction, transient, been of chronic 10-15% In in some will in acute psychiatric abnormalities generally not the large or nonspecific illness usually 14. treat- a-interferon, dysfunction, should because be transient thyroxinemia, be receiving During recombinant thyroid testing situations, malities [36]. that may often most 15. [37]. routine contrast, acutely developed note of patients interleukin-2 C with increased should which in 30-40% with hepatitis hypothyroidism temporary 1). One hypothyroidism, described of patients is substantially (Table usually immunotherapy ment there without recommended frequency of TSH 16. of abnorFor [7, 8, 38]. is a high suppression resolve be majority example, 17. of hyper[39/. These 18. rapidly. DEVELOPMENTS If the cost greatly reduced, need medicolegal for thyroid disease. Ann Intern screening by thyroid function teaching hospital. Am J Med of a high-quality arguments to be revised. As with initial for and test against measurement could eventually routine of blood testing he would glucose or in vitro testing 1994;102(Suppl in non-thyroidal illness. Exp 2):92-101. of thyroid status in S. Neuroendocrine-immune interactions. N EngI J Med 1246-53. 7. Wartofsky L, Burman KD. Alterations in thyroid function in patients with systemic illness: the “euthyroid sick syndrome.” Endocr Rev 1982:3:164-217. 8. Docter R, Krenning EP, de Jong M, Hennemann G. The sick euthyroid syndrome: changes in thyroid hormones, serum parameters and hormone metabolism. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) 1993;39: 499-518. 9. Bray G. Effect of caloric restriction on energy expenditure in obese patients. Lancet 1969;ii:397-8. 10. Carr FE, Seelig 5, Mariash CN, Schwartz HGL, Oppenheimer JH. Starvation and hypothyroidism exert an overlapping influence on rat hepatic messenger RNA activity profiles. J Clin Invest 1983; 72:154-63. 11. Brent GA, Hershman JM. Thyroxine therapy in patients with severe nonthyroidal illness and low serum thyroxine concentration. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1986;63:1-8. SITUATIONS FUTURE of unrequested and 5. Hamblin PS, Dyer SA, Mohr VS. Le Grand B, Lim C-F, Tuxen DV, et al. Relationship between thyrotropin and thyroxine changes during recovery from severe hypothyroxinemia of critical illness. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1986;62:717-22. 13. SPECIAL The ethical 4. Rae P, Farrar J, Beckett G, loft A. Assessment elderly people. Br Med J 1993;307:177-80. 12. normal EM. Thyroid Endocrinol 1993;329: INTERVALS thyroid TSH assumptions is frequently is begun. that Assuming nized the of is appropriate it before first sampling, subjects, little by serendipity. 1992;93:558-64. Clin and complex gained follow-up References 3. Kaptein emia raise be and 1. Helfand M, Crapo LM. Screening Med 1990;112:840-9. 2. DeGroot U, Mayor G. Admission tests in an acute general care Dopamine will can evaluation agents Interferon-cs syndrome information appropriate issues. Lithium Down No. calcium, in critical Glucocorticoids Goiter Autoimmune 42, abnormalities disease thyroid Chemistry 19. Becker RA, Vaughan GM. Ziegler MG, Seraile LG, Goldfarb W, Mansour E, et al. Hypermetabolic low triiodothyronine syndrome of burn injury. Crit Care Med 1982;10:870-5. Hughes J, Burger AG, Pekary AE, Hershman JM. Rapid adaptations of serum thyrotropin. triiodothyronine and reverse triiodothyronine levels to short term starvation and refeeding. Acta Endocrinol (Copenh) 1984:105:194-9. Re RN, Kourides IA, Ridgway EC, Weintraub BD, Maloof F. The effects of glucocorticoid administration on human pituitary secretion of thyrotropin and prolactin. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1976; 43:338-46. Kaptein EM, Kletzsky OA, Spencer CA, Nicoloff JT. Effects of prolonged dopamine infusion on anterior pituitary function in normal males. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1980;51:488-91. Van den Berghe G, de Zegher F, Lauwers P. Dopamine and the sick euthyroid syndrome in critical illness. Clin Endocrinol 1994; 41:731-7. Beck-Peccoz P. Persani L. Variable biological activity of thyroidstimulating hormone. Eur J Endocrlnol 1994:131:331-40. Heinen E, Herrmann J, Konigshausen TH, Kr#{252}skemper IlL. Sekund#{227}reHypothyreose und ihre Beziehung zur Prognose bei Schwerstkranken einer lntensivstation. lntensivmed Prax 1980; 17:90-3. Chopra IJ. Huang IS, Beredo A, Solomon DH, Chua leco GN. Serum thyroid hormone binding inhibitor in nonthyroidal illnesses. Metabolism 1986;35:152-9. 192 20. 21. NACB Smith PJ, Surks thyroid hormone Stockigt JR. High J Clin Endocrinol Metab Lim CF, of in vitro protein Barlow thyroid binding. Exp Di, Wynne plasma Topliss of 32. Drug-induced distur- circulating Schatz DL, Sheppard GA. Influence Endocrinol Metab 24. 1994;102(Suppl 2): in 25. 26. 27. 33. Frost PH, heparin-induced plasma. Kaptein EM, Weiner thyroxine. CS, deVeber of illnesses. PM, ZF, Udwadia predicts outcome Sumita S. Ujike tanabe A, et in critical V. Namiki al. critical Stockigt Utiger RG, eds. phia: JB Lippincott, Ross Ekins hormones. DS. Care TSH thyroid Werner 35. concentration H, thyrotropin its association M, severity measurements hormone In: transport. lngbar’s the thyroid, Wa- response with free ed. 36. tests hormone hypothesis 1992:38:1289-93. JA, Black in an measurement Patel A, Guttler I Clin generation Com- of nonthyroidal in hyperthyroidism. RB, Eigen A, Shen thyrotropin Endocrinol Metab I, Sheppard methods in patients with overt therapy, and those Metab CA, D, et assay to 1990;70:453- MC. Comparison for measurement hyperthyroidism, with patients nonthyroidal of of serum receiv- illness. I Clin 1994;78:1368-71. Eigen A, Shen of sensitive for thyroid disease D, Duda assays M, QuaIls of thyrotropin in hospitalized Schwartzentruber of patients 37. Baudin care 38. 5, Weiss (TSH) patients. (Oxf) of free 39. Hem Hosp P. Pouteau C, et al. Reversibility alpha interferon Clin S, et al. used to screen Chem 1987;33: MH, associated BD, Rosen- immunotherapy for Weintraub with 1991;68:2384-90. M, Colas-Linhart of thyroid in chronic N, Le Floch dysfunction hepatitis i-P. induced C. Clin by Endocri- 1993:39:657-61. JR. Hyperthyroxinemia Endocrinologist MD, DE, Zweig Cancer E, Marcellin Stockigt White dysfunction cancer. recombinant Philadel- acute with Lemmonier LE, Di, SA. Thyroid illness. and Influence indices chemiluminometric EG, Betteridge third Specificity nol function iT. hormone iS, of a new and Spencer berg 1994;96:393-4. Chem Franklyn to and Braverman 6th JM. in nonthyroidal 1391-6. Kawamata Med 1994:22:1603-9. and thyroid hormone and in Nicoloff measurement. Endocrinol iT. 1993:48:373-6. of and Nicoloff to survival Thyrotropin A, Watanabe thyroid Am J Med Clin indices Anaesthesia the LoPresti ing thyroxine WS, Hershman thyroxine 1983;128:670-5. thyrotropin thyroxine 1982:16:565-74. PG. EM, thyroid CA, second of 1991:463-85. Screening R. The Lawlr illness. Suppression illness. Crit JR. Serum of free Wheeler hormone Endocrinol hormone of Wi, thyroid Clin Mechanism 1987:65:1259-64. Robinson altered RR. ME, free 60. Endocrinol J Clin ST. Cavalieri Metab JM, non-thyroidal hospital. 30. Chandarlapaty in the concentration Endocrinol Relationship Rothwell Kunitake increase J Clin assessment 29. G, free Bradley 1992;38:720-4. serum J Med GS, measuring Kaptein on Spencer Hoo for Chem SMC, al. Applications 34. thyrotropin-releasing 28. on serum Clin Lum AE, methods subnormal 1969:29:1015-22. Mendel CM, the Steiner RH, of heparin Pekary of West competitors 110-6. 23. TK, illnesses DJ. of Wong illness. KN. binding 1984:59:62-6. effects Clin 31. parison V. Topliss inhibit JW, testing: on the 1984;5:514-24. Stevens JW, furosemide JR, CE, of diphenylhydantoin Rev of Stockigt Lim effects Endocr Barlow bances for Multiple system. concentrations thyroxine. 22. Ml. Symposium Jackson Psychiatry secondary to drugs and acute 1993;3:67-73. IMD. Thyroid 1990;12:232-44. function in psychiatric illness. Gen